To You Who Despise Me - Reviews

To You Who Despise Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The sensory details in these chapters are actually insane when you pay attention. Let me start with the train station scene—Janet leaning out of the carriage window, shouting over the mechanical roar because she needs to know how many passenger cars the train has. This detail matters. It's not just worldbuilding for aesthetics; it's the moment her heart FLUTTERS for the first time in a while. She's calculating, strategizing, and the steam and noise and scale of this new technology become the backdrop for something almost hopeful. The Wilton mansion near Deltz Street, close to both the train station and the bustling city—it's a geography of ambition, placed deliberately. Then you cut to the childhood flashback at Philodis Cathedral, and the atmosphere shifts completely. Pointed spires, a small sand playground, an orphanage tacked onto the back of the church like an afterthought. The air is hazy with kicked-up dust every time the pig-bladder ball bounces. A dozen children in mixed disarray, trained to chant "Thank you, sponsor!" in unison while one boy stands apart, soulless, clutching his malformed toy like a shield. And the most BRUTALLY vivid image? Janet holding that deflated pig bladder, yellow urine liquid still inside, staining her sky-blue dress, carrying it like it had value. Meanwhile Rihanel—then Nel—is standing there in his dirty clothes, suddenly hyper-aware of every stain, every smell, while this perfectly raised noble daughter treats his garbage like something precious. The contrast between her cleanliness and his grime, her wealth and his nothingness, it's all rendered through texture and odor rather than exposition. You don't need a paragraph explaining the class divide when the author just makes you SMELL the urine on that ball.
... Read More
Okay, let me just say this first: Rihanel is one of the most infuriating characters I've ever encountered and I literally cannot stop thinking about him. Watch how he handles that whole water scene. He grabs Janet's wrist—actually PHYSICALLY pulls her out of the water—and then the SECOND they're on solid ground, he 'tosses it aside.' Not holds her hand. Not even a careful gesture. He just DROPS her wrist like she's something he picked up off the street. And then he walks away from her while she's SHIVERING in a blanket, leaving her behind as he quickens his pace. But here's what gets me: he's SEETHING. He goes into the carriage and closes his eyes and literally thinks 'He was tired'—and then immediately starts replaying why he's angry. It's not just that he found her. It's that she risked her life for a RING. A thin thread ring with no jewel. And what breaks him is that she put so MUCH emotion on that detached face of hers over something so stupid. Then we get the flashback to the leather ball. Oh man. Young Rihanel staring at that ball on his narrow bed, too uncomfortable to even kick it because it reminded him of that girl. In HIS memory, she's the center of everything that day. But in HER memory? The ball was what mattered. That asymmetry is DEVASTATING. And then at the party—he doesn't even SHOW UP. Three hours. She waits three hours against a wall while women mock her dress and she counts pillars to pass the time. And when she finally tries to leave, some random mid-thirties man grabs her wrist and she FLINCS. Of COURSE she flinches. She's been conditioned by prison. And Rihanel isn't there to catch her. I keep going back to this detail: she had her right hand on top of her left, fingers neatly folded, because there would be a 'burst wound on the hidden palm.' She's hiding her own body from herself. From him. From everyone. And he notices the hands but somehow still doesn't SEE her. Who is this man, really? He claims he jumped in the water because he was 'disgusted' by her jumping in 'like a lunatic' and wanted to send 'a dog to fetch it.' But he JUMPED IN. He didn't send Flan. He didn't throw a rope. He went after her himself while telling his assistant to REMOVE the part of the article that makes it look like he cared. THE MAN IS LIED TO HIMSELF SO HARD I CAN'T. Does he love her? Does he hate her? Or is he just terrified of feeling either one?
... Read More
The opening image of this passage is haunting in its simplicity: water splashing around thighs, cold, people murmuring behind them. Just sensory details stacked on top of each other and suddenly you're standing in that water with them. But it's the party scene that really showcases what this author can do with atmosphere. Let me paint it for you: Janet, alone against a wall, for THREE HOURS. The text doesn't just tell us this—it makes us FEEL the time passing through the structure. First dance. Second dance. Third dance. Women going out flushed and coming back. Whispers starting at the second hour. Champagne flowing. The crowd thinning. And Janet, counting pillars. ONE. TWO. THREE. She's literally doing the same mental exercise Rihanel taught her in prison to pass the time. He TAUGHT her how to survive boredom. And now he's the reason she's bored to death at his party. The mockery scene is chef's kiss. Those women aren't just being mean—they're performing class solidarity. 'Passage Bellici was a street lined with high-end shops, mainly visited by wealthy middle-class people… haughty nobles never visited the place. They considered it vulgar to personally go in and out of various shops.' This is worldbuilding through cruelty. The author doesn't need a chapter on the Noble Special Law—we get the whole oppressive social hierarchy in a single insult about where Janet bought her dress. And Janet's internal geography of the room—estimating pillar heights, wondering what shape they could make, whether they'd be large enough to encircle the mansion—this is such a specific, character-revealing detail. She's not just killing time. She's building entire architectures in her head because the real one she's standing in has no place for her. The contrast between the warm, almost idyllic memory of the leather ball (young Rihanel on his narrow bed, the taut ball catching light) and the cold, brutal present is devastating. The past is warm. The present is freezing water and suffocating lace at the collarbone.
... Read More
Okay, can we just talk about how brilliantly the ring functions as a plot device here? It started as a symbol of Rihanel's humiliation and desire to erase her — melting it down so no trace remains — and now it's the actual mechanism that drives the entire conflict forward. He claims it because she lost it, but she says she didn't lose it, she had no reason to throw it away. That single exchange shifts the entire power dynamic between them. And then — boom — the ring is used as a vehicle for physical contact so he can access her memories. The author is playing 4D chess with this object. It's not just jewelry; it's the key to the curse, the lever for the bet, the evidence of past affection, and the weapon in their present-day game. Every time the ring reappears, it carries different weight. I also love how the present-day scene (the bet, the proposal, the negotiation) keeps colliding with the memory flashback. The story doesn't let us rest in one timeline — we're constantly pulled between what Rihanel thinks he knows and what the ring reveals. That ending where Janet asks what HE gained from the marriage? Chef's kiss. The author isn't giving easy answers, and I'm here for it.
... Read More
I'll be honest — the first few chapters felt like a warm-up lap. Lots of walking, lots of internal monologue about how heavy the shackles felt (metaphorically AND literally), lots of Janet adjusting to the world outside. And I get it — you need to establish what she lost, what she survived, the texture of those five years. But I was starting to wonder if this was going to be one of those atmospheric novels that takes itself very seriously and never gets anywhere. Then Rihanel showed up at the mansion door. Everything snapped into focus after that. The pacing went from "leisurely stroll through regret" to "full-throttle emotional car chase" and I flipped pages like my life depended on it. The structure of this opening is actually really smart when you think about it. Chapter by chapter, we get: release (slow, claustrophobic) → carriage ride (exposition disguised as travel) → arrival at the mansion (EXPLOSION). Each section raises the stakes a little more until the final scene where two people who should hate each other are forced to perform love in front of an army of reporters. That's not just good pacing — that's a trap. The author snuck all that worldbuilding and backstory into the first seven chapters and by the time I realized what was happening, I was already emotionally invested. My only concern: the exposition dump about the Noble Special Law felt slightly rushed. It came at the end and I had to re-read it twice. But honestly, the emotional beats hit so hard I didn't care. This book knows when to breathe and when to punch you in the chest.
... Read More
So I just finished reading these chapters and... okay. Let me process this. The wedding scene at Bedamio Cathedral is this massive set piece that starts with so much promise—intimidating crowd, noble guests whispering, people who actually bet money on whether this would happen. And then it just... doesn't. Not really. What happens instead is this chillingly efficient marriage of convenience where neither person actually wants what the other is giving them. Rihanel brings Janet a dagger on their wedding night—not as a romantic gesture, obviously, but as a test. Or maybe punishment. And Janet? Janet just... takes it. She asks 'Where should I cut?' like he's asking her to pick a restaurant. The plot twist here isn't some big reveal. It's that there is no twist. This woman really would have carved herself open. The real shock isn't what happens—it's how predictable it turns out to be, and how Rihanel can't handle the reality of his own cruelty when she actually goes through with it. He brought the knife hoping she wouldn't use it. She uses it. And suddenly he's the one panicking. I love how the author structures the post-wedding scene with Panianna—it's like we get the behind-the-scenes of all the scheming, and it completely reframes everything we just read. This marriage was never about love or even mutual benefit. It's about control, inheritance rights, and making sure Janet stays isolated enough that no one notices she's building something underneath all their interference. But here's what gets me—the wedding ceremony itself. 'Do you both marry of your own free will?' 'Yes.' '...Yes.' That delayed answer, that hesitation that almost ruins everything but doesn't. It's so perfect. The story builds this entire tension around whether these two can actually pull off being a couple, and the answer turns out to be... no. They can't. Not yet. But the fact that they're trying, even this badly, even with daggers and blood on the sheets—it's weirdly hopeful in a twisted way.
... Read More
The atmosphere in this book is SO thick you could cut it with a knife. Let me paint you a picture. The Reynes household is preparing for Janet's arrival, and the visual details are doing so much work. White maia flowers in every vase—because the duke mentioned she liked them, and the butler caught that detail. A world map replacing a painting, hung specifically for the railroad heiress who supposedly loves traveling. Every room spotless, every surface gleaming, every curtain fresh. It's a fortress of perfection built to接待 a woman the servants call a witch. And Janet arrives in a flowing white dress. Pale. Sickly-looking. The head butler greets her with stiff respect while Letsy internally screams. But the scene that lives in my head now is Janet on the bed. Curled up. Small. Letsy watches from the doorway and thinks: she looks like a dead person. Not a witch. Not a criminal. Just... still. The contrast between the house's gleaming performance of welcome and Janet's broken, vulnerable posture is devastating. She's performing composure while internally shaking—just like Rihanel performs control while his body betrays him. Then there's the makeup scene. Janet wrapped entirely in clothes, face dull and dark with bruises and wounds barely concealed. Letsy, who has十万 freckles she's proud of, tries to comfort this ghost of a woman with desperate humor. "I'm a makeup expert!" And Janet smiles—that light, fragile smile—and asks if she can cover everything. Of course she can't. But the attempt matters. The worldbuilding here isn't in grand descriptions of castles or magic systems. It's in the details: the servants' whispered fears, the way Janet walks (like a child, or like someone hiding pain), the scent of maia flowers that can't mask the rot underneath. Every setting choice feels intentional and alive. The house isn't just a backdrop—it's a character. And it's LOATHING her.
... Read More
The ring. Let's talk about the ring. It's described as a 'thin thread ring' with no jewel. It fell into water. It's now buried in underwater sand. It is, by any rational measure, unfindable and worthless. And yet Janet will drown for it. Rihanel will throw himself into freezing water to stop her. Three entire chapters orbit around this object that shouldn't matter. What IS the ring? It's the past. It's the version of themselves that existed before prison, before betrayal, before every sharp word and dropped wrist. It's the physical proof that something was exchanged between them—some vow, some moment, some gesture—that Janet refuses to let wash away. And Rihanel? He can't stand that she values something he considers worthless, because if the ring matters, then his rejection of it means he's rejecting HER memory of their past. Then there's the leather ball. Young Rihanel sitting on his narrow bed, staring at a ball he never kicked. 'He couldn't kick it because he kept thinking about that moment when he faced that girl.' The ball is innocence. It's the last thing he owned before his life became about power and reputation and performing cruelty. He never played with it because playing would mean admitting he was still a boy who cared about a girl who didn't care about his clothes or his dirt. The gloves. Janet isn't wearing them at the party. Rihanel notices and feels 'a stinging sensation as if someone was scratching his heart.' Why? Because the gloves were her armor. Without them, her hands are exposed—and we know from earlier that her palm bears a 'burst wound.' The gloves hid her damage. Removing them is either vulnerability or defeat. He can't tell which. And the water itself—the cold, the murmuring crowd, the darkness beneath the surface. Water as punishment (prison), water as danger (her jumping in), water as memory (that day with the ball). Everything in this story is saturated. Even the party scene: champagne, intoxication, the rising level of drunk aristocrats closing in on a woman who hasn't danced in three hours. One question the text keeps asking, silently: what happens to things that fall into water? Do they come back up? Or do they just disappear, and the people left on shore convince themselves they never mattered?
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about stakes because this scene redefined what stakes mean to me. On the surface, what's at risk here is obvious: Janet needs this marriage to survive under the Noble Special Law. Rihanel needs a wife for inheritance purposes. Both have practical reasons. Both think they're in control. But the real conflict isn't about law or inheritance. It's about who gets to define reality when two people are trapped in a room with a knife and a lie. Rihanel comes in expecting Janet to be some fragile noblewoman who'll faint or scream or beg. What he gets instead is a woman who treats self-mutilation like a business transaction and then worries about bedsheet stains. The stakes shift in that moment—from external (will society accept this marriage?) to internal (who are we when nobody's watching?). Janet proves she can harm herself without breaking. Rihanel proves he can command without being obeyed in the way he expects. And suddenly the whole power dynamic flips because he's the one losing control, not her. What's terrifying is how little is at stake in the literal sense—just a small cut, some blood, a ruined sheet—and how enormous it feels in the moment. That's masterful writing. The author makes you feel like this is life-or-death even though Janet walks away with a scar and a story she can tell. The external conflict—the protesters, the gossiping nobles, the scheming relatives—is all still there. But this scene makes it clear: the real battle isn't against society. It's between two people who keep choosing the worst possible way to communicate with each other. And until they figure that out, the stakes will keep rising until one of them actually does die.
... Read More
I need a minute. The scene where Rihanel makes Janet smile — 'smile happily' — and she does it, perfectly, coldly, like a practiced performance, and he lets go of her hand like he's been burned... I literally set the book down. This man spent the entire chapter trying to wound her, to assert dominance, to make her uncomfortable, and the SECOND she gives him exactly what he asked for, he feels『dirty, as if rolling in mud.』Bro. You wanted her to break. You wanted to see her pained. But when she actually does what you ask, it doesn't feel like victory — it feels like confirming that she doesn't care about you at all. And THAT is what hurts. Meanwhile, Janet — 'her smile was completely erased' the moment she walked away. She gave him the smile in that moment, then stripped it away like it was nothing. Who is actually winning this? And don't even get me started on Nel's memory. Sixteen-year-old Nel giving that crooked ring with such tender awkwardness, and Janet's genuine joy — 'I'll never lose it, I'll keep it no matter what happens.' And then the present-day Rihanel watching this, knowing she gave those words to someone else. I'm emotionally compromised. This is peak emotional writing.
... Read More
The title of this section —『Blessing or Curse』— is doing so much thematic heavy lifting. The Reynes family calls this memory-touching power a blessing, but Rihanel experiences it as『something that makes a person feel this dirty.』That's the core tension right there: is knowledge a gift or a violation? Can you ever truly know someone, or does that knowledge only corrupt? The ring operates on the same symbolic frequency. It's supposed to represent commitment and value, but Rihanel wants to melt it down, to erase it, while Janet says she'll keep it『no matter what happens.』Two people, two readings of the same object. And the blood — literal blood — is what unlocks everything. The glass cut on Janet's hand, the scab forming, Rihanel caressing that wound... blood as both wound and key, injury and revelation. There's also this quietly devastating theme about class and worth. Janet is called『not a noble』but Rihanel is the one desperate for the marriage, the one with conditions and games. Who really has the power here? And Nel's perspective adds another layer — the orphan who became『someone special』to someone radiant, only to realize he could never stand at her height. Worth, value, visibility — these themes are threaded through every scene.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or