Cloud and Mist Run Wild - Reviews

Cloud and Mist Run Wild
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let's talk about the imagery because oh my god the author knows how to paint a picture. The opening shot of Yi Si squatting by the roadside, drenched in sweat, fussing with a grape trellis—that's such an unexpected image for the Underworld. I expected grim darkness, but instead we get... agriculture? Vineyards? It's oddly pastoral, like the afterlife has a quiet countryside vibe. And then Gu Yunwu himself is described like a walking masterpiece: "his hair neatly coiled and fastened with an exquisitely carved jade hairpin," features like the bright moon, eyes like the morning light. This guy literally glows. Even as a ghost, he's radiant in a way that contrasts sharply with Yi Si, who is just dusty and smudged from working. The Bridge of Forgetfulness scene is gorgeous too. Nearly half an hour of walking, the Yellow Springs Road, the field of flowers where Gu Yunwu stumbles—it all feels cinematic. Like each location has its own mood. And Granny Meng! She's not the crone the stories tell, she's a graceful young woman whose mere presence draws crowds. The worldbuilding here is subtle but deep; you get the sense this realm has rules, routines, and a certain everyday beauty that makes it feel lived-in. The teahouse by the south gate of An'nan Town—I can already picture it. I want to visit.
... Read More
The stakes in this story just shifted from professional to deeply personal, and I am NOT ok with that. Let's break down what Li Si actually stands to lose here. Professionally: he's a ghost catcher whose job is to apprehend spirits. Gu Yunwu was supposed to be his case file — the first evil spirit he ever captured. Instead, Gu Yunwu became the person Li Si can't stop thinking about, the person he threw himself in front of a killing blow for, the person who now has reincarnated and moved on while Li Si is stuck filing paperwork. The internal conflict is brutal. Li Si keeps telling himself practical things: "He's bound to reincarnate." "That's not admitting it either, is it?" He's desperately constructing emotional distance while every action he takes proves the opposite. He sleeps for THREE DAYS from a soul shake caused by protecting someone. He broods for weeks. He gets irrationally angry that Gu Yunwu visited Chun Tao instead of him. And the external stakes? Gu Changwei is still out there. The old bastard tried to kill Gu Yunwu, imprisoned him, and clearly has deep connections to whatever happened to Li Si in his past life. Judge Cui Yu dropping that hint — "When the trial of Gu Changwei begins, I'll have someone notify you" — feels like the author absolutely promising more confrontation ahead. The tension hasn't peaked yet. It's coiling.
... Read More
I need to just appreciate the atmosphere the author builds in the Underworld scenes because it's genuinely stunning. The Naihe Bridge sequence is one of those moments that just stops time. Lady Meng with her red oil-paper umbrella, the reclining chair by the river, the sense that nothing has changed despite Li Si having just experienced a near-death (near-everything) event. "Everything around him was the same as he remembered, as if he had never left, only taken a nap." There's something deeply haunting about that normalcy — the Underworld doesn't care that you almost died. It just keeps flowing. And then the scene where Li Si encounters Chun Tao among the scattered travelers: "A young girl, bright-eyed, teeth like pearls, cheeks like peach blossoms. She was laughing as she walked." This image is so vivid it practically glows against the灰暗 background of the Yellow Springs. The contrast between her brightness and the Somber setting is heartbreaking because we KNOW she's the same person Li Si knew, but she doesn't remember him. The Hall of Yama itself is described with this bureaucratic dread — Yama holding the memorial with brows twisted into knots, the Bureau of Rewards and Virtues, Judge Cui Yu's dignified authority. It's a world that feels alive, layered, and ancient. Every location has texture.
... Read More
Let me just quote one exchange because it's everything: "You are actually not pregnant. Correct?" "Correct." And "And you already know something?" "I know." That's it. Four lines. Four words in the answers. But the dialogue here does SO MUCH heavy lifting. Madam Liu and Li Si have this incredible back-and-forth that feels like two people who've been circling each other their whole lives finally speaking directly. The restraint in their speech is the point—they don't need flourishes, they need truth. Compare that to Xia Yuan, who absolutely EXPLODES with emotion: "Can this be used as evidence?" and her near-tears reaction to the sachet discovery. Her voice is warm, impulsive, deeply feeling. Then there's Gu Yunwu, cold and clinical: "Without Chun Tao's testimony, this evidence means nothing." He speaks in judgments and warnings, never in vulnerability. Even his voice reflects his position—he's been betrayed, he's calculating, he's protecting himself before anyone can hurt him again. And Li Si! His dialogue shifts dramatically across this chapter. At the teahouse he's snarky and informal, then with Xia Yuan he becomes tender and urgent, then in the carriage he's all formal distance and controlled intensity. The narrative voice itself is fascinating too—it's third person limited but it dips into Li Si's head so frequently that we get his observations as raw as his thoughts. When he curses internally about the crow's mouth timing, that's pure voice. The author's style leans cinematic, embedding commentary in action rather than exposition. Even the fortune-teller's cryptic muttering feels distinct from every other character. Nobody sounds the same, and that's rare.
... Read More
I will say this—the pacing in this section is absolutely relentless and I cannot complain. We open with the fortune-teller encounter, which feels almost comedic in its absurdity, then immediately pivot to the teahouse investigation where Doctor Qin delivers the devastating herb analysis. The structure of this chapter is basically: hope (maybe we'll find proof) → disappointment (the medicine alone won't kill him) → new hope (the sachet!) → immediate threat (KNOCK KNOCK). That last beat is a masterclass in tension deployment. Just when the reader exhales, thinking they've found the evidence they've been waiting for, the author SLAMS the door open with danger arriving at their exact doorstep. What I love about the pacing here is how the author controls information delivery. First we get the fortune-teller's vague warnings, then Doctor Qin's clinical confirmation of poison, then Li Si's internal monologue revealing his long-held suspicions about Gu Changwei, then Chun Tao's accidental discovery of the toxic fungus. Each revelation builds on the last like a house of cards, and the sachet scene is the pinnacle—it reframes Chun Tao's entire character from "reckless servant" to "unwitting hero whose small act saved everything." The transition from the teahouse to the carriage feels organic too; Gu Yunwu warns about danger and then danger literally arrives. That's not coincidence, that's skillful structural design. The only slight drag I'd note is the Madam Liu conversation stretches a bit long in the middle, but honestly it earns its length because it's where Li Si's emotional arc peaks. The chapter ends on that fragmented, trembling question from Madam Liu, which is a PERFECT cliffhanger. I needed to know what she said immediately. The author knows exactly when to cut and when to linger, and this chapter proves it.
... Read More
The description of Annan Town after Li Si returns is just *chef's kiss*. Spring rains finally stopping, skies clearing brightly, streets bustling with that same old rhythm except now there's fresh gossip floating around like steam off morning congee. I could literally smell the damp stone and roasted tea leaves. The author didn't need a paragraph—they dropped three sentences and I was THERE, walking south to north in an hour, noting which gates are shut, which teahouses are open. But the best worldbuilding moment is hands down the gambling den. Calling it a "casino" is generous—it's just broken boards propping up a tent, a couple battered tables and chairs, smoke so thick you could chew it. Yet it feels MORE alive than most full-blown fantasy cities I've read. Why? Because the details ground it: idle men cursing, Wang Er Mazi shaking dice with his foot on a stool, the sound of coins clattering, the collective roar when someone wins. This isn't described setting, this is EXPERIENCED setting. You're in the room with them. The Underworld descriptions are sparse but efficient. We get merit systems, ghost officers, the concept of souls being bound to objects they carried in life. That pastry bag detail—Jia Yi pulling out this crumpled brown paper bag sealed with red paper, Yu Yun stamped on it—is the kind of thing that makes a fictional bureaucracy feel real. Someone thought about how paper bags work, where they come from, what the seals look like. That's the mark of a world that existed before the story started and will keep existing after it ends. Li Si possessing the martial arts roughneck's body is another gorgeous image—the riverbank washing, the faint trickle of power healing wounds, scars remaining, the itchy beard stubble he notices. Dead body, yes, but somehow more visceral than most living character introductions I've read. The author makes death feel tactile. I love that.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is absolutely ruthless and I am here for it. We go from the emotional aftermath of Gu Yunwu's confession/ breakdown in the study → to an ASSASSINATION ATTEMPT within a single chapter. No breathing room. Li Si gets impaled, drags himself toward the attacker, yanks off the mask, delivers the most dramatic line of the entire series: "Master Gu. I'll be waiting for you in the underworld. We'll meet again." — and then immediately passes out. I need to talk about this line though because it's doing SO MUCH WORK. On the surface it sounds like a threat to Gu Changwei ("that old bastard"). But layered on top? It's also directed at Gu Yunwu. Because Li Si just found out his first captive is about to reincarnate and never speak to him again. "I'll be waiting for you in the underworld" = I'm not letting you go that easily. Or maybe: we're going to meet again, and next time things will be different. The plot thread about Gu Changwei imprisoning Gu Yunwu and trying to kill him is still completely unresolved. And that missing name in the genealogy? Still unexplained. The memorial report Li Si struggles to write is basically the reader's frustration materialized — we WANT answers and the text keeps dangling them just out of reach.
... Read More
This chapter is layered with symbols that hit different on re-read. Let's start with the most obvious one: the medicine itself. Gu Changwei tampered with Gu Yunwu's medicine for YEARS, switching physicians to avoid detection. On the surface it's about physical poisoning, but the deeper meaning is about CONTROL—controlling who treats his son, controlling the narrative of care, controlling the appearance of a loving father while systematically undermining his own child's health. The prescription that includes aconite clashing with other herbs is basically a metaphor for Gu Changwei's entire relationship with his son: something that LOOKS nourishing on the surface but is fundamentally toxic underneath. Then there's Chun Tao's sachet. She wasn't trying to poison anyone—she was trying to PLEASE someone. She took the precious calming medicine and put it in an embroidered sachet, thinking it would make the young master happy. This accidental act of love became the evidence that could expose the truth. The symbolism is devastating: the only thing that could save Gu Yunwu came from someone who genuinely cared for him, not from the father who was supposed to protect him. The sachet represents genuine affection versus calculated cruelty, and its discovery feels almost fateful. And the fortune-teller! Repeatedly offering talismans, reading stars, saying he can't save them but can warn them. He's this recurring symbol of fate versus free will—can warnings change outcomes, or are people doomed by choices already made? The old man's persistence mirrors the story's larger question about whether truth will ultimately prevail against centuries of carefully constructed lies. Every time I think about this chapter, I see the image of that handkerchief spread on the table, herbs laid out like evidence in a trial that hasn't happened yet.
... Read More
OK so I need to talk about this moment where Gu Yunwu gives Li Si the surname "Li" because it was his mother's name. I literally had to pause and re-read that section twice. It's such a quiet thing to do—no grand speech, no emotional buildup—but it says everything. This guy has been through hell, probably betrayed by everyone around him, and yet he takes the time to give someone who was basically a nameless piece of gear a real identity. "I give you my mother's surname to crown your name. May you always live free, unrestrained, and fearless." That inner monologue right before he falls asleep next to Li Si? I'm not okay. That's the kind of moment that sits with you for hours after you read it. It's not romantic in the traditional sense, but it's deeply intimate in a way that feels earned. Two people who have seen each other at their most broken, choosing to stay.
... Read More
Let's talk about that pastry bag. A dead woman carries a paper bag of pastries into the Underworld—nothing else, no offerings burned, no family to send her paper money. Just this brown paper thing, folded over, sealed with red, Yu Yun shop name stamped on it. It's the only clue to her identity. And it IS a clue. The entire plot threads off this tiny object. What does that mean? I think it's about how the mundane outlasts the monumental. This woman might have been important in life—rich, powerful, connected—but none of that followed her. What she carried mattered. A snack. A receipt. Evidence she was someone who bought things, who existed in shops, who had routines. The bag becomes her entire biography in the afterlife. There's also the merit system, which is basically the spiritual economy. Li Si operates in merits, Jia Yi worries about losing hundreds, the deal is struck in thirty-five points. But then Li Si walks into Annan Town with TEN COPPER COINS and immediately enters a gambling den. Two economies, same pursuit. The irony is delicious: a ghost who can bargain with death ends up counting copper coins to pay a fortune teller. He's powerful but broke. Rich in authority, poor in change. Possession itself is symbolic—the dead roughneck becomes Li Si's vehicle, his temporary home. "The ghost within to move with ease." Identity is fluid here. Li Si inhabits bodies, changes appearances, negotiates with the dead. What is he, exactly? A person? A function? The story seems to say: you're whoever you're temporarily responsible for. He's responsible for catching a runaway soul, so he becomes a catcher. He's temporarily wearing a dead martial artist's skin, so he acts like one—rough, direct, willing to gamble. The old fortune teller offering to multiply copper coins into silver—that's temptation dressed as opportunity. It's the same energy as gambling, the same hunger. Everyone in this world is trying to convert what they have into something more. Li Si just happens to be good at it.
... Read More
Okay so this whole arc with Gu Yunwu and Li Si is just devastating in the best way. Let me just say it outright: Gu Yunwu went to see Chun Tao BEFORE reincarnating. Not Li Si. After everything—after Li Si got STABBED for him, after Li Si lay unconscious for three days—Gu Yunwu made a point of visiting Chun Tao to wish her well, and then vanished without a word to the guy who just took a blade through his body for him. And Li Si knows it. He literally broods about it: "Gu Yunwu would rather make a point of bidding farewell to Chuntao than come to see him." The jealousy is palpable, even through all the Underworld bureaucracy. But here's what wrecked me: the scene where Li Si reaches out and holds Gu Yunwu's fingers in the carriage after the study confrontation. "Li Si always felt that, in the moment he left the study, something within him had been forever left behind in that room." That line. That's not just guilt. That's grief for something that ended before it even really began. And Gu Yunwu's last words to Chun Tao: "May the young lady's next life be safe and joyful, free from worries for a whole lifetime." How gentle he is with everyone ELSE, and how completely he shuts Li Si out. Who is he protecting by disappearing? Or who is he protecting himself FROM?
... Read More
OK so I need to talk about Li Si because this chapter absolutely destroyed me. This guy has been a ghost haunting the story this whole time, kind of snarky and detached, and then suddenly—boom—he's the one shoving Xia Yuan out the back door like some wuxia protagonist. "If the shop is gone, you can earn again. If a person is gone, then they're gone forever." Are you kidding me? I literally gasped. And that faint smile before he pushes her? Chef's kiss. Perfect. But here's what really got me: his relationship with Madam Liu. She basically raised him, called him Tao'er like he was family, and he walks into that carriage knowing full well she could be complicit in everything that happened to Gu Yunwu. The way he sits across from her, no more false politeness, just stares right into those "deep, unfathomable gaze"—that is a character who has stopped playing nice. He's made his peace with danger. And Madam Liu? The woman is a mess underneath that composure. She admits she knew the pregnancy was a lie, knew the medicine was suspicious, placed Chun Tao in Yunsheng Pavilion but never told her WHY. She's been navigating this toxic marriage for years, half-aware something was wrong but powerless to act. Their dynamic shifted SO much in that carriage scene—from mother figure and child to two people who've seen too much, sitting across from each other with all the cards on the table. And Chun Tao, poor Chun Tao, dead but somehow still the most influential presence in the room. Her ghost is what cracked the case. Li Si found her sachet, she'd accidentally slipped poison into it, and that careless act became the evidence that could bring down Gu Changwei. I can't stop thinking about how Madam Liu's final composure cracks when Li Si delivers his advice about underworld judges. That trembling question at the end—she's finally facing the consequences of her own passivity, her own "cleverness backfiring." I need to know what she asked next.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or