Chasing The Phoenix - Reviews

Chasing The Phoenix
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about this scene where Li Zhi presses her hand against Xie Lanxu's right leg. This was the FIRST TIME she had ever touched a man's leg, and the author just dumps us right into her panic without any preamble. Her ears growing warm, fighting to keep her expression neutral—this is such a specific, human detail. You can almost feel her frozen in place, terrified of rejection. And the way she covers for it by inventing a fake twin sister backstory? Brilliant character work. She's improvising her way through intimacy, using the memory of her dead sister as a shield. But here's what really got me: Xie Lanxu doesn't push her away. He endures the discomfort, says thank you, and then shares his bun with her. He says "only a small piece is needed to feed the dog" but we know exactly what he's doing—he's testing whether she'll accept his gesture, and she does, cheerfully. This quiet exchange of half-buns between them is where something real is beginning. Meanwhile, the family dynamics are so toxic. Li Xiang literally screams "I'll never forgive you" over a dead sibling, and Li Jinzhi just pockets the bun she refused like it's nothing. Everyone's performing kindness while quietly stealing from each other. And Li Zhi? She keeps giving pieces of herself away while getting nothing back. I wonder when she'll finally stop.
... Read More
I need a minute. Just a minute. The twin relationship between Li Zhi and Li Xiang is written with this devastating intimacy that just gets under your skin and won't leave. "If only you hadn't slept so soundly that night... everything would have been different." This line from dying Li Xiang? I actually had to put the phone down. It's this terrible, unfair guilt that Li Zhi carries - she slept when her sister needed her. But then Li Xiang herself says "I know I'm only taking it out on you. It wasn't your fault." And that's the emotional whiplash, right? Both sisters are hurting, both are blaming themselves, and neither can stop. The physical details hit so hard too. Li Zhi stroking her sister's "dry, yellowing hair that had once been as lustrous as silk" - that contrast between what was and what is now. Or the way Li Zhi force-feeds the medicine, same method she used on that sickly dog Shendan. It shows how much she's had to harden herself, how survival has changed her. But then she's cradling Li Xiang's head in her lap afterward, gentle as anything. And that final scene - fifteen years of sisterhood ending with Li Zhi digging a grave with bloodied fingers, whispering to her dead twin like they're sharing a secret. "She must have been so tired to sleep this soundly." That's the kind of line that just destroys you. It's Li Zhi finding some twisted comfort in the idea that her sister finally got rest, that maybe death was mercy after everything they've endured. I'm not crying, you're crying. This bond between them feels so real, so precious, and watching it get ripped away in the harshest possible way... I need the author to make it up to me somehow.
... Read More
'Bright red blood and the soul-rending pain of loss — history seemed to repeat itself.' This line came out of nowhere and just stopped my breath. Because it's not just about Shendan dying. It's about the pattern. Li Zhi has lost people before. She's buried family before. And the word 'incompetence' follows it — 'Because of her incompetence.' That's the theme of this entire section crystallized in two sentences. Every time someone dies, it's framed as her fault. Not the guards. Not the system. Not the starvation or the cruelty. Her. This keeps happening and she can't stop it, and that's the real horror — not death itself but the cycle of helplessness. The Gobi Desert reinforces this. It's endless dunes and desolation, a place where nothing grows and nothing stays the same except suffering. Even the carriage — that recurring image of bells jingling faintly as the slowest exiles arrive — it's like a soundtrack to inevitable decay. And Li Zhi comparing herself to a sieve is the perfect symbol. She doesn't absorb pain or let it transform her. It just passes through. But sieves also break eventually. The dirt she's burying Shendan in is barren. 'Once she left, how lonely Shendan would be.' Even in death, the dog is alone. And Li Zhi is alone with him. That grave in the middle of nowhere is the most honest image in the book — no flowers, no marker, just a pile of sand and a carved wooden branch. The world keeps moving. The convoy keeps going. But some things are buried forever and no one will remember them except the person who dug the hole.
... Read More
Let's talk about the whiplash here. The author spends what feels like three full pages on this tender, awkward moment between Li Zhi and Xie Lanxu—her kneading his leg, the nervous dialogue, the bun-sharing—and then BAM, dogs start barking and suddenly we're in completely different emotional territory. It's like the author knows we got comfortable and decides to yank us out of that warmth. The dog reunion itself is handled well, I'll give it that. Shendan appearing out of nowhere is genuinely surprising, and the physical description—skin and bones, ribs protruding, matted fur—is brutal. It hits hard because we already know she found him during the Lantern Festival and her twin sister helped save him. That backstory insertion is well-timed, giving the reunion emotional weight instead of just being a cute moment. But then the family scene follows immediately, and the pacing inside that scene is excellent. Li Xiang's outburst, the simmering mother rivalry, Jinzhi's casual theft of the bun—all of it escalates naturally. The chapter basically does a full emotional arc: intimacy → joy → shock → family conflict, and I stayed engaged the entire time because the stakes kept shifting. One thing I will say: the wound-tending setup at the beginning felt slightly slow, but it established the harshness of their journey, so I can forgive it.
... Read More
Let's talk about what these people are gambling with, because it's everything and I mean EVERYTHING. On the surface level, it's survival. The convoy is killing people daily—those too weak to walk get executed without ceremony. Li Xiang is about to become another statistic when the imperial grandson's carriage appears. Li Zhi risks her own life standing up to guard authority. Zheng Gong threatens to whip her for disturbing the imperial procession. Zhen Qiao warns that interfering is punishable by death. One wrong move and Li Zhi joins the pile of dead exiles. But the deeper stakes are what actually keep me up at night. Li Zhi and Li Xiang's relationship is on the line. Whatever happened with Li Xia—whatever guilt Li Zhi carries—this moment forces it all to the surface. If Li Xiang dies, Li Zhi loses her last connection to their shared past, to the little girl who used to chase koi and climb trees. If Li Zhi fails to save her, she's failed twice now. And then there's the imperial grandson himself. Why is he here? Why does his carriage appear at this exact moment? The suspense is maddening because the author knows exactly how to dangle this. We get the wind chimes, the ash-gray fabric, theswaying curtain—but no face, no words, no resolution. Just the carriage approaching through the mountain pass while Li Zhi's forehead bleeds onto the rocks. "Freshly healed wounds on Li Zhi's back split open again." — this detail matters more than you'd think. She's already broken and breaking, and she's still kneeling. The physical stakes mirror the emotional ones perfectly. Both sisters are being torn apart, and the question isn't whether they survive but WHAT survives them
... Read More
Let me just say this: the desert scenes in these chapters are the most visceral worldbuilding I've read in a long time. The author doesn't describe the Gobi the way you'd expect — no sweeping panoramic vistas or poetic sand dune descriptions. Instead, the environment attacks you through deprivation. Food grows scarcer by the day. Rations are distributed by who you know, not who you are. Zheng Gong takes out his frustrations on Li Zhi because she's young and defenseless and he can. The sand isn't just dirt — it's where Shendan dies pinned beneath countless hands, where Li Zhi digs a grave with bleeding fingers, where the exiles eat dog meat and smile like they've been saved. There's a moment where Zheng Gong lashes her but stops when she shows no reaction, and then just... leaves her. He isn't even interested in torturing her anymore because she's already broken beyond the point of being worth punishing. That's worse than any whip. And the visuals — muted purple figure against the desert, the jingle of bells from the carriage as the weak stumble in, the bubbling pot of stew, bright red blood on black fur. These aren't pretty images. They're ugly and sharp and they stick to your ribs. The world feels alive in the worst way. It doesn't care about you. It doesn't care about Li Zhi. It just exists, vast and indifferent, and the people in it are smaller and smaller as the chapters go on.
... Read More
I am not okay. I repeat: I am NOT okay. The stakes in these chapters went from 'hard journey' to 'existential annihilation' so fast I barely had time to process it. Let's be clear about what Li Zhi is fighting: external enemies (Zheng Gong, starvation, the physical toll of three thousand miles), but also an internal one that's far more terrifying — the erosion of her will to keep going. After Shendan dies, she doesn't break down. She goes numb. And that's the real conflict here, isn't it? Not whether she'll survive the journey — that was always going to be hard — but whether she'll have anything left inside her when she gets to Mingyue Tower. Because right now, she's surviving on scraps: leaves, bark, weeds, decapitated insects. She eats whatever doesn't kill her. And emotionally? She's running on empty too. Zheng Gong can't even hurt her meaningfully anymore because there's nothing left to wound. When he whips her and she doesn't react, he gives up. That's the most depressing power shift in recent memory — the victim becomes untouchable because there's nothing left to take. And then Xie Lanxu appears and offers her nothing but his own pain, and she still can't respond. Two days later she collapses. The stakes just keeps climbing and the author never lets you catch your breath. What happens when she wakes up? What happens when there's truly nothing left?
... Read More
I need to talk about how this section is paced because it's masterful and also emotionally devastating in a way that I didn't expect. It starts with the convoy moving forward — steady, almost monotonous description of the exiles walking, the hierarchy of rations, Li Zhi's daily survival. This is the calm before. You feel the grinding exhaustion of the journey but nothing catastrophic happens. Then — BAM — Shendan dies. And the chapter doesn't pull punches. It lingers. We watch Li Zhi being held down. We watch Zheng Gong butcher the dog. We watch the exiles eat and smile. We watch Li Zhi dig the grave. And then Xie Lanxu arrives like a dream sequence and delivers this quiet monologue about his horse and walks away. And then — and then — Li Zhi finishes burying Shendan, returns to the convoy, and the next chapter opens with 'Two days after Shendan's death, Li Zhi fell gravely ill.' The pacing here is deliberate and relentless. There's no escape from the grief. The author forces you to sit in it the way Li Zhi sits in the sand. And that final chapter fragment where she can't open her eyes and hears blades and voices — it cuts off mid-sentence, mid-breath, and I immediately needed the next part. The structure mirrors Li Zhi's own deterioration: steady march, sudden rupture, numb aftermath, and finally collapse. Each beat lands because nothing is rushed. The silence after Xie Lanxu leaves is given space. The grave-digging is given space. Even the fever dreams get room to breathe. This is how you write suffering without melodrama.
... Read More
I need to just sit with this for a second because my hands are actually shaking. Shendan. A dog. A side character, basically, mentioned in passing as a pup that Li Zhi and Li Xia raised from starvation. And yet — yet — when Zheng Gong's men killed it and fed it to everyone, the entire book seemed to crack open. Not because of any grand drama. But because Shendan had been Loyal. Faithful. The kind of dog that trusts humans even when it should run. "Hunger had turned men into something worse than beasts." That line hit me like a punch. This isn't just a story about exile anymore. It's about how fast civilization gets peeled away when stomachs are empty. And Li Zhi — oh god, Li Zhi. She didn't scream. She didn't fight. She just... stopped. There's a part where she wanders around looking for a smooth branch because it was Shendan's favorite toy and she wanted to bury it properly. That's the detail that undid me. Not the blood, not the violence. Just a dog toy in a desert grave. She buried two family members in under a month with her own hands. Two. And the second time she collapses, it's not physical this time. It's spiritual. She becomes a sieve. Suffering pours through her and she doesn't hold any of it. What is left in a person after that, I don't know.
... Read More
I want to talk about how the pacing works across these chapters because it's genuinely impressive. The author starts with this slow, grinding accumulation of misery—the daily ration getting smaller, the cold worsening, people dropping dead—and then pivots HARD into the Li Xiang crisis. It's not a sudden shift; it's a slow tilt that becomes a freefall. Chapter by chapter, we see the convoy deteriorating. First it's just hunger and cold. Then it's executions of the weak. Then it's cannibalism being discussed openly. Then Li Xiang can't walk. Then a carriage appears. Each escalation feels earned because the author makes us LIVE through the gradual worsening rather than skipping ahead. We taste the sour sticky bread alongside Li Zhi. We feel the needles of wind. We watch Li Xiang's face hollow out day by day. The flashback sequence—where we learn about Li Xiang as a child, the tree-climbing, the egg-stealing, the koi pond, their twin-like bond—is perfectly placed. It comes RIGHT BEFORE Li Xiang collapses, which makes the contrast between who she was and who she's becoming hit like a truck. The author isn't being sentimental; they're using memory as a weapon against the reader's heart. And the structural parallel of Li Zhi kneeling and kowtowing while her forehead smashes against rocks—echoing the very opening image of the exiles collapsing exhausted on the same barren earth—creates this beautiful circular structure. They started at the bottom, and now Li Zhi is GOING TO THE BOTTOM on purpose, deliberately, to save someone. That's not accidental writing. That's craft.
... Read More
I have to nerd out about Li Jinzhi's dialogue because it is SO distinct and I love it. The man speaks in arguments. Every sentence is designed to corner the person he's talking to. Take this exchange: "Elder Brother, don't force Mother if she's unwilling," Li Huizhi murmurs. "Our teacher said—" "Did your teacher also tell you that without food, people starve? Or that winter without warm clothing leads to freezing?" THAT. The way he pivots from philosophical moralizing to brutal survival logic in the same breath. He doesn't just shut down his sibling—he reframes the entire conversation around his own urgency. And then he drops the nuclear option: "If something happens to you, where will Mother find the medicine to cure her regret?" Eight years old. He weaponizes an eight-year-old's potential death. And it WORKS. Madam Wang gets enraged and agrees. His voice is calculating, impatient, laced with this mocking edge—you can practically hear the sneer. Even when he's performing self-sacrifice, it sounds like a performance: "I'd even crawl on all fours and bark like a dog if it meant ensuring the Li family's survival!" Compare that to Li Zhi's voice, which is almost entirely internal. She observes. She questions. She doesn't argue. Her dialogue is sparse, and when she does speak, it's polite and measured—"Thank you for your kindness, Brother"—which makes her silence in other moments feel even louder. And Xie Lanxu? The man doesn't speak at all in these chapters. Not a single line of dialogue. He exists in gestures—chewing bitter herbs, crumbling bread, tossing scraps to dogs. His voice is absence. Which makes every other character's noise feel even more desperate by contrast.
... Read More
This chapter range hits different. You start with literal corpses everywhere — the eldest chieftain, his family strewn about, Xie Lanxu holding his dead son — and then it's just one relentless sequence of survival after survival after survival. The water crossing scene is such a smart structural pivot. We go from the chaos of the pond, Li Zhi nearly drowning while trying to follow him, to this quiet moment where he doesn't even look back at her. Just walks. Coughing. Soaked. And she's half-wading, half-swimming because she can barely keep up. The physical exhaustion mirrors the emotional distance between them perfectly. Then BAM — thirty lashes. Three days later, wounds still bleeding, scabs dissolving in sweat. The author doesn't let us rest. Doesn't give us a soft moment to recover from the punishment before dropping us back into exile mode. By the time we reach the carriage scene with the bun, I'm exhausted alongside her. And that final image of silver moonlight filtering through trees while she smiles up at him? Cinematic. Absolute cinema.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or