Dearest, Beloved - Reviews

Dearest, Beloved
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is wild. It starts almost conversational - kids complaining about orphanage life, Yafan sharing his story, that kind of setup where you think 'oh this is a slice-of-life story about troubled kids.' And then within a few pages everything explodes. One minute they're comparing tragedies like it's some morbid game, the next minute there's a predator in their sleeping quarters and a kid is dead. What I found interesting is how the author doesn't dwell on the aftermath for too long. The incident happens, Yafan dies, the orphanage closes, and then we cut to them being adopted by Liu Hao's grandparents. That jump feels almost too fast, almost dismissive, and I think that's kind of the point. Trauma doesn't give you time to process it - life just keeps moving and you have to move with it. Bai Xiao goes from a scared kid to an apprentice working herself to collapse in three months. That compression makes it hurt more. The chapter ends on what feels like a lull - Liu Hao finished his exams, Bai Xiao has a day off, they're planning to visit the grandparents together. But that 'These day' that gets cut off? Or maybe it's just trailing into the next scene. Either way, it feels like calm water before something else breaks. The author is setting up quiet moments between the disasters, which makes me trust that the next emotional hit is coming.
... Read More
The author has this incredible talent for making every space feel like it holds breath. Bai Xiao emerging from the salon in a black tank top and denim shorts waving energetically like an elf—that image just stuck with me. The contrast between her bright sunshine exterior and the storm inside her head? Chef kiss. Then the living room scene with steaming fried chicken on the table beer bottles and dried plums arranged like a picnic for two people who are about to cross a line. The damp hair, the cotton gloves, the hand cream being gently applied—the domesticity of it all made the intimacy feel so much more dangerous because it was wrapped in something so ordinary and warm. And then Gao Ze's empty house after he leaves. The author does not even need to describe it directly. You just feel the absence. Three days of leave stretched into infinite loneliness. The coast at Tamsui where he watches the sun set and rise again—that scene where he just sits there questioning everything he has ever worked for since he was nine years old? Cinematic in the best way. The military base looming in the background as a place that will separate them permanently. Every location in this story feels lived in and weighted with emotion.
... Read More
The suspension bridge setting for the opening confrontation is NOT accidental and I'm here for it. Think about it: a bridge connects two sides but you can't stand on both at once. Bai Xiao is literally standing between Liu Hao and Gao Ze, suspended over nothing, and she can't move without someone falling. That's the entire love triangle in one image. The pitch-black darkness around her mirrors how blind fate has been to all three of them. Then there's the Starlight Orphanage itself as a symbol. It's supposed to be a place of refuge but Bai Xiao describes it as prison. The children there are trapped by circumstance—either abandoned by parents or orphaned from the start. Liu Hao is the only one who CHOSE to be there temporarily, which explains why he's the most optimistic one. He has an exit strategy. The other two don't. The recurring motif of haircuts and transformation is interesting too—Bai Xiao shaving that dog, wanting to change herself, wanting to leave. She's always trying to reshape her world because she has no control over where it leads. And Gao Ze's father died in the air force, connected to sky and freedom, while his son is grounded in rules and duty. That irony isn't lost on me. This story is about how childhood bonds become invisible chains.
... Read More
I have to give major props to the dialogue writing here because normally I roll my eyes at love triangle conversations but this actually felt natural. Bai Xiao's voice is unmistakable. When she says "Mangoes and starfruit are meant to be eaten! If no one picks them, they'll just rot on the tree" about the stolen fruit, or when she deflects the dog incident by blaming Liu Hao for throwing the ball—that's a kid who talks her way out of everything and knows it. Her line about wanting to grow up fast and leave the orphanage? "She wanted her mother never to find her again, to regret her decision for the rest of her life. She wanted her mother to taste the bitterness of abandonment!"——That's not a child talking. That's a child with A LOT of feelings bottled up. The neighbor auntie's dialogue though? Perfection. "One day, when your wife runs off with someone else, then you'll feel the pain!" Came in hot and left a mark. Also Liu Hao handing out knockoff Barbies and Bai Xiao calling them boring while secretly being touched? The subtext in their dialogue is EVERYTHING. Gao Ze barely says much but when he does it hits different. His calm responses to Liu Hao's emotional outbursts show exactly who he is.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the author controls the pace here because it is masterful. It starts so slow and gentle—beer, fried chicken, movie night, playful bickering about hands and hair and nose length. You could almost mistake this for a romcom if you did not pay attention. But every small detail is building toward something inevitable. The steamy bed scene in the movie acting as a catalyst—not just sexual tension but emotional tension. Liu Hao getting aroused and cursing under his breath while Bai Xiao giggles and touches him like she is testing whether this is real. Then she stops. The brake moment. And then he cannot stop either. The pacing shifts from playful banter to something darker and more urgent without any warning and that is exactly how real life feels when lines get crossed. After that night the structure changes entirely. Gao Ze returns and the three days mirror something biblical or mythological almost—denial understanding acceptance—but none of it brings peace. Each day he spends by himself in Tamsui while back home the facade continues. By the time Liu Hao enlists and self-harms the pace accelerates so fast you can barely catch your breath. The chapter ends on a cliffhanger with Gao Ze sensing something is off and taking the initiative. I had to immediately read the next chapter.
... Read More
The stakes in this story are so personal they almost hurt to read. This isn't about saving the world or winning a war—it's about three people trying to figure out if love can survive its own impossibility. And that's somehow even more tense because there's no external villain. The conflict is internal, relational, existential. Gao Ze's conflict is the most devastating because he's aware of it and powerless to change it. 'If you let go of me, I probably won't survive…' That's not manipulation. That's a genuine statement of emotional reality. He's telling them the truth about what losing Bai Xiao would mean to him, and he's doing it without demanding anything in return. Liu Hao's stakes are different. He's fighting insecurity, jealousy, the fear that he's not enough. Every time Gao Ze is 'invisible' during Liu Hao's visits, it chips away at his sense of belonging. His conflict is quieter but just as destructive—he becomes petty, searching for evidence of past love like an archaeologist digging through ruins. Bai Xiao stands at the center of all of this and her stake is the simplest and hardest: she doesn't want to choose. And the novel's greatest act of courage is refusing to force her to. When she finally decides to leave, it's not a victory over anyone—it's a decision to stop playing a game where everyone was already losing. The bridge scene raises the stakes to almost unbearable levels. Three people in darkness, silent, unable to move. And then the auntie's voice breaks the spell like a stone through glass. The release that follows—the laughter, the decision to leave, the arm around Gao Ze's neck—feels like survival. Like they chose life over being stuck in that perfect, terrible moment forever.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about Bai Xiao and Liu Hao because this whole thing just wrecked me. It's not like a typical romance story at all - it's more like two broken people who keep running into each other at the worst possible moments. First there's the Yafan death scene, which is honestly brutal, and then suddenly Liu Hao is there taking care of her when she's sick. And it's not like he just shows up with flowers or whatever, he literally says 'Don't worry. You still have me' without even really saying it. That line though - I sat there just staring at the page. And what's weird is how guilt and responsibility twist into something else. Bai Xiao wasn't looking for love, she was trying to survive. She became an apprentice at a hair salon, worked herself to the bone, collapsed from fever. And Liu Hao, who she'd always treated like a little brother, starts seeing her differently. The author writes it like this 'a delicate sweetness mingled with the heartache of sleepless nights.' That's not cheesy - that's accurate. Because it's not sweet in a fairy-tale way, it's sweet in a 'we're both drowning but at least we're drowning together' kind of way. The Gao Ze thread makes it even more complicated since he's the one who connects them all, and now he's off serving in the military in Penghu. Six months between calls. The trio that held them together is literally scattered. I don't know if this is going to become a love triangle or what but right now it just feels like three people orbiting each other in different directions, hoping someone doesn't fall too far away.
... Read More
The dialogue in this section is sparse but every line lands because the author knows when NOT to write conversation. Most of the early part is these kids just existing together, complaining half-heartedly, sharing fragments of their lives. Yafan's voice comes through strongest: 'If I had a choice, I wouldn't have wanted to be born at all!' That line isn't dramatic - it's just true for a kid who's been treated like waste his whole life. But the real dialogue masterpiece is Yafan's death moment. He's lying in a pool of blood, barely conscious, and instead of screaming or begging, he basically says goodbye like he's relieved. 'You didn't like me, so I'm leaving. My soul will fly to a place where I will be accepted, a place full of hope and love.' This kid is dying and his last thought is that maybe death is kinder than whatever life offered him. I actually had to put the book down for a second. Bai Xiao's response is just screaming 'Hang in there! Don't go!' which is everything you'd expect from someone watching their friend die helplessly. No poetic lines, just raw panic. The author lets the silence after the dialogue do most of the work - the neighbors arriving, the ambulance, the black body bag, nobody really approaching Yafan while he's still technically being resuscitated. That contrast between the frantic adult responses and the cold reality that he's gone speaks louder than any dialogue could.
... Read More
'You three are just sitting there on that bridge? What, raising mosquitoes? Hurry and come down already!' I love this woman. I genuinely do. She is the single most important character in this entire excerpt and she appears for exactly two paragraphs. The author clearly had the option to keep everything elevated and literary—more internal monologue, more heavy dialogue—but they chose instead to let a grumpy auntie knock them back to earth and honestly? Perfect choice. Every character's voice is distinct. Gao Ze speaks in complete, measured sentences. Even when he's falling apart inside, his words are carefully constructed: 'I want to give you a happy home, even if the person by your side… isn't me.' You can hear the effort it takes him to say that calmly. Liu Hao's dialogue is shorter, more reactive. 'Hey! You didn't even ask me first!'—it's childish, which is exactly who he is in this dynamic. And Bai Xiao? She goes from fragmented cries to simple declarations. 'Ah! Right. Let's leave this place.' Four words. That's all it takes. The humor is dry and unexpected, never forced. The banter between the three of them at the end feels earned because we've suffered through enough pain to deserve that release. The author's voice is restrained but never cold—it has warmth underneath, like that line about tears having warmth. Very few writers can balance that kind of tenderness without becoming saccharine.
... Read More
waiting n waiting

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or