The Villainous Family is Against Independence - Reviews

The Villainous Family is Against Independence
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so let me just... I need to talk about this scene where Elodie gets summoned to the Duke's office. Because honestly? The way the author handles this is brilliant on a structural level. We get this massive internal monologue from Elodie running through every possible reason why she was called in - did she mess up the maids again? Is it about the engagement? And then when she finally walks in, the Duke doesn't even say anything at first. He just looks at her. But here's what got me - when he actually speaks, it's not about what she expected. She thought it was the maid incident. Nope. It's about the Crown Prince contacting HIM directly. That's such a clever misdirection. The reader thinks we know what's coming based on Elodie's past-life memories, but the Duke already knows before she even confesses. And then there's the twist about Carlot and Jansi watching her leave. That final beat where Carlot says "Isn't that a little weird?" and Jansi agrees she's changed? That's not filler. That's the author planting seeds that something bigger is happening with these brothers. I specifically noticed that the narrative keeps cutting back to their perspective, which means this isn't just Elodie's story anymore. The plot is widening, and I am here for it.
... Read More
There's this one scene during the monthly family dinner that I just cannot stop thinking about, and I need to unpack it because it represents everything this story is really about beneath the surface. Five people at a long table. More than ten servants waiting at the edges. Complete silence except for the clashing of dishes. And the narration calls it "a breathtaking mealtime, done all in complete silence" and then immediately follows with "it was also a familiarly stifling place." This isn't just a dinner scene. This is a portrait of an institution. The Duke of Perdia is described as "heartless to his wife, a partner in a purely political marriage, and his two sons, who were his own blood." A political marriage producing heartlessness. Blood relations meaning nothing. And Elodie, the illegitimate child who isn't even truly his, sits there performing the role of dutiful family member while internally noting that there is "no such thing as family love" and she should just eat the food because "food is innocent." That line hit me like a truck. Food is innocent. The only pure thing in this entire household is the meal itself. Everything else — marriages, bloodlines, loyalty, love — has been corrupted by politics. And then there's the poison motif running throughout these chapters. Elodie collapses from poison. She creates an antidote in secret. The Duchess protects her by lying about where the antidote came from. Arold swaps poison three years later. Beltran is associated with drunken debauchery and possibly toxins. The entire political system is literally poisonous, and Elodie's quest for independence is her attempt to build an immunity to it. But the most powerful symbolic moment is probably when Elodie deliberately chooses to stand by the West Pillar at the banquet. A pillar. Something that holds up a structure but remains invisible. That is exactly what she's positioning herself to be — essential support for someone else's empire while remaining unseen. Except pillars also have foundations, and foundations can crack. The symbolism of her chosen hiding spot almost mirrors her actual position in this world. "If I flatter my father in advance, maybe he will let it go even if it turns out that I'm not of his bloodline?" She's already preparing for the worst, already building emotional armor before the truth even comes out. The story isn't just about escaping a poisonous family — it's about learning to survive in a world where nothing is what it seems and the only innocence left is on your plate.
... Read More
Let me just say this — Elodie's internal narration is one of the best things about this book. She has this incredible ability to shift from deadpan observation to full-on dramatic monologue mid-thought, and it makes reading her POV feel like watching someone tell an incredibly dramatic story while completely maintaining eye contact. Take this moment right after she cuts up the First Prince's note: "That's nonsense, Martha." Just... coolly disposing of her entire political future because apparently the logic doesn't add up. And then immediately pivots to her real plan: "Preparations for independence are progressing step by step. Until then, let's save money like hell!" From romantic betrayal energy to aggressive frugality in two sentences. That is such a distinctly Elodie move. And then there's the family dinner where she narrates: "Anyway, I'm number one for being gloomy." What does that even mean?! It's perfect. She's just commenting on her own ranking among family members and apparently 'gloomiest' is the crown she's claiming. The dialogue with Arold is also surprisingly layered. On the surface it's this sweet, whispery conversation where she's telling him her 'secret' crush, but the narration underneath is pure venom: "It was obvious that he was asking out of courtesy — he doesn't care who I like." She's performing vulnerability while calculating every micro-expression. And Arold, for his part, plays along perfectly with his gentle smile that the narration describes as having "no word for betrayal in his dictionary." The contrast between what he says and what we know he'll do is delicious dramatic irony. Even the Duchess's brief lines carry so much weight. When she says "Don't talk nonsense" to Jansi, it's a warning disguised as maternal dismissal. And when she looks at Elodie and the corners of her lips rise slightly — that silent exchange says more than any monologue could. These characters speak in code and I love it.
... Read More
"I'm getting angry." "I'm sorry, Miss!" "Can't you hear me saying I'm getting angry?" "I told you I am boiling inside!" This conversation is a masterclass in failed communication. Elodie is literally screaming her emotions and the maids are hearing whatever they want to hear. They think she's threatening them. She's trying to tell them she's upset. The dialogue here does triple duty: showing her lack of control, showing their fear, and showing how isolated she is in her own family. But then look at how her voice changes after the memories hit. Gone is the hot, scattered energy. In its place: precise, measured, almost clinical. "One needs money to be independent." "A small house with a living room and a bathroom in the suburbs of the capital, Somnia." This isn't the girl who was screaming five minutes ago. This is someone who's done performing. Her internal monologue is where the real voice shines though. The sarcasm, the self-awareness, the dry observations. "Among so many novels, why must it be this novel?" "It was a very difficult engagement to procure." "Ha." That single laugh when she reads her own annulment request—it's the voice of someone who's just pulled off the greatest joke in history. The prince's dialogue is more formal, more restrained. Polite. Professional. But there's an edge underneath, especially when he's dealing with the Angellus family problems. "I've said everything I can, to the point where even I, the prince, am rude." That's not arrogance—that's exhaustion. He's tired of performing courtesy too. What I love is how the dialogue marks the transition between lives. Old Elodie's speech is reactive, emotional, desperate for acknowledgment. New Elodie's speech is proactive, strategic, indifferent to acknowledgment. Even her apology letter to the prince isn't apologetic at all. It's businesslike. Neat handwriting, clear terms, enclosed documents. She's not begging for mercy—she's negotiating terms. The author lets the dialogue carry the character development without ever stating it outright. By chapter three, we know exactly who Elodie has become, and we never needed a single exposition dump to get there.
... Read More
This section opens with exposition—actual mythological backstory about gods, sins, and founding families—and I was genuinely worried for a second. Not my favorite place to start a chapter. But the author is clearly using it as a foundation, and within the first few paragraphs we pivot from worldbuilding to Elodie's personal crisis (no powers showing up), then to the Severes blood revelation, and suddenly she's pivoting to a business plan. The pacing here is almost frantic in the best way. Everything moves with momentum. The transition from the greenhouse scene to the actual negotiation with the duchess is where I lost all sense of time. One moment Elodie is admiring rare plants, the next she's pouring poison onto a bug, holding her breath, watching it revive, and then—boom—she's negotiating for a percentage of sales. There's no filler in here. Every scene serves at least two purposes: advancing the plot while revealing character. The duchess's skepticism, Elodie's nervousness masking determination, the quiet threat beneath every polite exchange—it all compresses into what feels like a single continuous breath. I did want to linger on one moment though: the bug test. The author takes three seconds here—'1 second, 2 seconds, 3 seconds'—and stretches it into genuine tension. That's good pacing instinct. Knowing when to slow down inside a fast-moving chapter is what separates competent writing from great writing, and this hit exactly right.
... Read More
I have to say, the training ground scene was one of those moments where the author really let the setting do the heavy lifting. You've got the clash of metal, sand kicking up everywhere, knights training—then Elodie walks in and the whole place stops. Every single person turns to look at her. That image of one girl stepping into a battlefield of warriors and commanding all their attention without even trying? Cinematic as hell. And then there's Toinette Street, named after Empress Antoinette, the emperor's beloved. Just that one line tells you so much about this world's history in passing. A luxury commercial street for aristocrats and wealthy merchants—it immediately paints the picture of a society where class and money dictate every aspect of life. The fact that Elodie used to sweep through this place like it was nothing, buying dresses and jewels day after day, versus now counting every gold coin carefully? That contrast between the oldElodie and the new one is reinforced by the setting itself. The carriage ride through the capital city Somnia is another great vignette. The boulevard rushing past, the silence between Elodie and Carlot that isn't awkward because they've never been friendly—that's such a specific, lived-in detail. It makes the world feel real, like these two people actually share a history that predates the story. Even the annex bedroom, where Elodie spills her coins on the carpet and counts them by hand, feels intimate and grounded. Martha watching her with narrowed eyes, already suspecting something has changed. These small domestic scenes balance out the political maneuvering perfectly.
... Read More
The opening scene is so vivid I could feel the humidity. It's midsummer, glorious weather, but the servants are shivering as if it's winter. That contrast alone tells you everything about the atmosphere in this mansion. The heat outside mirrors the heat inside Elodie—boiling, restless, dangerous. And then the pendant hits the ground with that single word: "Crunch." I keep coming back to that sound. It's such a simple onomatopoeia but it carries the weight of her entire worldview collapsing. The author doesn't over-describe the moment—just the sound, the fall, the memories. Sometimes less is more. What stays with me is how the scene shifts from physical comedy (maids scrambling, Elodie flailing) to metaphysical horror (memories of another life flooding in) so seamlessly. One sentence she's angry about gossip, the next she's reliving her death. The description of the prince is interesting too. Silver hair, dark green eyes—classic romance lead aesthetics, but the author quickly undercuts it. Yes, he's handsome. Yes, everyone wants him. But he's also distant, formal, and already planning to replace her with a prettier doll. The worldbuilding here is doing double duty: establishing the romantic fantasy setting while quietly undermining it. And the capital city Somnia! Mentioned once but it paints a picture—imperial city, tallest tower, surrounded by four great founding families. The Perdia name carries weight for all the wrong reasons: underworld connections, black markets, gambling houses. They're the villain family by reputation, which makes Elodie's position even more precarious. She's not just unwanted—she's a liability in a house built on crime. But the realest detail? She has no money. Not a penny. Everything she owns is on loan from the household accounts. Even her dresses, her jewelry—it's all reported through the butler. In a world dripping with wealth, she's starving. That's the atmosphere I remember most: luxury surrounding someone with nothing, summer heat pressing down on someone who just wants to leave.
... Read More
Let me just say this—I wanted to put the book down after the Duke scene but I couldn't. The transition from the suffocating tension in the Duke's bedroom to the comedic relief of finding Carlot at the training ground is masterful. You go from high-stakes negotiation where Elodie's basically being monitored like a prisoner to "hey Carl wanna go shopping with me" and the shift in tone is seamless. The author understands something a lot of web novel writers don't: variety in pacing within a single chapter matters. The Duke conversation is long and pressurized, deliberately making you feel Elodie's claustrophobia. Then BOOM, she's storming the training ground, finding Carlot, and turning the tables on him. That confrontation with Carlot where she basically holds his threat over his head and he folds? Perfect beat. And then the carriage ride slows everything back down for character development. What really sells the pacing though is the internal monologue placements. Right when she's about to get caught in a social faux pas about spending less money, she zones out and calculates the worth in Korean won—that brief comedic break lets you breathe before the next wave of tension hits. The chapter ends on an almost peaceful note with them arriving at Toinette Street, which sets up the next conflict perfectly. The author doesn't rush the Carlot interaction either; she lets the moment where he drops his sword and loses color breathe before moving forward. Every scene earns its length.
... Read More
I need to talk about Beltran because this boy is a masterpiece of tragicomic self-deception and I am dying. Everything he thinks he understands about Elodie is wrong, and the novel lets us watch him construct an entire fantasy in real-time while we sit there screaming internally. Look at this little gem: "Her expression, which she thought was a rotten smile, seemed to Beltran like a shy smile that concealed her affection." SHE IS SCREAMING INSIDE YOUR FACE AND YOU THINK SHE'S SHY. He also loves that she answers "obediently, perhaps because she was shy." NO, BELTRAN. SHE IS BEING POLITELY MARITABLE WHILE CONTEMPTUOUSLY DISMISSING YOU. But no — he cannot perceive reality because his ego won't allow it. The novel is so clever here; we get her internal monologue right alongside his external interpretation, and the gap between them is comedic gold that also happens to be deeply pathetic. Meanwhile, the Adenmir situation — oh god, the Adenmir situation. He won't break up because "you, who want to break up with me, are quite useful." THAT IS THE MOST REVEALING LINE IN THE ENTIRE SCENE. He's not refusing out of love. He's refusing because she serves a purpose. But then his face after she steps on his foot — "he looked like he had a lot to say" — and he says NOTHING. Just escorts her politely. What is happening in that man's head?? And the father-daughter moment — "how many times do I have to answer?" — when she asks if he's actually worried about HER. That dry exasperation, that reluctant admission... something shifted between them even if neither of them will admit it out loud. I'm not ready for this relationship to resolve but I also can't stop watching it evolve.
... Read More
I just— I need a minute. Adenmir's entire internal monologue during the banquet scene is the most unhinged I've read this year and I am here for it. So the man who literally told Elodie to go ahead and break the engagement because she found someone else? The guy who was ready to blame her for everything so he could keep his political advantages? The second he sees her smiling at Beltran, the guy she allegedly has feelings for, his brain short-circuits into something absolutely unhinged. "I must never break off this marriage. For Elodie. And for himself and the Duke of Perdia, too. He will save Elodie from harm." BRO. You literally were fine with breaking up with her five seconds ago. You were the one pushing for it. But the second another man is vaguely in the picture, you're suddenly playing knight in shining armor? This isn't love, this is territorial panic. And honestly, the most disturbing part is how self-aware he is about Beltran's reputation — the man is known as 'human waste,' appears drunk on streets, no lady is safe from him — and yet Elodie is apparently smiling and LAUGHING with him? The cognitive dissonance on his face must have been spectacular. Meanwhile, Elodie is over there completely aware of what she's doing. She chose the West Pillar deliberately. She knew exactly which spot Beltran would see her from. She even gave herself a little internal cheer — "It was worth it." This woman has been planning her escape for three years and she just used the two most dangerous men in the kingdom as chess pieces in a single afternoon. The family dinner scene also shows us how profoundly broken this household is. Jansi calling out that Elodie ate everything like it's a strange phenomenon, the Duke silently drinking wine instead of addressing his daughter's behavior, Carlot being the only one who notices anything is wrong — this family doesn't communicate, they perform. And Elodie has somehow figured out that performing back is the only language any of them understand.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Carlot because this guy is genuinely one of the most interesting dynamics in the story right now. Elodie chose him over Jansi, and you know what, she's absolutely right. Carlot is so transparent it's almost painful. The carriage scene? Chef's kiss. He tries to start a fight by mispronouncing Martha's name and she just... smiles and plays along. The look on his face when he realizes his trap didn't work is described as if he'd been shot, and I literally laughed out loud. This girl has completely changed, and watching her handle someone like Carlot with ease instead of escalating like the old Elodie would have? That's the real emotional payoff here. And then there's the little moment where she explains why he's a good escort—his "ground collapse" power, his sword skills—and he gets all flustered like he thinks it's a compliment. The narrator literally wants to roll her eyes at his questionable intelligence. But underneath that snark, you can feel this weird protective instinct she's developing toward him. She chose him. She sees his value. That's huge for someone who barely tolerated him before. The Duke also counts as emotional undertones, honestly. The scene where he casually dumps 100,000 lalit on her and calls it "money education" while completely suffocating her with surveillance is both hilarious and deeply unsettling. She's trapped in this gilded cage and she knows it. The fact that she just takes it and plots her escape route shows how much her relationship with her own family has shifted from entitlement to cold calculation.
... Read More
"You're giving me a present right now… doing things like that—" Carlot's voice. That fragmented, interrupted sentence. He wanted to say something meaningful and Elodie literally shrugged him off. This man cannot form a complete thought around her, can he? It's either grumbling complaints or angry outbursts. There is no third option. But Elodie—oh, Elodie is a different creature entirely. Her dialogue is this carefully calibrated instrument. On the surface, she sounds almost playful: "Get used to it, Carl." "Your swords are all the same, so why don't you just use a cheap manufacturer?" These are barbs wrapped in casualness, the kind of thing that sounds like teasing but actually maps out the entire power dynamic between them. The dialogue that broke me though was the flashback exchange. Eight-year-old Carlot: "You illegitimate child." Eight-year-old Elodie: "I'm not dirty. I wash myself clean." That's it. That's the entire conversation. No grand emotional revelation, no dramatic confrontation—just a child trying to maintain basic dignity in the face of cruelty she doesn't understand. The simplicity is what makes it land. And the internal monologue! "'That's why I don't need an escort.' It was too difficult to move." This is the narrative voice at its best. Elodie thinks in practical calculations and emotional deflections, never in raw sentiment. Even her romantic feelings (if they exist) are filtered through logistics. "If I disappear, he'll be in trouble" — said with the qualifier "a little, very slightly sorry." Of course she frames it that way. Of course. Carlot's voice, meanwhile, is all exterior. He never gets interior access in the present timeline, which means we only ever hear him complaining, ordering, reacting. The author denies us his inner world deliberately—and that denial IS the point. Elodie sees through him. She's already written her verdict.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or