Your Ryan - Reviews

Your Ryan
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let's talk about what everyone here is actually fighting for, because the surface-level conflict (return borrowed books) is barely skimming the actual stakes. For Eloise, the conflict is existential — she's twenty-six in a rural town with no marriage market, her parents are dying, and the only identity she has is 'the unmarried daughter who bakes badly.' Her mother's entire arc in this section is built around the terrifying question of who will protect Eloise when they're gone. That's a stakes setup that will keep haunting this character. For Ryan, the stakes are literally life and death — he survived a battle where his own father wanted him dead, and now he's psychologically falling apart to the point where he hasn't eaten in two days. The Earl of Wallace isn't just a bad dad, he's a man who sent agents to stalk his own son as a child and still views him as less than human. And here's the thing that raises the stakes even higher: Ryan is currently staying at Blissbury under the same roof as the Surbertons. He's recovering from trauma in a house where everyone is quietly panicking about marriage prospects and social standing. The collision between their worlds is inevitable and it's going to be explosive. What's fascinating is that both characters are being watched — Ryan by his father's agents, Eloise by her mother's matchmaking schemes, and presumably by the whole village. Nobody in this story gets privacy, and that lack of privacy is what makes every interaction charged. When Eloise finally walks into Blissbury with those pies, she's not just delivering a gift — she's walking into a space where two people who've never been allowed to be seen as anything other than what others need them to be are about to actually SEE each other.
... Read More
Okay so can we talk about how Ryan literally cannot stop bringing up Eloise? He has a whole conversation with Julia and keeps circling back to the Surberton family like it is nothing personal. And Julia is sitting there serving gossip about Eloise being under house arrest and Ryan is just... listening. Carefully. Like every word matters. The text says: “whenever Eloise was mentioned, he found himself paying closer attention.” This is not subtle at all. This is the author screaming it into our faces and I am here for it. And Julia, bless her ambitious little heart, has no idea what is happening. She thinks she is playing the game perfectly, flitting from topic to topic, trying to secure this marriage like it is a business deal. Which honestly it kind of is for her. She needs this win after the Camborne disaster. But Ryan? He is somewhere else entirely. His mind is clearly occupied by someone who has been quietly poisoning his thoughts since they first met. The way Julia recounts childhood stories about Eloise while Ryan dries his wet hair and asks politely if she will visit again... this scene is so normal on the surface but underneath it is this huge emotional current. Ryan invited her back. Not out of politeness. Not because he had nothing better to do. The text implies he was actually growing bored of the conversation and was “searching for a suitable excuse” to end it, but then she mentioned the ball and everything shifted again. I also love how Eloise is completely absent from this scene yet she is the center of gravity. Julia is the one sitting across from Ryan, but the entire emotional weight of the chapter is pointing toward someone who isn't even there. That is some excellent storytelling. It makes you want to know what Eloise is actually doing while all this romance machinery grinds forward around her. And then Mrs. Surberton sending her off with that “listen to your mother” comment and talking about the stable collapsing last year... the family dynamics are so layered. Eloise claims innocence but everyone knows something happened. The author is threading so many emotional plots together here and I am obsessed.
... Read More
"Having traveled across sunlit fields, she had worked up a sweat, and now she shivered." This one detail — the temperature shift from hot sun to cold stone corridors — perfectly captures how Blissbury operates in the story. It's not just a setting; it's Eloise's secret sanctuary. The author gives us just enough to paint the picture without over-explaining: the magnificent painting room, the cabinet where her drawings live, the solid stone stairs that could have crushed her if Ryan hadn't caught her. And the staff! Mrs. Parker scolding about shawls, Mr. Palmer managing everything single-handedly, the Warren father and son keeping gardens perfect — this isn't background decoration. These people make Blissbury feel like a living, breathing entity that Eloise loves enough to risk everything to protect. Even her fear of getting sick "whenever the seasons change" and Emily's constant worry about her throwing caution to the wind — it all makes this world feel warm and real, like a place you could actually visit.
... Read More
There is a letter in this chapter that nobody reads out loud and it haunts me. Abigail finds a sheet of paper on Eloise's desk addressed to “Colonel Ryan Wilgrave” and the text just stops there. We do not get to see what it says. We do not get to know why Eloise was hiding it. This absence of information is itself the point. The letter symbolizes everything that cannot be spoken in this world. Eloise is under house restriction. Her father has apparently forbidden something. The letter is addressed to a colonel, not a sergeant, which suggests either a rank change or a different Ryan than the one Julia is pursuing. And Eloise is scrambling to cover it up when Abigail approaches the desk. This small detail—papers fluttering to the floor—contains so much narrative weight. Then there is Ryan's wet hair. The text lingers on it repeatedly. “A spring breeze carrying the scent of wildflowers filled the drawing room. That breeze lightly swept through Thornton's damp hair, making him look even more striking.” This is not accidental description. The dampness represents exposure, vulnerability, something raw breaking through the polished military exterior. He is dripping water onto the floor and Mrs. Parker is horrified by the mess, but Ryan stays. He does not excuse himself. He remains in this compromised state while Julia watches him dry his hair and invite her back. The food itself is symbolic too. Every family recipe represents heritage, lineage, the accumulation of love across generations. And Ryan refuses to consume any of it. This is not just stubbornness—it is a refusal to be nurtured, to accept care, to allow himself to be softened by community. The village tries to feed him literally and emotionally, and he stands at the window looking away. And the telegram about Lady Courtney—death arriving like an uninvited guest, shattering the domestic peace—this is the ultimate symbol of how fragile all these social games are. The food competition, the marriage hunting, the ball planning… all of it dissolves the moment mortality announces itself at the door.
... Read More
Let me just say this: the Ryan section hit me like a truck and I am not okay. He wakes up from a nightmare about Ingon — which I assume is some kind of battle — and the text doesn't give us the full scene but the fragments are enough. 'The despairing faces of his comrades as they looked at him.' Wait, WHAT did he do? What happened at Ingon? I need to know immediately. And then he sees the disciplinary committee, and ONE pair of eyes among them is especially sharp, and it's the Earl. His FATHER wanted him dead more than anyone in that battle. That single line rewrote everything I thought I knew about this character. He's not just traumatized from war — he's traumatized because his own blood wished for his death on a battlefield full of corpses. And then the river scene? He dives in fully clothed, repeatedly submerges himself, and just lies there damp and shivering under a tree for what seems like hours, skipping meals, ignoring sunlight. The emotional temperature of that passage is so low it's almost numb, and that's what makes it so painful to read. Meanwhile Eloise is dressed to perfection, checking her reflection, performing propriety — but she's also running from something. Her mother's voice chasing her down the stairs, the hurried escape, the way she 'quickly grabbed the pies and rushed outside' before the lecture could begin. They're both performing for people who won't be satisfied no matter what they do. And then they meet, and she's muttering to herself about eating the pie because it's 'too well-made to give to that man' — and I swear to god that's the most eloise thing ever. She's not being mean, she's just... deflecting. Protecting herself by pretending to be petty. I'm already emotionally invested in whatever happens between these two and I haven't even seen them speak yet.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is absolutely masterful and I need to break down exactly why it works so well. We open with something almost COMEDIC—Eloise calculating whether three pies is excessive, shushing herself about Mrs. Parker's dessert skills, mounting her horse with a basket like some kind of misguided hospitality ambassador. She's eating pie alone under a tree, making faces, almost finishing the whole thing. It's light. It's funny. It's basically a rom-com beat. Then Thornton startles her, the pie goes flying, and for a moment it's still playing it straight—frantic stain-removing, awkward exchange, he offers to help. The scene is bouncing along nicely. She offers him pie. He accepts. He devours it. This is the peak of the scene, right here, and it's gorgeous. And then—the pivot. She mentions Wilgrave. His entire demeanor shifts. The warmth vanishes. He basically tells her to go home. And suddenly we're in completely different territory. Eloise, caught off guard, doubles down on formality, produces the books, executes a perfect bow, and flees. The chapter ends with her snapping the reins and driving away, dust cloud behind her, while he stands frozen. What kills me is how FAST that turn happens. One paragraph she's sharing a snack, the next she's retreating like she's been burned. The author doesn't give us a long dramatic speech or a confrontation—just a few sharp lines and then EMPTY SPACE. And then the next chapter opens with the whole village gossiping about Thornton's sleepless nights. That structural choice—ending on her furious departure and opening on collective concern—is what makes me want to immediately flip the page. The tension doesn't resolve; it just changes shape.
... Read More
This book is quietly asking a question that goes much deeper than its surface romance. Eloise draws bodies without faces first — she says the artist deliberately omits them because once faces appear, people stop seeing art and start seeing indecency. But then she can't stand it. The drawings feel incomplete. So she gives them all Ryan's face. Why his? Because he's someone she's watched from behind newspapers and portraits, someone she's studied and admired from a safe distance. She wants to see him fully — not the hero the world praises, not the man whose battles get editorialized about, but the actual human being underneath. And when he sees her drawings, he calls her depraved and lecherous before learning the truth. The irony cuts both ways. Who really is the depraved one — the woman who privately studied a man she respected, or the men who publicly celebrated his war record and then abandoned him when peace arrived?
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this—the way this story drops the Ryan Wilgrave lore into the narrative is *chef's kiss*. Eloise gets this letter about a new steward coming to Blissbury, and in the span of maybe two pages, the author completely reframes her entire world. She's just this content girl living in Feltham, right? Happy to stay home, paint, scold geese. And then—BOOM—her father mentions "Sergeant Ryan Thornton" and she nearly loses her mind because it sounds like the man she worships. "Calm yourself. The man coming is Sergeant Ryan Thornton, a distant relative of the Stanford family." "He is not your Colonel Ryan Wilgrave." The way Mr. Surberton has to literally calm her down tells me everything I need to know about what's coming. This is the inciting incident, pure and simple. The whole setup feels deliberate—Feltham as a sleepy village, the post-war world changing, soldiers returning home like goldmines, and then suddenly THIS name enters the picture. The rumor mill in Feltham already starts spinning within hours. The ladies are calculating, scheming, and Eloise is caught in the crossfire of something way bigger than a new steward. I'm already predicting that Ryan Wilgrave himself might show up at Blissbury in some disguised or alternate identity. The military scandal is a loaded gun that hasn't gone off yet in the story, and I have a feeling it's about to blow everything wide open. Also, the fact that a pristine white envelope stood out in a bundle of ordinary letters? That detail is not subtle at all. White = important = dramatic entrance.
... Read More
Okay can we talk about the romantic tension here because I am NOT okay. Eloise sketching an undressed man with Wilgrave's face—what a deliciously scandalous detail. She clearly has a whole portrait of him on her wall. This girl is SO invested and the author just drops this information casually like it's no big deal. Then you have Thornton sitting there knowing exactly who she is, knowing she's been obsessed with him, watching her tear apart his carefully constructed humble persona in front of everyone. And his reaction isn't embarrassment or anger—it's that quiet "runs a hand over his freshly shaved jaw" moment. That's the look of a man whose entire plan just got completely upended by a woman who doesn't even know his real name. The dinner scene itself is layered with so much emotional subtext. Everyone's laughing and discussing wine and almond pudding while Eloise sits there barely eating, simmering. She's trapped between having to play the proper lady and having the most strong opinions in the room. And when she finally snaps? It's not a tantrum—it's a tactical military briefing delivered with the confidence of someone who has done her homework. I genuinely believe she read every newspaper article about Wilgrave and memorized troop deployment maps. The fact that she storms upstairs mid-conversation like she's attended a parliament session and everyone else is just left stunned—PERFECT. This is the kind of moment where a relationship actually begins to form, and I'm here for it.
... Read More
I keep thinking about what this book is really doing beneath the surface, and food keeps coming up like a recurring symbol I can't shake. Let me trace it. Eloise bakes three whole pies for a man she barely knows. That's not just hospitality—that's an offering. She's trying to nourish someone who won't let anyone get close, and food is the only language she has. Even her motivation for making them is layered: she's performing the role of a good host, yes, but she's also indirectly honoring Wilgrave's memory by caring for the man who served under him. 'Mr. Surberton had chuckled, saying he couldn't tell if it was a military memoir or a hymn of praise for Wilgrave.' That line hit me so hard. The battalion didn't just follow their colonel—they worshipped him. And Eloise, a complete stranger, has absorbed that devotion so thoroughly that she's defending a man she's never met against people who actually knew him. Then Thornton eats the pie. All of it. In silence. This man who hasn't been able to eat properly since arriving in Blissbury—the sight of Eloise enjoying food, the smell of butter and cinnamon, the simple act of sharing a meal—breaks through something in him. 'It was the first desire he had felt since arriving in Blissbury.' That single sentence contains an entire war. Hunger isn't just physical here. It's the hunger for connection, for normalcy, for a moment where he doesn't have to be the ghost of the 57th Infantry Battalion. And the books? Eloise bringing them isn't just a plot device to extend the interaction—it's another offering. Knowledge, stories, something intellectual to replace the emotional conversation he refused to have. She's trying to feed him in every way possible and he just... walks away. The flickering candle in Thornton's window, mentioned by Mrs. Parker later, mirrors that uneaten pie. Both are signs of someone burning out from the inside. The warm spring world outside and the dark, starved interior of this man—I think the book is asking a question about who gets to heal, and who decides when someone is ready.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about this scene because my heart is literally pounding. Eloise making those pies—three of them!—and then getting startled by Thornton and dropping one all over her dress? First of all, RELATABLE. But secondly, the way she immediately starts scrubbing at the stain like it's the end of the world while he just watches her? And then HE picks up the cloth himself, goes to the river, wrings it out, and hands it back? I SCREAMED into my pillow. That is such a small thing but it tells you EVERYTHING about this man. He doesn't mock her. He doesn't make it weird. He just helps. And then—the PIE. The absolute audacity of him sitting down beside her and DEVOURING that pie like he hasn't seen food in weeks. Five bites. Four bites. GONE. And Eloise is just sitting there watching him like what in the actual hell?? The fact that he ate from HER plate too, crumbs and all, and felt even MORE hungry instead of grossed out?? That is either the most romantic thing I have ever read or the most unhinged. Probably both. But then the WHOLE TONE SHIFTS when she brings up Wilgrave and he just... freezes. You can FEEL him retreating. He asks if the pie was the only reason she came and basically tells her to leave. And Eloise—who just five minutes ago was sharing her snack with a stranger—suddenly pulls out a bundle of books and gives this perfectly formal speech like armor. "I hope you have a peaceful stay in Blissbury until the day you return to the capital." SHE WAS DITCHING HIM AFTER BEING KICKED OUT AND I LOVE HER FOR IT. The way she snapped the reins and vowed never to come back until he's gone?? Iconic. Absolutely iconic. My chest actually hurts.
... Read More
I need to talk about Emily first because she is my favorite person in this entire story and I don't care who knows it. Here's this eighteen-year-old maid who nags Eloise about washing her hands, calls her out for having dirty sleeves, and basically runs half the house—yet no one in the Surberton family bats an eye at her impertinence. Why? Because she's the finest cook in Feltham AND she will absolutely destroy anyone who insults the family. That's not a side character, that's a main character energy. "Now, wash your hands quickly!" she says, and I swear to God that's one of the most vivid character moments in literature. And then there's the father-daughter dynamic between Eloise and Mr. Surberton. It's so warm and unforced. He teases her about dunking his letters in water because she read a spy novel at age eight and was convinced they were poisoned. That's not just worldbuilding—that's a full childhood biography compressed into one sentence. And he understands her reaction to the Ryan name immediately. No scolding, just gentle redirection: "Even if he's a different Ryan, be polite to him." But what really got me is Eloise's secret smile under the blanket. She's twenty-six, past marriageable age by every conventional standard, labeled a spinster, and her mother sighs about it constantly—yet she genuinely LOVES Feltham. She chose this life. She wasn't forced into it, she embraced it. That's a woman who knows herself. And now that peace is about to get disrupted by someone named Ryan who apparently comes tangled up in military scandal. I am HERE for this.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or