'Why don't you try talking to Lady Cielie at least once?' 'Young Duke… Lady Cielie waited for five hours in the drawing room again today.' These two lines hit me like a truck. Five hours. She waited five hours. And he never even gave her the courtesy of seeing her. Not once. I kept thinking about that throughout the whole chapter. Five hours of sitting in a drawing room, hoping, waiting, and Dietrian didn't even bother. And now he's the one making the grand gesture—writing a letter, choosing orange-scented stationery, practically radiating contentment. But it's too late, isn't it? She's already claimed someone else. She's already proven her love for Erden. And Dietrian is only now realizing what he had—or rather, what he never had.
"'That's Erden, of all people.'" The way the narration emphasizes this—like even Dietrian can't wrap his head around it. Erden of all people. The Academy's prodigy, the wielder of dark abilities, the guy who apparently had a legendary feud with Cielie. And now they're supposedly together? The feud was SO famous that even gossip-avoiders knew about it. That's not a normal rivalry. That's something personal, something intense. And now they're a thing. Meanwhile Cielie is walking around the Academy hearing people speculate about whether Erden fell for her because of money, and she just... endures it. Doesn't defend herself. Just keeps walking to the library, focused on something bigger.
Then there's Cashel. 'I haven't seen you since the accident… I think I understand why those rumors started.' The way he says it—so measured, so careful, dropping hints like he's testing the waters. And Cielie can't respond because the truth is that she's not the same person anymore, and explaining that would get her killed. The emotional loneliness in this scene is suffocating. Everyone around her sees fragments but nothing whole. She's surrounded by people who think they know her, and none of them do. Not Dietrian, who she rejected. Not Erden, whatever's going on between them. Not Cashel, who watches her from behind that polished crown-prince mask. And she can't tell any of them the truth because the truth is impossible.