Broken Time and Broken Promises - Reviews

Broken Time and Broken Promises
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I've read probably a hundred books where gifts between characters are just... gifts. Plot devices. Token gestures. But the cookie box in this chapter hit me like a freight train and I'm not okay. Let me explain why. Ellen spent time selecting cookies. Different flavors — chocolate chip, butter, tea, lemon — because she didn't know which one Lennox would like. She gathered a bunch. She was nervous about giving it to him. She rushed to explain it away before he could refuse. And Lennox? Lennox sits alone at night, cheek still throbbing from where the servants hit him earlier, and eats a tea cookie — his favorite — and the flavor lingers and the moonlight hits his face and for the first time in this entire text, we see him smile. Not a smirk. Not a polite half-expression. A smile that 'quietly bloomed on his lips.' The author chose those exact words and I am not over it. What made this scene land so hard for me is the contrast with Lennox's backstory. We learn that his mother was forced to kneel and beg for forgiveness because Lennox became friends with a noble lady. They were expelled. Their livelihood was destroyed. And now here is another noble lady — another Ellen — handing him something fragile and sweet, and his entire nervous system is going: THIS IS HOW IT ENDS. THIS IS WHERE IT GOES WRONG. But he eats the cookie anyway. He eats it. And he smiles. And he decides: 'I should greet her properly. Next time I'll smile at least once.' That is the most quiet, devastating act of courage I've read in any novel this year. Not a grand declaration. Not a dramatic confession. Just a boy choosing to believe that maybe, just maybe, this time could be different. And then the lemon candy. Oh god, the lemon candy. She calls it precious. He calls it just a single candy. The gap between those two perspectives IS the emotional core of this entire relationship. To her, it's proof that someone sees her. To him, it's barely something. And yet both of them are holding onto it like it's the only real thing in the world. That's what this book understands about emotional connections between people of different worlds — it's not about grand gestures. It's about the weight you give to small things.
... Read More
I need to talk about Laura. Just—Laura. Who is this woman and why does she radiate so much quiet warmth it literally makes my chest ache? Let me paint you the scene: Ellen, this girl who has apparently never been touched with kindness, is embroidering tulips. Failing. All over again. Her tenth or fifteenth attempt is a hot mess of tangled threads. And what does Laura do? She doesn't sigh. She doesn't say 'just give up.' She looks at that disaster and says—get this—'My Lady, you have a wonderful sense for color.' She finds something genuine to praise in something that looked like a rat had run through it. And then she sketches a pattern for her. Patiently. Gently. And the hair-stroking moment?? Laura just smooths Ellen's hair after she finishes and Ellen's entire face changes. 'The warm, gentle touch lingered vividly—a kindness she'd never received from her parents.' I literally gasped out loud. This girl had never been held like that. Never. But then—AND THIS IS THE KILLER—Ellen goes to present her finished embroidery to her MOTHER. The Viscountess. And what happens? The mother doesn't even take the box properly. She 'carelessly untied the ribbon Ellen had worked hard to tie.' She tosses it on the side table. Not one word of praise. Not one smile. And when Ellen finally summons the courage to ask for Laura as her nanny, the silence that falls is so heavy I could feel it through the page. The contrast between these two women—Laura giving everything freely, the Viscountess giving nothing—broke something open in me. I kept thinking about that dream Ellen has at the end: Laura embroidered nearby, alive and warm, while her real mother wasn't even in the picture. That's the whole story right there. Family isn't blood. It's the person who sits with you in the quiet and makes your world softer. I'm not okay.
... Read More
Okay so let me just start by saying the author really doesn't need flashy twists to make a plot work. This whole section is basically the slow build of two people who keep finding reasons to be near each other, and honestly? That's the part that got me. Not some big dramatic event — just a kid giving cookies to another kid, and then a year passing like nothing but everything. The structure here is really interesting because the plot doesn't move in the traditional sense. There's no villain, no external crisis forcing them together. What drives the story forward is simply: Lennox sees Ellen at the window, Ellen waits for Lennox at the window, and slowly the space between them collapses. The spring chapter, the summer transition, the autumn party — the author uses seasonal shifts as natural plot milestones instead of relying on external conflict. It's kind of revolutionary for a fantasy romance setup because the stakes aren't 'will they survive' but 'will they survive staying honest with each other.' And then there's Lennox's backstory — or rather, the backstory we learn in pieces. The first time he meets Ellen, we know almost nothing about him. By the time he refuses to let her scold the servants for him, we've only gotten fragments. But then BAM, Chapter 13 drops the entire history of his mother kneeling and begging, and suddenly everything Lennox does makes sense. Every distance he keeps, every flat reply he gives, every time he says 'no need' when Ellen tries to help — it all recontextualizes. The revelation doesn't feel tacked on; it feels like the author was setting us up to understand why this specific boy would be scared of exactly this situation. The ending of this section — Lennox coming to her window at night to tell her the party felt empty without her and asking her to sneak down — is the kind of moment that doesn't need fireworks. It's quiet. It's dangerous. And it's the biggest commitment either of them has made yet. He broke protocol. He risked punishment. He told her he missed her. That's the plot spike, and it lands perfectly because we earned it.
... Read More
I don't usually write about dialogue separately from plot or character, but this text has some passages that are so finely tuned I had to stop and just appreciate the craft. Let's talk about the lemon candy exchange. It's four lines of dialogue between Lennox and Ellen, and it contains more emotional information than most romantic scenes in entire novels. 'Can you stop speaking formally to me?' — Ellen initiates. She's the one crossing the boundary first, and she does it with such casual certainty that it's almost terrifying for someone like Lennox. 'Are you sure I can speak informally?' — Lennox. Not 'I don't want to.' Not 'that's inappropriate.' He's asking for permission. He's treating informality like something that could be taken away, like a privilege rather than a default state. 'No taking it back?' 'I won't!' — And here's the thing that made me laugh out loud: Lennox is literally negotiating the terms of their friendship like a treaty. 'Really?' 'Yes!' 'No taking it back?' 'I won't!' This is two children having the most important conversation of their lives and neither of them knows it yet. 'I heard from Marie. You like lemon candy from Allemang's Confectionery. I bought it for you on the way back from my errand.' — This is Lennox at his most vulnerable. He remembered. He sought out something specific. He incorporated it into his routine without making it seem like he did. And then immediately minimizes it: 'It's just a single lemon candy.' The self-sabotage is immediate and automatic. Ellen's response — 'This candy is more precious to me than anything' — is the kind of line that only works because the author has earned it through sixteen chapters of patient, unglamorous buildup. It's not dramatic. It's not overwrought. It's just true, and that's why it hits. The narrative voice throughout these chapters is also worth noting. It's restrained. It doesn't tell us how to feel about anything. It describes Lennox's mother kneeling and then immediately cuts to Lennox thinking about cookies. The emotional whiplash is intentional. The author trusts the reader to sit with the discomfort. And the final exchange before the party scene? Pure gold: 'Isn't it fine as long as no one sees you?' '….' 'I know a place where you can watch the party up close, but no one will see you.' No romance novel could write that line better. No amount of dramatic music could enhance it. It's just two people standing in a garden at night, and the entire future of their relationship is contained in that silence.
... Read More
"Was it sadness, despair, joy? Or perhaps all of those? Ellen herself didn't know the meaning of the tear — it simply fell as it pleased." I'm not crying, you're crying. This entire scene between them is built on five years of unsaid things. Five years of him trying to forget her and failing. Five years of her convincing herself she never loved him. And then during sex — which itself is complicated as hell given he's the knight who destroyed her home — she cries. Not from pain. Not from pleasure alone. From the sheer overwhelming contradiction of wanting someone who represents everything that was taken from her. And Lennox's internal monologue: "He had thought that after five years in the Aryan Empire, he could at least learn to hate Ellen, to stop loving her. But he hadn't." FIVE YEARS. He's been carrying this. And she thinks SHE'S the one who's been suffering in silence. The flashback to her childhood really reframes everything though. A little girl picking tulips for a mother who won't even look at her. Being called disgraceful on her birthday. That's the root of why she clings to Baron Dermann — someone abusive is still someone, right? At least he's her husband. At least he's family by law. It's pathetic and heartbreaking and I hate that her father told other noble families not to associate with her. She was alone then. She's alone now. Except Lennox is finally there.
... Read More
I keep coming back to two images from these chapters and I don't think they're accidental. First: the tulip embroidery. Ellen spent time making this for her mother. Clumsy, but done with love. Viscountess Valère looks at it and tosses it in the trash. "Completely useless." That single act says everything about the world Ellen lives in. Her love is literally thrown away. And she doesn't even know—she walks out happy, thinking she did something good. The reader knows. That dramatic irony is a knife. Second: the pinky promise. Lennox and Ellen make a heart-pinky promise that Ellen won't leave her room. But can a promise between two powerless children protect anyone from the will of a noble? Of course not. Lennox himself regrets it minutes later: "I should've ignored the stupid errand and stayed by Ellen's side." The deeper theme here is about the brutality of a world where a child's smallest desire—to play with her friend, to have her favorite maid stay—can destroy someone else's livelihood. Ellen wanted to bring Laura and Marie closer to her. That's it. That's her motivation. Pure. And it results in Marie being cast out, accused, humiliated. The story keeps showing us that in this world, goodness without power is just another form of vulnerability. Ellen is good. Ellen is kind. Ellen is also completely helpless. And the novel doesn't let us forget that.
... Read More
"My Lady, aren't you being unfair?" I literally gasped when Marie said that. Because of course she does. After everything—after being sick for one day, after being replaced overnight—Marie turns on Ellen and calls HER unfair. The reversal of who the victim is in that moment completely destroyed me. And Ellen's voice throughout this is just—God. "I just wanted Laura as my nanny, so you and I could…" She can't even finish the sentence. She doesn't understand that in this world, her intentions don't matter. Only outcomes do. Only power does. The adults' silence is its own kind of dialogue. Not one of them denies Marie's accusation. Adol tells her to watch her words, sure, but he doesn't defend Ellen. They all look away. Their silence speaks louder than any lie Marie tells. Lennox's voice is also so distinct—he's the only adult-adjacent character who actually feels like a child trapped in a servant's role. "Even so, Madam has no right to hurt Ellen." That's not how servants talk. That's how someone who sees the world differently talks. He's caught between two worlds and he can't fully belong to either. And Ellen's mother's earlier scene—the clipped, cold "Fine." "I understand your request. Now leave." No warmth, no explanation. Just dismissal. That's the voice of someone who has learned to survive by giving people nothing. And Ellen is absorbing every version of that coldness right now.
... Read More
Let me just talk about the WINDOW SCENE for a second because it haunts me. After all that violence, after Baron Dermann slaps her face and threatens to throw out her things, Ellen just... goes to the window. And there's this absolutely gorgeous description of autumn maple leaves drifting down, 'stained deep red with fallen maple leaves.' The leaf lands on her pale hand, 'tinged with yellow,' and she holds it for a moment like her whole world hasn't just been shattered. 'The red leaf, tinged with yellow, contrasted beautifully with her pale hand.' This is the kind of visual that belongs in a film. You can literally see the color palette. Deep crimson leaves against her almost-white skin, the gray of impending winter mixing with autumn's last breath. It's her moment of silence before everything explodes. And then—LENNOX wraps his arms around her waist from behind. The scent hits her first: 'the dank, musty scent of the basement.' The contrast between the fresh autumn wind at the window and that underground smell clinging to him is DEVASTATING. He lived in filth, in darkness, for five years, and he came back smelling like the basement to hold the woman he left behind. Later, when the screams and crashing start outside, those sounds become 'like a dark orchestral melody—sometimes real, sometimes surreal.' The mansion transforms from a gilded cage into a warzone in real time. And Lennox's pale blue uniform with golden epaulets, contrasting against the dirty gray robe he was wearing seconds before—the visual transformation is chef's kiss. The blood on his palm when he crushes Dermann's teeth, the rings that ONCE STRUCK ELLEN now sliding onto his own fingers. Every image in this chapter is loaded with meaning.
... Read More
I started this chapter thinking I was reading some pretty dark romance stuff and ended up completely blindsided. The pacing here is absolutely ruthless and I am HERE FOR IT. It starts SLOW—almost uncomfortably so. Ellen's daily routine, tucking Innis in, ignoring her father's letters. Very quiet. Very mundane. Then Baron Dermann appears and the pace STOPS. Every slap is described in real time: 'Smack!' 'Smack!' 'Smack!' Three separate strikes, each one given its own moment. You can't skip ahead because each blow changes the scene slightly—her cheek swells, blood trickles, her expression goes numb. The author makes you LINGER on each one. Then Lennox arrives and the pacing SNAPS into something completely different. There's a whisper, an embrace, a name spoken—'Lennox..'—and then IMMEDIATELY she pulls away, demands answers, and suddenly we're getting exposition dumps about five years of separation. But instead of slowing down, the author uses it as a countdown. 'Listen, Ellen. Hear the sound of this place you've lived in for five years being utterly destroyed.' And then—BOOM—the door bursts open, Baron Dermann is kicked in, and we're in full action mode. The transition from the intimate bedroom scene to the violent confrontation is seamless. One moment it's whispered names and trembling voices, the next it's teeth rolling across floors and heads snapping to the side. What keeps me hooked through all of this is that even during the action, the author never forgets Ellen's internal state. Every external event is filtered through her terror for Innis, her shock, her dawning realization of what Lennox has become and what he's done. And that cliffhanger ending where Lennox is calmly fetching water after beating a man half to death—chilling. Absolutely unhinged pacing and I want more immediately.
... Read More
Let me just — Lennox throwing those fancy accessories out the window? The perfumes? The clothes? I literally gasped. This man doesn't speak his feelings, he DESTROYS them. Every expensive thing in that room represented a life Ellen lived without him, and he couldn't stand the thought of any of it remaining. But then — THEN he applies medicine to her cheek himself. So gentle. After literally trashing the entire room like a storm. The contrast is everything. And Ellen! She says 'my husband is my family' and part of me wanted to shake her, but the other part completely understood. She's been so conditioned into believing she doesn't deserve better. Her own father raised his hand against her. She normalizes abuse because that's all she's ever known. When she tells Lennox 'you destroyed my country and home, so what's stopping my husband?' — OOF. She's equating political conquest with domestic violence like they're the same thing. That's not logic, that's trauma speaking. But the moment that wrecked me most: when she cups his cheek and calls their childhood bond 'play that's long over,' and he replies 'Yeah. It's over. I'm only realizing that now.' He's realizing he still loves her after five years of trying to hate her, and she's already convinced it was nothing. Who hurts more here??
... Read More
I keep coming back to the imagery of surfaces and what lies beneath, and I don't think that's accidental. The most obvious one: Lennox literally wears a human face mask. He peels it off in front of Ellen and underneath is the face she thought she'd never see again. But what about the OTHER masks in this chapter? Baron Dermann's mask was just violence and entitlement—he showed his true face when he struck her. Ellen's mask was perpetual gentleness, perpetual submission. She had to 'force herself to smile' or 'the consequences would be far too severe.' Even Emma tries to maintain the mask of normal service while Ellen is being abused right in front of her. Then there's the title. Dermann's barony came from LENNOX'S MOTHER. So every symbol of his power—the rings, the mansion, the estate—is actually borrowed from the family Ellen loves. His authority is a performance, just like Lennox's disguise as Theon. Both men were hiding who they really were, and both are now revealing their true faces simultaneously. The red eyes are another symbol that keeps appearing. First Ellen marks her wounds with 'that gaze' of red eyes filled with affection, and then when Lennox reveals himself, those SAME red eyes are now 'cold and dark as ice.' The warmth is gone—but the intensity remains. The eyes haven't changed color, only temperature. And the maple leaves—red against white, beauty against violence, nature's cycle of death and decay happening right outside Ellen's window while her life is being destroyed inside. The leaves keep falling whether she's watching them or not. The world keeps turning even as her world ends.
... Read More
The dialogue in this section is SO sharp. Every line between Ellen and Lennox feels like it's got three layers — what they're saying, what they mean, and what they're terrified to admit. Take this exchange: "Why do you say things like that?" / "Because it's true." / "Ellen." / "Lennox, don't forget. Even you, a stranger, destroyed my country and my home, the Dermann family. So what's stopping my husband?" On the surface, Ellen's making a logical argument. But really she's weaponizing guilt. She knows exactly which buttons to press. And it WORKS — Lennox goes from furious to dazed. The author uses dialogue as a weapon here and it's devastating. Then his reply is quieter but hits harder: "You once told me you'd become my family." And her dismissal — "You still remember childish words? How foolish, Lennox." — is either genuine cruelty or the biggest defense mechanism in literary history. I'm leaning toward the latter. What I love about Lennox's voice specifically is how his dialogue shifts from explosive to restrained. He starts by ordering rooms burned and ending sentences with exclamation marks. By the end, he's speaking in fragments, asking questions he already knows the answers to. The dialogue mirrors his emotional state perfectly. And Ellen's voice — always so controlled, so cold — cracks in the most interesting ways. She never once says 'I love you' or 'I missed you,' but every harsh word she directs at him is basically a distorted version of those feelings. The subtext IS the text here, and it's gorgeous.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or