"Our Qing'er is right, look at how much I treasure Qing'er. A girl needs to be loved."
Gao Xiulan speaks in bullets. Every sentence is a strike disguised as affection. She never says "I won" to her sister—she just mentions her three sons and watches the color drain from Gao Xiuju's face. That's masterclass dialogue. Show, don't tell, and make the telling feel accidental.
Then there's Guo Changsheng, and his voice is completely different. Official, strained, repeating phrases like a man reading from a script he didn't write: "There will always be difficulties. So many storms and waves have come over before." He's not lying—he genuinely believes this. But you can hear the crack in his voice when he says it. He's trying to sell hope and he knows the product is defective.
The children's voices matter too. Su Aiguo: "Mom, look at what you said, I can't let you take a bite less." Flat, practical, already raised in a world where food is the central crisis. This kid isn't dramatic about it. He's just doing the math.
And Gao Xiuju's explosion—"You black-hearted mother and daughter, why didn't the next thunder strike you to death?!"—is the most honest line in the entire chapter. Everyone else is negotiating, calculating, performing. She's just furious and says it out loud.
Su Qinghe rarely speaks in this section, which is interesting because she's the protagonist. Her silence feels intentional. She's observing, absorbing, processing the world around her. When she finally does act—deciding to cook, checking her secret storage—there's no dialogue to precede it. Just action. The narrative voice trusts us to understand that her internal shift doesn't need announcement.
"This year, we can not eat new grain and tighten the belt of our pants." Guo Changsheng's delivery of this line is the kind of dialogue that becomes a cultural reference point. People in this world will be quoting it to each other for months.