Okay so I need to talk about this scene where Wendy lies to Lucas and honestly I am NOT okay. Let me walk through why this plot development absolutely wrecked me.
From the very beginning of this passage, the author sets up this beautiful anticipation. Wendy gets that Christmas market ticket from her father, goes through this whole emotional journey of deciding whether to ask Lucas, finally works up the courage to write him a letter. And Lucas responds! He sends flowers with that famous card saying 'he received her letter well' and that they should meet later. Wendy is literally pressing the card to her face like 'YES IT WORKED.' I was genuinely hopeful there. I thought, okay, maybe this time things will go differently. Maybe he actually wants to see her.
But then—the scene at the Crystal Palace. She arrives early. Waits from 1:30 PM until 6 PM. SIX HOURS. In the cold. Alone. And when Lucas finally appears, he's not alone. He's with Melinda. And watch how the plot unfolds from there: Lucas spots Wendy first, asks if she's alone (which is his way of showing concern, not anger), and Wendy—oh Wendy. Instead of telling him the truth, she lies. She says she came with a friend. She says she was about to leave anyway. She even fake-describes the decorations she hasn't even seen inside yet.
The brilliance of this plot moment is that Wendy's lie actually makes Lucas think the market is worth visiting. 'See, Lucas, I told you it's worth coming.' And he dismisses it as 'just Christmas decorations.' Melinda calls him unromantic. And Wendy, shivering outside in the cold, has to nod along and pretend she's already experienced all of this. The dramatic irony here is absolutely devastating because the reader knows everything Wendy is hiding.
What really gets me is the structural setup: the author spent roughly three-quarters of this passage building up Wendy's hope and agency—her father's effort, her decision to take action, writing the letter, the successful response. And then in the final quarter, all of that agency is stripped away. She's reduced to performing happiness while her heart breaks. It's a masterclass in how to make a reader feel powerless alongside a character. The plot doesn't give her a dramatic confrontation or a moment of clarity. It just... leaves her standing in the cold while the people she loves walk into warmth together.