We Can't Let Go of Each Other - Reviews

We Can't Let Go of Each Other
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about that opening moment—the Madame lingering by the door after they paid. Two silver coins. That's it. And Rosalie and Angela had SKIPPED LUNCH for this. They were going to treat themselves to cake at a café on the way back and instead handed over their emergency fund as a tip because they couldn't bear to look awkward. You don't need a narrator telling you these women are drowning. The author just SHOWS us the arithmetic of survival. And then Angela's line—"What weight do you have to lose, Rosalie? You're already as thin as a stick." Said with genuine affection, which makes it hit even harder. Because in Ipelda, curves are beauty, and Rosalie is fading. Not just physically but economically, socially. She's becoming invisible. The ball itself is structured as a series of humiliations dressed up as opportunities. Countess Aloua picks out Rosalie's dress like she's selecting livestock. "The dress I chose suits you well. I'm pleased." Pleased. Not warm, not kind—pleased, like a gardener happy a flower grew in the right spot. Then Jeremy appears, and the entire plot hinges on this single disastrous meeting. He can't even stand in the same room as her without trembling. Wind blows and he nearly cries. Rosalie trips trying to be gracious and sprains her ankle—and then Hys finds her there. Of course he does. His dialogue in that scene is merciless and I couldn't look away: "If we're caught together, do you know what will happen to our reputation? Ah, but you don't have any reputation left to lose, do you?" That's not just cruelty—that's a man who has rewritten their entire history into something he wants to bury. And Rosalie, broken as she is, still reaches for him. Still says his name. "Hys!" And he flinches like she burned him. The structure here is brutal in its efficiency. Every scene strips away another layer of Rosalie's dignity until she's alone on the ground in a garden, ankle swollen, no match, no friend, no future. And then Jeremy shows up at her door to apologize like any of that matters now.
... Read More
There are so many layers to unpack thematically in these chapters and I want to focus on the most striking one — the color red, specifically the red hair that connects all the victims and now Rosalie herself. Red is never a neutral color in this story. It marks you. Inès had fiery red hair. Countess Marti had it. The waitress at the restaurant had it. And Rosalie — 'Having stayed home, her loosely tied hair fell over her cheek.' The text specifically draws attention to her hair, to its color, to the fact that it's falling loose around her face. She 'flinched' and 'tugged at her fallen hair.' This is not accidental description. The author is visually coding Rosalie as both part of the pattern and separately aware of it. What interests me is how red hair functions as a kind of curse in this world. It's visible, it's distinctive, and it seems to mark these women for danger. But there's also something about visibility and invisibility at play. Inès was visible — she was the Princess's favorite maid, she was seen at the opera with the Duke, she was discussed in newspapers and salons. And yet she died alone in a back alley. The Countess Marti was a gambling addict, visible in the worst social circles, and she disappeared after a charity auction — presumably someone wanted her gone quietly. The waitress was 'very pretty' but unnamed, her face 'horribly slashed,' reduced to a rumor that circled back months later. Rosalie, meanwhile, has spent most of the story trying to be invisible — hiding her past with Hystein, hiding her discomfort about Inès's earrings, hiding her own ambitions. And now the killer's pattern is closing in on someone who looks like her. The irony is almost cruel. There's also the symbol of the moon — 'the silvery moon hidden behind cloudy skies' when Rosalie walks home after the opera. Hidden light. Concealed truth. Things that shine but cannot be fully seen. And the rain that 'hadn't fully stopped' — the lingering dampness, the aftermath of something that passed but didn't resolve. The Queen Marguerite biography Jeremy is reading is also symbolically significant. A queen who 'won two conquest wars and invented a unique script' — she was a woman of achievement who was also scandalized ('She did cheat with a foreign envoy, though'). Rosalie is navigating a world where women's worth is constantly judged alongside their transgressions. The parallel is uncomfortable and I think intentional.
... Read More
Can we talk about Jeremy for a second because honestly he is the sweetest disaster and I cannot stop thinking about him? He's reading a book — Queen Marguerite's Biography, no less, which is basically the biography of the protagonist from the novel Rosalie already knows — and he immediately slams it shut when she approaches. Like a kid caught writing fanfiction. And then when she says she likes the queen, he blurts out that the queen 'cheated with a foreign envoy' and then immediately shuts himself down because he realizes he's being awkward. This man cannot lie to save his life and it is adorable. His entire demeanor around Rosalie radiates this nervous, earnest energy. He's naive, yes, but he's trying so hard to be good enough for her family. When he says 'If you had fun today, Miss Rosalie, that's enough,' he's practically dripping with sincerity and it's making me soft inside. But Rosalie is where the real character depth is in these chapters. The moment she realizes Inès got earrings from Hystein — her tattered heart is mentioned almost casually, like she's already learning to ignore her own feelings for the sake of her family's plans. And then later, she doesn't tell Gerard or Angela about the earrings. She just carries it alone while pretending everything is fine. That's not naive. That's strategic. That's someone who has learned that her feelings are secondary to survival. The relationship between Rosalie and Hystein is a ghost that haunts every scene. She doesn't see him after the opera but the knowledge of his connection to Inès poisons her evening. And Gerard — oh Gerard. His protective fury toward Hystein is so visceral. 'Because of that man, Rosalie's life had been thrown into the gutter.' He literally cannot separate his sister's past suffering from any present interaction Hystein has. That's not just jealousy, that's trauma. And Rosalie seeing Jeremy tomorrow, thinking he might prefer the Aloua mansion because it's 'stacked with books' — she's already calculating how to make herself fit into his world instead of asking him to fit into hers. There's this beautiful imbalance in their dynamic that makes me want to shake them both.
... Read More
"What are you doing? I don't know what you're misunderstanding, but…" That line. THAT LINE. Hystein starts saying something and then stops himself mid-sentence. Rosalie is right there, about to kiss him, and he literally cannot finish the thought. His body moves — he shields her, he pulls her back inside — but his mouth refuses to betray him. And Rosalie chasing him BAREFOOT. Not even putting on slippers. Just running after a man who literally told her he's not moved by her, through his own hallway, tears still wet on her face, because she CAN'T let him walk away again. She stomp-stomps in regret and then pursues anyway. That is so painfully human. I lost it when she says "It was a mistake. I was just reminded of the past." As if ten years of history between them is just "the past" like it's nothing. As if her impulsiveness is a mistake she can apologize away. And Hystein's response: "How shameless, for someone with a fiancé." OOF. He brings up the engagement like a shield. Like that's the reason she can't touch him. But is that really about morality, or is it about HIM not being able to handle the fact that she still wants him? The worst part is Rosalie's internal monologue afterward — she blames HIM for being nice to her in the first place. "He shouldn't have been so nice from the start." She's so angry at herself AND at him, and neither of them will just communicate. The tension between them is absolutely suffocating in the best way. I am not okay. I need them to talk. I need Hystein to stop weaponizing politeness and just tell her everything.
... Read More
Okay so this chapter? I am NOT okay. Rosalie and Hystein's whole dynamic is giving “we used to be something and now I don't know what we are but my body remembers.” Like—he's being all cold and commanding, making her undress, wiping her down like she's some kind of porcelain doll he's afraid will shatter—but then he STILL can't stop himself from touching her ankle the way he used to tickle it behind the studio curtains. That ONE detail ruined me. He says he's “not even tempted” but bro, you're kneeling on the floor wiping her calves like a devoted knight. Where's the not-tempted energy at? And Rosalie—sweet summer child. She's noticing everything. The luxurious bed, the gold embroidery, the way his gaze follows her every move even when he's trying to look away. She remembers how he spoke to her at Countess Aloua's ball too, that sharp tone she recognizes. He's not the gentle painter anymore, she tells herself, but then he's literally carrying her, covering her eyes so she doesn't have to see—wait, WHAT? He covered her eyes when he carried her? That's protective to a fault, husband. The wrist grab though—when he says “When I first saw you, I thought you were someone else” and just holds her wrist like he's checking if she's real? I'm screaming. He's studying her like she's a painting he's trying to decipher, and then abruptly changes the subject to chocolate. Classic deflection. This man is a walking contradiction and I am HERE for it. Also side note: Jeremy blushing and avoiding her gaze? Guy has feelings and I'm calling it. But also Gerard's whole panic scene where he's imagining Rosalie dead with half her face ruined? Yeah, that trauma hits different. The contrast between Hystein's clinical care and Gerard's desperate love—both men wanting to protect her in completely different ways. Hystein's方式是—no wait, I said English only. Hystein's way is forceful tenderness, Gerard's is frantic helplessness. And Rosalie is stuck in the middle wondering which one she belongs to. “You may seem fine now, but when you wake up, you won't be.” That line though—Hystein knows exactly what she went through today and he's not letting her sugarcoat it. He's the only one who sees through her “I'm fine” act because he's the one who found her. And yet he still lets her pretend, still warms her chocolate, still sits by her bed like a guard dog. This relationship is a whole mood and I need the next chapter immediately.
... Read More
Okay so can we talk about how this whole charity auction chapter was basically a pressure cooker? It's not even the big dramatic moments that got me — it's the way everything quietly spiraled toward that climactic reveal. Let me explain. We start with Rosalie being paraded off to an event she dreads, locked in a carriage with Jeremy, who is honestly such a soft touch. The author does something really smart here: they make us think the scene is about Rosalie trying to get through this social obligation gracefully, but the real tension lives underneath the surface. She's scanning the dark auditorium for Hystein between every item. That detail — that single action — tells you everything about where her heart is, without a single internal monologue confessing it. Then Jeremy does THE THING. He bids 2,000 yura for a book she mentioned offhandedly in the carriage. Let me repeat that. A man who stammers, who cries at crowds, who can barely walk through a doorway without flinching — he raises his arm and drops a week's worth of food money on a FIRST EDITION of a novel she loves. And he does it with the most adorable misunderstanding of the title: "I'm a Queen" instead of "As a Queen." Rosalie nearly laughs out loud. This man is genuinely trying, and he's the sweetest person in this entire society of sharks. But then — BAM — 100,000 yura. Duke of Vallière. The room shifts. Rosalie's whole world tilts on its axis. And Hystein? He doesn't even stay for the ceremony. He bids, smiles at the crowd like it's nothing, and disappears through a doorway like a ghost. Of course he disappears right before Rosalie goes to thank the Duchess. Of course she ends up trapped in a classroom with him. The plot is threading these moments together like a noose. I'm just sitting here thinking about how the author used the auction as both a social performance AND a battlefield. Every bid is a statement. Every silence is loaded. Jeremy's bid is love. Hystein's bid is power. And Rosalie? She's caught between them, holding a book she didn't know she'd get and a man she can't stop thinking about.
... Read More
I need to vent about Jeremy for a moment because I am SO OVER him and also I think he might be the only genuinely good person in this entire novel. Let's be real — when Countess Aloua first pairs Rosalie with Jeremy, the setup feels like punishment. The 'lover of the lame bedwetter' insult floating around high society? Oof. But then the carriage ride happens and suddenly Jeremy is just... a person. A real one. Not a prop in someone else's scheme. "Crowds are scary." "I just want to stay home and read." He's literally confessing his fears to a woman he's supposed to be performing courtship with, and he's BRAGGING about having read a history book seven times. Seven times, Rosalie. Seven. And she asks him to tell her about the next dynasty and he Lights Up. Like, actual sparks in his blue eyes. The man transforms from trembling mess to passionate lecturer in about thirty seconds. And then he buys her the book. Two thousand yura — almost two maids' salaries — for something she casually mentioned. He remembered. He LISTENED. In a world where everyone is calculating marriages and alliances and social capital, Jeremy is the only person who actually pays attention to what Rosalie wants. Meanwhile Hystein walks in looking like a brooding statue carved by someone who only knew the word 'majestic' from a dictionary. Pale, sweating, avoiding Inês like the plague, and STILL managing to look devastatingly attractive while doing it. Rosalie notices he looks sick — "your lips were once red and full, now pale" — and reaches out to touch his forehead, and he REJECTS her. Brushes her hand away like it burns him. But here's what kills me: he doesn't let go of her shoulder. He grips it harder. He pulls her deeper into his arms when Inês approaches. He's torn between wanting to push Rosalie away and needing to keep her close, and that conflict is WRITTEN ALL OVER HIM. Rosalie's internal state during this scene is just *aching*. She's grateful to Jeremy for the book, torn about her duty to Gêrard and Angela, and completely undone by the man hiding in a classroom with her. Her heart is a war zone and she's the civilian casualty. I just... I keep thinking about that line: "You're so skinny." Hystein says it like an accusation, but it sounds like grief. He remembers her body against his from some past moment — "a day when she had rested her head on his chest and napped" — and now she's frailer, and he's distant, and neither of them knows how to bridge the gap. God, I hope Jeremy figures out that Rosalie doesn't love him romantically before he invests any more 2,000-yura book buys. Not that I blame him. Sweet men deserve someone who chooses them back.
... Read More
I have been haunted by one object from these chapters since I finished reading: Agathe's first edition of 'As a Queen.' Not because it's particularly valuable — well, 2,000 yura is valuable, sure — but because of what it represents for Rosalie. The text explicitly tells us this is the book that "had given Rosalie strength during the time she was shunned and shut away by high society." Think about that. A story about a queen who lost her beloved lover became Rosalie's anchor when her own world collapsed. She found herself in a powerless position — bankrupt family, ruined reputation, forced into engagements — and what sustained her was a fictional queen enduring similar pain. That's not just a plot detail. That's the novel whispering to us about why stories matter. Rosalie doesn't just read for escape; she reads for survival. The queen in the book lost her lover, and Rosalie, in her own way, is living that same narrative. Only Hers is more complicated because the lover hasn't actually been lost — he's right there, in the same building, hiding from another woman's advances. The earrings Hystein buys are another symbol that won't leave me alone. Diamond and ruby — precious, cold, beautiful things given as a gift at a charity auction. But for who? The nobles immediately start speculating, and Rosalie doesn't even want to know. These earrings represent everything Hystein is: expensive, unattainable, dangerous to possess. He buys them with 100,000 yura — fifty times what Jeremy spent on a book — and the gesture is so grand it basically screams dominance rather than affection. And Jeremy's misnaming of the book? "I'm a Queen" instead of "As a Queen" — it's almost like he's accidentally renaming the story, making it about his own identity rather than the queen's suffering. He's not a queen, he tells Rosalie, flushed and flustered. He's a man. But in buying this book for her, he's performing an act of such tender devotion that it transcends gender roles. He's giving her a queen's story because he sees her as royal in spirit, even when society treats her like trash. The school for the deaf as the venue is also deeply symbolic, though I won't over-explain that one. Silence, communication without words, people who hear but choose not to speak — these themes echo through every interaction in this chapter. Rosalie and Hystein communicate entire conversations without saying a word. Jeremy communicates his love through a book purchase instead of words. And Inês can't stop making noise because she has no idea what silence is worth. I keep coming back to that book. A story about loss that helped a woman survive loss. Now she's holding the physical object — the first edition, purchased for twice what it was worth — and Hystein is standing behind her in the dark. The loop is closing and I don't know whether to celebrate or sob.
... Read More
The rose in Chapter 5 is doing SO much work, y'all. Jeremy brings it unpick of thorns, his finger bleeds, and Rosalie notices immediately. She grabs his wrist to check the injury, and he pulls away because he's still scared of her. The thorn-pricked finger is basically the entire relationship in miniature—he wants to give her something beautiful, but he's clumsy, he's hurting himself, and he doesn't know how to handle closeness without trembling. But here's what really gets me: Rosalie keeps the rose. She inhales its scent while pretending to listen to Jeremy read history. That flower becomes this anchor point between them, this proof that he tried. Then in the tea party chapter, the symbolism flips. The greenhouse becomes a symbol of artificial perfection—beautiful glass dome, coordinated outfits, controlled environment—but Rosalie is the only one who doesn't fit. She's sweating, uncomfortable, wrong-dressed, and everyone can see it. The princess's garden party is supposed to be about elegance and refinement, but it's actually about exclusion and control. And Rosalie? She survives it by being polite, by giving the right answers, by not crying. The theme here is so clear: in this world, women are constantly being tested, dressed, judged, and positioned. The rose with thorns and the greenhouse with glass walls are the same story—beauty that requires endurance.
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter are so quietly devastating. On the surface, it's just a tea party invitation, right? But every conversation at that greenhouse is a loaded weapon. Inès asking Rosalie point-blank whether she's interested in the Duke of Vallière—that's not curiosity, that's reconnaissance. And when Rosalie has to sit there and say she "only wishes for him to find a suitable bride and be happy" while her chest feels like it's collapsing? Oof. The author never lets up. Even the charity auction mention becomes another test—will Rosalie react when Inès asks if Jeremy will be her partner? The tension escalates with each question, each glance from Princess Camille, and Rosalie is just sitting there sweating in the wrong dress, knowing she's being evaluated. What makes the stakes feel so real is that there's no villain cackling in the corner. Everyone is smiling, sipping tea, asking polite questions. The cruelty is wrapped in etiquette. And the worst part? Rosalie knows this gathering exists to see if she'll break. She knows Princess Camille is testing whether she can still function around Hystein's memory. When Rosalie gives the "correct" answer and feels relief? That's not victory—that's survival. The author has built this整个世界where a single wrong word or outfit choice could destroy a woman's reputation. And Rosalie is navigating it alone.
... Read More
Can we talk about how Jeremy's dialogue is written? The author could've made him sound cute or comedic with all the stuttering and hesitations, but instead every broken sentence feels like you're watching someone construct courage in real time. "T-this." / "Oh, thank you. That's why I came today." "N-not at all. W-wow, it's g-going to be f-fun…!" That second one—delivered at the opera while he's clearly terrified of crowds—his forced enthusiasm is heartbreaking. The repetition of sounds ('g-going', 'f-fun') isn't mockable, it's human. You can hear the anxiety vibrating through every syllable. Compare that to Inès: "You've been appearing everywhere lately. I didn't expect you to come see the opera as well, Miss Rosalie." Clean, sharp, loaded with implied judgment. Her dialogue is a weapon. Jeremy's is a negotiation with his own fear. And the narrator's voice—oh god, the narrator. Lines like "His voice shrank, just like when they first met. Through his messy blond hair, his high nose and twitching eyelashes were visible" read like poetry disguised as prose. The author switches between external observation and internal landscape so seamlessly you don't notice the seam. "Jeremy, wearing a white shirt with the top button undone and his glasses on, was reading a book. It was a peaceful and drowsy afternoon." That's not just description. That's atmosphere. That's the sound of rain against glass and the warmth of tea and the feeling of a moment that could last forever if the world would just let it.
... Read More
Let me just appreciate the CINEMATOGRAPHY of this chapter because the author is not playing around. Rosalie wakes up in a room she's never seen, wearing a robe, and the first thing she notices isn't Hystein — it's the LIGHT. Warm sunlight pouring through the curtains Bibi had specifically told her not to open. That detail matters. Someone wanted her to see the light. Someone wanted the room to feel different. And then the FOOD spread — truffle potage, salmon with caviar, oven-roasted chicken brushed with butter and garlic, a mountain of fluffy white bread in a wooden basket. At 10 AM. This is not normal breakfast food. This is a declaration. The table itself becomes a character in this scene, overflowing with things Rosalie couldn't afford before her family went bankrupt. The contrast between her current state and what's placed before her says more than any dialogue could. The bathroom scene is equally vivid — the antique vanity, the small chair, the bath salts, the rose petals scattered on the robe Bibi drapes over Rosalie afterward. Every object in this house seems curated with intention. Even Bibi's bruised arms suggest she was the one who prepared everything, and Hystein's barely-visible physical toll for her comfort. When Rosalie steps into the bedroom and sees Hystein standing by the window — "his hair as black as the night sky, dressed in a perfectly fitted white shirt and navy suit trousers" — the visual contrast between his darkness and her pale, robe-clad vulnerability is almost painterly. And then the moment his emerald eyes widen when she touches his face? The lighting, the positioning, the silence before he speaks — it reads like a film frame. This author builds atmosphere the way some authors build plot. The house itself feels like a character watching them both.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or