This section completely restructured everything I thought I knew about Carlo. For chapters, maybe even the whole book up to this point, the narrative has positioned him as the cruel manipulator and Laila as the suffering victim. But then he gets on his knees. Just—drops to the ground and begs. And what does he beg for? That she walk into a war she's terrified of, kill people, destroy herself. The plot twist here isn't just that he asked; it's that she said yes.
What made my stomach drop was the exchange right after she agreed. She says: "When I return from the war, you'll stop pretending to be some charming flirt just to win the ladies' favor." She's making terms with the man who's using her, negotiating her own exploitation like it's a business deal. And then—the masterpiece of this entire arc—he replies, "Laila, you know that isn't my true self." He's already lying. Or he's telling the truth and doesn't realize how much it hurts her more.
But the real structural shift is the confession scene. Six years of him dodging the word, six years of "we're friends," and suddenly she forces it out of him. "Do you love me or not?" And when he finally says it—"Fine! I love you—I said I love you!"—he looks dazed, like even he doesn't understand what he just gave away. The author built this moment perfectly: every time Carlo thought he was the one controlling the situation, Laila seized the reins instead. She weaponized her vulnerability.
The ending of this section also changed my reading of everything that came before. When Carlo says, "Feelings like that always do"—and she knows it's because his father destroyed his mother through love—it reframes his entire character. He's not just cruel; he's broken. And she's not just naive; she's chosen to fix something that may be beyond repair.
The last scene with the robe falling open? Chilling in the best way. He's furious because she walked outside half-dressed at dawn, and his reaction—grabbing the fabric, pulling her close, the aggression—shows exactly what kind of man she's binding herself to. Love or not, this is a predator.
So now I'm left wondering: is Laila going to come back from war victorious, or is she going to die and destroy herself to save a man who can barely promise to love her after? And honestly? I need to know.