Five By Five - Reviews

Five By Five
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I keep coming back to how the author controls tempo in this section. It starts slow — the narrator notices Jihoon's expression shift, sees him glancing down the alley, realizes there are more people than expected. Then it accelerates: the lighter hits, voices rise, Cheol-seung signals, Jihoon steps in front, gets hit, the narrator calls police. The middle of this sequence moves like a sprint. But then — and this is the brilliant part — once the police arrive and the thugs scatter, the pacing DOESN'T resolve. It drops into a weird, quiet limbo. Five minutes with the officer, they're told to go home, and then... nothing. Just the narrator and Jihoon standing in the same alley with nowhere to go. And that's when the real scene begins. The confrontation, the punch, the confession about parents, the ending where the narrator just keeps talking while Jihoon listens. If the author had ended on the police arrival, it would've felt like a cheap escape. Instead they used the cooldown as a springboard for the emotional climax. The structure here is basically: tension buildup → crisis → false resolution → deeper confrontation. And each phase gets the exact amount of words it needs. No rushing, no padding. Just the right breath at the right moment. I also loved how the grandfather flashback is inserted at the precise second when the narrator needs to understand Jihoon's father better — it's not exposition, it's organic discovery happening in real time. That's pacing with purpose.
... Read More
This grandfather isn't just a backdrop; he's a vault. When he says 'Stay at home' at 2 AM, it's not paternal concern—it's containment. He's shielding me from something, but also from himself. Their relationship is all unspoken negotiations: he sends me on errands to the community center, but never explains why those particular women know about my aunt's death before I do. Meanwhile, Lee Jihoon used to share bus timetables with me—tiny rituals of trust—and now he won't even look at me. The shift isn't gradual; it's a door slamming. What breaks that? Grief, obviously, but also guilt. Kang Youngsoo's mom prepared side dishes for me 'because your grandfather is still at the funeral home,' which implies my grandfather's presence there is both expected and ominous. And Lee Jihoon's uncle? Who is he? Why does Kang Youngsoo mention him like a fallback plan when Lee Jihoon is clearly drifting into darker company? The protagonist's isolation isn't just physical (new town, absent parents) but relational—everyone's connected through loss except him, until he chooses to step into the alley. That's when he stops being an observer and becomes complicit. Or maybe a savior. Or maybe just another person who can't look away.
... Read More
Can we just appreciate how natural all the dialogue sounds here? Every character has a distinctly different voice and I can tell who's speaking without seeing tags. Jihoon's lines are sharp and defensive — 'Just go about your business, you idiot' has that mix of urgency and self-protection. The thugs sound like actual street kids, casual and cruel: 'He still looks good no matter how many times I see him. You're still acting all high-and-mighty these days.' Cheol-seung especially feels real — that performative friendship mixed with actual menace: 'Hyung is acting up again. Hitting me won't make you tougher.' The narrator's voice is different though, and it's my favorite. Under pressure he gets clinical, methodical. Even while calling the police he's reciting specifics like a report — 'approximately fifteen times since 4 PM,' 'third-year students from Jaehang Middle School.' It's almost disturbing how calm he is, which makes it all the more powerful when he finally drops the truth bombs about Jihoon's mother and his own parents. And Jihoon's breakdown dialogue? 'Have you seen my mom? Have you even spoken with her?' It's not polished. It's fragmented and desperate and completely human. The author isn't trying to write witty banter here — these people are scared and hurt and saying exactly what they mean, which is infinitely more compelling than any clever one-liner ever could be.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is absolutely vicious and I love it. It starts with Youngsoo's confession—this heavy, messy, tear-streaked scene that drags you into the emotional weight of it all. You're sitting there thinking 'ok this is going to be a turning point,' right? And then it CUTS. Just straight to Seon-uk at Jihoon's door at 3 AM. No warning. No transition paragraph. One moment you're crying over fast food fries, the next you're watching someone silently unpack fourteen years of repressed feelings into a shoebox. The tension building is masterful. Jihoon asks 'Is this…?' and the text just lingers. Doesn't complete the thought. Lets the silence do the work. Then Seon-uk interrupts him with 'Congratulations on your marriage' and suddenly the pacing ACCELERATES. It's like the narrative itself is running away from the emotional gravity of what just happened. But the real pacing genius is the ending. He runs. He sprints down that corridor. And THEN—the car. THE CAR. He buries his face in the steering wheel and finds the blood. The pacing drops from a sprint to a crawl in that final paragraph, forcing you to sit in the aftermath. The last line 'I was unprepared' hits like a physical blow because everything before it was rushing toward it.
... Read More
I've read a lot of stories about complicated friendships, but this one hits different because it refuses to name what it actually is. Let me just start with this: when Lee Ji-hoon says "Can you close the window a bit? I'm about to freeze because of you," he is delivering one of the most emotionally complex lines I've encountered in this genre. He could have said anything. He could have walked away. Instead, he made an excuse to stay in the same room with you. The padded jacket detail is killing me. He noticed you were cold enough to bring a jacket, but he won't even say your name right. He sleeps at his desk with his uniform spread out like a blanket, and the protagonist's only thought is that HE is the reason Lee Ji-hoon is any different from his first day. Not that he cares — no, just an observation. But we FEEL it. And then the adult timeline hits with this radio show narration: "When someone is missed, it's as if memories of places we've been together, music we've listened to, and the food we've shared come flooding back." This is basically the thesis statement for the entire book dressed up as background music. The protagonist listens to this and immediately thinks of Lee Ji-hoon. At the END of his work day. After a long shift. He doesn't even try to hide it from himself anymore. The flight schedule messages are the most romantic thing that isn't technically romantic. Every departure time, every return flight — it's a language. And Seon-uk memorized it all without being asked. "I was crazy for memorizing his schedule every time he sent them, but Lee Ji-hoon was also crazy for sending them regularly." This sentence contains an entire love story that neither of them will ever tell out loud.
... Read More
I need to talk about Lee Ji-hoon because honestly I think I'm obsessed with how complicated this character is written. The man forgets your name but somehow knows your bus schedule better than you do. He calls you by the wrong name without even caring enough to look around and confirm. And yet — and YET — he notices you're freezing, brings a padded jacket, and opens the window exactly one seat away from where he sits. This is the mostLee Ji-hoon behavior possible: caring without ever making it comfortable. Then there's the adult timeline version of their friendship, and it breaks my heart a little. Lee Ji-hoon sends flight schedules like they're something normal to share. "Do you want to meet up tomorrow, the three of us? Bring your girlfriend." This is the kind of casual statement that contains an ocean of meaning. Is he testing something? Deflecting? genuinely asking? The fact that he never pushes when Seon-uk cancels is both beautiful and devastating. He knows. He absolutely knows that his friend is avoiding something, and he pretends not to notice. Kang Young-soo is this wild card in their dynamic. In the school timeline, he's this loud older brother type who can't stop embarrassing his sister. In the adult timeline, he's the bridge between Seon-uk and Lee Ji-hoon, the one delivering messages, the one who asked about Lee Ji-hoon's vacation and got THAT famous blank smile response. The three of them form this triangle where everyone knows something the others don't, and the reader is the only one who sees the whole shape. "When someone is missed, it's as if memories of places we've been together, music we've listened to, and the food we've shared come flooding back." This line about Lee Ji-hoon taking you back to a younger version of yourself — that's the core of their entire relationship, isn't it?
... Read More
I need to talk about this moment where Jihoon punches the narrator and immediately breaks down. Because on the surface it looks like violence, right? But honestly it was the most raw emotional scene I've read in a long time. This kid has been taking hits for someone who isn't even his friend, smiling through pain, trying to protect the narrator from his own world — and then the narrator says something that cuts to the bone: 'Even if your mother has passed away, you still have your father.' And Jihoon loses it. Not because the words are cruel, but because they're TRUE and they touch the exact wound he's been holding shut. The narrator doesn't flinch. He just takes it. And then instead of retaliating or pulling away, he shares his own vulnerability first — that he moved in with his grandfather because his actual parents don't care about him. That's when the dynamic completely flips. Jihoon wasn't just angry, he was terrified that this stranger understood him too well. And the narrator? He's basically saying 'you're not alone in this.' The blood mixed with saliva detail when he spits on the ground — god, that image stays with you. Two broken kids who don't know how to ask for help finding each other in the worst possible way. What a moment.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this whole chapter sequence is a masterclass in how to escalate stakes without melodrama. You have the narrator walking down this seemingly random alley, runs into Jihoon getting cornered by Park Cheol-seung and his crew, and instead of being a passive observer, he makes a split-second decision to intervene. The way the plot unfolds from there is insane. First he tries to physically pull Jihoon out, gets interrupted by the lighter toss as a signal, then Cheol-seung demands he come closer, and Jihoon steps up to protect HIM of all people, taking hits for the narrator while trying to send him away. And then the narrator does what? Pulls out his phone and calmly calls the police. Not a punch, not a dramatic speech, just a straight-up report with precise details learned from a school bullying seminar. That detail about remembering the instructor's words — that's the kind of thing that only lands if the author has been foreshadowing earlier. The resolution comes fast (five minutes for police to arrive and clear the alley), but the aftermath is where the real plot weight hits. Jihoon's explosion of rage, the reveal about his mother, the narrator revealing his own family situation. The plot doesn't just resolve the alley conflict — it rewires the entire relationship between these two characters. One punch, one truth, and suddenly everything shifts.
... Read More
Okay so let me just... how do I even unpack this chapter sequence. The whole thing starts with Youngsoo basically blurt-ing his secret out to his best friend in a fast food joint, right? And then it cuts to Seon-uk showing up at Jihoon's apartment at 3 AM with a BOX of memorabilia. A BOX. Like he spent all night sorting through fourteen years of accumulated feelings and neatly catalogued them into cardboard. The plot move here is actually brutal. Seon-uk tells Jihoon 'I'm going to date a man' as this fake soft launch, and then IMMEDIATELY follows up with 'the man I liked was you.' Like, the narrative whiplash is something else. He wanted to wait until he stopped loving him to confess, but of course he still loves him, so now he's confessing at the worst possible moment. And then—get this—he tells him CONGRATULATIONS ON YOUR MARRIAGE before walking out. That's not a breakup scene, that's a surgical removal of a twenty-year-old bond. The structural symmetry is disgusting in the best way. Fifteen when they met, thirty now, fourteen years of this. And the baseball? He returns the baseball. THE BASEBALL. It stopped being about baseball when Jihoon stopped playing at fifteen. That ball is literally the period at the end of a sentence they never knew they were writing.
... Read More
The opening description of the school hit me differently this time around. Seon-uk looks around and thinks 'Maybe there was one somewhere in Taean, but certainly not around here.' This small observation tells us SO much about the setting — it's remote, rural, not the polished urban environment he's used to from Seoul. The fact that he can't even picture where an academy would be shows how disconnected this place feels from his old life. But what really made the world click for me was the baseball field scene. The tall fence, the black-and-white photo display case inside the school showing former players, the number 72 bus arriving on schedule — these details create this almost cinematic quality. You can literally see the winter sunlight being 'dazzling,' the way Seon-uk has to cover his forehead and tilt his head back just to see over the fence. The author doesn't just describe locations, they describe how it FEELS to be in them. The classroom scenes are also brilliantly rendered. Empty classrooms with open windows, the smell of winter air mixing with stuffy indoor air, the duty student's scolding echoing through empty halls. Even Seon-uk's grandfather's house in the village — the man bringing pork belly, hopping over the threshold, speaking in that Gyeongsang-do accent — it all creates this layered sense of place. Taean isn't just a backdrop, it's almost a character itself.
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter are DECEPTIVE. On the surface, it's just two friends hanging out, right? Wrong. Because every single conflict is running on triple overlap and I was gripping the边缘 of my seat the entire time. External conflict: the grandfather is dying and the narrator is drowning in medical bills and caregiver searches with no end in sight. That's the backdrop, the weather system everyone is breathing through. But the INTERNAL conflict is where this chapter lives or dies. The narrator has spent fifteen years building a wall between himself and Jihoon, and every instinct screams at him to maintain it. He's terrified—not just of being gay, not just of rejection, but of what happens to THEIR FRIENDSHIP if the truth comes out. Jihoon, meanwhile, is carrying his own unbearable weight: he flew across the world to see someone who won't look at him, and he's been waiting fifteen years to say something he can't name. The scene where the nurse hints at needing a new caregiver and the narrator can only apologize? That's the external world intruding on an already fractured internal one. And then the movie plays this whole other layer of conflict—the same-sex couple breaking up, the stranger making a move, the hesitation, the glance back at the ex. Every conflict in that fictional film mirrors a conflict in the real one, and the narrator can't even watch it without changing the channel. When Jihoon finally says "if you're not ready to talk, then fine"—he's not backing down. He's offering an out. And the narrator chooses to walk through the fire anyway. "Even if the depths were an unknown darkness, if Jihoon was there, then I had to go there." That's not courage. That's desperation. And I NEED to know what happens next.
... Read More
Can we talk about Jihoon? This character walked into a room and immediately rearranged the entire emotional atmosphere. He shows up after a flight, changes clothes, cleans the fridge (WHOSE FRIDGE IS THIS), orders from the exact same chicken place for TWO YEARS, and then casually drops a conversation bomb that flips the entire power dynamic. I'm OBSESSED. The narrator is so careful—so meticulously calculated in every movement around Jihoon. Not looking at his bare torso. Avoiding eye contact. Reaching for the remote as a deflection. All these tiny physical performances of someone trying desperately not to feel something. And Jihoon? Jihoon notices everything. He catches the narrator staring. He snatches the remote. He reads the silence like a document. When he says "I still don't get what's funny. Is it wrong for two men to do that?"—that is NOT a random question. That is a man who has been circling this exact conversation for fifteen years and has finally stopped pretending he hasn't been. The narrator's internal monologue about the two types of defensiveness (protecting yourself vs. protecting someone else) and how BOTH apply in this moment? That scene alone justified every page. And then the grandfather's last words—"I want to go home"—and how the narrator couldn't even let him have that. Jihoon represents everything the narrator is afraid to want: directness, honesty, refusing to pretend. I am not ready for whatever explodes next between them.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or