Between The Fingers, Boredom - Reviews

Between The Fingers, Boredom
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about this sequence because WOW. The way the plot unfolds here is just...chef's kiss. We start with Zhao Yuan discovering some huge truth, his heart literally pounding, and then the narrative immediately pivots into one of the most revealing dream sequences I've ever read. And it's not just a random dream—it's the plot doing its absolute best work, showing us everything that Zhao Yuan has been refusing to consciously process. The dream itself is structured like a pressure cooker. First, the idyllic terrace scene with bitter black coffee—that's already a signal something is off. Then he enters a house that doesn't belong to him, sees Bian Liming in a formal setting acting like a successful businessman, and Bian Liming casually drops that they're "already married." Married! In a dream! And Zhao Yuan's reaction—shiver down his spine, trying to pull away but unable to—this is the plot perfectly externalizing his internal panic. Then the car scene. The white void outside. Bian Liming driving obliviously while Zhao Yuan screams "WHERE ARE YOU DRIVING TO?!" That moment right there? That is the entire central conflict of this relationship crystallized into one devastating image. They may be heading somewhere together in the dream, but Zhao Yuan has no idea where, and Bian Liming isn't even asking. And then—the parents' conversation, which lands like a nuclear bomb. The mother casually mentions "two betas, both men" and the social criticism that comes with it. The Bian family's offer to fund their education as a condition of getting together. The father's simple, devastating question: "Do you really like Bian Liming? Do you want to get engaged to him?" Zhao Yuan's complete inability to answer this directly tells us everything. What's brilliant about the plot structure here is that every single revelation cascades into the next. The dream exposes his fear, the parents expose the practical stakes, and we're left with this absolutely gut-wrenching cliffhanger about some morning outbreak that I am DREADING. The author is playing 4D chess with plot twists and I am here for it.
... Read More
I'm going to quote a few things because I literally cannot contain myself. First: "It's also how I think." Bian Liming says this about politics after Zhao Yuan attributes the mindset to Uncle Bian. Two words, and suddenly this character who seemed like a passionate but somewhat sheltered musician reveals he's been reading and thinking about power dynamics way more than anyone gave him credit for. Then there's the lemon tea scene—Zhao Yuan's exaggerated "Oh! How can the precious fingers of our Big Pianist be used to open a can for me!" and Bian Liming's fake cool retraction with a smile leaking from the corners of his mouth. The banter is so natural it sounds transcribed from real life. But the line that lives in my head rent-free is "there's a taste of success in an ordinary lemon tea!" Zhao Yuan saying this while tipping his head back and closing his eyes—that's not just dialogue, that's a mood, a thesis statement, a whole aesthetic. And Bian Liming calling him "Dr. Zhao! Can you be more materialistic?" with exasperation and affection warring in his tone? The author has given these two such distinct voices that even without tags, you'd know who's speaking. The humor is warm, the subtext is thick, and zero lines feel written—they feel lived.
... Read More
Let's talk about pacing, because the author here is absolutely murdering it (in the best way possible). Chapter 54-57 opens with Zhao Yuan stepping into the rain, heart racing after some major discovery. The sensory details hit us immediately—the rain, the half-soaked pants, the long-untouched cigarette—and we're thrown into his panic without any exposition dump. We don't know WHAT he discovered yet, but we FEEL the impact. That's excellent pacing: emotion before explanation. Then comes the cigarette, which triggers a cascade of reflections. This is where the author could have info-dumped their entire backstory, but instead they give us these beautiful, rapid-fire contrasts between Zhao Yuan and Bian Liming. One liked cappuccino, the other preferred Americano. One studied medicine, the other pursued art. The rhythm here is staccato—short, punchy sentences that build a picture through accumulation rather than explanation. It works beautifully because it mirrors how Zhao Yuan's mind is working: overwhelmed, racing, trying to process. And then—the dream. The dream sequence is where the pacing shifts dramatically. It moves from the frantic energy of the real world into something slower, more surreal, more deliberate. The terrace, the coffee, the unfamiliar house, Bian Liming in formal attire. Each detail lands with weight because the reader has earned the right to absorb it after the rapid-fire opening. But then the car scene hits like a punch to the gut, and we're back in high gear—Zhao Yuan panicking, screaming, and suddenly—HE'S AWAKE. Drenched in sweat. The transition from dream to reality is so sharp you feel the jolt alongside him. And then—the parents arrive. The pacing does this incredible thing where it slows down again, settling into the mundane rhythm of dinner preparation and family conversation. But the TENSION is still there, building beneath every seemingly ordinary exchange. By the time the father asks "Do you really like Bian Liming?" the emotional crescendo is absolutely massive after this careful buildup. And then the cliffhanger. "This morning, there was an outbreak of arme..." The author just STOPs. Mid-sentence. Leaving us absolutely hanging. The pacing here is pure torture in the best possible way. I need to know what happened next immediately.
... Read More
The opening of the second section gave me chills in the best way. 'Yancang City had never been a city with distinct seasons. The transition between spring and summer was vague and repetitive, with temperatures fluctuating with each rain.' I immediately felt the humid, uncomfortable atmosphere. This isn't just weather description—it's SETTING THE MOOD for everything that follows. Then you get the magnolia tree. Zhao Yuan looks up at it repeatedly but 'no white petals could be found among the glossy and abundant leaves.' A magnolia tree without flowers. That's... something, right? The tree is lush and alive but missing its defining feature. Coincidence? I don't think so. And the coffee shop! 'The new shop still served coffee, but the interior had been redecorated, and the name had changed.' Everything has moved on except the memories attached to it. Zhao Yuan passes by Bian's closed courtyard gate—still lush greenery inside—but he can't go in. The physical spaces feel so alive and textured. You can almost smell the humid summer air and taste the cappuccino foam. The author builds worlds through atmosphere, not exposition dumps, and it works beautifully.
... Read More
"Tears of excitement blurred Zhao Yuan's vision." Just six words and the author completely destroyed me. Let me sit with that for a moment. Because this isn't just about a competition win. This is about watching someone you care about deeply finally find something that makes them shine. We know Bian Liming used to be melancholic, always blamed life, never felt proud of himself. And here he is on stage, composed, articulate, winning, and Zhao Yuan is crying. Not sad tears, not happy tears—just overwhelming emotion at witnessing his person finally standing tall. The sunflower metaphor is unbearable in the best way. And then the embrace! Zhao Yuan doesn't care if anyone sees, he just OPEN ARMS goes in. No hesitation, no social calculation. Bian Liming pats his waist casually and asks what's going on, and Zhao Yuan leans close to whisper "Congratulations! You're my number one." The trembling in his voice says everything that his words don't. This is a relationship built on quiet devotion, on showing up, on being the person who notices and celebrates. It's tender and aching and beautiful and I'm not okay.
... Read More
I need to talk about how this chapter handles its middle section because honestly it could have dragged and it absolutely does not. Let me walk through the structure. We open in media res under a theater awning. Rain. A conversation that's already loaded with subtext. Two paragraphs and we've already got the ticket reveal. Then—no pause, no wind-down—we cut to them running through the rain. Another beat, another cut, and suddenly we're at the bed. "They didn't sleep soundly." Done. Moving on. Then the season jump. One semester passes. Not "one semester passed and during that time this happened and this happened and blah blah." ONE SENTENCE. The author trusts me to understand that time is passing without needing to fill every gap. This is confident writing. I respect it deeply. Both parents leave. Zhao Yuan is alone. Bian Liming comes over in PAJAMAS. They decide to go to Yutong Mountain. This entire sequence—from decision to departure to arrival—reads like a single breath. No hesitation, no internal monologue about whether this is a good idea. They just GO. And I think that's the pacing genius: the rush mirrors the emotional state of both characters. They are running toward something and running away from something simultaneously, and the prose moves at the speed of that running. The slow-down at the inn is deliberate and perfect. The heater, the carpet, the wine, the blurry light, the piano. Everything decelerates because for the first time in this entire chapter, they're not running anymore. They're sitting. And Bian Liming closes his eyes and plays. The pacing shifts from kinetic to stillness, and that stillness is where the real tension lives. The cliffhanger ending—the description of Bian Liming's jawline, the bones of his neck, the shadow on the keys—cuts off at exactly the moment I needed it to. Not a dramatic revelation. Just a moment suspended in amber. I am NOT okay with this writing.
... Read More
I need to talk about the conflict and stakes because this chapter elevated everything to a new level. Let's be real here. These two men are navigating feelings that society might not accept. The stakes aren't just emotional they're existential. When Bian Liming says let's be together this isn't just a romantic confession. This is a choice to potentially lose everything. And Zhao Yuan's hesitation about what happened last night isn't just awkwardness. It's fear. Fear of what this means. Fear of crossing a line that can't be uncrossed. The internal conflict is enormous. Zhao Yuan literally can't look in the mirror in the morning. He's terrified of facing his own reflection because the person staring back has changed. The external stakes are hanging over them too. They're in an inn with only one bed. Their relationship status is now undefined in the most dramatic way possible. Bian Liming sleeping until eleven and pretending everything is normal while Zhao Yuan wakes up at dawn. This tension between what's said and unsaid creates incredible suspense. The author maintains this through the entire mountain walk. Every glance every accidental touch every moment of silence raises the question of what happens next. And then in the pavilion with the rain closing in the stakes peak. They're trapped together physically and emotionally. The question becomes can they survive this conversation? Will they run or will they stay? The author makes you care deeply because these aren't abstract concepts. These are real people facing real fear and real desire. The conflict feels urgent because the reader understands what could be lost.
... Read More
I have to talk about the dialogue because some of it is so good it made me laugh out loud and then immediately feel sad. The shop assistant scene is perfect comic relief that also tells us everything we need to know about Zhao Qian. He drops a casual "snow in a propitious year, it's a good omen" and the assistant hears "business" and immediately pivots to: "We'll also help promote your business when we have a chance!" And Zhao Qian's response—pretending to be alarmed, waving his hand, saying "no need, no need"—this is a man who is charming but deliberately small. He doesn't want attention. He doesn't want to be known. Then the contrast hits with Bian Liming. No small talk. No warmth. Just: "I am Bian Liming, don't you recognize me?" The indignant tone, the immediate correction of "Mr. B" to his actual name—this is someone who has spent time thinking about this moment, rehearsing it, dreading it. And then the softness underneath: "When I came, I brought a cup of cappuccino for you, hot." The pause before "Have you had breakfast? I don't remember you..." is devastating. He's searching for memory, for connection, for something to anchor himself. Zhao Qian's dialogue is minimal, controlled, almost defensive. Bian Liming's is emotional, slightly fractured, slipping between professional formality and personal desperation. These two voices are completely distinct and that's rare. The author isn't just writing characters who speak differently—they're writing men whose entire histories are encoded in how they choose their words.
... Read More
There is a scene in these chapters where they go to a supermarket on a Friday afternoon to buy snacks before watching the news, and I need you all to understand: this is one of the most vividly rendered everyday moments I have ever encountered in fiction. Let me paint it for you. Friday afternoon. Not crowded, not empty. Shelves lined with goods. Loudspeakers at promotion booths repeating discount info and "welcome to taste" messages. A small shopping cart. Shoulders bumping as they walk. And then — just naturally, without any announcement — Zhao Yuan loops his arm through Bian Liming's. "It seemed like the first time they went grocery shopping together, or perhaps it had become the last time. However, at that time, no one thought about what would happen later. Both of them comfortably stayed in the present, in the limited future." The lighting in this scene — fluorescent supermarket lights, Friday afternoon slump, the mundane glow of a shopping aisle — it's so specific and so warm. I could see the whole thing as a film. The way the author writes about the coffee shop closing down, the way the last visit becomes ceremonial without either of them acknowledging it as such... every scene in this book has this quality of ordinary objects carrying enormous emotional weight. The brother arriving from the "independent state on the main island" — I don't even know what that means geopolitically but it immediately paints a picture of distance, of someone who has to plan and fly and schedule love into their life, while the protagonist's love lives in spontaneous arm-linking and shared shower thoughts.
... Read More
The dialogue in this passage is a case study in economy. Every line serves multiple purposes—character revelation, plot advancement, emotional subtext—all without ever feeling over-written. Take this exchange: "Studying medicine now, and still smoking every day?" "Habit. Can't quit." That's it. Two lines. And in those two lines, we get Bian Liming's concern (is this self-destructive?), Zhao Yuan's deflection (it's just a habit), and the unspoken truth (grief is a habit I can't quit). The subtext is louder than the text, and that's the mark of skilled writing. The grandfather cigarette scene is dialogue at its most devastating: "This cigarette belonged to my grandfather. From childhood to now, his hands always had this smell." No elaboration. No emotional punctuation. Just a statement of fact that carries the weight of an entire relationship. Zhao Yuan doesn't say "I miss him" or "I'm sad." He says his grandfather's hands smelled like cigarettes, and that's somehow more heartbreaking because it's so specific. Bian Liming's voice is distinct from Zhao Yuan's, which is crucial because these two characters communicate almost entirely through implication. Bian Liming asks questions—"Why did you start smoking?"—and Zhao Yuan deflects with actions rather than answers. This verbal asymmetry tells us everything about their personalities: Bian Liming seeks understanding; Zhao Yuan protects through silence. The dialogue tags are minimal. The author trusts the dialogue to stand on its own. Even the narration around the dialogue is sparse—"Zhao Yuan chuckled lightly, flicked off the cigarette ash, pressed the cigarette against the wall behind him"—just enough action beats to ground us without interrupting the flow. And that opening moment—Bian Liming asking "How was it? Did you like it?" with those eager puppy-dog eyes—captures his entire personality in three words. He's the performer seeking approval. Zhao Yuan is the reluctant audience, arms crossed against vulnerability. Their voices are already established before we even understand the full scope of their history. The author doesn't waste words. And in a story about grief—where words often fail us—that restraint feels almost sacred.
... Read More
Okay so this section is actually doing something really clever with the plot structure. On the surface, it looks like a simple subplot where Bian Liming decides to enter a piano competition, right? But if you pay attention, the author is quietly setting up a whole arc about ambition versus authenticity. Bian Liming has been stubborn since we met him, and now he's throwing himself into a competition that literally nobody else wants to touch because it's too hard and the odds are bad. That's not random—that's character. And the fact that he chose to ask Zhao Yuan of all people for help? That's the real plot move here. It's not about the music; it's about who he trusts to see him. There's also this weird parallel thread with Bian Liqin dragging his dad around on some military business trip, which feels like it's setting up a family conflict subplot. The car scene with those two suitcases tied to the roof? That image of a frail old man struggling under heavy burdens—come on, that's not accidental foreshadowing. Someone's about to crack under pressure. I'm just curious whether the competition will actually matter to the plot or if it's going to be a red herring that gets abandoned later. Because right now it feels like it should be big, but the author has a habit of subverting expectations.
... Read More
I've been staring at this image for hours and I can't shake it. The nanmu coffin at the Bian family memorial—no body inside. Just clothes. A white shirt. A brown leather belt. Well-ironed suit pants. Old leather shoes that had already creased. This is the most devastating piece of stage direction I have ever read. What does it mean? Bian Liqin is gone, but what remains is only what he wore—the artifacts of a life, the shell without the substance. The clothes are neat, folded, arranged with care, as if dignity can be ironed into fabric. And that tear Zhao Yuan drops onto the white shirt—"with a plop"—the sound alone is devastating. A single drop of grief landing on perfectly pressed cotton. Then there's the red backdrop at the piano competition, described as "as red as fresh blood." Red everywhere. Blood-red curtains at the venue where Bian Liming celebrates, and then red velvet surrounding the empty coffin. The color doesn't change but the meaning does—it goes from celebratory to funereal without the author having to say a word. And those old creased leather shoes. Bian Liqin, who was always "so dazzling and perfect, no one could find fault with him," reduced to worn footwear at the bottom of a coffin. Perfection dies too. That's the theme I keep circling back to: the story seems to be asking whether anyone truly deserves the pedestal they're placed on, and what happens when the person on that pedestal is gone.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or