Dearest, Beloved - Reviews

Dearest, Beloved
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
That suspension bridge is doing so much work in this story. It's not just a setting. It's a symbol for the entire situation—three people standing in darkness, suspended between what was and what could be, held up by fragile cables of trust and love and desperation. The pitch-black suspension bridge appears at a crucial emotional turning point. They're literally and figuratively in the dark. But instead of falling, they stand together. The neighbor auntie calls them 'heads in the clouds,' and maybe she's right—maybe that's the only way to survive this kind of love. Maybe thinking too much is both the curse and the gift. And then there's the repeated question at the end: 'Three people, can it work? Three people, can it really work?' This isn't just narrative closure—it's the central philosophical question of the entire story. Can love be divided without being diminished? Can three hearts share one life without destroying any of them? The Barbie doll memory is also significant. A childhood dream, a night market purchase, a promise to leave. These small objects carry the weight of everything the characters wanted before the world got complicated. The author keeps circling back to these moments of innocence—the haircut incident, the doll, the promise to escape—like they're anchors reminding us what was lost and what might still be saved. Whether this ending is hopeful or devastating depends entirely on whether you believe three people can truly build a home together. I'm still not sure which answer I want.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about Gao Ze because honestly he broke me. You know how most novels treat the 'nice guy' as either a background prop or a villain in waiting? This guy was just… present. All the time. Even after finding out his partner was involved with someone else, he didn't erupt. He didn't manipulate or scheme. He sat them down, said 'I know,' and basically offered to step aside so they could have their fairy tale while he quietly went on surviving. 'I know… I've always known about you and Liu Hao. But the love I've given you—there's no taking it back and giving it to someone else.' That right there. That's not weakness. That's a kind of fierce, terrifying emotional maturity that most characters in this genre never achieve. And Bai Xiao—don't get me started. She cried and then she laughed and then she just… decided to leave. Three people, one decision, no vote needed. The power dynamic shifted so dramatically in that moment. Liu Hao went from anxious jealous subordinate to scrambling to keep up, wrapping his arms around both of them like, hey wait, what about me? And they all just laughed. I keep thinking about how Gao Ze and Liu Hao's relationship with Bai Xiao mirrored each other yet were completely opposite. One gave freely and hurt himself doing it. The other clung desperately and made things harder for everyone. Neither was wrong. That's what makes it so painful.
... Read More
Okay so this whole plot is just one beautifully painful triangle and honestly I kept waiting for someone to just BREAK something because the tension was so thick you could cut it with a knife. Liu Hao coming over with beer like he thinks alcohol will give him courage? Classic move, and the fact that he practices what hes going to say but cant actually say it when the moment hits? That is such a real human thing to do. And then Bai Xiao touching his erection and LAUGHING about it—like she deflected the intimacy with humor because she was scared too. But the real plot twist that hit me hard was Gao Ze lying. He comes home and basically says I need to leave early when what hes really feeling is I know something is wrong and I hate myself for staying. That scene where he leaves with barely 2000 NTD after travel expenses and three days left on his leave but feels homeless? That is a gut punch. The author built this entire false harmony between three people who are all pretending everything is fine while their hearts are literally breaking on opposite sides of the same room. And then Liu Hao self-harming right before his draft notice? That escalated from emotional tragedy to full blown desperation in one move. I read that part and just sat there stunned. Bai Xiao promises herself to Liu Hao but cant confess anything to Gao Ze—that line alone contains the entire tragedy of this story in one sentence.
... Read More
Beer appears right at the beginning as liquid courage and Bai Xiao also mentions wanting to drink to forget. Alcohol as both catalyst and escape runs through these chapters like a nervous system. Then there is the hand cream and cracked hands—Bai Xiao's hands bear the physical marks of her labor at the salon and Liu Hao notices them and wants to care for them. His desire to apply cream and put on gloves becomes a surrogate for the intimacy she shares with Gao Ze but cannot have with Liu Hao properly. The movie Sleepless Town with Takeshi Kaneshiro is itself a symbol because it is about impossible love and longing and these three are watching a story about love triangles while living their own. Steam and heat from the screen bleeding into their actual bodies. Gao Ze lying about money and leaving early—he gives her his entire paycheck which is all he has saved since he was nine years old. Money as love language and sacrifice. The draft notices hanging over both young men like swords. Military duty versus personal desire as the ultimate force that will tear them apart. And that final line the boy became a man but the girl became a sinner—gendered morality as theme. He gains something through transgression while she loses her innocence and becomes defined by guilt. The entire story is about how love between good people can still destroy everyone involved.
... Read More
Everything in this stretch circles back to one devastating idea: these kids were never wanted. Bai Xiao opens up about how their very birth was considered a sin because their moms were runaway workers. Yafan's orphanage had HIV-positive babies that nobody visited, bullied by other disabled kids while counselors looked away. The system didn't just fail them - it actively pretended they didn't exist. Yafan's death becomes this perverse form of liberation. His dream words sum it up perfectly: 'It's great… I don't have to try anymore! After all, I wasn't born into this world with anyone's expectations.' That's the core tragedy - he only finds peace in death because life offered him nothing but exhaustion and rejection. And Bai Xiao nearly follows him into that same feeling when she's delirious with fever, right on the edge of giving up too. The V8 camera is its own kind of symbol - this man wasn't just preying on vulnerable children, he was documenting it, turning their violation into something he could possess and take with him. The fact that Gao Ze caught him with the camera still flashing red is almost poetic justice, but it doesn't undo the damage. Then there's the family that forms afterward - not by choice but by circumstance. Liu Hao's father sends money and severs ties, which mirrors how the whole world has treated these kids. Abandonment as currency. And yet somehow Bai Xiao and Liu Hao keep reaching for each other anyway, which feels like the book's quiet argument: being unwanted doesn't mean you stop wanting connection.
... Read More
Okay so the opening scene on that pitch-black suspension bridge? Immediate hooks. Like, you drop me into the middle of an already explosive situation and I'm like wait wait wait WHAT just happened here. Bai Xiao standing between two men who both clearly care about her but also clearly hurt—that's a setup that works every time. But then the flashback to the orphanage totally reframes everything. What I love about the structure here is that the author doesn't just give us exposition dump. We get the bridge confrontation first, feel the emotional weight, and THEN we learn WHY these three are so tangled up. Liu Hao's line about the counsellor spying on Xiaobai? That's a plot thread that hasn't been resolved yet and it's clearly going to blow up later. The fact that Gao Ze discovered this and it changed the course of everything? Chef's kiss. The narrative arc from childhood innocence to adult torment is classic but executed really well. That cycle Bai Xiao mentions—"fate that tied the three of us together, in a cycle of no escape"—that's the thesis of the whole plot right there. I'm invested now and I need to know what happens next.
... Read More
That one line though—the night the boy became a man but the girl became a sinner—just destroyed me. I have never read something that captures the gendered guilt of a first time so perfectly in six words. Bai Xiao guarding this stolen love like it is something fragile and illegal, acting like a real couple while silently agreeing never to mention the future. She is preserving something beautiful by pretending it cannot exist. And Liu Hao—oh god Liu Hao. He brings her hand cream because her hands are cracked from work at the salon. He remembers she loves chicken tails. He wants to be her knight even if she ends up with someone else. The man is genuinely the sweetest person and that makes everything hurt so much more. Then Gao Ze lies to protect everyone and Bai Xiao cries into his shoulder soaking his neck. He kisses her hair tenderly while his own heart is probably screaming. The physical intimacy between Liu Hao and Bai Xiao—the tickling, the bare foot pushing against his chest, the heat radiating between them—that wasn't just lust it was two lonely people colliding. And Gao Ze sensing the stiff embrace the night before and choosing silence? That is love disguised as letting go. I am not even joking I felt physically anxious reading these chapters.
... Read More
Let me just say: the stakes in this story are already dangerously high and we haven't even gotten to the main conflict yet. On the surface, it's a love triangle. But beneath that? Liu Hao is asking Bai Xiao to choose between love and family practicality. Gao Ze is essentially saying "I have nothing but you" while Liu Hao has everything except what he wants most. And Bai Xiao? She's the one holding all their fates in her hands and it's clearly tearing her apart. The counsellor subplot is adding external pressure too. Someone was spying on Bai Xiao when she was a kid and Gao Ze discovered it. What does that mean? Who is this person? The author dropped this bomb and went back to childhood flashbacks—classic tension-building move that leaves me sweating. But what's making ME truly care about the outcome is how much these three genuinely love each other. They're not fighting because they hate each other. They're fighting because they each want what's best for Bai Xiao and they can't see past their own hearts. Liu Hao collapsing on the bridge crying, Gao Ze turning away so she won't see his pain—that's not petty rivalry. That's genuine devastation. And Bai Xiao's fear that if she speaks, if she chooses, the balance will break forever? That's the real stakes. It's not about who gets the girl. It's about whether this friendship survives at all.
... Read More
I need to talk about Gao Ze because WOW. This boy has been covering for Bai Xiao since he was nine years old and taking bamboo cane hits for her and it is making me both swoon and have a stroke simultaneously. Look at this moment: the director swings that thin bamboo cane at Bai Xiao and Gao Ze just... takes it. His bronzed arm gets marked and his first reaction isn't even about himself—it's about protecting her. That's the kind of devotion that should come with a warning label. But here's what's haunting me: Gao Ze's world was described as black and white until Bai Xiao appeared. He's the disciplined stickler, the martyr's son, the one who follows every rule. And she's the wild girl who steals dogs and shaves them and throws dodgeballs through windows. Of course he fell for her. You can't write chemistry better than this. And Liu Hao! Poor baby. He's got everything—family, money, love—and he still feels inadequate because Bai Xiao doesn't choose him the way he wants. His line about genetically losing to the martyr's son broke me a little. He's self-aware enough to know his disadvantage but still hopeful enough to ask anyway. That's tragic and beautiful.
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is deceptively casual but every line carries weight. Bai Xiao calling Liu Hao idiot when she catches him staring and then tugging his ear playfully—that is exactly how someone masks vulnerability with humor. The chicken tail exchange where she pretends not to hear his confession about always being her knight? That is the most painful rejection that is not actually a rejection because she hears it perfectly and is just unable to respond. Liu Hao saying put these cotton gloves on after his realization about Gao Ze and the hair drying—it is domestic but also deeply intimate because he is doing something Gao Ze used to do and he does not even realize the substitution until the moment passes. And Gao Ze's voice when he lies to Bai Xiao so quietly saying I need to head back early with that forced gentleness in his tone. His lines are always shorter more restrained than anyone else's and that restraint IS his character. The tickling scene where Liu Hao says back then you had fried egg boobs and now they are barely little dumplings—it sounds crude but it is actually tender teasing between people who know each other intimately. The dialogue here never feels scripted. Each character speaks in a completely distinct rhythm and vocabulary and you can always tell who is talking even without name tags.
... Read More
There are two scenes in this stretch that I just cannot stop thinking about. First is the orphanage itself - six bunk beds crammed into one room, girls on top bunks, boys on bottom, because apparently the one safety measure they could think of was having boys act as bodyguards for girls going to the bathroom at night. That detail alone tells you everything about how underfunded and desperate this place was. And then Starlight only took them until sixteen, which means at that age you were just... thrown out. Into a world that already treated them like garbage because their moms were runaway workers. Their birth was apparently a sin. But then the flashlight scene. Oh god. I read it twice. The counselor coming through with that little V8 camera, the flickering light casting shadows over Gao Ze's face - the author builds this whole sense of dread before you even understand what's happening. And then it just escalates so fast. Gao Ze waking up, sensing something wrong, and walking in on that. I don't even want to think about what he saw on that camera footage. And then Yafan chasing after him, blocking the windshield, the screech of brakes, that sound. 'Like he was singing his final lament.' Bai Xiao sitting up in bed not even knowing what happened, just feeling it in her bones - 'a bitter taste rose in her mouth.' That physical reaction before any explanation? Chef's kiss. The whole sequence from discovery to death to the ambulance arriving to the black body bag feels like a single breath held for too long. The author doesn't let you look away.
... Read More
I'm still processing the structure of these chapters. The first part—Gao Ze's confession, Bai Xiao breaking down, the three of them on that bridge—is absolutely suffocating. You feel every heavy silence, every unspoken word pressing down. The author doesn't rush any of it. They let the tension build like pressure in your chest until you literally can't breathe. And then—just like that—the neighbor auntie shows up and shatters everything. 'What, raising mosquitoes? Hurry and come down already!' This is such a brilliant structural choice. After pages of heavy emotional drama, a casual neighborhood woman comes in and effectively says: you're overthinking this, kids. Just live your life. And the shift is instantaneous. From tears to laughter. From paralysis to action. Bai Xiao says 'Let's leave this place. I don't want to choose.' And the next paragraph? They're laughing, arms around each other, already decided. No drawn-out planning scene, no dramatic montage. Just… gone. The ending with 'Three people, can it work? Three people, can it really work?' feels almost like the author winking at us. Like they know we're desperate for more resolution, more certainty. But they refuse to give it. And that refusal is somehow the most honest thing about the whole story.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or