To The One I Must Hate - Reviews

To The One I Must Hate
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I'm still not over the Grandma Lulu scene. I need everyone to understand what I experienced when I read that moment because I literally put the book down and stared at the ceiling for twenty minutes. Throughout this entire story, Grandma Lulu has been this warm, mysterious figure. She gives Lesia cryptic advice, she makes cakes, she exists in this space of gentle authority. The bedtime scene with Lesia and Juliana — that domestic happiness, that "good night, sleep well" exchange — it felt like the calm center of the story. And then the night tears it all apart. But Grandma Lulu doesn't just die. She DIES ON HER OWN TERMS. That's what gets me. She could have run. She could have hidden. Instead she stands on a burning bridge with a dagger in her hand and smiles at Lesia. That smile — I keep thinking about that smile. It's not a smile of resignation. It's a smile of love. Of pride. Of "I did what I came here to do." The physical detail of it breaks me every time: her wrinkled hand on Lesia's forehead, the rough breath tickling her ear, those impossible final words about killing the man. She's teaching her granddaughter that sometimes love means becoming dangerous. The tenderness and the brutality existing in the same sentence — that's the emotional core of this entire book, isn't it? And Lesia's reaction. She can't speak. "But Lesia couldn't speak. She just felt an indescribable emotion surging up, making her throat burn." That's the most honest description of grief I've ever read. Grief isn't words. Grief is your throat closing. Grief is standing still while the world moves without you. The mother-daughter thread between Juliana and Lesia is what holds this whole thing together emotionally. Watch how Juliana's entire physicality changes. In the beginning, she's pulling Lesia's arm too hard, she's frantic. But when they're running and Lesia asks if she's okay, Juliana's face does this thing — she flinches, she smiles faintly, she lies. She's terrified. But she never stops moving. Never stops protecting. And that final moment when she's begging Ryuel — the submission, the表演 — it's all for Lesia. Everything Juliana does in this chapter is armor for her daughter. The switch to violence at the end isn't anger. It's love weaponized. The community of Flora Village — all of them, Chalson, Jordan, Isaac, Grandma Lulu — they form this protective circle around Lesia and Juliana. And one by one, it gets cut down. Each death isn't just a plot point, it's an emotional amputation. By the time Lesia is alone with her mother on the other side of a collapsed bridge, the reader feels that same hollow space she feels. We've lost our village too. "As long as Lesia is safe, that's all..." Juliana's voice at the end, cracking through tears. That's the thesis statement of this book. Safety costs everything. Love is what's left after everything else is burned away.
... Read More
Let me just start by saying Juliana is my favorite person in this entire book and I will die on this hill. Because this chapter? This is her moment. This is the moment where the author finally lets us see what's underneath all that gentle mothering. Every time Juliana touches Lesia in this book it means something. The way she pulls Lesia along in the beginning — "Lesia, let's go. Hurry." — she's dragging her, yes, but she's also protecting her. And when Lesia says "Mom, are you okay?" and Juliana responds with "I'm fine. Nothing will happen" — that line is devastating because it's clearly directed at HERSELF. She doesn't believe it either. She's holding herself together by a thread. But then there's the ending. THE ENDING. Juliana begging, offering money, rubbing her hands together, looking submissive — and then the switch. The branch aiming for the heart. The word she screams: "Die!!" I need to process this. I need to sit with it. Juliana wasn't backing down. She was buying time. Every second she spent pretending to negotiate was a second closer to getting within range. That's not desperation — that's calculation under extreme pressure. That woman loves her daughter and she would burn the world to keep her safe. The fact that she went from cowering mother to lethal fighter in one breath is the most beautiful character beat I've read in months. And what about Lesia? Watching her throughout this entire nightmare — she never stops looking back. Not once. Even when she's being dragged away, even when Grandma Lulu covers her eyes, she wants to SEE. She wants to witness everything her community loses. "Mom, they're all dead. Everyone, trying to protect us..." I couldn't finish that thought in my head without crying. She carries the guilt of being the reason this happened. She's a child who is suddenly the most important person in a war she didn't ask for. Grandma Lulu's death is the kind of character moment that haunts me. She smiles at Lesia before she dies. She cuts the bridge. She takes the fire with her. And her last words to Lesia — "Get as far away as possible. And if you get the chance, kill him. Then, you'll be able to live." — that's not just an instruction, that's a passing of the torch. She's telling Lesia that survival requires violence. That the innocent life she's been living is over. And Chalson! He just disappears into the fire and we don't even get a proper goodbye. He was the warm uncle figure, the one who made cakes and waved swords and promised safety. His death isn't dramatic — it's just... gone. That hurts more. Jordan too. Small, trembling, charging anyway. His last act is looking at Lesia as he falls. Not at the killer. At HER. Like his entire purpose in that moment was just to give her a few extra seconds.
... Read More
The pacing in this chapter is absolutely ruthless and I love it. It starts almost comically—Cesar trying to flee from a girl who just says 'Wow, it's so pretty' and ends up tackled on the ground. You're laughing. Then the necklace falls and the tone pivots so hard. Suddenly we're in full survival mode. Winter night, excruciating pain, death approaching. Lesia searching through undergrowth with cut hands. Cesar watching her, thinking maybe this is fortunate, maybe dying here isn't so bad—and then she finds it and he's sobbing. The emotional whiplash is intentional and effective. But then Teresa appears and the pacing slows to this glacial, heavy rhythm. Every line she speaks lands like a stone. 'Children will be children. It's fine.' 'What a pretty child.' 'If you wish, you can keep that child by your side until she dies.' Each one more layered than the last. And then—BAM—the chapter cuts to the cheerful return journey with the villagers. Cake, giggling, a bumped head. It feels almost too light, almost too normal, which makes Grandma Lulu's warning hit even harder. And then it cuts OFF mid-sentence with 'If the ru—' I literally screamed. The author knows exactly what they're doing with tempo shifts here.
... Read More
I need to talk about the garden scene. This entire chapter builds to two parallel deal-making moments, but the one between Cesar and Luxes in that castle garden is cinematic perfection. Let me walk through it because the direction in your head should be: Luxes watching Cesar across a tea table, noticing that every time he tries to ask about the curse, Teresa (the Grand Duchess) intercepts. The suffocating atmosphere of a room where you can't speak freely. Then Luxes making his move—"I'd appreciate it if the Young Master could show me around"—and Cesar agreeing so eagerly it unsettles Luxes. That's the detail that sells it. Cesar SHOULD be defensive or suspicious, but instead he agrees immediately, which tells Luxes something is very wrong and very interesting about this boy. Then the walk itself. Cesar barely knowing the castle geography, moving through rooms he rarely ventures into. "Both had clear objectives in mind"—two predators pretending to be something else. And then Cesar stops, turns around, and Luxes actually FROWNS because he can't read him. For a Crown Prince who prides himself on reading everyone, this is devastating. "Your Highness will become the Emperor someday, correct?" And Cesar's answer—"And I will become the Velius Grand Duke. Without fail." That single sentence reframes everything. Then the offer: "Velius will become Your Highness's strength." Seven years. The chapter ends and I was just sitting there like—WHAT DOES HE MEAN BY SEVEN YEARS. The setting perfectly mirrors the power dynamics. A cold winter castle, a garden that's beautiful but inaccessible, tea that serves as a social shield. Every physical space in this story feels weighted with meaning.
... Read More
This chapter is structured like a house of cards and every card matters. Let me break down why it works so well. It opens with Lesia and Ryuel—the personal, intimate scale. A whisper in the ear, a hand shown, a deal made. This is grounded, character-driven, emotionally immediate. Then it pivots to Cesar and Luxes—the political, strategic scale. A garden walk, a question about the future, a seven-year prophecy. The contrast between these two scenes is deliberate: one is warm and chaotic with laughter and awkward titles, the other is cold and precise, two geniuses sizing each other up across a teacup. The transition is clean. Time passes. Five years. The chapter uses this time jump not as filler but as devastating compression—we see Lesia deteriorating, the Grand Duchess manipulating access to Cesar, the magic stones becoming her only lifeline. Each sentence here is a small punch. And then the ending. Ryuel appears with another magic stone, reminds her of her three-year deadline, and drops the revelation that proximity to Cesar will undo the stone's protection. The chapter ends mid-sentence: "What do you want from m—" That's not a cliffhanger, that's a violence. The author deliberately refuses to let us finish the thought, forces us to sit with the incompleteness, and I was absolutely feral. The pacing here demonstrates masterful control of scale. Personal → political → personal again, but the second personal scene is darker, more desperate, more unresolved. Every structural choice serves the emotional arc.
... Read More
There are SO many layers beneath the surface of these chapters that I just can't stop thinking about. The most obvious one is light and darkness as recurring motifs. The banquet is full of light—fireworks, candlelight, the Grand Duke's luminous presence. But Grandma Lulu's warning comes in a whispered dark moment, and then the literal blackout plunges everyone into darkness where the real story happens. Light is performance and illusion; darkness is truth and consequence. But then at the lake, there's moonlight—"silvery-blue moonlight scattered like stardust"—which is neither full light nor complete dark. It's that liminal space where transformation happens. Then there's the red eyes. The Grand Duke has red eyes. Cesar has red eyes. This clearly means something, and I'm not even sure what yet, but the repetition is deliberate and significant. Beauty as danger is another huge theme. The Grand Duke is breathtakingly beautiful—a description that could apply to Cesar too, with his glossy black hair and flawless skin. But beauty here is lethal. "The Grand Duke of Velius destroys everything belonging to the person who becomes their companion." Beauty is a trap. It's also the only thing that makes Cesar reach out to Lesia. She sees his beauty and says so with total honesty, and in that moment, the curse might actually crack. The broken necklace is symbolic on so many levels—it's the physical manifestation of their fates entangling, the thing that connects them now fractured and lost in the dark. Lesia searching for it through the night, unable to find it, represents her desperate attempt to repair what she's already damaged. And César's line about his heart being "parched earth that had never known rain"—that's the core metaphor of the entire novel, isn't it? This is a story about a barren soul that encounters something that might nourish it, and the terrifying question is whether nourishment means salvation or destruction for a family cursed to consume everything it touches. I keep coming back to one thing: Lesia was told never to get entangled with the Velius family, and she's already past the point of no return. The real story hasn't even started yet.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the author handles narrative voice across different sections because it's honestly impressive how distinct each voice feels. Little Lesia's dialogue is perfectly calibrated for a bright, precocious ten-year-old. 'You should have some too, Grandma!' with that trembling hand offering half her cake—that's not just dialogue, that's character in action. Her exchange with her mother about wrinkles and Grandma Lulu's cane shows she's clever, quick-witted, and already navigating the social dynamics of her village. When she demands to hear the story about the curse, it's not fear that drives her—it's fascination. 'I'm already 10 years old. I'm not scared of such things anymore!' Classic kid energy. But then there's the prologue, and the dialogue shifts dramatically. Cesar's 'Lesia, please...' spoken with a dying voice is devastating in its simplicity. And Lesia's response—'Just as your existence became a curse to me, I hope my existence remains a curse to you'—is delivered with this chilling flatness. There's no drama in her delivery, no theatricality. She says these world-destroying words the way someone might say the weather is nice. That contrast between the emotional weight of what's being said and the emotionless way it's delivered is masterful. Grandma Lulu's storytelling voice creates this wonderful layered narration. She's recounting historical events almost like fairy tales, and there's this bittersweet quality to it because she clearly knows how this story ends for the girl sitting across from her. When she says 'The story of the Velius Grand Duke family's curse is frightening. You might not be able to sleep at night after hearing it,' she's not just warning a child—she's mourning something she sees coming.
... Read More
There's this one detail that I couldn't stop thinking about: the door to Lesia's room. The text specifically notes it's "structured so it couldn't be opened from inside. Since it could only be opened from outside, Lesia felt like she was in a prison cell." A door that only opens one way—that's not just set dressing. That's the entire story in miniature. Lesia's existence has been hijacked. Her choices were never hers. Her body isn't hers anymore (the curse transfer will essentially consume her). Even her grief isn't allowed to go anywhere—it's trapped inside her like air in a sealed room. And then there's the water imagery. Her mother's blood splattered on Ryuel's cheek, brushed off with disgust. The lake from the earlier chapter where Cesar first saw her. Water as both beauty and violence, memory and drowning. The Velius curse itself—something inherited, inescapable, running through their bloodline like a poison passed from generation to generation. The curse is a symbol of aristocratic rot, really. These people are literally dying from within, and their solution is to consume someone else's life to extend their own. How fitting that the victim is a commoner whose life they consider worthless. "Miss Lesia's life is no longer her own." That line repeats like a mantra throughout the chapter, and each time it lands harder. It's not just imprisonment—it's the systematic erasure of personhood.
... Read More
I need to talk about this scene where Lesia hugs her mom and neither of them says much for a while. Like, I was genuinely tearing up. After everything — the nightmare, the empty village, the betrayal of being excluded from the banquet — Lesia just walks in and wraps her arms around Juliana's back. And then she says: "Mom, I love you more than anyone in the world. So I won't do anything that makes you sad." And Juliana's response? She kneels down, pulls Lesia into her arms, and says "I would gladly give my life for you." I mean. Come on. That hit me so hard. What I loved about it is that it wasn't some dramatic, over-the-top confession scene. It was quiet. Lesia is literally ten years old and she's already making this conscious choice to give up something she desperately wanted — the banquet, the world beyond the village — because she sees how scared her mother is. She notices Juliana's pale face and just... drops her own wish like it's nothing. That level of emotional intelligence in a child character is rare and it made me respect Lesia so much. And then the description of Lesia: "A pretty little girl with snow-white hair and blue eyes, looking like a doll crafted with blood and sweat by a master artisan." This line does SO much work. It's beautiful but also deeply unsettling. "Crafted with blood and sweat" — that's not a normal way to describe a child. It implies something artificial, something made rather than born. And I couldn't help but connect it to the earlier hint about her registered in the imperial records but not in the Grand Duke's registry. What IS Lesia? The warmth of the embrace in the middle of winter — whether it's the sunlight or the mother's arms, Lesia isn't sure, but she knows she doesn't want to lose it. That ambiguity felt so honest. Like when you're in a good moment and you're desperate to memorize every detail because you know it won't last. This book has been building this incredibly tender mother-daughter thread since the beginning and it just keeps getting deeper. Juliana's protection of Lesia isn't just overprotectiveness — it's terror. And Lesia understanding that and choosing to comply... that's the kind of emotional maturity that comes from loving someone more than yourself. Absolutely devastating in the best way.
... Read More
I have to talk about the opening atmosphere of this passage because it's genuinely frightening and I don't use that word lightly. Lesia wakes up alone at 2 PM. The house is empty. Her mother is gone. She checks Juliana's flower shop — locked. She checks Chalson's bakery — locked. She checks Aunt Dania's place — locked. And then she notices something that should have been the first red flag: "there wasn't a single person on the streets either." That sentence. That's it. Fourteen words. But it creates this overwhelming sense of isolation that made me actually feel uneasy. It's not that the village is destroyed or burning — it's that it's EMPTY. All the doors are closed, all the people are gone, and the only explanation is that they've all converged on one location without telling anyone. The fact that Flora Village is described as the outermost village, the most isolated, makes it even creepier. There's nowhere to run even if you wanted to. And then the scene at Grandma Lulu's house — the door creaks open ("Creeeak..."), and she peeks in to see ALL the missing villagers gathered there, having a serious conversation. The transition from the terror of absolute solitude to the relief of finding people, only to realize they're talking about something she's not allowed to be part of — that whiplash is masterful. The atmosphere shifts again later when the villagers depart and Lesia is left alone in the pavilion. The text says she "sprawled out" — this image of a ten-year-old girl alone in an empty village, surrounded by closed shops and silent houses, while the forest swallows the departing procession behind her. And then that final ominous line about "dark hands reaching out." The isolation that started as procedural (everyone went to a meeting) becomes genuinely threatening (everyone went and left her vulnerable). The author uses emptiness as a recurring atmospheric device throughout this passage and it works on multiple levels — the physical emptiness of the village mirrors the emotional emptiness Lesia feels at being excluded, and both foreshadow the literal danger that awaits her in solitude.
... Read More
Let's talk about what happens when Lesia finally works up the nerve to ask Ryuel WHY she's the one chosen. The answer he gives is casually monstrous: "It was to prevent the annoying situation of you whining, 'I want to go home, I miss my mom.'" That's it. That's the whole justification. He says it like he's discussing weather. And then when she slurs her reaction—disgusted, trembling—he GRABS HER BY THE COLLAR. His hand on her throat, cutting off her air, and then he just... lets go and smiles again. Offers her soup. The stakes in this chapter are layered like an onion made of knives. On the surface, Lesia vs. the Velius family—they took everything from her. But underneath, the real tension is: HOW does she survive? She's not a fighter. She's not powerful. She's a commoner trapped in a gilded cage, married to a curse she didn't ask for, surrounded by people who see her as livestock being fattened. And the author doesn't let up. Just when you think the worst is behind her, Ryuel reminds you that she's still in danger. Still controlled. Still not free. Even the title of her role—"Companion"—sounds almost tender but is actually a death sentence. The Emperor's subplot at the end adds another layer: the political stakes are escalating too, with the Velius family re-emerging from seclusion and crossing paths with imperial power. But honestly? I was too busy holding my breath during the collar scene to care about geopolitics right then.
... Read More
Ryuel tells Lesia she has three years left to live and the way this hits you—it's not dramatic, it's almost clinical. He's giving her facts. Magic stones, timeline, prognosis. Three more years of slowing the curse, then it rushes in "like floodwaters over a dam." She's eighteen now. She dies at twenty-one. But before you even process that, the chapter takes you back five years. Five years of her body weakening, losing weight, suffering fevers with every season change, unable to beat the curse no matter how hard she tries. Five years of the Grand Duchess strategically reducing her time with Cesar—from monthly to bimonthly to quarterly—until their meetings become rare events she desperately clings to. This isn't just a ticking clock; it's a slow erosion of everything. And the magic stone Necklace? It works. God, it works so well that Lesia walks to the barred window in one go when normally she needs several rests. Her complexion changes completely. For a moment, she feels light. This temporary relief makes the eventual outcome so much more painful because you've seen what hope looks like for her. Then Ryuel drops the second bomb: "even if the magic stone blocks the curse, if you remain by Young Master Cesar's side, the stone will eventually lose its effectiveness." So the person she's being kept away from is also the source of her deterioration. The person she needs is the thing killing her. The stakes just escalated from "you have a deadline" to "your salvation and your destruction are the same thing." "What do you want from me?" And the chapter cuts. I am NOT okay.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or