To the One Who Hates Me - Reviews

To the One Who Hates Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this—Damian is NOT stupid and I love it. Like, the man noticed Emma was missing and immediately flagged that Sarah wasn't the right maid. That is some next-level observational skills right there. He didn't even have concrete proof yet, but his gut was already screaming something was wrong. And Logan?! What a disaster of a human being. The whole setup is horrifying in the best way. He literally sold his illegitimate daughter as a replacement for his dead noble daughter because he's drowning in debt. The fact that he hit Bel today wasn't even really about her—it was about HIM being humiliated at court. She's just a vessel to him, a walking ATM that happens to have the same face. But here's what got me: the Bartgen subplot. A fraudulent physician who ran away from being exposed as a charlatan, now playing doctor for gold coins. It's almost funny how desperate everyone is. Logan needs money, Bartgen needs a fresh identity, Bel just needs to survive. And Damian? He's slowly peeling back layers and I am HERE for it. The tension between Bel's internal guilt and Damian's growing suspicion is delicious. Every scene with her lying awake at night wondering if he'll find out, and every scene where he's silently investigating—that's where the plot really lives. Not in the big dramatic confrontations, but in these quiet moments where everyone is pretending. I also loved the reveal about the servants being dismissed for gossiping about the wedding night. That detail matters because it shows Damian already has informants everywhere. He's been quietly dismantling any threat while pretending to be absent. Classic power move. My only question now is: how close is Damian to the truth? Because at this point it feels like one more conversation away from everything exploding.
... Read More
I've read the canopy scene three times now and I still can't look at it the same way. "The thin fabric slipped from his grasp and drifted down again, veiling the bed from sight." This single action—a hand falling, fabric covering the truth—contains the entire emotional weight of the chapter. He reached for it. He HESITATED. His knuckles went white. Something in him was holding back, even as he marched through a rainstorm to confront whatever truth he feared. And then he saw it wasn't her. The canopy didn't just hide the woman—it became a metaphor for everything that had been hidden, everything false, everything between them that was never truly seen. "A hollow laugh slipped from his lips." That laugh. Not anger. Not rage. A hollow, broken sound from a man whose entire world just shifted under him. He felt betrayal but it wasn't even the right word, because how do you betrayal someone who doesn't even know who they are? Meanwhile Bel is in her own corner of hell, thinking his coldness means indifference. Two people drowning in different ways, never realizing the other is right there with them. The emotional dissonance is suffocating and beautiful and I am NOT OKAY. This isn't just romantic angst. This is existential. Who ARE you if the person you love was built on a foundation that never existed?
... Read More
I need to talk about Bel for a minute because my heart actually hurts. "Perhaps this is for the best." She literally says this. She wishes for him to tire of her, to discard her himself, because being cast out for deception would be easier than... what? Him finding out the truth? Him rejecting her? The tragedy here is so thick I can barely read through it. Bel thinks she's a fraud. She's spent all this time believing her love is based on a lie, and instead of fighting for him, she's quietly packing her bags in her head. She's preparing to lose him before he even has the chance to. That is the most heartbreaking kind of self-sabotage. And Damian—oh god, Damian. The man who shot her tea burns off without flinching because "compared to being struck by a sword, this is nothing" is now lying on the floor of his own bedroom, completely broken because the woman he's grown attached to isn't who she said she was. The relationship dynamics in this chapter are a disaster zone and I love it. Bel shrinking away from him while he's trying to piece together truths he never wanted to find. He's not angry about the lie—he's devastated by the impossibility of it. There's a moment where he realizes asking her won't help because if she truly has amnesia, she can't answer him. That helplessness in him? Brutal. They're both suffering independently, heading toward the same collision point, and I cannot wait to see what happens when they finally really SEE each other.
... Read More
Can we just talk about Bel for a second? Because this girl has been through absolutely WORSE than any of us and she's still trying to be a decent human being inside a Lie. "I often imagined that if I were to die, her body would not be found until it had decayed beyond recognition." — This line absolutely DESTROYED me. She was forgotten. Completely erased. Locked away, starving not for food but for human contact, and the person who came to pick her up did so out of pure desperation, not love. And yet—she STILL feels guilty. Like, instead of just being bitter and going along with it, she's lying awake at night torture herself because she's betraying someone who's been kind to her. That's the thing that got me. Damian hasn't even done anything particularly romantic yet and she's already agonizing over hurting him. The Logan dynamic is nauseating in the best writing way. He calls her "useless" and hits her, but also he's the one who literally pulled her out of isolation. She feels grateful AND trapped, which is such a realistic toxic relationship spiral. She said herself: "Being sought out, even as a substitute, felt like salvation." BROKE. And Isabel—oh Isabel. She tormented Bel too, just casually learned cruelty from watching her father. The text says it plainly: "Having grown up watching her father treat his other daughter like a subhuman being, perhaps she had simply learned that cruelty was acceptable." One sentence and suddenly Isabel isn't just a ghost, she's part of the problem too. Damian's treatment of the maids though—"Who is attending her now?" with that voice "sharp as steel"—this is a man who notices EVERYTHING. And I'm convinced he's going to figure it out not through some grand revelation but because he'll catch some tiny detail that doesn't add up. Also the Bartgen thing is giving me so many thoughts about complicity. He KNEW Logan was lying but took the money anyway. He has zero moral compass but also... he's just a survivor doing what he always did. Kind of makes you wonder how many other people in this story are just trying to stay alive by playing roles. I need Bel to figure out she deserves better soon or I'm going to lose it.
... Read More
I finished this chapter at 2am and I genuinely cannot believe how well-structured it is. It opens with Bel's interior panic—slow, suffocating, almost meditative in its sadness. She's lying there doing nothing, overthinking everything, weighing whether to divorce HIM. The prose is sluggish on purpose, mirroring her emotional paralysis. You FEEL her depression. Then—the flashback cuts to ten days earlier. The pacing accelerates immediately. Eric delivering reports, Damian reading documents, the reveals stacking: unlicensed physician, vanished maid, another daughter, a forgotten name. Each piece of information arrives like a hammer blow. The prose gets sharper, more clipped. Damian's dialogue becomes increasingly sparse—"Find him." "Place men on the Baron." "What was the name?" Three-word sentences that carry the weight of a man whose instincts are screaming. And THEN—the grave scene. The pace slows again but it's a different kind of slow. The digging. The waiting. The rain starting. The coffin opening. Every beat stretched thin. Back to the bedroom. The rainstorm intensifies. Damian's approach—measured steps. The hesitation. The lightning. The revelation. And then the final image: the canopy drifting shut, sealing the tragedy. The chapter moves from suffocating silence to frantic investigation to storm-driven reckoning. It's like a symphony building to a crescendo and then cutting to silence at the worst possible moment. I am already losing sleep.
... Read More
The dialogue in this text is mostly silence, and that's what makes it so devastating. Bel's final moments are rendered almost entirely through internal monologue and fragmented speech. "Why? Why? Why?" — three questions that collapse into each other like a building losing its foundation. And then her hallucination: "It's your fault." That single line, spoken by a ghost or her own breaking mind, carries more weight than any speech the author could have written for her. But the real masterpiece is how Isabel speaks — or rather, how she almost doesn't. Everything about her dialogue is constrained. She stammers. She truncates her sentences. "N-No." "I-I can do it." Even her thoughts are edited before they reach the page. The narration constantly reminds us of her barriers: the veil, the aphasia, the instructions. Every time she opens her mouth, there's a warning waiting for her. Damian's dialogue, by contrast, is impossibly smooth. "Please, don't worry. I will speak to them." "It's all right, Isabel. There's no need to be tense." His voice is gentle, attentive, almost tender. And that's what makes my skin crawl. Is he genuinely caring, or is he performing care? The ambiguity is intentional, and the author never gives us enough to be sure. When the Baron tells Isabel "Don't show your face to the Grand Duke" and Isabel responds with "Yes. Of course" — that "Of course" feels like the most honest line in the entire chapter, because it's the only time someone says exactly what they mean without ornament.
... Read More
I need to talk about Bel in that garden scene because my heart literally ached. She's sitting alone, shivering in the cold, and what does she overhear? Gossip that the Grand Duke has already lost interest, that her face is grotesque, that she was left alone on her wedding night. And her FIRST reaction isn't anger or self-pity — it's: 'Would it harm Damian? Would the viscount fly into another rage?' She's STILL thinking about OTHER PEOPLE even while being destroyed by these words. And then the guilt hits her: 'Deceiving him by pretending to be Isabel was sin enough. She didn't want to cause him any more harm. If only he would tire of her!' CHOMP. That right there, that's the emotional core of the entire story. She's trapped between her duty (or however you frame it) to protect Damian and her own impossible situation. And the irony is that Damian himself is the one who's been hurting — facing the Empress's mockery, being paraded as some pitiful match — but he's the one who chose her, who stood by her, who wrapped his arm around her waist as a silent reassurance. Meanwhile she's willing him to fall out of love with her so she won't be a burden anymore. This is so painfully one-sided in the worst way and I just want to shake her and say YOU ARE NOT A BURDEN BUT ALSO I UNDERSTAND WHY SHE THINKS THIS WAY.
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is doing some brutal work. Damian's lines have gotten shorter, sharper, like he's consciously stripping away everything that isn't necessary. 'Leave.' 'Never enter my space without permission again.' Each word is a door closing. But Bel's voice—her stutter, the way she fragments her sentences ('I—I was trying to open the w-window')—that's not just nervousness, that's the sound of someone whose entire identity is constructed on quicksand. The real conversation happens in the silences though. When the butler says 'His Highness has been quite occupied lately' and can't quite hide that troubled look... that's the author letting us in on the joke. Damian isn't occupied. He's investigating. And Bel knows it but keeps showing up like a ghost hoping to haunt someone who's already moved on. The study scene is mostly physical action—clattering papers, gripping arms, slammed doors—but the dialogue underneath it is screaming. He calls her a rat. She stammers apologies. Neither of them says what they actually mean. That's the kind of writing that makes you sit with a chapter for twenty minutes after you finish it because the real story happened in all the words they refused to speak.
... Read More
The dialogue in this section is doing SO much heavy lifting. Take Damian's question: 'Can a person change so suddenly?' On the surface it's a casual inquiry to his physician, but read between the lines and it's a man trying to solve a puzzle that keeps getting more complicated. And Isabel's responses—short, hesitant, sometimes cutting off mid-sentence—speak volumes about her internal state. When she says 'No. I'll speak to him… myself,' after he offers to discuss the doctor with her father, you can hear the panic in that stumble. Her dialogue has this quality where what she doesn't say is louder than what she does. Damian's voice, meanwhile, is consistently measured but with these tiny cracks—the way he trails off, the questions that hang unanswered, the gentle corrections ('What do you mean?' about the cat). Their conversations feel like two people dancing around something enormous.
... Read More
This entire sequence kicks off with such a deceptively simple moment—Isabel tripping over a step—and then it cascades into something much bigger than a twisted ankle. What I love about how the author structures this is that every physical injury seems to mirror something deeper. The ankle sprain forces Damian to carry her, to touch her, to see her vulnerable in ways she hasn't allowed before. Then the salmon scene becomes this tiny catastrophe that reveals she can't even eat in his presence without her body betraying her. And underneath all of it is the eye mystery—the fact that her own father told her healing was impossible but now claims to have found a doctor? That's the kind of parental lie that makes your skin crawl.
... Read More
Okay so Damian's detective mode is FINALLY activated and I am HERE for it. He goes back to his estate thinking about the accident, and the pieces just... click. Emma had red hair. Only a small percentage of people have red hair, right? So if Isabel had a treasured redhead maid by her side during the worst moment of her life, Damian would remember her. Unless she wasn't there. The implication is just DEVASTATING in how quietly it lands — Isabel didn't just change maids. Something happened to Emma. And if Emma isn't the one standing beside Isabel now, then WHO is? That reveal when Eric says 'The red-haired maid with spectacles?' and Damian confirms — it was so casual, so matter-of-fact, but the reader's entire understanding of this story just cracked open. Because we already KNEW Bel wasn't Isabel, but Damian is only NOW starting to suspect. And the timing? Brutal. He's about to walk into an imperial banquet treating her as his wife when his own instincts are whispering that something is profoundly wrong. This subplot about Emma is basically a ticking time bomb and I can't stop thinking about what's going to happen when he figures out the full picture.
... Read More
Okay so let me just breathe for a second because WHAT JUST HAPPENED. I literally had to pause the book and stare at the wall. The entire chapter is built on this gorgeous, devastating dramatic irony. We get Bel hiding in her room, convinced Damian's coldness means he no longer cares, while parallel to that, Damian is uncovering the truth about the dead daughter—the REAL Bel Ester who supposedly died in a fire between 1713 and 1723. And her grave? EMPTY. Not a single bone. Not a whisper of remains. Just damp earth and weeds and the horrifying implication that someone—Baron Logan—buried nothing and called it a daughter. The twist hits like a truck. Bel didn't die. She was replaced. And then somehow, impossibly, THIS woman (the fake Bel / Isabel) ended up married to Damian. The layers are INSANE. A fraudulent physician, a maid who vanished on the exact day of the accident, an entire household purged of witnesses... this isn't just a romance drama, this is a full-blown conspiracy and someone played the longest con imaginable. But the real plot masterstroke? Damian discovering the truth from two directions at once—he finds the empty grave, but when he storms back and pulls back that canopy, he sees it with his OWN eyes. The woman in his bed isn't Isabel. The evidence is undeniable now. I'm shook. The way the author tied all these loose threads—the fake doctor, the missing maid, the dead daughter's name, the ring, the sudden personality shift—into one explosive reveal? Chef's kiss.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or