To The One I Must Hate - Reviews

To The One I Must Hate
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Ryuel's dialogue is genuinely unsettling in the best way. Listen to this exchange: "Do you perhaps know about the Velius Curse?" He asks it like a teacher testing a student. Then when Lesia doesn't answer but her shoulders twitch: "So you do know." He reads her body language and just... confirms it. No hesitation. No warmth. And then the laugh. He LAUGHS at her. "What a low-class human." And he's smiling the whole time while describing how he killed her mother. The voice consistency is terrifying—Ryuel never drops character. He's always this smooth, almost cheerful psychopath who treats violence like a minor inconvenience. Compare that to Cesar, who can barely form coherent sentences when he's apologizing: "I'm sorry. I'm sorry." His dialogue is fragmented, weak, desperate. And then later, semi-conscious, barely speaking: "...sia." Just her name, cut off. The contrast between Ryuel's polished menace and Cesar's broken muttering creates this incredible vocal texture. Teresa is even better. One line: "She's your companion, so handle her well." Click. Door closes. That's it. She orchestrated the genocide that destroyed Lesia's life and her parting words are almost polite, like she's delegating housework. The author's gift is making each character sound completely distinct without needing elaborate narration tags.
... Read More
Let me just start by saying the structural brilliance of this chapter is insane. It opens with Cesar experiencing something entirely foreign—a crisis of emotion he can't name, something dangerous and tidal-wave-like—and his instinct is to RUN. Not because he's cruel, but because he genuinely doesn't understand what's happening to him. He's so isolated from human connection that any attachment feels like a threat to his survival. Then the mask literally falls off. His physical mask, his social mask, his emotional armor—all stripped away by a clumsy tackle from a girl who just wanted to show him how pretty the lake was. The necklace flying off is the perfect symbolic mechanism. The thing that keeps him alive becomes the thing he can't survive without, and the only person who can help him is someone he was trying to flee from. And Teresa's intervention is the plot's masterstroke—she's been watching, waiting, orchestrating. 'If you wish, you can keep that child by your side until she dies.' Is that a gift or a curse? The ambiguity is delicious. And then the whole Flora Village departure scene with Lesia oblivious and happy, contrasted with Cesar watching from a window like he's watching an ant colony he can't bear to leave—that's devastating foreshadowing. The grandmother's warning about the ruby at the very end? I'm not ready for whatever that means.
... Read More
Okay so the pavilion at the start sets this incredibly specific mood—empty, unusually spacious, the kind of quiet that comes from loneliness masquerading as freedom. Lesia lies there watching clouds and the sun rising and rolling side to side because... why not? It's the first time it's ever been truly empty, and she realizes some fantasies are better left as fantasies. That's a whole mood in one paragraph. Then BAM, you're in Will Castle and the sensory overload is REAL. The text does this thing where it contrasts the empty pavilion with the bustling entrance—people queuing from dawn, the inner fortress even more crowded, mixed crowds of nobles and villagers all in different tiers of luxury. You can literally FEEL the scale shift from her tiny village world to this massive, overwhelming place. The traveling band scene is what got me though. 'They're artists who travel around the world and perform music wherever they go.' And Lesia's response—'Just like birds'—this child who has NEVER left her village is trying to process the concept of people who choose to move freely across the world. The comparison to birds isn't accidental. Birds = freedom. Freedom = everything she's been denied. And that alley! 'Unlike its somewhat dreary exterior, the inside was clean and well-organized. Most importantly, there were many familiar faces.' The text moves from the grand spectacle of the castle to this intimate, almost homey space where everyone she knows is already gathered. It's a masterclass in pacing the reveal—big world, then small comfort, then emotional collision when Juliana spots her.
... Read More
"I don't want you to become anything." Four words that contain an entire thesis about freedom, control, and the stories we tell ourselves about love. These chapters are dripping with symbolic contrast and I can't stop thinking about it. Let's start with the most obvious one — light and darkness. The banquet hall is all "white cloths and iron chairs with delicate engravings" and "lace that fluttered gently, decorated with flowering vines," a world of manufactured beauty. Meanwhile Cesar is in a dark room with a magic stone necklace, looking out at the same celebration like it belongs to another species. The silver-blue moonlight on Juliana's face and the harsh banquet lights are two different kinds of illumination — one intimate and private, the other public and performative. Then there's the castle itself, which the author describes as "so large and tall that it cast shadows everywhere." Shadows. That's not accidental. The Velius Grand Duke's power literally casts a shadow over everything, including the villagers who are invited in as guests but seated on the periphery. Flora Village gets the least noticeable seats — the outermost people in the outermost village. And food keeps appearing too: Jordan giving away his last scraps, the lavish banquet tables, Lesia dreaming of eating delicious food while traveling. Food as community, food as survival, food as something shared versus something hoarded. The curse itself is probably the richest symbol here — an inherited burden that Cesar can't escape, passed down through lineage just like the title and the expectations. His mother's magic stone only delays the inevitable. It's a gorgeous metaphor for how privilege and pain travel together through bloodlines. The companion trope subverts the usual rom-com destiny narrative by making it feel less like fate and more like a rescue mission with an expiration date. What happens when the person being rescued doesn't want to be rescued? That's the question hanging over everything now.
... Read More
I keep coming back to that dream sequence and I genuinely think it's the thematic core of everything happening here. Lesia passes out, enters this void—not sleep, not coma, something ELSE—and finds a boy whose hair is 'blacker than the darkness itself,' trembling, possibly crying, surrounded by ominous black smoke. Red eyes. This isn't random imagery. This is the text telling us something fundamental about the world's magic system, about Lesia's connection to it, about what's coming. The fact that she hesitates before speaking to him—'[Who are you?]'—suggests this isn't her first time in this psychic space or that there's something recognizing something. And the timing: right before she's taken to the Grand Duke's domain, right before the banquet where social hierarchies will be laid bare, she encounters THIS figure. It feels like the story is foreshadowing that her true power or destiny is connected to this darkness, not to the glamorous banquet world. Then there's the pavilion itself as symbol. It's always been filled with people who call her over, feed her sweets, treat her like a precious community project. Today it's EMPTY. The text explicitly says 'she was just about to get up and head home when a voice suddenly called out to her.' This emptiness is the threshold—her old life of comfortable, suffocating safety is about to be shattered. The fact that Jordan finds her in this moment of existential realization feels deeply intentional. And Lesia's obsession with beauty and worth—'Am I cute?'—that's not just teenage insecurity. It's her internalizing a world that measures value by appearance and status, and the text keeps circling back to it. The Grand Duke's son is 'the sky,' she's 'beneath it.' But then she has this dream touching something infinitely darker and more powerful. The irony is delicious.
... Read More
Okay so here's what I think is the single most important plot mechanism in this entire passage, and I want to break it down because the author is playing 4D chess here. On the surface, it's simple: Grandma Lulu decides Lesia shouldn't go to the banquet. But look at HOW this decision gets made. It starts with someone asking "But what about Lesia?" — and Lesia, who has been eavesdropping this whole time, HICCUPS. She tries to cover it but barely. Then Juliana immediately jumps in saying Lesia is too young, and the villager who raised the question presses back: the official notice says everyone 7 and older must attend. Ten years old. She IS old enough. The rules say she should go. And then Grandma Lulu drops the real reason, and it's so clever: "Lesia's personal information shouldn't be recorded in the Grand Duke's registry." Juliana confirms: she's registered in the IMPERIAL records but NOT the Velius Grand Duke's. So the danger isn't that Lesia is missing from the count — the danger is that she EXISTS in a different registry, which would raise questions. If they show up and someone checks, her identity doesn't match. It exposes them. This is brilliant plot construction because it transforms Lesia's exclusion from a cruel rejection into an act of protection. The villagers initially feel guilty — one even asks why ALL the other village children get to go and Lesia can't. But Juliana's refusal, backed by the registration logic, shuts it down. And the way the group dynamic shifts when they realize Juliana is her legal guardian... that's social pressure working in real time. But here's what keeps me up at night: the final line. "But Juliana didn't know that dark hands were already reaching out for Lesia." After all this elaborate protection, all this reasoning about registries and age limits, someone ALREADY knows where Lesia is. Someone is watching her while the entire village is gone. The exclusion from the banquet was the safe choice — but the real danger was never the Grand Duke's mansion. It was right there in the empty house, waiting. The plot is layering threats like an onion and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
The symbolism in this opening is rich enough to unpack for pages, but let me focus on what's been burning in my head since I finished. White hair. It connects Lesia to Grandma Lulu, sure, but it also marks her as fundamentally different—an outsider even within her own community. In a village where everyone else has presumably darker hair, her whiteness sets her apart visually, which mirrors how she'll eventually be set apart by destiny and curse. It's the same whiteness that grandmotherly figures carry through age, suggesting mortality and time passing, while Lesia's is innate, suggesting something preordained. Then there's the curse itself as a metaphor that works on multiple levels. On the literal level, it's a magical affliction that forces heirs to destroy what they love. But symbolically, it represents the destructive nature of power—how institutions of authority (the Velius dynasty) perpetuate violence against the vulnerable in the name of self-preservation. Every Grand Duke choosing survival over love isn't just a personal failure; it's a systemic one. The curse externalizes the moral rot at the heart of this noble family. The cake keeps appearing too. That simple castella cake, plain by village standards but heavenly to Lesia, represents everything warm and temporary in her life. The villagers deliberately sharing it with her on their birthdays is an act of communal love—a small, sweet resistance against the harshness of their isolated existence. When Lesia offers half to Grandma Lulu, trembling with the sacrifice, it's one of the purest moments of generosity in the text. And yet this same girl will one day tell the man she loves that her existence is a curse to him. The trajectory from that cake-sharing moment to that tower scene is where the tragedy lives. Black smoke chasing Lesia in her nightmare right after hearing the curse story—that image of the curse as something predatory, something that hunts—and then we cut to her waking life full of sunlight and flowers. The curse isn't just a family affliction; it's an approaching threat that has already begun closing in on her, even as she sleeps.
... Read More
I need to talk about Cesar and Lesia because WOW. The way they fall into each other is so layered and I can't stop thinking about it. Cesar is this tragically fascinating creature. He's dying—Ryuel said half a year, but Cesar knows it's less than that—and his heart is basically a parched desert. No family love, no warmth, just this hollow existence held together by duty and resignation. When he watches the villagers smiling at the banquet, his first thought is, "Did they even know that if he fell in love with one of them and made them his companion, they would live a terminal life in his place?" And that line DESTROYED me. He's protecting them by staying away, by being cynical, by refusing to want anything. But then he sees Lesia. "With her white hair, she really did look like a rabbit." I literally gasped at that description. She's trembling, isolated, surrounded by people but utterly alone—just like him. So he does this impulsive thing, grabs her arm, pulls her out of the crowd. Not because he wants a companion. Not because he's planning anything. Just because someone like her deserved not to be scared. And Lesia—she's ten years old and already carrying so much. That moment when she grabs his nape in the dark and their necklace snaps, and then she falls on top of him and says "you're really beautiful" with total innocent sincerity? I'm not okay. He's expecting pain, expecting darkness, and instead he gets this child who looks at him and sees beauty instead of some cursed monster. What kills me is that Grandma Lulu warned her: "The Grand Duke of Velius destroys everything belonging to the person who becomes their companion." But by the time those words land, Lesia has already crossed the threshold. She's already held his hand. Already touched him. Already seen his true face. The tragedy isn't that they're destined to be destroyed together. The tragedy is that he might actually survive long enough to need someone, and by then it'll be too late for both of them.
... Read More
Okay so the world-building in these chapters is absolutely *chef's kiss* and I need to unpack why it works so well. Let's start with the banquet scene because it's a masterclass in sensory immersion. You've got the Grand Duke descending onto the stage—"silky black hair reaching her waist, snow-white skin, red eyes, and equally red lips"—and suddenly the entire noisy hall falls silent. Not a gradual quiet, not a ripple. Instant, absolute stillness. That tells you everything about power without needing a single exposition paragraph. Power isn't just political in this world; it's almost supernatural. Then fireworks explode, and those "colorful lights seeped into Lesia's white face" while Grandma Lulu whispers the curse's true nature into her ear. The juxtaposition is devastating—celebration and horror happening simultaneously, beauty and dread tangled together like vines. This is a world where joy is never innocent, where every feast has a shadow underneath. And then the lights go out. Everything goes BLACK and suddenly the setting transforms from a grand public banquet to something intimate and terrifying. Cesar leads Lesia through dense underbrush—"leaves brushing against her skin"—into this secret lake that "appeared far more beautiful than he remembered." The water is described as having "silvery-blue moonlight scattered like stardust" and the night sky rippling like silk. It's enchanted. It's otherworldly. It feels like stepping through a portal into another layer of reality. The lake itself is a character. It's hidden, unmanaged, unknown to almost anyone except Cesar, who discovered it as a six-year-old while running away in fear after learning about the curse. Of course the most beautiful place in the entire castle is a secret refuge born from childhood terror. Of course. Every location in these chapters feels alive and intentional—the banquet hall full of false cheer, the dark path through the trees, the hidden lake that becomes the stage for their first real connection. The world doesn't just exist around the characters; it reacts to them, mirrors them, shapes them.
... Read More
This chapter is a masterclass in how to pack devastation without slowing down. Let's trace the pulse: It opens IN MEDIA RES with a dagger piercing Juliana's chest. No warning, no setup—we're already watching a mother die. That's bold. Most authors would give you a breathing room chapter before the emotional nuke, but nope. Thud. She's gone. Then comes the aftermath: Lesia waking up in the mansion, the slap, the confrontation with Teresa, the Ryuel exposition dump. This could have dragged—there's a LOT of backstory to deliver about the curse and the Companion system—but the author keeps it clipped, almost clinical, which paradoxically makes it hit harder. Ryuel isn't giving a dramatic monologue; he's reporting facts. Then the three-year time jump. One paragraph. "After three years had passed..." Just like that. We're not given the slow burn of adaptation—we're dropped into the consequence. And then the cliffhanger: Cesar wakes up, sees her, and immediately the Emperor subplot crashes in like a tsunami. Three distinct narrative movements in one chapter, each escalating the stakes, and not a single moment of filler. The structure mirrors Lesia's experience: violent disruption, forced adaptation, then a wider world opening up to threaten her again. The pacing doesn't let her rest, and it doesn't let us either.
... Read More
Okay, let me just say—the visual direction in this chapter is *chef's kiss*. There's this one image that won't leave my head: Cesar propped against a tree in the middle of winter, vision going blurry, watching Lesia push through cold undergrowth. She's soaked with sweat despite the freezing weather, her face and hands flushed red, probably covered in scratches from branches. And he's lying there thinking maybe tonight is actually a good night to die, and then suddenly her smiling face fills his entire vision. It's cinematic. The author doesn't over-describe the setting but every beat hits visually. Then you have Teresa appearing in moonlight like some kind of gothic specter—long black hair, red eyes—and the power dynamic shifts so sharply. The Grand Duchess saying 'What a pretty child. White hair and blue eyes too. She hardly looks like a commoner's child' while casually handing her son permission to keep this girl by his side until she dies. The contrast between that cold, calculated maternal figure and the warm, chaotic humanity of Lesia scrambling through bushes at midnight—it's gorgeous writing.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say—this prologue has some serious audacity. We drop into absolute chaos at a coming-of-age banquet and watch this white-haired woman throw herself off a tower after telling some guy her existence is a curse to him? And then—BAM—we're suddenly in a sunlit village with a little girl with white hair eating cake like nothing happened. What the hell just happened? Or rather... what is happening? The dual timeline structure here is doing some heavy lifting. We get these haunting flashes of the future tragedy while simultaneously being grounded in this warm, almost idyllic village life. It creates this incredible dramatic irony where every seemingly innocent moment with little Lesia carries this undercurrent of doom. I know what happens to her. I know she ends up on that tower railing. And that knowledge colors everything. The curse exposition dropped through Grandma Lulu's storytelling was genius on the author's part instead of an info dump. Working it into a bedtime story format makes the worldbuilding feel natural while also giving us the emotional groundwork we need to understand why the ending happens. The fact that we're learning about the curse from Lesia's perspective as a child—and she doesn't yet understand the full weight of it—creates this heartbreaking gap between reader knowledge and character ignorance. I'm genuinely invested in figuring out how we get from that fluffy village life to Lesia throwing herself off a tower telling Cesar her existence is a curse. The narrative tension between what we saw in the prologue and what we're reading now is addictive. I need to know what broke her. I need to know what happened between those two.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or