Broken Time and Broken Promises - Reviews

Broken Time and Broken Promises
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
What the stakes are in this chapter honestly made my chest tight. On the surface, it's a party. A social gathering. Nothing dangerous right? Wrong. Because the real drama happens when everyone pretends nothing is wrong. The Viscount and Viscountess perform affection for the nobles while privately tearing each other apart. And Ellen - sweet, desperate Ellen - is caught in the crossfire. She clings to her mother's skirt, savoring the scent, trying to hold onto a moment of warmth because she KNOWS what happens when they leave the hall. She tries to warn her mother without actually warning her. She bites her lip and holds back tears because she's learned that crying makes it worse. The stakes for Ellen aren't about life or death. They're about something more terrifying for a child - the potential loss of the only love she has. If she's too much, if she embarrasses her mother, if she's too attached... her mother might hate her. And that's a fate worse than death to someone who's never felt truly loved. Meanwhile Lennox has his own stakes. He's a fallen noble serving in a mansion that likely represents everything his family lost. He's caught between worlds - noble blood but servant status, dignified past but humiliating present. When Ellen grabs his sleeve and begs him not to leave, he could walk away. He has every reason to. But he doesn't. And the party itself? The setting where every word is performed, every smile calculated, every concern faked - it's a pressure cooker. The argument in the lounge could spill out at any moment. Ellen could be discovered crying. Secrets could be exposed. The chapter ends with Ellen saying 'we're friends now' and Lennox reluctantly agreeing to come back. Two people who've spent their lives surviving by staying small, by hiding, by performing... finding each other. And I know exactly what's coming. Because stories like this always end with either tragedy or rebellion. There is no middle ground for characters this broken and this determined. I am not ready for the emotional damage ahead.
... Read More
I need to talk about the back door scene because it is absolutely visceral. Ellen running out, ignoring Laura calling after her, the backlight making the adults look like shadows—just cinematic. You can literally see this. The mansion isn't just a setting; it's a cage. Every window, every door, every glance from a servant creates this suffocating atmosphere around a ten-year-old girl. And then there's the contrast of her room—that cozy blanket, the sunlight, the space where she used to feel safe before she even knew what was happening. Laura wetting the towel with cold wash water to wipe Ellen's face. That detail about the water being cold? It's small but it hits. Ellen's still shivering from the confrontation outside. The visual of Lennox standing by the closed door, unable to enter, while his friend is inside trembling—that isolation within a building is so well done. The architecture itself becomes emotional architecture. Walls, doors, windows, height differences. Ellen has to look up at everyone. Even Lennox, when he extends his pinky, they can't even touch. The world is built so that she can never be equal to anyone. I keep thinking about that window in Chapter 19 where she greets him. She's above him, but separated by glass and distance. By the end of these chapters, that window feels like a memory of something innocent.
... Read More
I keep thinking about that one phrase. 'If only you'd been born a boy to continue the family. Instead, something so useless was born.' It's the kind of line that plants a seed and then grows into a tree. The father says it on a day she was terribly sick with a high fever, half-indifferent and half-concerned. And then he says it AGAIN at the party, completely callous, and the mother doesn't even deny it. Doesn't shield her daughter from it. Just stands there and lets those words land. But here's what got me - Ellen's immediate internal rebellion. 'No, I'm not useless.' She refuses to accept it. And I understand why. Because the moment she agrees, the moment she internalizes that she's worthless... she'll never smile in front of her mother again. Her sense of self is the last thread holding onto hope that maybe, someday, her mother will look at her with love. The red eyes. Lennox's red eyes. I can't stop thinking about how the text specifically mentions them twice - first when Ellen sees them in the garden and can't forget them, then when she locks eyes with him in the darkness. Red eyes. Autumn leaves. A color associated with both beauty and decay. Is that symbolic of Lennox himself? A fallen noble, beautiful but withered by circumstances beyond his control? And the secret exchange - Lennox reveals his family sold their title, which in noble society is basically social death. Nobles who sell their titles 'quietly disappeared' and were erased from existence. Yet Ellen's reaction is pure joy. 'So this is our secret, just between us?' In a world where identity and status mean everything, the one thing that connects them is something hidden. Something that would destroy them if revealed. Their bond exists entirely in the shadows. I have so many theories about what this story is really building toward.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this: the pacing in Chapter 19 is absolutely brutal and I mean that in the best way. The chapter starts almost gently—Ellen greeting Lennox, bright-eyed, excited about Laura becoming her nanny. You think nothing's wrong. And then Lennox asks "Why?" and everything starts to crack. The author doesn't rush this at all. Ellen's confusion builds slowly. She doesn't understand why her plan backfired. She doesn't understand why Lennox looks serious. And then—bam—Laura tells her Marie is leaving. The pivot from joy to devastation happens in about three paragraphs and it destroys you. What's genius is how the author uses Ellen's own naivety as a pacing device. She *should* have known better. She's smart enough to catch Laura lying. But she's also ten, and she's still clinging to hope. Every time she gets pulled back, the reader wants to scream at her to just run outside and find Marie already. And then Chapter 20—almost entirely aftermath. No new plot events. Just Ellen breaking down, remembering her mother's words, crying silently. From a traditional plot standpoint this might seem like it slows things down, but emotionally it's exactly what we need. We sit in the wreckage with her. The breathing room is the point. I finished these two chapters and had to just stare at the page for a minute.
... Read More
Okay so I need to just sit with what I just read. The way Lennox appears—TEARING OFF HIS OWN FACE MASK in front of Ellen—is one of the most unhinged and iconic moments I've ever read. I literally gasped. Like, he was living in the basement as a mute worker named Theon, covering himself in human skin to stay hidden, and the first thing Ellen does when she thinks it's her maid is say something completely normal like 'When he loses interest in me, I'll put on the medicine then.' And Lennox just... embraces her. From behind. Let that sink in. The emotional whiplash is insane. But here's what got me most: their history. Five years ago she 'beat him and sent him away' after her wedding. She chose survival over love, over him. And now he's back as Commander of the Pamphilenet Order—the Crown Prince's personal guard—and the first thing he does is utterly DESTROY her entire life. He's taking off Dermann's rings with his own hands, pulling out his teeth with bare palms. And he says 'No need to show her this' to Karan like Ellen is something fragile made of glass. I hate that I felt a tiny flutter when he revealed himself but I also know that's exactly what the author WANTS. Because Ellen herself is torn—her heart 'swelled with excitement and joy' when she realizes his power, 'but only for a moment. As reality sank in, her heart quickly turned cold.' She's NOT supposed to be happy about this, is she? And the Baron Dermann thing—his title came from LENNOX'S MOTHER. Ellen had NO IDEA. She married a man whose entire status was built on a transaction with the person she loved, and she was too isolated in that mansion to know ANY of it. She's been living as a prisoner wearing silk, completely cut off.
... Read More
I need to talk about Lennox because this boy has commitment issues with warmth and I am HERE for it. The first time he gives Ellen cookies, he's literally defending himself. 'Just so you know, this is also a kindness from a noble to a servant. Got it?' He can't just receive the gift. He can't just say thank you and mean it. He has to frame it as transactional, as if emotional vulnerability is something that needs a receipt. And then — and THEN — he eats the tea cookie alone at night and has the most honest moment of the entire text. 'Tastes good.' Not the cookie. The night. The feeling. His mother's voice telling him never to get close to a noble lady echoing in his head, and still he thinks: 'If it was Ellen, maybe things would be different.' That right there. That is the entire character arc of Lennox Valère in one sentence. He believes the world will punish him for caring, and yet here he is, already caring anyway. The tragedy of his character isn't that something bad will happen — it's that he's already bracing for it while simultaneously letting himself want something good. That tension is what makes him so three-dimensional. And Ellen? Don't get me started. She's not naive. The text carefully shows us she's not. She knows the rules. She knows her father's strictness. She knows what happens when servants cross lines. And still — still — she waits at the window every morning. She notices he uses formal speech and actively asks him to stop. 'When you speak formally to me, it feels like there's a distance. It doesn't feel like we're friends.' She's mapping the boundaries and then politely asking him to cross them with her. The most revealing interaction for me was the lemon candy scene. Lennox remembers she likes a specific candy. He buys it on his way back from an errand. He gives it to her like it's nothing — 'It's just a single lemon candy' — and she receives it like he handed her a crown. That's not romance that's been built over years. That's two people who have never experienced unconditional positive regard from anyone, suddenly finding it in each other. His mother warned him. His entire life has been about not getting close. And yet here he is, inviting a noble lady to sneak into a servants' party at night. That's not a plot point. That's a character choice. That's Lennox deciding, consciously and deliberately, that the risk is worth it.
... Read More
Can we just stop and appreciate Lennox for a second because this boy has delivered some absolutely devastating one-liners and I am HERE for it. Ellen: 'When I get good at embroidery, I'll embroider initials on a white handkerchief and give it to you as a present. Promise.' Lennox: 'Will I get it before I die?' I literally wheezed. This is a CHILD saying this with total deadpan sincerity and it's the funniest thing I've read all year. But also—it's heartbreaking? Like, what kind of kid asks that question so casually?? It tells you everything about Lennox's emotional state without the author having to explain a single thing. And the dialogue between Ellen and Laura throughout the embroidery scene is SO natural. You can hear the class difference but it's handled with such subtlety—Laura calls her 'My Lady' but Ellen immediately tries to bridge that gap. 'Could you make something prettier instead of just fixing it?' has this perfect mix of entitlement and genuine longing. She's a noble girl ordering a servant, but she's also just a kid who wants a pretty flower and someone to make it happen for her. The Viscountess's dialogue though—chilling. 'I can't stand children who only watch for my mood and can't say what they want. If you want something, say it now.' That's not a mother talking to her daughter. That's a king issuing a decree. And the way Ellen's voice breaks throughout that scene—'A-actually…'—the stammering, the hesitation, the way she can barely form the words 'I want Laura as my nanny'—it's not over-written. The author trusts the dialogue to carry the emotion without need for internal monologue. Just broken sentences and silence and the weight of what's unsaid. 'Hello, Ellen.' 'Hello, Lennox.' So simple. So perfect. Their morning and evening greetings became this tiny ritual of normalcy in a house full of dysfunction.
... Read More
This entire passage is built around embroidery and flowers and I keep coming back to the symbolism because it's SO layered. Tulips. The Viscountess's favorite flower. Ellen chooses them specifically—'Mother's favorite flower. She always said tulips blooming in spring were so beautiful.' But here's the thing: tulips are fragile. They don't grow in harsh conditions. They need care, the right soil, the right温度. And Ellen is basically trying to grow a tulip in a house that's more like permafrost. The embroidery itself is the central symbol—and it works on so many levels. Each failed cloth represents an attempt at connection, at beauty, at proving her worth. She starts messy ('full of mistakes and looked sloppy') but keeps going. 'After failing dozens of times, she failed less often than before.' That's not just skill development—that's the entire arc of someone learning to believe they can create something good despite growing up in an environment that treats their efforts as worthless. And the color! Laura specifically notices: 'Even with the same red, there are many shades, and you chose them so well.' Red—the color of the Viscountess's hair, the color of the ribbon Ellen ties, the color of tulips. But red also means passion, life, blood. Ellen chose red among all colors, and Laura recognized that choice as meaningful. The mother sees only the object; the nanny sees the person behind the choice. Then there's Lennox and his 'before I die' comment—another flower metaphor inverted. He's so used to expecting nothing, to assuming he won't survive to receive kindness, that a simple handkerchief becomes a life-or-death question. The boy who 'showed no interest in anything' is the one who teaches Ellen that generosity shouldn't come with an expiration date. The dream at the end ties it all together: flowers being made, not bought. Love being stitched, not inherited. That's the thesis right there.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about this moment where Ellen shares that she can't tie ribbons properly. I know it sounds stupid on paper but it's literally the most vulnerable thing a girl who's been emotionally starved her whole life could do. Think about it - her father calls her useless, her mother pushes her away, and this one tiny embarrassment is the closest thing she has to intimacy in her entire world. And Lennox? The boy who just told her he sold his family's title because they were drowning in debt... he didn't laugh. He didn't look disgusted like she expected. He just... nodded. The way Ellen literally glows after sharing a secret for the first time is heartbreaking. 'So this is how it feels.' Those three sentences destroyed me. She's never had a moment with another person that wasn't performative or transactional. At this party, surrounded by nobles smiling and exchanging pleasantries, she finds something real in a servant hiding in a garden corner. And Lennox staying? He planned to leave the second she said anything annoying but he watched her wilt and stayed anyway. That's not friendship yet but it's the seed of something. 'He decided it would be fine to spare a little time.' God, he barely knows her and already he's giving her something no one else does. Also the ending where Ellen says 'we're friends now since we share a secret' and Lennox can't bring himself to correct her because of her sparkling eyes? I am SOFT. This book knows exactly what it's doing with these two. I genuinely cannot wait for whatever happens next with them. They balance each other so perfectly.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about the visual storytelling here because the author is REALLY doing something with space and light and I need to break it down. First you've got Ellen's world with Laura—warm, intimate, domestic. The embroidery hoop, the white cloth, the red thread. Afternoon light fading as they work. Laura tidying clothes, Ellen focused and clumsy and trying. It's a small room, a small moment, but it's SO FULL of life. Every detail grounds you: the failed cloths piling up, Ellen hiding her work in her skirt like a child caught doing something secret, the way she rubs her sore neck when she looks up. You can FEEL the afternoon stretching out around them. It's quiet. It's safe. Then—BAM—you cut to the Viscountess's room. Same color palette almost (red hair, red ribbons, tulips) but the atmosphere is like walking into ice. 'Her red hair elegantly pinned up, her posture perfectly straight as she held a teacup.' The room is 'large and bright, filled with sunlight. Yet somehow, the atmosphere felt dark—not a trace of affection could be seen in her gaze.' That line is EVERYTHING. Sunlight but no warmth. A big room but suffocating. The purple velvet door decoration, the side table where the gift gets carelessly tossed—it's all choreography for a scene where Ellen is performing, not living. And then the DREAM sequence at the end: Lennox reading, Marie bringing cookies, Laura embroidering. No grand setting, no palace description, just four people in a room and it feels more like home than anywhere else in the book. The author doesn't need castles and ballrooms to build a world—the emotional geography is what matters, and this story knows exactly where home is. Also low-key obsessed with how the failed embroidery cloths become this recurring visual—this physical evidence of effort and imperfection. They're literally piled beside Ellen like a monument to her trying. I love that.
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is SO sharp I need to address it. Every character has a completely distinct way of speaking, and it's not just about what they say—it's about how the author USES dialogue to reveal power dynamics in real time. Baron Dermann's voice is all noise. He shouts, he spits, he kicks letters around, he screams 'Don't call me 'Dear,' you filthy woman!' His dialogue is performative aggression—he needs to be heard to feel powerful. Even when he's yelling at Ellen, he's just making sound. 'Ugh!' 'D*mn it.' 'Nonsense!' He's all volume, no substance. Ellen's voice is the complete opposite. Her lines are short, measured, strategic. 'I will.' 'No.' 'Dear.' She uses exactly three words—'Dear'—as a weapon, and the moment he rejects it, she goes completely silent. When she's speaking to Lennox after the reveal, her dialogue becomes fragmented: 'Le… Lennox!' 'What are you doing…' She's losing control of her voice because she's losing control of her world. But LENNOX. Oh my god. His dialogue is minimal but EACH LINE hits like a hammer. 'Listen, Ellen. Hear the sound of this place you've lived in for five years being utterly destroyed.' That's not a threat—that's a PROMISE delivered with the casual tone of someone ordering coffee. And then: 'Tur Dermott, your father was said to be very wealthy.' Said with what tone? I need the author to address me personally about that line. It's so casually devastating. The narrator's voice is also worth noting—it's deeply intimate, always inside Ellen's head, never stepping back to give us objective perspective. We experience EVERYTHING through her sensory overload. That choice makes the dialogue feel even more visceral because we're not just hearing characters speak—we're feeling what Ellen feels when they speak.
... Read More
Let's talk about the setting transitions because the author is playing 4D chess with atmosphere and I am HERE for it. We start at this fancy party with the Viscount and Viscountess putting on their perfect noble performance. Everything is bright, musical, full of silk dresses and polite laughter. Ellen in her fresh green dress, the high-quality curtains fluttering in the spring breeze - it all reads like a painting. But then the parents retreat to the lounge and the mask drops. The music becomes 'almost unreal' from the garden. The pretty green dress looks 'drab.' The curtains look 'lonely.' The space feels 'suffocating.' I got CHILLS reading that. The environment literally mirrors Ellen's emotional collapse and I'm not even mad about it - I'm impressed. The author doesn't need to state 'Ellen felt empty and abandoned' because the world around her already tells us. Then Lennox appears. Dressed neatly, carrying a tray, red eyes like autumn leaves - this visual contrast between the warm golden party lights and the cold dark garden where two lost children find each other is so cinematic I can already see the adaptation. The sounds of insects blending with distant music creating this quiet bubble around them while the rest of the mansion continues its pretense? Chef's kiss. Also the way the garden itself becomes their sanctuary. Ellen has wandered these paths until her feet hurt. She knows every dark corner. This is the only place where she can actually breathe, where the performance isn't required. And Lennox? He's navigated these halls for a month, knows where to hide, where to appear unseen. Two people who've learned to exist in the margins finding each other in the margins. The setting isn't just background here. It's doing heavy emotional lifting.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or