Even If You Despise Me - Reviews

Even If You Despise Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Can we just talk about Iden for a second? Because this guy is some next-level awful human being and I have so many thoughts. The fact that Selina is the ONLY one who fights back against him — she snaps at him about his mother deafness and suddenly he gets this satisfied smirk like he won something. What does that say about their dynamic? He's been tormenting her since forever and the one time she actually lashes out, he leans in even harder. That's not just bullying, that's power play of the most toxic variety. And the worst part? No one stops him. The maids literally continue fixing her hair afterward like nothing happened. "Well. You do look a bit better all dressed up. Not that anyone's going to care what you look like." He says this with a CHEERFUL smile. Who does that? Who can be genuinely cruel and then immediately chipper like flipping a switch? But then Calix walks in and everything shifts. He doesn't just appear — he appears like sunlight cutting through gloom, which is honestly such a perfect description. The way he takes her hand and says "or is it possible... that the groom has changed overnight?" He knew. He knew exactly what was happening and he chose that moment to walk in. Whether that's genuine heroism or calculated performance... honestly I can't tell yet and that keeps me up at night. Then her father calls her a "disgusting little bastard" while smiling. SMILING. At his own son-in-law-to-be. The fact that he says "the first trial" — implying MORE trials are coming — and then quietly sends her to Iden's room afterward? That's not a father. That's a man who sees his daughter as a chess piece and I am SHOOK that he's this openly ruthless.
... Read More
Okay let's talk structure because this chapter is a masterclass in tension building and I need to unpack why it works so well. We open IN MEDIO RES — right in the middle of Iden tormenting Selina. No warm-up, no context, just pure conflict. That's bold. Most authors would ease you in, but here we're immediately thrown into the fire and Selina's internal monologue about wanting to ignore him but being pushed past her limit — that's instant character establishment. We learn everything we need to know about their dynamic in the first few paragraphs. Then the knock at the door. The head lady-in-waiting confirms Calix hasn't arrived. Selina's internal spiral — "endless darkness," "windowless cellar" — hits rock bottom. And THIS is exactly when the author brings him in. Not a moment sooner, not a moment later. The timing is surgical. Rock bottom → miracle entrance. Classic structure but executed perfectly because we've earned the despair first. The walk down the aisle is where pacing really shines. Short, sharp exchanges between Calix and Selina, his cold politeness melting into something warmer, the whispered promises — it builds steadily. Then her father appears and drops the "first trial" bomb. Just when you think the chapter is wrapping up with the wedding completion, BAM — more conflict. And the final beat where Maya leads her NOT to the dressing room but to Iden's room? That's a cliffhanger disguised as a transitional moment. The chapter doesn't end with celebration, it ends with dread. My only tiny note: the transition from Calix's entrance to the ceremony felt slightly rushed compared to the slow burn of the opening. But honestly, that's a minor quibble. The author knows how to keep you turning pages and this chapter proves it. I went from hating Iden to holding my breath at the ending in under 2000 words.
... Read More
The dialogue in this passage works because everyone is saying something different from what they mean. Selina says I like potatoes, but she means I am hungry and ashamed and grateful and four other things at once. Calix says Open up, but he means I want to care for you even though I do not know how. When he later says At the very least, I can tell you are in no shape to walk back like that, he is masking concern with criticism. The soldiers are the funniest voices. Rochester's You might just have a rival for your affections—a potato—is genuinely witty. Zenfri's I told you not to bother—she is a noble lady carries years of resentment in three words. The unnamed soldier's Do you think milady would like sweet potatoes too? is the kind of awkward question that reveals a character completely—he is trying to be nice and failing, which makes him lovable. But the most important dialogue is the silence. Calix does not say I was worried. Selina does not say I was scared. Neither says the thing that would actually fix everything. Their speech is functional, not vulnerable. This is how people who do not trust each other talk. The narrative voice outside dialogue is equally sharp—the author does not explain feelings, only actions. She wrings her fingers. She hides behind her hair. She bows her head. The voice trusts us to read between lines. When Calix wraps his coat around her and says Here, put this on, there is no elaboration. The gesture is the emotion. This restraint is what makes the later silence hurt. We already know these characters cannot speak honestly. The dialogue teaches us that before the plot takes that ability away completely.
... Read More
I keep coming back to the convent. It's not just a setting, it's THE symbol of everything that's broken between these two. Calix goes there expecting to find proof that the girl who saved him existed—proof that his trauma wasn't imagined, proof that someone cared enough to stay. He finds nothing. Empty halls. Locked doors. Just silence. And Selina? She had the SAME hallucination. She walked in her sleep toward the same empty place. Is the convent a purgatory? A shared dreamspace? A literal manifestation of their combined wound? I'm honestly not sure and that uncertainty is what makes it so effective. Then there's the dress scene, which I swear is loaded with symbolism I can't even articulate properly. The pin sticking into Selina's back—that's Calix literally being pricked by the consequences of his own choices. He's been handling her with pinpricks of controlled closeness, never fully touching, never fully letting go. And when he finally removes the pin and touches her bare skin? That's the moment the fortress cracks. He traces her nape, his mouth on her skin, and he's trying to figure out if she's real or another phantom—another ghost like the girl from the convent. "I can't tell where you end and your act begins." That line though. That's the entire theme of this novel in one sentence. It's about authenticity in a world where everyone is performing—where Selina was sent as a political pawn, where Calix performs coldness to survive, where even their bodies might be lying to them. The question isn't whether they'll fall in love. It's whether love can exist when neither person knows if the other is genuine.
... Read More
Okay I NEED to talk about the glove scene because this is THE moment that broke me open. Calix asks Selina for a dance, she refuses (because she can't dance, obviously), he misinterprets it as her already sharing her first dance with someone else—Waldemar—and then decides they're leaving immediately. Which is honestly kind of a mess on his part. He's so wrapped up in his own narrative that he doesn't even ask her what's actually going on. But then—THEN—in the carriage, when she's shaking and anxious, he just... notices her gloves are uncomfortable. And takes them off her. And says that line about doing things for each other that you could do alone being one of the virtues of marriage. WHAT. That is SO Calix. He doesn't know how to be tender directly, so he wraps it in philosophy. He watches her sleep. He puts his coat over her shoulders when she falls asleep. These are not the actions of a man who is cold or manipulative. They're the actions of a man who has completely lost his ability to process his own emotions and is now accidentally stumbling into genuine care. And Selina—she's caught between resentment and pity, between remembering the gentle boy he used to be and hating the calculating man he's become. She studies his sleeping face because even his defenselessness feels like something she's not allowed to have. That dynamic is devastating. They're so close and so far apart simultaneously.
... Read More
Okay I need to process this scene because my heart is still recovering. Selina is standing there, absolutely defeated, convinced her future is a windowless cellar, and she's basically preparing herself to die inside at this wedding. She's already said her goodbyes to hope. And then Calix walks in. The line that destroyed me: "I prayed." She says this like it's the most natural thing in the world, like of course she prayed — even after everything, even after he threatened her with a sword the night before, even after every reason she had to believe he'd never come, she still prayed. That's not just romantic. That's desperate, human, achingly real. She clutched her trembling hands together and prayed to whatever god was listening just to stay by his side a little longer. And then Calix — the man who literally yesterday seemed impossible to reach — presses a kiss to the back of her gloved hand and whispers, "From today on, I intend to be a good husband to you." SELINA'S WORDS, NOT MINE. But I had to write them down because this moment is everything. The physicality of it all — the warmth of his lips through the gloves, the way he takes her hand and leads her, the shiver she feels — it's so intimate and so carefully orchestrated. Is it real? Is it performance? Probably both. But here's what got me: she thinks, "A new flutter of excitement bloomed in her chest — the hope that maybe this relationship could turn out well after all." That word "maybe." She doesn't dare hope fully. She's been hurt too many times. She wants to believe he doesn't hate her, that this isn't another trap, and that tiny sliver of hope is both beautiful and heartbreaking. Meanwhile the imperial princess is flirting RIGHT IN FRONT OF HER and Calix pulls Selina closer and says "I rather like my new bride" like it's nothing, like he's making a statement that basically draws a line in the sand. Selina's cheeks burn. Is it embarrassment? Is it something else? The author doesn't tell us and I am SCREAMING.
... Read More
Let's talk about how this section moves, because the pacing here is deliberately, masterfully uneven. We open at the ball—social tension, unspoken hurt, Calix's jealousy simmering under polite conversation. Then the abrupt decision to leave. The Marquis interception. The performative farewell. The carriage ride. The stop. The introduction of new characters. Each beat lands at a different temperature. The ballroom sequence is claustrophobic. Every exchange is loaded. Calix asks for a dance, Selina declines, he withdraws. Her father intercepts. They leave. It's a tight knot of anxiety that the author doesn't loosen until they're actually in the carriage—except even then, the anxiety just transforms rather than disappears. Selina's worried about the journey. Calix is exhausted but hiding it. The Marquis's whispered threats linger. Then the carriage slows everything down. Literally—fifteen days of travel compresses into a single night of dialogue and observation. The author uses the stop at the campfire as a breath, a pivot point where the perspective opens beyond just Selina and Calix. Rochester and Zenfri arrive like a door opening onto a new room. The cliffhanger isn't dramatic—it's barely a cliffhanger at all. It's just the chapter ending mid-conversation with a greeting. But it works because we've been riding this emotional wave for pages and we NEED to know what happens next. The author trusts the reader to stay engaged without a bang.
... Read More
I'm still thinking about how each character sounds completely distinct and I can't stop replaying their exchanges in my head. Iden's voice is venom wrapped in casualness. "Maybe he realised just how worthless you really are?" said with a sneer. "It must be obvious." The punctuation, the phrasing — he doesn't shout, he doesn't need to. His cruelty is precise and surgical. And that line about pearls on a pig? "It's like putting pearls on a pig." It's such a vivid, original insult that I immediately remembered it. He's not just mean — he's creatively mean, which makes him infinitely more annoying and memorable. But Calix is where the dialogue gets really interesting. On the surface he's all politeness — "I came here today to get married" with an innocent puzzlement. "Thalia's traditions, huh? Seems you've forgotten this is the Empire." He plays the charming nobleman perfectly for the witnesses. But underneath? "You were always beautiful, but today you're positively radiant." Then immediately deflects with "Is there some hidden meaning behind telling you you're beautiful?" This is a man who says exactly what he wants to say while making it seem accidental. The subtext IS the text with Calix. The imperial princess is fascinating in her own right. "Sir Calix, you're even more handsome than I'd heard." Said directly to HIM while Selina exists in the room. And then the pivot: "Did you know I was originally supposed to marry you?" The fake modesty, the veiled threat — "that wasn't my wish" implying she gave up something for Selina's sake. Every line is a performance. And Selina's father Bryson: "Disgusting little bastard." Muttered with a SMILE. That's three words that tell you everything about this man. He calls his own daughter disgusting and says it while looking at his future son-in-law like they're sharing a private joke. The casual brutality of his dialogue — "you should have done whatever it took" — makes him sound like he's giving parenting advice, not discussing human trafficking-adjacent politics. The author's voice throughout is sharp, observational, and unafraid of letting characters be genuinely awful. No one is purely good or purely evil here — everyone has edges, and the dialogue makes sure we feel every one of them.
... Read More
I have never read a passage that swings so hard from comedy to genuine dread. Selina eating that potato with desperate gratitude—she remembers dipping roasted potatoes in salt at the convent and feeling like she owned the world—and then Calix appearing with another one, wrapping it gently to her lips, and I was melting. This is the moment the romance should bloom. Instead, the author takes us into darkness. Ari leads Selina away from the fire, away from safety, away from the only person who might protect her. The climb is hard. She is out of shape. The trees close in. She reaches the cliff and for one perfect moment sees her old prison transformed by moonlight into something beautiful, and Ari brushes her cheek like a blessing. This is the emotional peak before the fall. Then the growl. Then the pack closing in. Selina runs, falls, tears her dress, scrapes her legs, and cannot even scream because she is too afraid of what might hear her. The solitude is brutal—no Ari, no Calix, no one. Just her and the dark. And then he finds her. Not with comfort, but with anger. He asks what she is sorry for, and she apologizes for wandering off, and he presses about the border, and she lies again. The emotional whiplash is exhausting. You want her to tell the truth. You want her to trust him. But she cannot. The intimacy of the piggyback ride is undercut by his coldness. She smells his coat on him—tobacco and something uniquely him—and feels dizzy, but he does not soften. The chapter ends with two weeks of silence. Two weeks. I have never wanted a couple to just talk to each other more in my entire reading life.
... Read More
I need a minute. Just give me a second. THE KISS. Let me walk through this because my heart cannot process it fast enough. Selina is standing there, freshly told she needs to murder the man she's emotionally compromised over, and Calix is out here—smoking some bittersweet herbal cigar, making playful remarks about her dress, genuinely softening when he thinks she's ill. The man is trying to care for her while being completely unaware that she's holding a knife to his metaphorical throat. And then he tilts her chin up and says 'I believe curiosity should be indulged, but only up to a point' and KISSES HER like his life depends on it. 'Open your mouth.' THREE WORDS. Three words and Selina completely unravels. The author writes 'Almost before she could process his words' and I WAS THERE. I felt that. The helplessness of it. The way she clamps her mouth shut like it's a reflex, like even her body doesn't trust itself around him. And then he cups her cheeks and coaxes her open and suddenly she's the one making sounds she didn't know she could make. But the most devastating line in this entire passage is the simplest one. When he breaks away just enough to murmur 'Don't forget to breathe'—that is a man who is losing his mind and trying to ground himself in something physical, something real. And when Selina gasps for air and he immediately captures her lips again, rougher this time? That's not romance. That's desperation. That's two people who are both running from something and using each other as an escape hatch. And then FOOTSTEPS. Of course. Because the universe hates happy endings. Selina is completely oblivious until the sound of shoes on stone shatters the moment. She was so lost in him that she didn't even hear someone approaching. That level of surrender from a girl who's been guarding herself her entire life? That's the most romantic thing I've ever read and I will not be taking questions at this time.
... Read More
There's a passage in this section that I keep returning to like it's a film scene I can't stop rewatching. Calix has fallen asleep. His long legs are folded awkwardly in the carriage, but his face is perfectly composed. Selina watches him. The narration describes him as an angel lost in peaceful slumber, which is such a deliberate contrast to the cold, calculating creature he presents during the day. The ballroom scene earlier is all glitz and performance—crimson eyes, polite smiles, strategic positioning—but the carriage is just darkness and quiet breaths and the soft sound of wheels on road. Then the stop. Night has fallen. Soldiers around a campfire. Selina steps out and they all go silent. That moment—when the noise dies and she's suddenly hyperaware of every pair of eyes on her—is one of the most visceral atmospheric pieces I've read this year. You can feel her isolation. She's the wife of their commander, the daughter of the man they despise, and nobody quite knows how to categorize her. And then Rochester appears. Bright hair, puppy-dog eyes, laughing. The tonal shift is so sharp it almost hurts. One second you're holding your breath, the next you're breathing again because someone is genuinely, unnecessarily cheerful. Zenfri's dry entrance right after—exhausted, blunt, saying exactly what he means—completes the portrait. These two men represent two halves of Thalian military culture, and the world suddenly feels enormous and lived-in.
... Read More
"Apparently, doing things for each other that you could easily do alone is one of the virtues of marriage." I am not okay. I am sitting here not okay. Let me unpack why this destroyed me. Calix is a man who plans everything. He strategizes battles. He manipulates social gatherings to make himself look good while secretly using his wife as an intelligence asset. He notices every detail about the political landscape. But somehow, in a carriage rolling through the night, the most vulnerable thing he does all episode is remove someone's gloves. And then he justifies it by turning it into a principle. That is honestly the most romantic thing I have ever encountered in fiction. He's saying: this matters to me, but I can't say that directly, so I'll frame it as marital philosophy instead. Selina's internal monologue during this whole sequence is equally devastating. She keeps trying to reassure herself—fifteen days is fine, we'll stop to rest, I'll be okay—but her body tells a different story. She freezes when Calix looks at her. She studies his sleeping face like it's a language she forgot how to speak. She's grateful for his coat and terrified of what that gratitude means. The romance here isn't in grand declarations. It's in the space between what they say and what they mean. It's in the way he notices she's tired before she admits it. It's in the way she memorizes the shape of his eyebrows when he's unconscious because that's the only time she's allowed herself to really look.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or