Five By Five - Reviews

Five By Five
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The symbolism in these opening chapters is doing HEAVY lifting and I am not okay. Let me start with the display cabinet—that's the first thing the narrator's eyes land on, and it's basically a physical manifestation of memory itself. Twenty-five objects from twenty-five flights, each one a frozen moment someone chose to keep. The narrator keeps what Jihoon never asked for. Who is the collector and who is the cherished? The refrigerator magnets are another layer—someone puts them up, someone takes them down, and neither will admit it out loud. Then the movie within the movie: five couples, one same-sex couple, all meeting and breaking up in the same cafe. That final scene where the man stays behind after his boyfriend leaves and a stranger asks for his number—HE GLANCES AT HIS EX BOYFRIEND WALKING PAST BEFORE HANDING IT OVER. That is the emotional core of the entire chapter compressed into one gesture. The narrator watches this and immediately changes the channel because he CAN'T sit with it. And the grandfather's life support system—a machine keeping someone alive who just wants to go home—is the ultimate symbol of love as imprisonment. The narrator is paying for warmth that will vanish like vapor. He's holding on so tightly he's suffocating the very thing he loves. Meanwhile Jihoon, who collects souvenirs but also CLEAN FRIDGES and TELL THE TRUTH, seems to understand something the narrator hasn't yet: that sometimes letting go is the only honest way to love.
... Read More
This alley scene is one of those moments where the atmosphere does so much heavy lifting. The narrow passage between two buildings behind a bus station — you can already feel the claustrophobia. And then all those people filling that space, watching, waiting. The narrator deliberately doesn't look around, which is such a smart choice because it forces us to experience the tension through Jihoon's fear rather than our own curiosity about the threats. But the sensory details are everywhere if you pay attention: the cigarette smoke on Jihoon's clothes, the black lighter with 'Coffee Shop' engraved on it tossed at the narrator's feet like a warning flare, the cold alley air after the police leave and everyone scatters. That detail about the warm yellow light slipping from the grandfather's door — it's a memory flashback but it changes the mood entirely. It's domestic and tender against the brutality of the alley, and it makes the connection between past and present hit harder. The visual of Jihoon's father kneeling with his head down, crying through the night about his son, recontextualizes everything we've seen. Suddenly the alley isn't just a dark place with mean guys — it's another version of that living room, another place where someone is falling apart alone. And the narrator choosing to step into that darkness instead of walking away? That's not heroism, it's empathy wearing the costume of coincidence.
... Read More
'Forget it, just come!' — Coach's voice booming through the fence. Then Ji-hoon's response: 'Yes, Coach!' sharp as white vapor in winter air. The dialogue here is so perfectly calibrated to character. You can tell Ji-hoon's a baseball player by the brevity and snap of his responses. No unnecessary words. Just like how he talks to Seon-uk — 'Over there, the ball! Please help me pick it up!' — direct, informal, commanding but not mean about it. And then the senior girl's dialogue is SO different. 'Can I have your number?' 'I heard you came from Seoul, and you really do speak Seoul dialect. It's fascinating.' There's this performative quality to her speech, like she's been practicing this interaction in her head. Her friends laughing and spitting on the floor, the playful nudges — it creates this whole social ecosystem in one hallway scene. But the BEST dialogue moment is the village man bringing pork belly. 'Thanks, you're as handsome as they say.' 'The rumor is that you came back, and I've been busy but finally had time today to buy some meat.' This is such natural Korean countryside dialogue — the mix of humor, genuine warmth, and that awkward boundary-crossing that happens when elders give gifts to younger people they barely know. The Gyeongsang-do accent described in narration ('His tone was friendly') combined with the actual spoken lines makes it feel alive.
... Read More
I want to talk about how this chapter is paced because it's doing something really clever. It starts almost lethargic—the narrator is exhausted, moving through the apartment like a ghost, and the prose matches that energy. Long descriptive passages about the hospital, the phone screen, the blinking cursor. Then Jihoon enters and suddenly the tempo SHIFTs. Not dramatically, but perceptibly. Every sentence gets tighter, more pointed. The baseball commentary, the chicken, the movie, the remote control battle—each beat adds another layer of tension without raising the volume. It's like watching someone slowly realize they're in danger. The scene transitions are all done through object focus rather than time jumps: TV → chicken bag → fridge → remote → Jihoon's hair. These small pivots keep you moving forward without you noticing the gears turning. And that movie sequence—embedded inside the main narrative like a story within a story—acts as both relief and intensification. It gives the narrator (and us) a safe distance to process what's actually happening BETWEEN them, and then the author SLAMS that distance shut when Jihoon turns from the screen and says "I still don't get what's funny." From there, the pacing accelerates almost imperceptibly until the final paragraph where Jihoon delivers that monologue about fifteen years and thirty years and the time before they met. Each sentence gets shorter, more urgent, and the chapter ends mid-thought because the narrator literally can't finish processing what just happened. The structure mirrors the emotional arc perfectly: numbness → awareness → panic → surrender.
... Read More
I've been thinking about the baseball for days. I can't stop thinking about the baseball. The ball that Jihoon tossed during practice, told him to 'keep this as a memory,' and Seon-uk has carried around for FOURTEEN YEARS. Fourteen years. Since they were fifteen. The story opens with 'we were fifteen, and by next year, we'll be thirty'—that arithmetic is the whole theme right there. Time passing. Time running out. The space between who they were and who they're becoming. The baseball is everything. It's the token, the artifact, the unsaid thing between them. 'Even the ball floating above the fence must not have known either. That someone would cherish it for so long.' That line broke me. The ball didn't know. The fence didn't know. Nobody knew except Seon-uk, holding onto this dumb rubber sphere like it was sacred. And then there's the blood. Nosebleeds. Multiple times in these chapters. The physical toll of everything he's carrying internally—literally bleeding out. It's not just stress, it's the body refusing to contain what the mind won't release. The house too. Jihoon's immaculate, staged-for-sale home versus the messy reality of Seon-uk's emotional life. One is curated perfection; the other is chaos and forgetting and car mats you gift to someone and then can't bear to remember. What is this story really about? I think it's about how love that was never spoken becomes the architecture of your entire life.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this — the author has this incredible talent for making the most mundane moments feel like turning points. The entire bus stop scene in Chapter 27-28? Could have been three paragraphs. Instead, we get this whole sequence: Lee Ji-hoon blocking the way, their eyes meeting for the FIRST TIME since the baseball incident, the NAME MIX-UP (Seong-uk vs Seon-uk, I literally laughed out loud), and then this random but perfect detail about him calling your grandfather "old man." This isn't just filler. This is the protagonist's entire world tilting slightly off-axis. And then there's the parallel timeline narrative that starts hitting in Chapter 30-something. The adult Ji Seon-uk recalling flight schedules, the unexplained tension around Kang Young-soo's drinking party invitation, the weird ghost of a conversation about whether Seon-uk is gay. What I love is that the plot doesn't explain ANY of this. It just drops it on you and keeps moving. The adult Seon-uk avoided the drinking party, got kicked from the group chat, spent a sleepless night, and Lee Ji-hoon's message read receipt just... disappeared. That "1" next to the unread message that eventually vanished is one of the most painful plot details I've encountered this year. A single notification counter, and it carries an entire emotional breakdown. The bus schedule revelation (7:45 vs 7:48) also serves as this really clever structural device. It mirrors how these characters know each other — or don't. Lee Ji-hoon memorized the schedule for someone he barely knows properly, and the protagonist memorized Lee Ji-hoon's schedule without even realizing he was doing it. The plot keeps folding in on itself like origami.
... Read More
I have to admit something — I thought this might drag at first. Seon-uk's routine of waking early, camping at the bus stop, taking the same bus every day at the same time. On paper, that sounds like filler. But the author is playing a long game here, and it works. Each small detail accumulates: yesterday the bus came at 6:55, today at 7:00, the day before at 7:03. These tiny observations about the number 72 bus become this rhythmic heartbeat underneath the whole narrative. Then you have the school scenes cutting between Seon-uk studying alone in an empty classroom and Ji-hoon sleeping through morning assembly. Parallel routines, parallel isolation. The pacing here is almost meditative — quiet, deliberate, but underneath there's this current of anticipation. When does Ji-hoon acknowledge Seon-uk properly? When will the ball become more than just a ball? And then — BAM — the senior asking for his number. The pacing shifts instantly from quiet introspection to social awkwardness. Ten math problems to finish, phone vibrating every five minutes with messages he doesn't know how to respond to. The author uses this interruption of Seon-uk's controlled routine to remind us that his internal world isn't the only thing at play. There's this whole social layer he has to navigate too. Brilliant structural choice.
... Read More
The opening scene is pure atmospheric dread. A cuckoo clock ticking past 2 AM, a stoic face unusually pale, townspeople clustered like mourners before the funeral even starts. They're already wearing black. Not 'dressing for'—*wearing*. As if death here is so routine it predates the announcement. The protagonist's grandfather doesn't explain; he just exits into the dark, and the gate creaks open to reveal not him but Kang Youngsoo, red-eyed, bearing food like a peace offering or a penance. Later, the community center where women make kimchi becomes a gossip hub, but the real worldbuilding happens in alleys. That narrow passage between buildings, littered with tattooed arms and yellow hair, feels like the town's underbelly literally spilling out. And the incineration site where the protagonist empties trash—that's where the smoke from Lee Jihoon's cigarette first hits him. Decay isn't just thematic; it's olfactory, visual, spatial. The school's playground punishment runs feel like grotesque parody of baseball drills, the protagonist's math workbook ignoring the boy outside his window. Even the bookstore transaction—hesitating over 19,000 won, choosing cash over the parent-issued card—micro-buicks isolation into the economy of the town. Nothing here is neutral; every setting pulses with unspoken history.
... Read More
I need to sit with this baseball symbol for a moment. Ji-hoon gives Seon-uk the ball and says 'Just keep it as a memento for you.' A memento. Not 'here, thanks for picking that up' or 'my bad, you're welcome.' Memento. Something that marks a moment, preserves a memory, connects two people who might never speak again. Seon-uk's whole journey is about loss and preservation. He lost his parents' family unit. He lost his old school, his old friends. He lost the familiarity of Seoul life. And suddenly he has this dirty baseball that represents a single afternoon where someone acknowledged his existence — not as the village chief's grandson, not as the transfer student, but as someone worth asking for help with a simple task. The name tag detail is also symbolically rich. Ji-hoon noticing the color of Seon-uk's name tag tells him exactly which school division Seon-uk is in — but more importantly, it's how Ji-hoon identifies him without knowing his name yet. In a story about connection, this small visual marker becomes this bridge between strangers. And the bus itself — the number 72, arriving at consistent times, connecting Seon-uk and Ji-hoon daily — it's like this invisible thread tying their lives together. Seon-uk memorizing 4:02 PM as the time he got home? That's him marking another moment, preserving another piece of evidence that he exists somewhere new.
... Read More
The stakes in this sequence are layered like an onion and I love it. On the surface: a bullying confrontation where Jihoon is physically threatened by Park Cheol-seung and his crew. Simple, right? Wrong. Because the author keeps adding layers. First layer — Jihoon's safety. Second layer — the narrator choosing to get involved despite having zero reason to. Third layer — what happens to Jihoon if Cheol-seung's revenge escalates after the police report. And the deepest layer, which only becomes clear at the end: what happens to their relationship if they survive this? The narrator gambling on calling the police is terrifying because we know nothing about Park Cheol-seung beyond 'bad rumors.' He doesn't have backup, he doesn't have weapons, he has a phone and some knowledge from a school seminar. The tension during that call is unbearable — every second Cheol-seung debates whether to grab the phone feels like an eternity. And then the relief is short-lived because Jihoon's rage is a completely different kind of danger. When he's yelling 'Who do you think you are!' the physical threat is gone but the emotional volatility is maxed out. The author never lets you exhale. Even after the police arrive and everyone clears out, the conflict hasn't ended — it's just changed shape. Jihoon still has his fist raised. Still grasping the narrator's collar. Still shaking with something between grief and fury. The stakes keep climbing even as the immediate danger fades. That's skillful writing.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Lee Ji-hoon because WOW. This boy is everything. The way he asks Seon-uk to pick up the ball — he doesn't even look at him directly, just this casual gesture through the fence gap, like he already knows Seon-uk will come help. And then when he finds out they're at the same school, there's this tiny moment where he looks at Seon-uk's chest and notices the name tag. His expression freezes for literally a second before he smooths it over like nothing happened. That's such a loaded detail. He's trying to figure out WHO this person is without seeming like he's trying. Classic tsundere energy but like, more aware of it than your average manga love interest. And then Seon-uk — man, he's so observant but also so guarded. He memorizes Ji-hoon's name within a DAY. He notes the exact time he got home (4:02 PM). He tracks the bus schedule like it's some kind of lifeline. This kid is clearly someone who holds onto small anchors when everything else is falling apart. His parents divorced, he was yanked from Seoul, suddenly living with his grandfather. Of course he'd latch onto the fact that he shares a bus route with a baseball player. The dynamic between them is so quietly electric. Ji-hoon giving him the baseball as a memento — that's NOT casual. That's a significant gesture disguised as a throwaway line. And Seon-uk carrying it around on the bus, glancing at it repeatedly? He's holding onto something, anything, that makes this place feel less alien. I re-read that whole fence scene like four times because the subtext is just screaming.
... Read More
Okay first of all THIS OPENING LINE: "There are days when everyone in the world should come face to face, but not Lee Jihoon." I literally paused and re-read that. That is such a specific, aching kind of truth. This whole chapter operates on two parallel tracks and I am HERE for how they feed each other. On one level you've got the narrator's grandfather barely hanging on—hospital bills, skipped meals, searching online cafés for caregivers at 75 years old in an unconscious state. That storyline hits you in the gut because it's so quietly brutal. But then on the other level, Jihoon shows up and suddenly EVERYTHING in this apartment feels charged. The fact that Jihoon cleans the house before anything else tells you SO much about who he is without a single exposition dump. And that display cabinet with the 26th flight souvenir? Chilling. Because the narrator immediately thinks about who sticks the magnets on versus who takes them down. That's not just set dressing—that's the thesis of their entire relationship written in three sentences. The baseball scene, the movie scene, the fridge cleaning—all of these little moments stack up into something that feels like a pressure cooker building toward an explosion. And that ending? "The time we've spent together has already exceeded the time I lived before I met you"—I NEED to know what comes next.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or