Even If Your Regret Tries to Hold Me Back - Reviews

Even If Your Regret Tries to Hold Me Back
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Dion Sedrick is a gift to literature and I will die on this hill. Let me just bask in this exchange for a moment: 'I'm not merciful enough to accompany a servant who talks too much.' 'I, who have neither gold nor anything else, should keep quiet on my own.' WHO WRITES LIKE THIS?? The man is being verbally annihilated and he replies with poetry. 'Silence is golden'—literally, because he has no gold. The self-awareness is chef's kiss. And then the carrot field threat sequence is pure comedy gold: 'If it's useless, prepare to be planted upside down next to these carrots.' 'You might want to dig around carefully, you might still have the fortune you stole then. It would be good to add it to the expenses.' 'I must have been temporarily insane.' Dion apologizes with the formal 'you' after getting warned. The transition from casual to formal address as a threat indicator is a brilliant character detail—shows Ian's authority without any exposition. And Dion immediately plays along, scrambling off to prepare with theatrical deference: 'Your Majesty's faithful servant, Dion Sedrick, will now go to prepare for Your Majesty's safe journey to the destination.' Meanwhile, Helena's dialogue with her family is so raw it hurts. The difference in voices between characters is unmistakable. Eugene speaks in declarations and internal calculations. Ian speaks in brief, controlled bursts—he's a man who doesn't waste words. Matilda's dialogue is sharp, dismissive, casually cruel: 'What kind of Grand Duchess dresses like that? Not even wearing a single proper piece of jewelry.' She's inspecting Helena like merchandise at the door. And Viscount Owen? 'Do you perhaps have some money?' The man hasn't hugged his daughter in years and his first question is about cash. The dialogue does ALL the work here—no narration needed to tell us these people are monsters. But Helena's explosion at the end—'No matter how much you've given up on being human, you shouldn't be worse than beasts!'—that's the line. That's the quote I'm carrying with me forever.
... Read More
I need to talk about how this batch is STRUCTURED because the author is playing 4D chess with pacing and I am HERE FOR IT. Scene 1: The family confrontation. This is ALL dialogue, escalating from verbal abuse to physical violence to emotional execution. It moves FAST — you don't even get a breath between 'Where is the bottom for you people?' and SLAP. Then Helena's speech is the exhale. Long, devastating, unhurried. She takes her TIME listing their crimes. The pacing says: this is the moment she's been waiting for. Scene 2: The aftermath with the family. Immediate tonal whiplash. Helena just left in tears and blood and we cut to Matilda fanning herself and Eric yawning. The casualness is DEVASTATING. Five seconds of dramatic peak and suddenly we're back to business as usual. That's when you know these people are irredeemable. Scene 3: The ballroom. Eugene enters slowly, sipping wine, watching everyone. Deliberate pacing — almost bored. Then the Count opens his mouth and within THREE exchanges, Eugene has destroyed him. 'Consider it canceled.' That's it. That's all. The pacing snaps tight and releases. Scene 4: Night. Quiet. Almost gentle. Until Natasha mentions divorce and the whole thing CRASHES back down. The chapter ends mid-tension — 'contrary to expectation' and it just cuts. I had to immediately open the next chapter. Four scenes. Four different speeds. And I was gripping my phone the entire time.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the physical spaces in this novel feel so alive they could swallow you whole. That cemetery scene in Praeterita? Chilling in the best way. Helena spending her last coins on flowers that 'would neither quench her thirst nor fill her stomach' — what a devastating image of someone prioritizing emotional necessity over survival. The author paints that village as one of the poorest in the north, yet 'people here were always kind,' which creates such a painful contrast with the cold marble tombstones. And Eugene's journey through Evergale mansion — oh, the symbolism in those spaces is *chef's kiss*. Starting in the sun-drenched inn room where Helena dreams of being 'swallowed alive,' moving to the dark-clouded mansion exterior that contrasts with the bright interior where servants gossip, then to that garden corner with the yellow flowers Eugene usually avoids because of pollen sensitivity. Every location mirrors psychological states. The tea service scene where he touches the gold-handled cup engraved with his initials — that's where the realization hits him she must have engraved it 'suppressing her feelings that were about to burst.' These aren't just backdrops; they're emotional landscapes. The training grounds where knights feel 'empty' without her sparring partner energy, the bedroom where even the 'empty space beside her felt cold' — the worldbuilding operates on a level where architecture and nature actively participate in telling the story. I'm still haunted by that final image of Helena kneeling before two neatly placed tombstones with 'an awkwardly woven bunch of wild flowers' next to her new bouquet.
... Read More
The stakes in this batch are layered like an onion made of barbed wire. On the surface, Helena's conflict is obvious: her family wants money, she refuses, they try to force her. But the REAL conflict — the one that keeps me up at night — is internal. When Helena says 'To think I believed I could pretend to have a family with such trash,' that's not just anger. That's GRIEF. She's mourning the parents she wished she had while standing in front of the people who gave her life. She could have just said 'no' and walked out. Instead she engraved every betrayal like a curse. That's someone who cared TOO MUCH for too long. Eugene's stakes are different but equally high. He's trying to LIVESUM normally. Has remarried, has a stepdaughter who loves him, has political power. But Helena — gone, possibly divorced, possibly in love with someone else — and he's using Natasha to numb it. 'Helena made him feel incomplete when he should always be fulfilled.' COMPLETED. He's supposed to be complete. The fact that she breaks that completeness is the highest-stakes conflict in the whole book. And then there's the unnamed man who came looking for Helena five days ago. 'Shabby appearance like an ordinary commoner, yet with a handsome face that didn't match at all.' The text doesn't tell us who he is or what he wants. But Matilda immediately assumes the worst — that Helena ran off with a lover. The irony is KILLING ME because we KNOW Helena wouldn't do that. This mystery man is a ticking bomb and nobody in this story knows it except the reader.
... Read More
This passage is dripping with symbolism and I think the central metaphor is the ocean itself. Helena walks toward it almost reverently—'Go to the sea' is described as an instinctual call, something deep within her. The sea represents finality, silence, oblivion. It's also cyclical, just like her existence. Waves boil up like foam and then shatter, over and over, exactly like her regressions. But then the sea also becomes a place of rescue. Ian dives into it and pulls her back. The ocean that promised her peace refuses to let her go. This is the central paradox of her existence: she is cursed with being remembered. Every time she dies, someone finds her. Every time she thinks she's free, she's pulled back. The sea turning to blood when her red hair spreads through it—that's the world itself reacting to her suffering, or maybe her suffering coloring the world. The scar on her forehead from hitting it against a table while defying Matilda is another symbol worth unpacking. 'A scar that had gradually taken away her memories even into adulthood.' Her trauma is literally carved into her body, and it's erasing her. Yet Ian remembers her. The contradiction is brutal—he remembers her across thirteen years while she's losing herself through the very mechanism of her survival. And the child Paul bringing news that someone paid for his brother's funeral—charity, generosity, a stranger caring—this happens right before Helena decides she wants to die. The world keeps offering small proofs that people matter to other people, and she can't accept it. 'Since loving you was the reason for my life, now...' Her entire existence was tied to Eugene, and without that anchor, even death feels like something she has to fight for. The final image—Helena waking up in an inn, changed into dry clothes, with Ian beside her—this is rebirth symbolism. She died in the water and was pulled back. But does she want to be reborn? That's the question hanging in every line.
... Read More
Let me just say: the pacing in this section is absolutely relentless and I cannot breathe. We open with Helena in a deeply personal, slow, almost frozen moment at the cemetery—just her, the grass, the memories, the silence. Then BAM, cut to Eugene striding through marble halls with rhythmic footsteps, every scene escalating his irritation until he's throwing himself against a sword sparring partner. The training ground scene is kinetic, full of metallic sounds and unspoken tension, and then he's back in his office kicking the door open. Every beat pushes him further toward that encounter with the stranger, and when the stranger says his line and vanishes—Eugene is left standing there in defeat, surrounded by everything and still having nothing. And then the narrative pivots to Ian, who is basically running on pure adrenaline and obsession, covering ground at breakneck speed. Five days ago he was getting beat up, now he's commanding armies and riding toward Futuo. The author does something really clever here: instead of following Helena's journey (which we can't see), they show us three parallel tracks of people orbiting her absence. Eugene's track is internal and psychological. Ian's track is external and physical. The stranger's track is mysterious and disruptive. And Helena herself—her absence is the gravitational center pulling everything toward it. The chapter ends mid-conversation with Dion and Ian declaring they're going to Futuo, which is basically a cliffhanger wrapped in a setup wrapped in a question mark. Chef's kiss.
... Read More
Okay I need to sit down because that scene in the dark where Helena is having her full meltdown and Ian just... doesn't flinch. Doesn't get angry. Just stands there like an absolute rock while she's screaming at him. And then he says the line: "In the most wretched way, you killed me again in a way that's unbearably miserable!" — and I was NOT prepared for that level of raw vulnerability coming from a character who has been so stoic this whole time. She's begging him to leave, begging him to hate her, and he just gently rubs her whitened knuckles with his thumb. THUMB. RUBBING. HER KNUCKLES. After she just called him a murderer. This man is obsessed in the healthiest, most devastating way possible. "Even if you end up hating me for the rest of your life because of this, I'll save you again and again. Call it an obsession from fearing loss if you must." I am deceased.Absolutely deceased. The fact that he's willing to be hated by her forever rather than let her die is the kind of romance that makes you want to throw your phone across the room. It's not possessive in a creepy way — it's genuinely selfless and it KILLS me every time. And then the morning after? She leans out the window like she might jump and he says "I don't think you'd come out unscathed" — that warning tone disguised as casual concern. HE WAS WATCHING HER THE ENTIRE NIGHT. He didn't sleep. He just lay on the floor beside her bed and watched over her while she tried to die. That is not love. That is worship. Who hurt this man so he could love like this? Also who hurt Helena so she can only accept love through the lens of self-destruction? Both of them deserve everything. And also absolutely nothing because I can't survive this.
... Read More
This batch moves like a freight train and I am here for it. We open with Eugene's internal monologue about his pursuit of Helena—reflective, almost nostalgic, revealing his manipulative nature in retrospect. This is the kind of passage that rewards re-reading because on first pass you think it's romantic and on second pass you realize it's a psychological profile of a man who weaponizes affection. It's dense but not slow; the revelations come like mini punches. Then BAM—we cut to Ian and Dion traveling through Praeterita. The tone shifts completely. Warmth, humor, a kid offering flowers, a king accepting them. Dion's running gags about being threatened with carrot-planting. This section is lighter, almost fairy-tale-adjacent. It gives you room to breathe. But the author doesn't let you stay comfortable. Helena's section starts with that eerie silence at the mansion—"Is anyone here?"—and then the alcohol stench, the broken furniture, the slowly dawning horror that her family has imploded. The pacing here is deliberate and suffocating. Each detail lands heavier than the last: the missing servants, the hiccups from her father, Eric's bandaged face, the demand for money, the revelation about Basil. And then the confrontation escalates FAST. Helena goes from polite visitor to furious accuser in three exchanges. The author doesn't slow down to let us process—it's relentless. 'While you were flipping those paper cards and giggling, Basil died without even getting proper medicine!' And her mother's response? 'He was always a sickly child, don't be unreasonable!' The flashback to Basil's death on her birthday—where Helena realizes she's been conditioned across regresses to suppress her grief because 'Evergale is now your responsibility'—this is the emotional gut-punch that recontextualizes everything. Then we're back to the present, rushing to Basil's empty room, and the scene CRASHES into that final confrontation where Helena has lost all restraint. The chapter ends mid-sentence on Helena's scream. No resolution, no soft landing. Just raw exposure. And honestly? That's exactly what this moment needs.
... Read More
Let's unpack the symbolism here because this author is stacking metaphors like crazy. The marigolds Helena buys at the cemetery — the flower seller says they mean 'happiness that will certainly come,' yet she's visiting graves. That's not accidental. It represents hope persisting through grief, which mirrors Helena's entire situation: searching for happiness while standing on埋葬ed memories. Then there's Eugene's teacup with his initials, a gift from Helena she made 'one character at a time, suppressing her feelings.' He remembers the smile she gave him, but now it's 'blurry' — the physical object becomes a symbol of manufactured intimacy, something beautiful but built on hidden labor and suppressed emotion. But the deepest symbol is that yellow flower bed. Remember how the text says Helena 'extremely avoided flowers' in the mansion, removing vases everywhere, yet this one corner flourished under her care? That's her true self — the part she hid from society, from Eugene, from everyone. The gardeners notice 'even plants that cannot speak know it,' suggesting her genuine nature radiates outward even when concealed. And the dress! The olive-brown satin she deemed too extravagant for her position as Grand Duchess but would look beautiful on — it's armor she refused to wear, just like her skills in sparring or her taste for sweets she pretended not to have. Every material object in this novel becomes a vessel for unspoken truth.
... Read More
There's this one line from Ian that I keep coming back to: 'But I'm not sorry. I don't want to regret it either. And still, I don't dislike you.' Let me just sit with that for a moment. After thirteen years of searching, after crossing an ocean and risking his life, after finding her in the water and pulling her back, his version of a love confession is... don't dislike you? The restraint is everything. He could have said 'I love you.' He could have said 'I've been looking for you.' Instead he says something so deliberately underwhelming that it carries the weight of every word he didn't say. And Helena's reaction—her fury, her demand that he feel proud of himself, her accusation that he thinks he's done something good—that's her voice too. Sharp, defensive, lashing out because the alternative is falling apart. But here's what I really appreciate: neither of them is performative. When Helena screams 'Who are you to save me as you please?' it's not poetic. It's raw and ugly and real. And Ian doesn't counter with poetry—he just says 'It's okay. You can resent me all you want.' Two characters who have lived through endless cycles of pain speaking in a language that's stripped bare of pretense. The Emperor's dialogue at the beginning is also worth noting—'If you want, I can have you disguised as a servant and sent in.' Dion's response: 'Please wait for me!' His master whose 'mind had long since gone astray.' There's this dark humor in how the Emperor talks about planting spies in the Grand Duke's residence while Dion desperately flatters him. It's tonal variety that keeps the dialogue from becoming monotonous. And Paul! The kid says 'Aren't you Helen Noona? You moved away when I was seven or eight.' Simple, innocent, completely unaware that he's talking to a woman who's about to walk into the sea. The contrast between his bright, casual voice and the weight of everything happening around him is exactly the kind of thing that makes dialogue sing in this novel.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or