To You Who Despise Me - Reviews

To You Who Despise Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about Rihanel pulling Janet's hand at the riverbank. Like... I literally stopped reading and just stared at my phone screen. The way the narrative builds from this violent, almost feral chase—Janet lunging into freezing water after some brat who stole a worthless-looking ring, her old wound reopening, sand scraping her palm—and then Rihanel appears out of nowhere with this distorted expression, grabbing her arm like she's about to do something irreversible. And she says his name. "Nel...?" Not Rihanel. Never Rihanel in that moment. But what wrecked me was the flashback it triggered. Oh god, the flashback. Watching sixteen-year-old Rihanel (still Nel) experience Janet's memories as if they were his own was devastating in a way I didn't expect. He realizes—no, he FEELS—that the girl who ran after his pig-bladder ball wasn't being proper. She was ALIVE. Her pupils were full of life, her face bright with a smile, chasing something ridiculous because she wanted to help him. And in that moment, as her guest and beneficiary, he was the one turning red with embarrassment over his own poor, smelly creation while she held urine-stained leather like it was treasure. The irony of him now wearing the name Rihanel Reynes, the Duke himself, standing over a woman everyone calls a witch, pulling her back from a river she'd risk everything for—that thin, jewel-less thread ring that once belonged to someone important—hit me so hard. Five years in prison changed her. The scars underneath her clothes. The way she flinches at her uncle's scrutiny. And yet here he is, still recognizing the ghost of a girl who once ran through sand for a stray child's toy. Something between them existed before all this nobility and scandal. I'm not even sure what it was—protection? gratitude? something darker?—but it's definitely not dead.
... Read More
Okay, so let me just talk about the absolute energy between these two because WOW. Janet gets out of prison after FIVE YEARS and her first interaction with Rihanel is him lifting her up like a bag of groceries because she won't walk fast enough and she just... lets him? And then puts her HAND on his hand? Like, I am not okay with this level of controlled chaos. What I love most is that they both have completely opposite readings of the same moment. Rihanel thinks she's being calculating and manipulative — "How dare she, knowing her place" — while Janet is just pragmatically surviving. She's playing the game because she has to. The scene where she wraps her fingers around her ring finger like it's an actual ring that isn't there? That broke me a little. She's performing the role of a lovestruck fiancée while internally screaming. And Rihanel — oof. He's trapped too. His grandfather forced this marriage, and now he has to pretend he adores a woman the whole world calls a witch. But watch how he acts around those reporters: arm around her shoulder, whispering romantic nonsense, picking her up. The man is furious but he commits to the bit with such physical intensity it's almost impressive. When he carries her into the mansion and sets her down like he's tossing her aside — that's not anger, that's frustration at being forced into intimacy with someone he doesn't know. They're both pawns and neither of them knows it yet. Also, the fact that he threw her into the arms of her own uncle (the one who probably ruined her life) and said thank you to HIM instead of defending her? Rihanel is already learning to play this political game and Janet is still reading the rulebook. This power imbalance is going to be SO interesting to watch shift.
... Read More
I need to talk about the blood scene because I am SHOOK. So Rihanel sees Janet cut her hand, and his entire body betrays him—he freezes, nauseated, because he has hemophobia. But then she touches his uninjured hand and suddenly his heart RATE DECREASES. He literally goes from panic to calm because of HER touch, and his own brain tries to convince him it's because he finally feels "human warmth" instead of whatever this IS. Denial level: maximal. But here's what wrecked me: we learn WHY he has this phobia. His grandfather took him hunting, saw him freak out at a bird's blood, laughed it off, then SENT him through years of exposure therapy that basically amounted to torture. Dozens more animals had to bleed. Hundreds more. And when he fainted from the horror of it all, his grandfather's look wasn't concern—it was "terrible disappointment." No shame allowed. Just endure. So this man who has been conditioned to see his natural reaction to blood as weakness is now touching someone else's blood voluntarily because of Janet. His body remembers the trauma, yes—but his HANDS reach toward her anyway. "Perhaps he could look at her blood. Maybe he could even touch it. Then her memories..." He's thinking about HER after all this time. After five years apart. After she burned a cathedral and went to prison. And he's still, irrationally, drawn to her. She cares for HIS wellbeing before her own wound. "Are you okay?" she asks, while bleeding. That's the kind of person she is—not the arsonist the servants fear, not the criminal the world sees, but someone who still has a heart capable of putting another person first. And he RESENTS that about her, doesn't he? Because she's everything his world told him to be and never was, despite all his privilege. This is going to be so painful. I can feel it.
... Read More
The pacing in this batch is absolutely relentless and I have no complaints. It opens with Rihanel's chapter — cold, calculated, dealing with documents and marriage requirements. Brief, efficient, establishing his emotional distance. Then it cuts to Janet's nightmare. One moment she's reading papers, the next she's waking up gasping from a dream about being strangled. The transition is so sharp it hits like a punch. And instead of giving us relief, the author immediately plunges us into Janet's powerlessness — no authority, no wedding planning role, just sitting in her room practicing smiles in a mirror. Then the train station scene acts as a breather — a moment of warmth, unexpected connection with Carsia, something almost hopeful. But it's brief. Two paragraphs max. We don't get to linger on that positive moment because the very next scene is the tea party, and the warmth gets sucked out of everything instantly. The tea party itself is masterfully paced. It starts slow — Janet arriving early, standing politely, being ignored. Then Carsia's entrance shifts the energy. The revelation about the secret engagement quickens the pace. Panianna's attempt to pivot to Selize creates false hope before driving the knife in deeper. And then the final exchange — Panianna's offer, Janet's instinctive refusal — it all happens in rapid succession, ending on that devastating 'Because I like Duke Rihanel.' No chapter ends on a traditional cliffhanger, but emotionally? We are LEFT BREATHLESS. Janet's choice hangs in the air like smoke. Five years in prison and she chose THIS. The structure doesn't let us rest, and honestly, that's exactly what the story needs.
... Read More
Okay, first of all, this book is a masterclass in slow-burn tension. Let me count the ways. Janet walks into the Reynes mansion like a wolf in sheep's clothing—or rather, a sheep who's survived a wolf and learned to grow teeth. The servants' hostility is palpable. Letsy Maya literally calls her a witch. Beji promises to scold her if she lays a hand on anyone. The whole household is bracing for impact, and yet Janet is just... walking. Slowly. Like a three-year-old toddler, apparently. Which, honestly? Perfect camouflage. Then breakfast happens. And this is where the plot goes FULL THROTTLE. She asks him point-blank whether he's going to marry her. Rihanel nearly chokes on his water. "It's a choice with an expiration date," she says—cold, calculated, merchant-like. And then she SMASHES her glass on purpose. Why? Read it again. Read it again. She wants a reaction. She wants HIM to move. And when he does—grabbing her wounded hand, furious and frantic—the entire power dynamic shifts in one scene. He thinks he's in control. He's not. She's been playing chess while he's been playing checkers. And that line—"Rihanel has the days he lived basely etched all over his body, and Janet has the days she lived preciously etched in her every action." That's not just a pretty sentence. That's the entire thesis of this book right there. Two people carved differently by their lives, colliding in a house full of hatred. What happens next? I genuinely have no idea and I NEED to know.
... Read More
'I need to find the ring. It's over there…' That ellipsis. That trembling pause. That is the entire novel right there in three words and an abandoned sentence. Janet Wilton will drown herself for a ring. Not because the ring means anything materially—it's a thin thread, no jewel, already lost to underwater sand—but because it's the last physical proof that someone once looked at her like she mattered. And when Rihanel drags her out of that water, his voice going soft and kind for exactly half a second before turning to ice… that's the moment that wrecked me. He asks her: 'Is that ring left behind by your lover who abandoned and hid from you?' AND THEN: 'Or is it a token you received after whispering sweet nothings with a prison guard?' TWO ACCUSATIONS in two sentences. He's not just insulting her. He's rewriting their entire history into something sordid because the alternative—that she waited for him, that she still cares, that she's standing in freezing water memorizing a gesture from eight years ago—is something he can't control. And Janet. God, Janet. She doesn't fight back. She says 'Just go back without worrying about me. I'll look more…' and trails off because she literally CANNOT finish the sentence. She's so used to shrinking herself that even her own voice sounds apologetic. But then—then at the party, three hours of waiting, and when Theo says 'I've never met anyone as wise and straightforward as you. Whatever it is, everything will work out'—she smiles. A REAL smile. Not the practiced one she'd been wearing all evening. And the text says 'It felt like the knot in her chest loosened a little, just a little.' JUST A LITTLE. That's the tragedy. One kind word from a near-stranger loosens the knot more than three hours of Rihanel's presence ever could. And she STILL goes back inside hoping he'll finally show up. The scene where she practices smiling in the mirror before the party—it's horrifying and beautiful. 'Janet deliberately smiled at her reflection in the mirror. Lifting the corners of her mouth had become quite natural.' She's training herself the way she trained her body to survive prison. Performance as survival. And she does it all so that Rihanel might look at her and see something worth staying for. I'm not okay.
... Read More
This chapter is a masterclass in building and releasing tension. It opens with Rihanel watching Janet from across the ballroom — that『strangely empty』feeling — and within three paragraphs he's already proposing a twisted game. The pacing is relentless from there. He confronts her, they spar verbally, the ring becomes the centerpiece, the kiss-for-the-ring sequence hits like a freight train, and THEN the author drops the memory flashback. Most writers would have us catching our breath after the terrace scene, but instead we're shoved into Nel's perspective, into a completely different emotional register, and it somehow makes the present confrontation even more painful because we now understand what he's losing. Then back to the present, the marriage conditions, the『I'll marry you』and『let's do that』exchange that's equal parts business transaction and emotional landmine, and it ends on her walking away with her smile gone. The chapter never lets up, but it varies its intensity — there are moments of quiet (Janet's『I see』when she deduces his conditions) that make the louder moments hit harder. The structure feels almost musical in how it modulates.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say — the tea party scene is an absolute masterpiece of dramatic tension. On the surface it looks like a harmless social gathering, right? You'd expect some polite greetings and maybe a little gossip. But no. What we get is Janet standing beside the hostess, COMPLETELY IGNORED while everyone talks around her like she's furniture. And the worst part? It stings more than if she'd been seated in a corner. Because standing next to Panianna, in the most prominent position, makes the exclusion so much more visible. She has nowhere to hide. Then Carsia drops the bomb about the secret engagement and everything unravels. Panianna tries to pivot to talking up Selize — clearly trying to set Janet up for failure — and even sighs regretfully about Rihanel and Selize being a better match. The woman is openly trying to sabotage the marriage in front of everyone. But the real plot turn? When Panianna offers Janet an out — introduce her to other noblemen, arrange a marriage under her name — and Janet says yes to staying with Rihanel without even thinking. Her mouth answers before her brain catches up. 'Because I like Duke Rihanel.' Was that prepared? Or was it real? The narrator leaves us hanging and I am NOT OK with this ambiguity. Also, that dream sequence at the beginning where Rihanel is strangling her while telling her to smile? Chilling. Absolutely chilling. The plot doesn't let up for a second.
... Read More
This author understands pacing like a surgeon understands a scalpel. Chapter starts with memory—Janet and Rihanel's past, her arson accusation, his mockery. We're immediately thrown into the emotional wreckage. Then the present: Janet arriving at the mansion. The servants' preparation scenes give us breathing room—darkly comic, slightly tense, establishing the hostile environment without heavy exposition. Letsy and Beji's conversation is the kind of scene that could slow things down, but it doesn't. It builds dread while making you laugh. Then BAM. Breakfast. Twenty pages of nothing and suddenly she's asking if he's going to marry her and breaking glass and revealing his phobia. The pacing accelerates like a car hitting the gas. Each beat lands harder than the last: - The question (shock) - Her merchant-like response (more shock) - His verbal evisceration (tension peaks) - The glass breaking (physical interruption) - Her wound, his panic, his breakdown (emotional explosion) - The flashback to hunting (context/deepening) - Her hand on his, his relief (aftermath) And then—immediately after that emotional climax—the chapter pivots to a quiet morning scene. Letsy trying to do Janet's makeup. Janet leaving alone. The contrast between the explosive breakfast and this fragile, intimate moment is *chef's kiss*. It gives the reader space to process what just happened while layering in new questions: Why is she so damaged? Where is she going? What is her plan? The chapter ends with her walking out into Deltz Street, alone, and I immediately opened the next one. No cliffhanger, no dramatic announcement—just the sheer momentum of the story dragging you forward. Brilliant.
... Read More
That ring. That absolutely gutted me and I need to process it. A thin thread ring without a single jewel. That's it. No grand gemstone, no family crest, no symbol of status. And yet Janet risks falling into a river for it. Children call her a witch and steal it from her finger like it's trash, and she CHASES them. When the boy throws it into the water and it disappears into the current, she immediately strips off her shoes and wades in, reopening the wound from that morning, scraping her palm on river sand, searching for something that might already be gone. Why does this object matter? It's the physical remnant of a self she had before prison. Before the fire at the cathedral. Before the world decided she was a monster. The narrative explicitly states: "It was one of the few remaining precious things that used to fill the old Janet." The word "used to" is doing the heaviest lifting here. The old Janet is gone. This ring was all that remained of her, and now even that is lost to a river she couldn't possibly retrieve it from. The children calling her a witch while stealing from her—this is the public verdict on her character, enacted by innocent-seeming voices who've absorbed prejudice without understanding it. They don't know what the ring means. They think they're punishing a monster. But Janet knows it's the last tether to who she used to be. And then the flashback reveals the origin point: a nine-year-old girl running through sand for a dirty pig-bladder ball, treating a poor orphan's clumsiness as something worthy of care. The girl who believed kindness mattered more than propriety. The girl who got crushed into the woman now chasing a thread ring into a freezing river. What was lost isn't just her freedom—it's that version of herself that could smile at a smelly toy and mean it.
... Read More
I need to talk about two scenes that completely blew me away this batch. First: the train station. Janet sitting on a bench, watching travelers arrive, feeling their excitement and nostalgia wash over her. The detail about passenger trains only running four times a day and people tending to stay as long as possible because it's expensive — that's worldbuilding through observation, not exposition. We learn about the economy, the class system, the daily rhythms of this world just through Janet watching people. And then the handkerchief scene with Carsia! A thin handkerchief flying through the wind, landing at Janet's feet. Carsia's line — 'You can't lie, can you?' — delivered with a laugh. The entire exchange happens in about three paragraphs but it's so rich. Carsia's elaborate silk shawl, her narrow-brimmed hat with flower decorations, that captivating smile. She walks away with a confident gait and a 'if fate wills it, we'll meet again' and I swear to god my heart exploded. Second: the tea party garden. Past the famous fountain, tea tables arranged on the other side, about twenty people already seated. Janet arriving early and still being late to the conversation. The way the author describes Panianna waving her hand 'as if telling her to wait' without even looking at Janet — you can PHYSICALLY feel the coldness of that gesture. And then Carsia appearing, and Panianna's immediate warmth returning the moment someone important arrives. The setting itself becomes a weapon. Every detail of the garden, the fountain, the seating arrangement — it all reinforces Janet's isolation. I could literally see this as a film scene.
... Read More
"Your steps were getting in the way of me leaving the place." I am DEAD. Rihanel says this with a smirk on his face like he's genuinely annoyed that Janet's walking too slowly instead of, you know, acknowledging that he just picked her up in front of twenty reporters and carried her like a bride. The audacity. The absolute gaslighting energy. And Janet's response is just... silence. Dry, golden-eyed silence. She doesn't argue. She doesn't defend herself. She just lets him have his moment of superiority while internally computing every way this could go wrong. That's not weak — that's survival mode and the author makes it feel authentic. The dialogue between these two is basically combat dressed as conversation. Every line has two meanings: what they're saying and what they're actually thinking. Rihanel says "You look better. Did prison life suit you?" and he MEANS something completely different from what comes out of his mouth. Janet answers "I received the flowers and gifts well. Thank you." and we BOTH know she's talking about the yellow carnations — the flowers that symbolize contempt — and she's using politeness as a weapon. The reporter scenes are also chef's kiss. "Witch Returns from Hell. Will She Cling to Savior Reynes?" — that headline? Perfect. It tells us everything about how the public sees Janet and sets up the central conflict immediately. The author doesn't waste words. Every line of dialogue advances either character development or plot, sometimes both at once. Also Janet muttering "I've become a celebrity" while reading that headline and paying for the magazine like nothing? That's not comedy — that's trauma response disguised as humor. I appreciate a character who can laugh at themselves while their life falls apart.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or