Feng Yu Jiu Tian - Reviews

The storyline had potential, but it fell flat for me from the start. The main character, ML, subjected the original fake prince to severe abuse and even rape, ultimately leading to his tragic suicide. It wasn't his fault being kidnapped and made a scapegoat; why subject him to such cruelty? The original prince was a victim on all counts – the true villains should be his overprotective biological parents, who couldn't safeguard him. Additionally, the main character's victim-blaming attitude pushed them further into a negative light, as they seemed to blame the victim.

I registered an account specifically to pen this review. I gave it one star solely because it didn't involve rape; I couldn't proceed beyond Chapter 12 to fairly judge the entire novel. The main character (MC) lacks empathy – despite being in a different body, he engages in intimate acts with the rapist who abused the previous body. His behavior is insensitive, like he's okay with being kissed by someone who assaulted him.

The original prince's tragic backstory tugs at my heartstrings; a victim who never received love and ultimately took his own life, leaving no mourners. As for the male lead (ML), while I don't necessarily厌恶他作为强奸犯或阴谋家的角色, I despise his lack of remorse for raping someone repeatedly, even after his death. He seems to have no regard for the person whose body he profited from and shows no empathy for his actions that led to suicide. His acceptance of the situation and quick move on to enjoying the new occupant is truly despicable.

I appreciate stories with themes like jealousy, angst, and redemption, but this one pushed it too far for me. I would have preferred the story if it didn't involve transmigration and focused on the ML's struggle to win the original prince's love.

In this review, I'm expressing my strong disapproval of the MC and ML's lack of compassion, which is a deal-breaker for me. I'd prefer a story where Rong Tiang experiences extreme jealousy over the original prince, perhaps enduring hardships before finally winning him over.

All stories receiving less than 3-star ratings, I must say, shame on you! If this isn't your preferred genre, just admit it! Why leave a bitter aftertaste? How can a poorly executed story survive 29 volumes and still continue? Don't discourage potential readers who might want to explore a different perspective.

Do you believe the main character (MC) is weak and unappealing? Have you grown tired of overpowered and excessively intelligent protagonists? I have! I crave stories with relatable, struggling characters, not just constant sunshine and rainbows. When the MC transmigrated without a system or any cheat, he was naturally confused, like a typical teenager. How would you feel in his shoes?

The narrative goes beyond the MC's story; secondary characters also develop their own arcs. If you're not prepared for emotional depth and tragedy, that's understandable. But if you enjoy historical dramas like "Romance of the Three Kingdoms," give this a chance. The MC evolves from an ignorant pretend prince into a wise and cunning figure, primarily driven by survival instincts. His reliance on historical strategies, like Sun Tzu's "The Art of War," adds an ironic touch.

"Feng Yu Jiu Tian" is, in my opinion, a brilliant work. It's a rollercoaster of emotions, combining humor, sadness, genius, tragedy, and cunning. It tugs at your heartstrings and offers a solid, human narrative.

To be honest, I registered this account specifically to address negative comments about my favorite book. Yes, I may be a dedicated fan, but I have valid reasons for defending it. So, what if I did?

Oh my goodness, the overly emotional readers are at it again with their Pixel Rights fuss. It's just a genre, girls. Rating something low because you can't handle a bit of mature content isn't fair. Let me clarify: fiction authors aren't here to spoon-feed you lessons or preach. You should rate based on the story's quality, not the character development, especially the main love interest (ML).

A major warning: there's a toxic relationship coming up. If you're someone who easily gets upset, I suggest you skip this one. The romance starts off with hate and evolves into love, which is a common plot device. I admire the protagonist's lack of being an omnipotent being or having a magical system; he relies solely on his intellect, which adds depth to the story. The world-building is intricate, resembling a grand historical gay soap opera filled with war and politics – definitely worth a read.

As readers, we're meant to dislike the ML and the misunderstandings they face – it's a standard trope. Judging by the reviews, the author has successfully portrayed these elements. So, those three stars or lower seem unfair and biased, considering the overall quality of the narrative.

The only issue I have is the protagonist applying modern concepts in an ancient setting, seemingly claiming them as his own innovation.

This was my very first Chinese novel adaptation story I came across, but unfortunately couldn't complete due to limited reading resources. I stopped at volume 4 without knowing the conclusion. Despite its occasional dull moments, I found the story intriguing despite its dark undertones – it was quite enjoyable to read.

I initially discovered and read this story in a manga, and I really enjoyed it. Unfortunately, it hasn't been continued, which is why I'm sharing my thoughts here. Honestly, the main character (MC) can be quite annoying at times – he's stubborn, often reckless, and constantly complains about boredom. He's also easily manipulated. However, what I appreciate is his intelligence from his modern background, which he ingeniously utilizes in the era he finds himself in to outsmart foes.

As for the male lead (ML), I have nothing negative to say; he's deeply in love with the MC and always stands by their side, ready to protect them. The story has a well-paced progression, without feeling rushed, and the plot is clearly explained. Character development is solid, too. Of course, whether you'll enjoy certain aspects may depend on personal preferences. If you're looking for a longer, engaging read, I definitely recommend giving this a try.

The protagonist appears quite foolish, really. Upon being transported to a different world without understanding the situation, they recklessly act out of character instead of keeping a low profile. It's amusing, perhaps, if that's their character design, but personally, I can't stomach a protagonist who acts stupid for no apparent reason. They lack endearing innocence as well. Unfortunately, this kind of character has the potential to derail an otherwise intriguing storyline.

This is one of my absolute favorites. I wholeheartedly appreciate YuanShu's decision to revive this exceptional gem. The novel possesses all the elements that make it an outstanding read:

1) Our protagonist is intelligent, dashing, and wealthy, with a charming personality,尽管有点过于天真。
2) The romantic storyline, including a passionate and intense love interest, adds depth to the narrative.
3) Intricate political dynamics between royalty and the realm provide rich backdrop for the story.
4) The time travel element is particularly intriguing, as the main character effectively employs modern knowledge to thrive in the past.

Overall, it's a well-rounded and captivating tale.

This reading experience has been quite distressing. The main character (MC) is a disappointment to transmigrators and many modern readers. Despite the abundance of historical dramas showcasing the intricate nature of ancient societies, the MC naively trusts people, despite being vulnerable. While the initial chapters might be somewhat comprehensible, the repetitive instances of being deceived without any learning have made me seriously consider stopping. The MC's anger over not getting his horse, gullibility, and self-promoting behavior, acting as a "flatter-me-with-modern-knowledge" fame-seeker, are concerning. The male lead (ML) had warned him about the consequences of revealing his intelligence, which isn't substantial, yet the MC proudly flaunts it. To those who rate this negatively, I understand your perspective, and our opinions are grounded in our experiences.

Alright, I'm writing this review because I felt compelled to share my thoughts. The storyline of "Feng Yu Jiu Tian" is indeed intriguing, particularly its engaging war elements and the concept of uniting all kingdoms under one ruler – these aspects initially drew me in. However, I took a break from it but eventually resumed due to the captivating side couple, He Di and Zi Yan, who quickly became my favorites in the story.

As for the main couple, Feng Ming and Rong Tian, I must admit that I'm not a fan. Despite not outright hating Feng Ming, he doesn't come across as the intelligent, cunning character he's described to be. He seems overly girlish, childlike, and somewhat naive, which becomes frustrating at times. Feng Ming felt more like a female character from a shoujo manga to me, and his behavior annoyed me enough to consider dropping the series initially.

Rong Tian, on the other hand, is portrayed as quite abusive towards the original prince, An He. It breaks my heart to see An He suffer so much, and though I can understand a character being ruthless to others, Rong Tian crossed a line with his treatment of An He, making him a character I dislike.

The antagonist, Ruo Yan, is a formidable presence and serves as the novel's scariest character, earning the title. Both Rong Tian and Ruo Yan share similarities, and the antagonist's strength is undeniable.

While the plot itself is captivating, I feel it's been stretched out unnecessarily. The treatment of An He, who faced immense trauma and injustice, deeply affected my perception of the main couple. Feng Ming's constant blame on An He as the body's original occupant further soured my feelings. He Di and Zi Yan's relationship, though toxic, had a stronger appeal to me than the main pairing.

In conclusion, if you can overlook Rong Tian's abuse and tolerate Feng Ming's annoying traits, the intriguing plot makes "Feng Yu Jiu Tian" worth a read. However, for those sensitive to these issues, it might become unbearable. The plot remains the standout feature of the novel for me.

This was my first BL novel, and I've followed it closely for years, so it holds a special place in my heart. That might color my opinion slightly. I genuinely adore all the characters in the story, even Rou Yan, who's often portrayed as the "bad guy." At times, I find myself torn between which character Feng Ming should choose, which adds an interesting layer to the narrative. Feng Ming does face quite a few kidnappings or gets into trouble, which can become repetitive, but I appreciate how his character evolves with each challenge. If he didn't encounter these obstacles, I doubt he'd grow, as Rong Tian might shelter him too much. Instead, Feng Ming's journey showcases his determination to be on par with his partner. Their romantic relationship is sweet and honest, with their love developing quickly, unlike in many other novels. The story is filled with action, adventure, and diverse gay characters, resulting in multiple couples, which I find delightful. I wholeheartedly recommend this book, even considering Feng Ming's flaws, as I can't imagine anyone not enjoying it.

I would rate this a solid five stars. The only issue is the lack of a permanent translator, and it seems to be ongoing. I truly adore the narrative. However, if you prefer lighter themes or avoid heavy content, I wouldn't recommend this. Please don't spread false information. As you progress through the story, you'll grow to appreciate the characters. There's a wealth of loveable aspects within the tale.

Compared to other darker genres I've encountered, this one still strikes me as relatively mild. For those who are sensitive, it might not be the best fit, as the story revolves around Rong Tian and Feng Ming's intense bond. Regardless of their flaws, such as being ruthless or seemingly unintelligent, we know they have an unwavering love for each other. That's what truly matters.