Even If Your Regret Tries to Hold Me Back - Reviews

Even If Your Regret Tries to Hold Me Back
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Oh my god, the way this chapter peeled back Helena's layers made me literally gasp. We're given these devastating reveals through Eugene's POV almost like a detective story where he's both investigator and victim. First the maids casually mentioning how much they miss Madam and how she always let them eat leftovers — that casual line hit so hard because we know Helena's been playing a role this whole time. Then the olive-brown dress conversation! When the maid says Helena found it too extravagant because it 'wouldn't uphold the dignity of Evergale,' and then Eugene realizes she actually cultivated that yellow flower bed herself... I swear my jaw dropped. The author is doing something brilliant here with dramatic irony — we readers already knew Helena had skills and tastes, but watching Eugene discover each secret piece by piece creates this agonizing tension. And that sparring scene with the knights! When they say 'sparring with her was my only joy' and Eugene has to force himself to ask 'Helena spars?' — you could feel his whole worldview cracking. The structure is perfectly crafted: domestic details first (the dress, the flowers), then physical evidence (the sparring), each reveal more shocking than the last. And that dream sequence sandwiched in? Genius. It mirrors his real-life fear — 'you who speak such words don't know' — before we even get the graveyard scene where Helena's honesty finally breaks through. This pacing is absolutely surgical.
... Read More
The opening of this section with the cemetery is already devastating, but then we get移 to the beach and the imagery just—elevates. 'The layered waves boiled up like foam and then shattered.' 'The salty sea breeze refreshingly tousled her hair.' There's this strange beauty in how the author describes Helena's walk toward the ocean. It's not desperate anymore, it's almost peaceful. 'If death had a smell, she rather liked that it smelled like the ocean.' And then the rescue scene—'The red hair spreading in the blue water was chilling. It was as if the sea was turning to blood.' CHILLING. That metaphor just rewrote the entire scene for me. The ocean goes from something beautiful and calming to something grotesque, and Ian diving in cuts through it like a blade. The description of Ian himself is also incredible: 'Silver hair like a melted full moon, lavender eyes as warm as lilacs. Though filled with nothing but cleanliness and warmth, perhaps due to his distinct nose bridge and jawline, his overall impression tended toward ruggedness. A man more suited to a battlefield covered in the scent of blood than to a spring field. Such a man was now crying.' This is the kind of contrast that stays with you—a warrior type, stained with violence and war, reduced to tears over a woman in the water. The visual of him kneeling on the sand, droplets falling onto her face, backlighting making it impossible to tell if they're tears or seawater—cinematic doesn't even cover it. Also the inn scene afterward: 'The bland patterned wallpaper commonly used in inns was monochrome.' That deliberate ordinariness contrasts with everything—the ocean, the rescue, the emotional explosion. It grounds the scene in a way that makes it feel real, not romanticized. Even the dark green linen fabric that replaced her wet clothes—so much care in the environmental details that makes you feel like you're actually there.
... Read More
We need to talk about Natasha's scene because it completely changes the temperature of everything we just read. One minute we're in this intensely intimate, almost tender moment between Helena and Ian, and the next — CLICK. CLICK. Natasha folding a silver dagger with skulls and grim reapers on it. The tonal whiplash is incredible. "A woman in love has no reason to refuse a gift from her beloved." This line hit me like a truck because it's so clearly NOT love. It's manipulation dressed in the language of romance. But what makes Natasha fascinating is that she's not a cartoon villain — she's calculating, self-aware, and genuinely unsettled that Helena gave up so fast. "Given that woman's personality, I thought she would have endured for several more years." That's almost respect. Natasha expected Helena to fight longer. That says SO much about both of them. And then the masterstroke: Natasha looking at the full moon and murmuring "Come soon, Grand Duke. We have so much to do." She's not just waiting — she's preparing. The fifteen days since Eugene last sought her out, the worry that Helena's absence affected him, the decision to act now before any lingering attachment can take root. This is a woman who understands the weaponization of vulnerability. What's terrifying is that Natasha might actually be right about Eugene. Those five years of marriage — whether built on love or hatred — create layers of connection that can't be erased overnight. Natasha's cold analysis of Helena's psychological state shows she understands people far better than Helena gives her credit for. The dagger itself is such a loaded object. Gifted with cruel meaning, used for comfort, she rubs it until her fingerprints turn red. Is she calming herself or sharpening her resolve? Both, probably. Natasha is the antagonist this story deserves — intelligent, patient, and utterly unhinged in the most compelling way.
... Read More
I need to just... I need to sit with Heidi for a second because her dialogue voice is absolutely vicious in the best way. Let me just drop a few lines: "Somehow I feel like I'm entrusting the fish to the cat." "As you know, I'm quite perfect in many ways. Looking at it from any angle, the throne suits me best, don't you think?" "So if you don't want to lose it, make sure you find your first love and come back." This woman is delivering threat-negotiations wrapped in glitter and calling it sibling banter. The narrative voice treats her exchanges with Ian as though they're the normal baseline of human interaction, and that's what makes them hilarious. Ian says 'I'm just repaying a debt' and Heidi's response isn't belief or skepticism—it's the quiet satisfaction of someone who already knows the answer and is just enjoying watching him dig himself deeper into a lie. The dialogue here operates on two frequencies: what's being said and what's being Weaponized. Compare that to Dion, whose voice is pure anxious administrative energy: 'But how could you not have given me any hint all this time!' He's the straight man in a comedy where everyone else is improvising. And Helena's internal monologue—mostly unvoiced, mostly compressed into these sharp, fragmented thoughts ('How nice would it be if emotions could be cut off as easily as cutting useless hair?')—creates this brilliant contrast. The court characters speak in complete sentences and subtext; Helena speaks in broken thoughts and silence. The author's voice shifts register depending on whose head we're in, and that's a skill most writers never develop. The dialogue isn't just characterizing—it's worldbuilding through rhythm. Every person sounds like their political and emotional station demands they sound. Nobody overlaps. Nobody sounds like they're reading from the same script. Which, knowing this author, is probably by very deliberate design.
... Read More
Okay so the way this chapter intercuts between three completely separate locations—Helena in that haunting cemetery scene, Eugene back at the manor trying to maintain composure while utterly crumbling inside, and then Ian's whole parallel storyline unfolding simultaneously—is honestly really well done. The Owen stable hand dropping that bombshell about Helena being "practically sold" to the Grand Duke, Ian punching people, discovering Dion was also there, the horse incident—it's chaotic in the best way. And that line from the stranger at Eugene's door: "It seems your wife had a good reason to leave"—what does that even mean?? Is this guy some kind of spy? A childhood friend? Someone who knows something about Helena that Eugene doesn't? Because clearly there are layers here we're not getting yet, and I am so here for it. The plot is basically setting up three separate quest lines converging on Helena: Eugene's desperate search, Ian's mission to find her, and whatever this stranger's agenda is. That's a lot of moving pieces and the author is juggling them without losing the reader. One thing I found slightly confusing was the transition into Ian's backstory—five days ago, he went to the Owen mansion, got told Helena was dead, almost died, and then five days later is at Evergale. Time compression is a bit heavy but it works for pacing. The real question hanging over everything: where IS Helena and why did she leave?
... Read More
Let me just say—the author does NOT let up. We open with Dion and the Emperor discussing their 'last attempt' to find Helena, and already you know something dramatic is coming. Then we cut to Helena at the cemetery, and the transition is so smooth you barely notice you've left the political intrigue behind. For several paragraphs we're just watching her exist in grief, which is already heavy, and then—'Booooo—' A ship's horn. The world shifts again. The structure here is basically: hope (someone might still be looking for her) → despair (she's going to the sea to die) → connection (the child Paul recognizes her) → almost-death (she walks into the ocean) → salvation (Ian pulls her out) → explosion (her rage at being saved) → vulnerability (the childhood flashback). Each beat hits harder than the last. The child Paul moment is genius pacing. Just when you think Helena is completely alone, a child runs up calling her 'Noona' and reminds her that she existed somewhere, that she was remembered. It gives her a moment of human connection before the fall, which makes the fall so much worse. And his line 'I'm on my way back after meeting with the funeral director to set a date' for his brother Theo—because someone generous gave them gold coins—this is Helena's last thought before she decides to die: wondering if she could have received something too if she'd arrived earlier. That detail about the funeral donation is devastating in its mundanity. Then the climax—the rescue, the confrontation, the 'I don't dislike you' line—and right when that peaks, we cut to childhood Helena against the wall. No transition, no warning. Just Bam, we're in trauma again. And the chapter ends on 'Her disheveled hai'—apparently cut off mid-sentence, which means there's more to come. The author is stringing us along mercilessly and I am here for it.
... Read More
Can we just talk about Eugene for a second because THIS man. He comes home after a long day, immediately asks about Helena, gets no answer, goes to train with a sword like a thousand times, and then when a random guy shows up looking for his wife, his whole demeanor shifts. The way he says "wife"—just that one word makes the stranger flinch. That's a power move and Eugene knows it. But what's actually heartbreaking is how much he doesn't understand their relationship. Ask Sir Agyle how much he knows about Helena and the knight basically says "lol you're the husband, learn about her yourself." Eugene's internal monologue about her being as constant as a stuffed deer head mounted in the hallway is either the most brutal roast ever or the most tragic confession of neglect. And then this stranger shows up and drops that "your wife had a good reason to leave" line and Eugene just... stands there defeated? Meanwhile Ian—Ian who punched people because they said Helena was dead, who is riding horses across continents, who has blood on his knuckles and still looks dignified somehow. This guy is a force of nature. And the contrast with Eugene is so sharp. Eugene has a title, power, a mansion, and still can't reach Helena. Ian has nothing but his obsession and he's closer to finding her. The triangle between these two men and the absent Helena is the most interesting dynamic in the book right now.
... Read More
"A pleasant time with family." Could there be a more dissonant sentence? I read that line and actually had to put the book down for a second. Because the author took the most generic, Hallmark-card phrase in the English language and turned it into something that sounds like glass grinding in your ear. Helena's response isn't anger. It isn't sadness even. It's this absolute, suffocating wrongness—like someone handed you a mirror and reflected back a version of your life that never existed. The coachman means well. That's what makes it unbearable. The whole chapter is built on this kind of emotional whiplash. You have Helena, who has spent her entire adult life performing versions of herself that aren't real, arriving at the one place where she's supposed to be able to stop performing, and finding that the performance is all she has left. The Grand Duke's physician told her to 'take deep breaths and clear her mind,' which is the kind of advice that sounds helpful until you realize it means she has panic attacks regularly enough that someone prescribed breathing exercises. That's not a throwaway detail. That's a character sketch in two sentences. Meanwhile, three pages away, Ian is riding into the night thinking about Helena the way people think about religious experiences. 'Helena. I'm finally coming to you.' No fanfare, no declaration of love, just this quiet, almost domestic certainty that after ten years and an empire and a thousand battles, his destination is simply... her. The contrast between their emotional states—her paralysis and his momentum—is what makes the romantic tension feel earned rather than manufactured. They're not destined because the plot says so. They're destined because both of them have been orbiting the same gravitational center for a decade without knowing it.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about this scene where Ian saves Helena from drowning because HOLY. Like, the text says his lips pressed to her forehead repeatedly, kissing it like he was combing through her hair, and calling her name in a voice she was hearing for the first time yet somehow not. That line hit me so hard I actually had to pause. And then her response—she's furious. Absolutely boiling with rage that he saved her. 'Who are you to save me as you please?' This woman has died so many times across so many cycles, each one more painful than the last, and the one person she actually loved in all of them is the reason she can't even die in peace. But here's the thing that destroyed me: when she yells at him and calls him a complete stranger, he just says 'It's okay. You can resent me all you want.' And then drops the bomb—'But I'm not sorry. I don't want to regret it either. And still, I don't dislike you.' DON'T DISLIKE YOU. After thirteen years of searching, after crossing oceans and enduring with the sole resolve to protect her, he says he doesn't DISLIKE her?! The restraint is killing me. Also the detail that his molars were clenched, that he felt unbearable self-reproach because he thought he was too late—that's not someone who merely 'doesn't dislike' her. That's someone who has never stopped loving her across every single cycle. What I love most is how Helena's anger isn't really about him saving her. It's about the fact that even in her final act of autonomy—choosing her own death—he took that away. 'Can't I even decide about my own life?' That question has been haunting her through every iteration. She loved Eugene, she lost him, she tried again and again, and now the sea won't even take her. The irony is brutal. I also noticed the flashback structure—right after Ian saves her, we cut to young Helena crying against a shabby wall while Matilda screams at her. 'Just looking at your face makes me so angry I can't stand it!' And then the child Helena whispers 'She promised, she has to find me.' This parallels so perfectly with Ian finding Helena at the beach. The girl who waited for someone who never came vs. the woman someone finally found. I'm not okay.
... Read More
Okay so can we just talk about how brilliantly the plot threads are woven here? Because on the surface you've got Helena arriving back at her village, which feels like a quiet character moment, and then you've got Ian declaring he's going on a secret trip to the Eastern Empire, which reads like a political adventure setup. But the real masterstroke is the structural irony—the author cross-cuts between them without saying a word. Three weeks before Helena's divorce announcement, Ian is already riding toward her across an entire sea. That's not coincidence, that's architecture. And then Eugene appears with his little coin-roll scene, flashing back six years to when he first encountered Helena, calling her '50 Krsant' like some cruel joke of a nickname. The timeline is doing heavy lifting here—Helena's past as the scorned village girl, Eugene's twisted devotion, Ian's decade-long fixation, all converging on this one pivot point. The plot isn't just moving forward, it's folding back on itself like origami. Every reveal compresses years of history into a single paragraph. I kept wanting to re-read sections because the causal chain is so tight—you can trace every current decision back to a wound from eight years ago. What's wild is that none of these characters know what the others are doing. Helena has no idea Ian is coming. Eugene doesn't know Ian exists in this context. And Ian's walking into a situation where everyone's playing from incomplete information. That's not just dramatic irony, that's a powder keg.
... Read More
The storm sequence in Chapter 54 is one of the most visually striking scenes I've read in ages. Let me just paint it for you: lightning strikes like a scream, oil lamp goes out, total darkness, and suddenly all you have is Helena's racing heartbeat and Ian's rough breathing. The author strips away every visual cue and forces you to experience this scene the way Helena experiences it — disoriented, claustrophobic, raw. You're not watching from a distance, you're IN that room with them. "Thump-thump-thump. It sounded like someone vigorously knocking on a door." That line made me physically press my hand to my own chest. The metaphor of heartbeat as knocking — is someone trying to get IN or trying to get OUT? Both, apparently. That's the whole novel in one image. Then the morning scene is such a stark contrast. Sunlight so bright it's painful, the smell of fresh bread, cart wheels on the street, ordinary people doing ordinary things. Everything feels wrong because Helena is still alive. The author captures this beautifully: "It felt like sneaking a peek at the aftermath of a story that had already concluded." That line alone is worth the price of the book. The world keeps moving when you're not ready for it to. And Ian sleeping on the floor? The detail of fresh sunlight pouring through the window because the curtains are folded back — this is a man who didn't even make himself comfortable because he was guarding her through the night. The worldbuilding here isn't about castles or magic systems, it's about how a single room becomes the entire universe for two broken people. The storm outside mirroring the storm inside is a classic technique but the author executes it with such precision that it never feels cliché. By the time the rain starts, you're so deep in Helena's head that the weather doesn't feel symbolic anymore — it feels real.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is a masterclass in controlled escalation. Chapter 54 opens at maximum volume — Helena is screaming, lightning is striking, the oil lamp crashes to darkness. It's chaos. And then, within the same scene, it collapses into the most quiet moment: two people breathing in the dark, heartbeats echoing, Ian rubbing her knuckles. The author takes us from a thunderstorm to a whisper in three paragraphs and makes it feel completely natural. The structure of the confrontation itself follows a perfect arc. Helena attacks → Ian absorbs → Helena escalates → Ian holds ground → Helena physically fights → Ian overpowers → storm interrupts → they lie in silence → "Good night." That ending. THREE WORDS. After all that violence, all that emotional devastation, the chapter just... ends with good night. The anticlimax IS the point. It mirrors how life goes on even when your internal world is collapsing. Then Chapter 55 with Natasha — short, sharp, chilling. The dagger clicking, the fifteen-day gap, the full moon. It's a structural breather that actually ramps up the dread. We know something is coming. The pacing tells us without showing us. And Chapter 56 opening with painful sunlight — the slow reveal of Helena waking up, the sensory details accumulating (bread smell, cart wheels, street noise), then Ian's voice cutting through like a blade. The author stretches time in the morning scene the way they compressed it in the storm scene. Morning feels longer because Helena has to face reality. Night was escape; day is confrontation. The chapter breaks are also doing heavy lifting. Each one lands on a beat that makes you immediately open the next. Not cliffhangers in the traditional sense — more like emotional freefalls. You read "Good night" and you NEED to know what happens when she wakes up. The structure doesn't tug at your sleeve, it pulls you by the wrist.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or