Even If You Despise Me - Reviews

Even If You Despise Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The atmosphere in this section is Chef's Kiss. The author builds this entire scene like a film director would—starting wide, tightening the frame, then going IMMEDIATELY intimate. Let me break down why the sensory details work so well. First, the banquet hall. We never actually go inside, but the author establishes it through absence. Selina excuses herself, Maya hurries back toward it anxious about being scolded, Calix escapes the imperial princess's 'ceaseless chatter.' The hall is this oppressive, suffocating space where everyone is performing. And the terrace? The terrace is freedom. Cold air, open sky, a railing to lean against. The contrast is deliberate and it works. But the real star of this passage is the CIGAR. Think about it—smoke curling around Calix, the bittersweet woody scent infused with Thalian herbs, the way Selina describes it like she's discovering a new world. 'Almost like something you'd smell in a forest.' This is a girl who has been locked in a convent her entire life, and here is Calix offering her something that smells like WILDNESS. The smoke becomes a metaphor for everything she's never experienced—danger, freedom, intimacy, the outside world. Then there's the dress. Oh god, the dress. The author spends actual words describing how sheer the muslin is, how the neckline threatens exposure, how a single tug on a ribbon could unravel everything. The dressmaker's intent is 'all too clear'—this is armor that's also a trap, just like Selina's entire existence. She's on display, vulnerable, expected to perform femininity while harboring a lethal secret. And that ending! Footsteps. The sudden intrusion of reality into what should have been a private moment. The author doesn't even tell us who's coming—just the sound of shoes—and suddenly the whole delicate atmosphere shatters. The terrace goes from sanctuary to danger zone in one sentence. That's masterful scene crafting.
... Read More
I keep coming back to the sensory details in these chapters because the author really knows how to paint a picture. Let me start with the opening scene — Selina getting dressed while Iden torments her. The maids fussing over her, the bracelet on her arm that Iden flicks like it's worth nothing, the pearls-on-a-pig metaphor that just CUTS. "It's like putting pearls on a pig." That's not just an insult to her appearance, that's a statement about her PLACE in this world. She doesn't belong in luxury. She was never meant for this. And yet here she is, being dressed for a royal wedding. Then the ballroom: "glittering chandeliers, opulent decorations — a space fit only for the most important figures in the Empire." It sounds magnificent but read between the lines and it's suffocating. Selina thinks the dress is "even more suffocating than I expected." The setting itself is pressing down on her. This isn't a fairy tale wedding — it's a political transaction happening in a room full of people who are all calculating something. The visual contrast between Calix before and after he appears is chef's kiss level. Before: Selina in shadow, trembling, expecting nothing. After: "he was as dazzling as sunlight cutting through the gloom; the shadow that only appears when the sun itself rises." This is such a deliberate metaphor — Calix isn't just handsome, he's THE light in her darkness. And then the wedding scene itself, draped in "holy white," with Calix beneath it like some kind of golden figure at an altar. The imagery of religion and commitment mixed with cold political calculation is haunting. And ending on Iden's room? That's the author deliberately shifting from the brightest, most public moment to the most threatening private one. The contrast between the holy ceremony and where she's being sent next... I literally gasped.
... Read More
The pacing in this section is *chef's kiss*. Let me break it down because the author really knows what they're doing. First, we open with the aftermath of two weeks of Calix completely ignoring Selina. Cold open, no explanation, just "he either ignored her completely or walked away as if she didn't exist." You immediately feel the weight of that duration. Then Rochester appears and gives us exposition about Calix's "fortress"—which serves double duty as both character insight and plot propulsion. Selina now HAS a goal: get through that door. But then BOOM, the carriage door opens and Calix is there. Perfect comedic timing that also raises the stakes. His first line after TWO WEEKS is "Get out." The contrast between silence and violence is devastating. Then the chapter pivots hard to Calix's POV and we get the convent reveal. This is where I stayed up until 2 AM because the author dangles the biggest question of the novel: WHO IS THE OTHER GIRL? And Selina knows it too, which is why she goes there. The parallel structure between Calix's midnight journey and Selina's sleepwalking is gorgeous—two people independently drawn to the same haunted place. And then the dress shop scene? It takes all this tension and compresses it into physical space. The pins, the back contact, the interrupted intimacy—it's a masterclass in delaying gratification. Every time they almost connect, something pulls them apart.
... Read More
The abuse scenes hit different when you know where they come from. The Marquis didn't just hit Selina—he hit her where the marks wouldn't show. Calculated cruelty. And then he tells her she'll end up locked in the cellar 'just like your mother did.' That's not anger, that's control. That's a man who has been doing this for years and has built an entire system of keeping her powerless. And her response? 'I'm sorry.' Just apologizing. Again. Because she knows no matter what she says, the violence comes anyway. It broke my heart honestly. She's standing there after everything—after walking into the palace with her father, after feeling that spark of hope when she saw Calix—and and gets hit for being exactly where she doesn't belong. But then there's this tiny thread of hope. When Calix looks at her, when he lifts her chin with the sword, there's this moment where she feels something. Joy or despair, she can't tell. She says 'her heart swung wildly, as if caught on a pendulum.' That image stayed with me. It's not just romantic tension—it's the terror and relief of seeing someone you waited for, someone you cared for, someone who might actually see you for the first time. 'I almost wondered if the marquis had finally lost his mind.' That line from Calix when he talks about the failed assassination—his voice staying flat, detached, while everything around him is chaos. That's also heartbreaking in its own way. He's learned to be this cold because the world won't let him be anything else.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this: the way Calix and Selina's dynamic has shifted is everything. I mean, we spent all these chapters thinking he was this gentle boy who got washed up on an island, right? And then BAM—here he is, sword at her throat, but then he FLIPS IT to lift her chin. That's not cruelty, that's... something else entirely. The Marquis tried to use Maya as a pawn, threw her to the ground like she was nothing, and honestly it made me so furious. But what gets me is how Selina reads the whole thing. She sees through Bryson immediately. She knows he's setting a trap, playing both sides. And Calix? He sees through it too. When he says 'Hans was a loyal knight' and then quietly tells Maya there was never any Ilios crest in the first place... that's him taking the conversation offline. That's him protecting people in the only way he can without causing an incident. But the real killer moment is when their eyes actually meet. No shadow hiding them anymore. Selina thinks 'It really is Calix' and then immediately doubts herself because she was always hooded, always dirty, always hiding. And Calix—does he recognize her? Does he? He looks right at her, then turns away. What does that mean?? Is he playing it cool, or is he genuinely not seeing the girl who took care of him? Or is he choosing not to see? I need to know what happens next because this tension is unbearable.
... Read More
Okay, can we talk about Rochester's speech? Like. He basically handed Selina a cheat code and then immediately ruined it by walking in. "There's a boundary, you see, that His Grace keeps around himself—a kind of secret fortress that only a chosen few are allowed to enter." I was literally sitting there like SELINA PLEASE STEP THROUGH THAT DOOR. And then Calix shows up and yells "Get out" which is honestly the most romantic aggressive line ever written and I'm dead. But here's what's actually haunting me: Calix went to that convent *alone* in the middle of the night because he was searching for the girl who saved him. He kept the promise to stay there forever burning in his chest. And Selina—his actual wife, who he's been ignoring for TWO WEEKS—had the exact same hallucination and walked right to the same place. Who is this other girl? Is Selina some kind of reincarnation situation? Because Calix literally looked at her crying in the forest and thought "why do I see her?" He can't stop projecting the savior girl onto Selina and it's making everything so painful. Also the dress shop scene??? He pulls her onto his lap and says "Shall I find out whether it's real or not?" while she's literally wearing a dress he bought her with another man's money?? The sexual tension is through the roof and also the emotional violence of it?? I love it. I hate it.
... Read More
I am actually shook. Like, I need to sit down after reading the scene where Selina opens that letter. Let me process this. Her entire journey to Thalia—every hope she'd built up, every fragile moment of connection with Calix—gets PUNCHED in the face in one paragraph. Find Calix's weakness. That's it. That's her mission. Not the marriage alliance, not political diplomacy... murder by proxy. And the father's reasoning? 'Those who possess the power of the sun are bound to have a fatal flaw.' BRO. That line hit me like a truck. It's such a cold, calculated thing to say about your own daughter's husband. But what really wrecked me was the setup. The author takes their time here. First, we get the dread buildup—Selina's chest tightening, steeling herself. Then the empty room. Then the letter itself sitting there like a landmine. And the reveal comes in drips: first the mission, then the poison backstory, then the antidote vial. By the time I realized the full scope of what her father has done to her since childhood, I was literally feral. This isn't just political manipulation; this is child abuse wrapped in a bow of 'you're just a disposable pawn.' And the timing! The author literally drops this revelation right before Selina runs into Calix on the terrace. How is she supposed to stand next to him, look into those violet eyes full of unshed tears, and pretend she doesn't know she's supposed to betray him? The structural genius here is that the reader knows something the character opposite her absolutely doesn't. Every sweet moment between them afterward is layered with this awful dramatic irony. I kept wanting to scream at Selina to just TELL him but you know she can't. Can she? The Emperor's refusal to send the princess is another thread I'm tracking. Calix correctly deduces they're not abandoning their ambitions—they're changing tactics. From assassination to alliance. And he's playing along while already calculating how many months of peace this buy him. Six months? A year? The suspense is killing me because I know the father is watching her. Even in Thalia, she's not free. The net closes tighter with every chapter and I am here for it.
... Read More
OK let me just start by saying: CALIX grabbing Selina's wrist and pulling her back to the terrace is the most iconic character moment I have ever read and I will die on this hill. Like, think about what just happened emotionally for Selina. She has just learned her entire existence is a lie, her father has turned her into a poisoned weapon aimed at the man she's falling for, and she's trying to physically flee the situation. And he just—catches her. 'If anyone saw, they'd think you were running away from me.' Not 'are you okay?' Not 'what's wrong?' He just PHYSICALLY anchors her in place while she's internally having a complete existential meltdown. But here's the thing that makes Calix so fascinating: he's NOT oblivious. The narration literally tells us he's been thinking about her. 'Just the memory of those eyes, shining with unshed tears, felt like a sharp needle pricking at his heart.' SHARP NEEDLE. The man is emotionally compromised and he KNOWS it, and he's still trying to play the strategic game. He's running calculations in his head about peace treaties while his own body betrays him with how much he wants her nearby. And Selina—OH MY GOD SELINA. The contrast between who she had to be (a poisoned child-soldier playing the delicate, sheltered noblewoman) and who she actually is (someone who pressed a blade to his throat and wasn't even apologetic about it) is everything. When Calix says 'That's a shame. I was hoping you'd meant to wear it for me' and she just—stammers and blushes and completely fails to maintain her cover for even one second—that's not an act. That's a girl who has spent her entire life performing and has no idea how to stop. The dynamic between Calix and Zenfri also deserves mention. Zenfri is the only person Calix lets see his real thoughts. 'Let's hope that isn't how you really feel' → 'Whoops. Nearly let that slip.' This is a man who literally cannot trust anyone except one person, and even then he's half-joking. Meanwhile, Selina has Maya—sweet, oblivious Maya who has no idea her mistress is carrying a death sentence in a vial. Two parallel pairings, both built on secrets.
... Read More
Let's just appreciate Calix's dialogue for a moment. The man has said approximately four complete sentences to Selina in two weeks and each one hits like a freight train. "Get out." Two words. Spoken after Rochester is inside the carriage having a tender conversation with her. Is he jealous? Terrified? Both? The subtext is screaming so loud I could hear it from outside the book. And then later in the shop, when he's removing the pin: "Your back." Not "are you okay?" Not "what's wrong?" Just... identification. He already knows. He's always known. He just doesn't know how to pretend he doesn't care anymore. "I can't tell where you end and your act begins." This line changed my entire understanding of the story. It's so Calix—reducing an emotional crisis to a forensic investigation. He's not saying "I'm hurt" or "I need you to be honest with me." He's framing her vulnerability as evidence in a trial where he's both prosecutor and jury. Which is tragically accurate because that's EXACTLY how he's been treating their whole marriage. But then he says "Shall I find out whether it's real or not?" and suddenly the forensic investigator becomes someone desperate for proof. The shift is almost imperceptible but it's devastating. He's asking for authenticity the only way he knows how—which is through physical proof, through sensation, through something he can't argue with. Rochester's voice is also perfectly calibrated. His lines are warm but edged with the caution of a soldier who knows when to speak and when to shut up. "His Grace can be... rather exhausting, can't he?" Said like a man offering advice he's not allowed to give.
... Read More
Can we just talk about how GOOD the dialogue is in this chapter? Because I need to appreciate the author's craft before I lose my mind over the plot twists. Let me start with Calix's voice. The man speaks in layers. On the surface, he's all polished politeness—'An interesting idea. I, too, would be curious to see how His Majesty might react' to the imperial princess. But beneath that? The narration tells us he'd 'rather listen to crows cawing.' His dialogue is a weapon he wields without bleeding. Even with Zenfri, his friend, he's careful: 'Let's hope that isn't how you really feel' when Zenfri says the assassination attempts failed. He deflects with humor but the tension is everywhere. Selina's dialogue is even more interesting because it's full of things she DOESN'T say. Watch how she deflects: 'My stomach's a little upset' when really she's about to vomit from shock. 'I just didn't choose this dress on purpose, so please don't misunderstand' when really she's panicking because she's supposed to betray him. Every sentence she speaks is a performance, and the audience (both Calix and us) are increasingly unsure what's real. But the best dialogue moment has to be this exchange: 'Would you do anything just because I told you to?' / 'Not anything! I was just curious…' / 'Curiosity isn't a good enough reason. If something isn't good for you, don't do it.' This is Calix DRAWING A LINE. After all his political maneuvering, all his calculated responses, he stops and says NO to something because he genuinely cares whether it's good for her. Not because of politics. Not because of strategy. Because SELINA asked to try his cigar and he doesn't want her hurt. That single moment of honesty in a chapter full of deception is worth more than a thousand romantic declarations. And Zenfri? 'Whoops. Nearly let that slip…' Perfect friend energy. The guy knows exactly when to push and when to let Calix recalibrate. Great supporting character voice.
... Read More
The stakes in this passage operate on three levels and they compound rather than replace each other. On the surface, Selina is lost in dangerous woods with wild beasts. That is physical stakes—her body is at risk. But underneath, there are relational stakes: she lied to Calix, and he knows she lied, and neither will name it. The silence that follows is not empty; it is loaded with unspoken accusations and fears. The deepest level is political. The marquis sent her to find Calix's weakness. She does not want to betray him. But what if she cannot help it? What if the information she gathers is enough to wound him even without malice? Every scene raises the question: can Selina survive her father's designs while keeping the man she loves safe? The potato scene seems trivial, but it establishes that Selina is capable of instinctive, almost animal need. The soldiers see this and shift. Calix sees this and cares. But the marquis sees this and recognizes a tool. The beasts in the forest are almost secondary—they are nature's version of her father's schemes, indifferent to her intentions, closing in whether she runs or not. The conflict is not just external; it is structural. Selina is trapped between love and duty, truth and survival, the girl who prayed for a boy to live and the woman who must pretend to betray him. Every lie she tells to protect herself brings her closer to the betrayal she fears most. The stakes keep rising because the author refuses to let us forget that Selina's father is still in the room, even when he is not.
... Read More
What strikes me most is how Calix and Selina communicate—or fail to. The potato scene shows them at their most physically close and emotionally distant. He feeds her. She eats. Nobody says what they are actually feeling. Later, when he carries her on his back down the mountain, the silence stretches so thick you can almost hear it. He is angry, but not just about her wandering off. He suspects she is playing some game, and he is right to suspect. She lied about getting lost. She omitted the convent, the cliff, the reason she climbed into darkness. Every omission is a brick in the wall between them. Yet Calix still wraps his coat around her. Still carries her. Still finds her when she needs him. That contradiction is the whole relationship in miniature. The soldiers are fascinating too—Rochester teasing, Zenfri scowling, the unnamed man asking about sweet potatoes. They represent a community trying to process their new mistress. They did not want this marriage. They thought she was nothing like her father. And then they saw her eat a potato like she had not eaten in weeks, and something shifted. Even Calix's men are starting to see her differently. But the most important relationship here is the one between Selina and her own past. The convent is not just a place; it is a version of herself she buried. When Ari shows it to her glowing under moonlight, beautiful and peaceful, Selina gets to see her prison as something else. She gets to remember the boy she saved, the feverish days, the prayers. That memory is the emotional anchor that keeps her from hating Calix completely. She tells herself he is still that boy. She tells herself she will not betray him. But the marquis's orders are real, and Selina is trapped between love for a ghost and duty to a monster.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or