You like it - Reviews

You like it
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about the bathroom scene because it is PHENOMENAL. Let me just say this: the author takes the most mundane, everyday moment — someone showering their feet at midnight — and turns it into something that feels like a film scene. The frosted glass door, the Cantonese song playing softly, the way Meng Wanqiu curls her toes and the water reflects light on her skin. And then Sheng Xun appears. The description of him looking at the puddle on the floor afterward, touching it with his fingertips, his face burning — this is not just writing, this is pure atmosphere. It's intimate without being explicit, charged without being dramatic. The contrast between the countryside memory (drawing well water, her grandfather scolding her) and the present moment (modern bathroom, late-night music, a boy watching through glass) creates this layered sense of place that feels incredibly lived-in. And the Borges quote at the end — 'Tonight's universe has the vastness of oblivion and the precision of fever' — it's almost too perfect, but somehow it lands because the scene has earned it. The author builds worlds through sensory detail rather than exposition. You don't need to know the city, the school, the family dynamics — you just need one midnight bathroom encounter and you understand everything.
... Read More
Hide-and-seek. That's the central metaphor of this entire batch and I can't stop thinking about it. You hide, someone seeks, and the whole game is about the tension between being found and staying hidden. But what are these characters really hiding from? Meng Wanqiu is hiding from her feelings for Sheng Xun — she physically avoids him, gives false answers about choosing him as a deskmate, tries to log out of location sharing. Sheng Xun is hiding his vulnerability — he pretends this is all a game, that he deliberately got caught just to find her, that he doesn't care about the seating arrangement. The Borges reference is doing heavy lifting here. 'The Road Less Traveled' — she never finishes it, and neither does he finish his Borges collection. These unread books are symbols of the things they're curious about but too afraid to fully engage with. And the seating arrangement subplot? It's about how the system tries to optimize human connections, but feelings don't follow algorithms. Old Fan thinks he's being clever with his reverse psychology, but he's just another force trying to control something that can't be controlled. The sports day — running 1000 meters, someone waiting at the finish line — that's the next layer of the metaphor. Running toward something or away from it? The finish line is inevitable, but who's there to meet you?
... Read More
Okay so the hide-and-seek scene is honestly one of the cleverest plot devices I've seen in a while. On the surface it's just a game, right? But the whole thing is basically the author's way of forcing these characters into proximity without making it feel forced. Sheng Xun deliberately lets himself be caught so he can track down Meng Wanqiu — that's not just plot convenience, that's character motivation laid bare. He's been avoiding her, she's been avoiding him, and the game becomes the excuse to finally have a real conversation. And then the whole seating arrangement subplot? Genius. Old Fan basically reverse-psychology arranges everyone so that the people who actually want to sit together end up paired, while the ones who chose each other get separated. The fact that both Meng Wanqiu and Sheng Xun claimed they chose each other when neither actually did — that double bluff is delicious. I love how the author uses academic logistics as a vehicle for romantic tension. It's not just 'they like each other,' it's 'the entire school system conspires to keep them together despite their best efforts to dodge it.' The sports day setup at the end is the author laying the next plot thread — Meng Wanqiu signing up for 1000 meters, Shang Yan offering to wait at the finish line. That's a triangle waiting to happen, and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is what I'd call 'comfortably restless.' It starts with the camping trip — leisurely, meandering, lots of dialogue and character interaction. Then it pivots sharply into the academic world: report cards, teacher meetings, seating arrangements. The shift is jarring in the best way, because it mirrors how these kids' lives actually work. You can't just stay in the carefree summer moment forever; school and expectations are always waiting. And then BAM — midnight bathroom scene, which is a complete tonal shift from everything that came before. It's quiet, intimate, almost dreamlike after the chaotic energy of the hide-and-seek game and the classroom politics. Then it ends with sports day planning, which pulls the reader back into the daylight world. The author knows exactly when to slow down and when to speed up. The hide-and-seek sequence drags just enough to make you feel the afternoon laziness, then the bathroom scene slows to a near-standstill, then the sports day sign-up snaps everything back into motion. I stayed up way too late reading this batch because the transitions between scenes felt so natural — like flipping between channels on a lazy evening, except every channel was more interesting than the last.
... Read More
Here's the thing about this book — the conflicts are incredibly small-scale on paper. A seating chart. A game of hide-and-seek. Someone hearing music through a bathroom door. But the author makes you care SO much about all of it. How? By making the emotional stakes feel real. When Sheng Xun says 'I didn't choose you either' and his face falls, you feel it. When Meng Wanqiu discovers she's still sitting with him despite both of them lying about choosing each other, the quiet devastation is palpable. These kids are navigating something enormous — first love, family expectations, academic pressure, social hierarchies — through the only vehicles they have: classroom logistics and weekend games. The tension in the bathroom scene isn't about what might happen physically; it's about what happens emotionally when two people who've been dancing around each other finally share a moment of raw, unguarded proximity. And then the sports day announcement? Shang Yan offering to wait at the finish line is a quiet act of devotion that raises the stakes dramatically. Because now there's a third person in this emotional equation, and Meng Wanqiu's reaction — wanting to say the 1000 meters is nothing but smiling anyway — shows she's already aware of the triangle forming. The author never lets up. Every scene adds another layer of tension without ever raising its voice.
... Read More
Can we just take a moment to appreciate how Sheng Xun speaks? The man says barely anything and it's always devastating. 'When did you learn to lie?' — three words, delivered with a smile, and suddenly Meng Wanqiu is exposed. His dialogue is this perfect blend of casual and calculated. He's never shouting, never over-explaining, just dropping lines that land like punches wrapped in cotton. And Meng Wanqiu's responses? 'Oh.' 'I didn't.' 'You were too close, just like that night.' She says so little but says exactly the right amount. The author gives each character a distinct voice without making it cartoonish. Lian Shiyue is all energy and complaints — 'I don't like people who are always so pretentious' — she sounds like a real person venting to her friend. Shang Yan is gentle and practical, offering to wait at the finish line like it's no big deal when it absolutely is. Gu Siyu barely speaks but her presence is felt in every room she enters. The group chat moments are particularly well-done — those quick 'I won't tell you' messages and location-sharing betrayals feel exactly like how real people communicate through phones nowadays. The dialogue never feels written. It feels overheard.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or