Back to My Dad’s Youth - Reviews

Back to My Dad’s Youth
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so here is the thing that completely got under my skin reading this. Fu Xuexue ranks first, everyone cheers, Lin Wangye does his usual happy dance — and then like five seconds later the whole floor drops out from under you. Because of course someone has to lose when someone wins. Of course. And it is Xu Suinian. Not some random kid. Him. The one who went to the hospital, the one who Lin Wangye literally spent hours tutoring, who dropped six places in the grade. And now he's just... making himself disappear from Class A to give Fu Xuexue a seat. No protest, no drama, just a quiet conversation with the teacher and poof — he relocates. Like a pawn sacrificed on turn twenty-eight and nobody even clapped. What are the actual stakes here? Fu Xuexue gets to stabilize her grades by injecting herself into the most competitive class in the school. Xu Suinian loses his position, his environment, everything, for reasons we still don't fully understand. And Lin Wangye is out there sending frantic WeChat messages while nobody replies because of course they don't reply. The suspense here is absolutely brutal because you can feel the trap closing but nobody is screaming. It's the silence that's scary.
... Read More
I'm still recovering from the pacing in these chapters. Let me try to diagram what the author did because it's genuinely masterful. The scene opens with exposition — Shi Yuan's philosophy about not bullying girls, Lu Chengxuan's coldness. This establishes the emotional baseline and gives us context for why Lin Wangye is the way he is. Most authors would skip this and jump straight to action, but the author knows we need to understand Lin Wangye's moral framework before we can appreciate the comedy of his failure. Then the inciting incident: Lin Wangye storms back to the classroom and SLAMS the love letter on Lu Chengxuan's desk. 'Smack.' Onomatopoeia as a punctuation mark. The noise 'caught everyone's attention, and dozens of eyes turned toward the love letter.' We're in motion now. The confrontation between Lin Wangye and Lu Chengxuan plays out like a tennis match. Lin Wangye serves with emotion, Lu Chengxuan returns with cold logic. The rally goes back and forth until Lu Chengxuan's speech about the college entrance exam and 'responsibility' wins the point. Lin Wangye is left speechless. We've reached the first emotional low. Then Lin Shen enters the fray, providing comic relief and escalating the tension: 'High moral standards, impressive.' The perfect rebuttal that leaves Lin Wangye choking. This is the author giving us a moment to breathe before the real hit. The request to open the letter feels inevitable — Lin Wangye seizes on Lu Chengxuan's ambiguous 'up to you' as permission. The three of them lean in together. Suspense builds. The reader is leaning in too, wondering what's inside. And then: the reveal. The pacing here is surgical. The author gives us the first line of the letter, then immediately cuts to reactions. 'Holy shit!' from Lin Wangye. Lin Shen stretching forward to read it himself. The rapid back-and-forth between shock and panic creates a cascade effect. By the time Lin Wangye stuffs the letter in his pocket and storms out, we're moving at full speed. The math teacher encounter is the perfect decompression valve — a comedic deflation after the emotional peak. Lin Wangye runs to escape embarrassment and runs straight into the person he fears most. The timing is impeccable. And the chapter ends on an almost cinematic note: Lin Shen freezing mid-pen-spin when the homeroom teacher enters with someone new. The word cuts off — 'The ba' — suggesting the text continues with whatever dramatic revelation comes next. Cliffhanger energy. We need to know who walked in. The structure moves from exposition → confrontation → escalation → climax (the reveal) → denouement (math teacher) → new inciting incident (door opens). Classic five-act structure compressed into a single scene. No wasted movement.
... Read More
Vivian. I need to talk about Vivian because this woman walked into a room and immediately rewired the emotional temperature of everything around her. Here's Lin Wangye—he's been through something terrible enough that he ended up sitting by a pile of trash in a dead body, and the first human interaction he gets is being told to get some clothes and take a shower. Instead of interrogation or suspicion, he gets kindness. Vivian doesn't pry into his past. She doesn't demand explanations. She just... makes space for him. 'Are you still getting used to things, dear?' That single line does so much work. It acknowledges displacement without forcing him to relive it. It's the kind of emotional intelligence that most adults never develop. And then the goodbye scene. She waits until late at night every single day just to see her son. She rubs his face. She calls Lin Wangye 'Lovely Angel' and pinches his cheek. The text says Lin Wangye felt 'a soothing spring of affection'—and I believe it. After whatever he went through before being reborn, that kind of unconditional warmth must have been almost painful in its intensity. Then there's Lu Chengxuan. 'I take after my dad.' Cold. Flat. But the fact that he noticed his mother's warmth and actively chose not to mirror it? That's character depth right there. He's not just 'the aloof rich kid' trope. He's making a conscious choice about his emotional posture, and that's way more interesting. Lin Wangye's question—'Your mom is so kind and warm, how come you're always so cold?'—feels like the most honest thing he's said in this entire passage. It's not judgment. It's genuine confusion from someone who clearly values connection. And Lu Chengxuan's response isn't defensive. It's just... stated. Like he's already accepted that he's different, and he's not even trying to explain himself anymore. I'm obsessed with watching these three navigate each other. The mother who gives too freely, the son who guards everything, and the stranger-in-a-new-body who doesn't know how to receive either of them yet.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about this exchange because it is EVERYTHING. Lin Shen says he's the school goddess. Not even defensive, not even explaining — just casually declaring himself the goddess while mid-game. And Lin Wangye's response is to immediately turn it into a competition: "Then I must be the class goddess!" This is not a father-son conversation. This is two guys who happen to be related by circumstance, bantering like they've known each other forever. And Lin Shen's response to the kowtowing suggestion? "Does kowtowing work? Go ask, and if they say yes, I'll head to the police station and start bowing right now." That level of dry, self-aware sarcasm is so distinctly his voice. He could've been heavy and dramatic about being unable to adopt Lin Wangye. Instead he makes it a joke. That's the mark of a writer who truly understands this character. Lu Chengxuan is the straight man in all of this — measured, precise, delivering life-altering information in perfectly calm sentences. His line about the uncle being 'child-free by choice' with legal adoption rights reads like a social worker's report. Which is exactly the point. He's the responsible adult. But even he can't hide the emotional undertow when Lin Shen's keyboard suddenly goes silent after hearing about the adoption.
... Read More
I don't think I've ever read a school-life novel that captures the ache and warmth of adolescent friendship so effortlessly. Lin Wangye whining to Lin Shen about switching seats—he's being a brat, sure, but there's genuine affection underneath the pestering. And when Lin Shen realizes he's being used against his own words (“Are you seriously using my own words against me right now?!”), it's not angry; it's fondly exasperated. That's the tone of people who know each other too well to be fake. Then there's Lu Chengxuan. He doesn't say much, but his line—“I'll switch with you after class”—given to Shi Yuan without hesitation, says everything. It's a quiet promise, an assurance that he'll make space so Lin Wangye doesn't have to suffer. And Lin Wangye's instant pivot to puppy-dog eyes at Shi Yuan? Perfect emotional comedy; he knows exactly who to manipulate. But the real heartbreak is in the winter break homework passage. The narrator reflects on how Lin Wangye's past-self never really tried, never pushed past seventy percent effort, because he was spoiled, pampered, sensitive to discomfort. Now, sitting next to Shi Yuan, he feels romance as a distraction. “It was ridiculously hard not to sneak glances at the person next to him during class.” That line—ah. That's the whole book in one sentence. It's not about drama or betrayal; it's about the terrifying vulnerability of caring about someone's presence more than your own grades. And Shi Yuan noticing, catching him, giving a warning look—that's intimacy in microcosm. They're learning each other's rhythms. Meanwhile, Lin Shen's complaint about being a “laboring sidekick” masks a deeper fear: of being overlooked, of not having a title that matters. When Lu Chengxuan offers him the study monitor role, Lin Shen calms down instantly. It's not about work; it's about being seen. These characters aren't performing emotions; they're living them in ordinary moments.
... Read More
So here's the thing nobody talks about but EVERYONE should: the most important romantic scene in this entire book doesn't have a single romantic line in it. Think about it. What ACTUALLY happens? Lin Wangye wakes up. His clothes are warm because someone folded them inside a blanket overnight. His shoes are cleaned. Socks placed neatly in them. Someone made him water. Someone stayed awake all night instead of sleeping because holding another person was somehow more exhausting than restful. This is Shi Yuan's love language, and it is DEVASTATING. The man cannot say feelings. Will NOT say feelings. But he will burn his entire life down to make sure the person he cares about sleeps warm and wakes up to clean shoes and hot water and porridge made by his grandfather. And Lin Wangye — he notices ALL of it. He "happily rolled in the blanket with the sweatshirt." He felt the warmth and it made him feel completely enveloped. This boy who has apparently spent his whole life alone, who slept without a camera in his room his entire childhood, is experiencing something he has zero framework for. The dynamic here is so specific and so aching. One gives through action. The other receives through slow, dawning realization. They're both terrible at talking about what they feel, but the text doesn't need them to. The details speak louder than any confession ever could.
... Read More
God, the way Shi Yuan just... gives in. Every time. Lin Wangye says 'let them keep sealing you away' because he's jealous of people staring at Shi Yuan, and what does Shi Yuan do? 'Alright, whatever you say.' No resistance. No negotiation. Just completely, unreasonably indulgent. That hits different when you think about their history. Shi Yuan grew up with dirt on his face and no praise for his looks—he never had a clear sense of how good-looking he actually was. So Lin Wangye, this heartbreaker type even without glasses, gets possessive and Shi Yuan just... folds. It's not weakness. It's the kind of surrender that comes from being truly seen by someone who chooses you anyway. And Lin Wangye? He's clearly insecure underneath all that confidence. The fact that he gets jealous of strangers looking at his boyfriend says everything. He counts down to holidays during breaks but can't wait for school to start again—because at school they're together all the time. That vulnerability he shows? Pushing Shi Yuan against a tree under moonlight, trembling lashes, desperate kisses like he's drowning and Shi Yuan is the only air? That's not the cool, composed Lin Wangye everyone remembers from the past life. That's someone who finally found something worth losing control for. Their dynamic is perfect because it's not symmetrical. One gives, one takes. One plans, one follows. And it works because they both know exactly what they're doing.
... Read More
This author understands something most writers miss: dialogue isn't just what characters say, it's what they DON'T say while saying something else. Watch this exchange: Lu Chengxuan: 'This is my…' Then the narrative drops: Random passerby? Rival? Pitiful orphan? In that moment, we get three words of spoken dialogue and an entire paragraph of subtext. Lu Chengxuan is trying to introduce his friend to his mother and his brain is running a crisis management simulation. That's not exposition—that's CHARACTER. Pure, distilled character through failed verbal output. And then Vivian's lines. 'What happened to you, my darling? Isn't it cold outside? Look at how cold your hands are.' Three questions in a row, none of them rhetorical, all of them genuine. Her voice is immediate warmth. Compare that to Lin Wangye's polite deflection: 'Hello, Auntie. My name is Lin Wangye. I'm really sorry for the sudden visit. You… you're so beautiful, I've never seen such dazzling blonde hair before.' The shift from formal apology to desperate compliment is comedic gold, and it's entirely accidental on his part. The narrative voice throughout is this sardonic, almost sarcastic undertone that sits right beside the genuine emotion. It's like the narrator is winking at you while the characters are living through actual feelings. The contrast makes everything sharper. I laughed out loud at 'My knees nearly gave out. He almost dropped to the ground and kneeled right there in front of Lu Chengxuan' and then immediately felt bad for how much it also reveals about Lin Wangye's actual social positioning.
... Read More
Can we just talk about Lin Shen for a second because THIS character. The way he throws a fake tantrum about being abandoned, then immediately cracks when offered 1,000 game coins? That is such aSpecifically, THAT moment when Lin Wangye pulls out the game card and Lin Shen's entire posture shifts from wounded to greedy? Iconic. Absolutely iconic. He literally goes from "my heart is dead" to trying to play it cool five seconds later. The awkwardness is so real—I've absolutely been that friend who can't accept a gift because admitting you want it makes you look soft. And their dynamic is giving best friend energy but also something deeper, something almost sibling-like despite the weird "dad" reference (which I'm still processing). Lin Wangye noticing that he's been neglectful and immediately trying to make it right? That's not just guilt—that's genuine care. He doesn't just apologize, he BRINGS THE MONEY. Action over words, classic Lin Wangye. But here's what's killing me—the ending of that exchange. "Then I'd fall in love with him." Is this platonic? Is it... something else? The text leaves it beautifully ambiguous and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
I genuinely cannot figure out how the author manages to make a chapter that has almost nothing 'happen' on the surface feel like it contains a dozen chapters worth of emotional compression. Let me walk through the rhythm here because it's actually brilliant. First beat: the afterlife joke and Lin Shen's dramatic threat. Quick, funny, light. You think we're in a comedy. Second beat: the snow stops, Lin Shen walks into class, confetti explodes. Warmth, sensory detail, community. Still feel good? Good. Third beat: Zhao Youyou asks about Shi Yuan's discharge. The pivot happens right here, and it's so smooth you barely feel it. The question goes from casual to devastating in two sentences. Fourth beat: the hallway conversation. Zhao Youyou laying out the entire tragedy of Shi Yuan's family in a single flowing monologue. No pauses, no cushioning. Just truth after truth hitting Lin Wangye like physical blows. Fifth beat: Lin Wangye sitting in English class, drifting into memories. The emotional afterdrop. What's wild is that the chapter doesn't rush any of it. Each section gets room to breathe. The transition from confetti to tragedy isn't jarring because the author has already trained us to expect life to do that — beautiful moments followed immediately by something that cracks them open. And the ending on that memory of Shi Yuan crawling toward him at one year old? Perfect punctuation. It's quiet, it's intimate, it's the last thing you feel before closing the book.
... Read More
This chapter is a masterclass in tonal whiplash done right. It opens with high-energy gaming banter—Lin Shen demanding to take over the match, Lin Wangye carrying the game like a boss, the whole competitive brotherhood vibe. You're laughing at "wild dad," you're impressed by the gameplay description, you're wondering if this is going to be a lighthearted reincarnation comedy. And then—boom—the tears hit. Not gradually, not foreshadowed, just straight into grief because the protagonist's defenses finally crack and it's devastating. The transition works because the author doesn't rush it. Lin Shen is still rambling about teammates, still focused on the game, while Lin Wangye is quietly crumbling beside him. The contrast between the dad's oblivious chatter and the son's internal collapse is heartbreaking. And then the pivot back to normalcy is just as quick—Lin Wangye wipes his tears, makes a joke about not having a father, and Lin Shen immediately apologizes. The mood shift is so fast it's almost jarring, which I think is intentional. Grief doesn't give you time to process, and neither does this chapter. What I love about the pacing is that the internet cafe scene itself—setting up the machines, the private room, the cola cans, the cigarette lighter—acts as a buffer zone between the emotional high and low points. It gives the reader space to breathe before the next emotional beat drops. The chapter doesn't overstay its welcome either. It ends on the account problem, which is a perfect minor cliffhanger that keeps you wanting more without being dramatic about it.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say — I did NOT see this coming. Lin Wangye storms into that hospital room ready to absolutely destroy whoever messed with his dad, right? Full on righteous fury, sleeves rolled up, about to hand out justice. And then he sees WHO it is and literally bolts. That moment? Chef's kiss. The narrative almost tricks us into thinking this is a simple 'find the bully' moment, but it's actually this whole layered reveal about connection and misunderstanding. And honestly the structure here is so smart. You've got three parallel scenes: the car ride banter (setup), the history class moment with the empty seat (ominous foreshadowing), and then the hospital confrontation (payoff). The empty seat before Lin Shen leaves for the cafe — that tiny detail that almost nobody notices but which makes SO much sense in hindsight. Classic misdirection done right. The subplot with Qu Liuliu getting rejected also ties back beautifully. Everything connects. Lin Shen saw her crying, assumed bullying, jumped in — completely misunderstanding the situation. Yet this 'mistake' creates the entire chain of events that brings Lin Wangye and Shi Yuan together. The author is playing 4D chess with cause and effect here. Every wrong turn leads somewhere important.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or