The Villainess Wishes for Redemption - Reviews

The Villainess Wishes for Redemption
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There are two scenes in this section that absolutely painted pictures in my head and I can't stop thinking about them. The first one: Hesion sitting alone in his room, the fierce wind and snow hammering against the window. Ray comes in and tries to close the curtains because the firewood's running low and it's freezing, and Hesion says no—I want to look outside. The snow looks like Vieta, he thinks. Swirling, merciless, beautiful in a way that hurts. This is such a gorgeous visual metaphor. The storm outside mirrors the storm inside his head—he's watching snow that reminds him of a woman who screamed herself hoarse in a dungeon, and he can't look away. Then Ray comes in with a stack of books reaching to his chest and mentions that Hesion practiced reading books to Esta. The mundane detail of it—the domestic normalcy—contrasts so sharply with the violent memories flooding back. One moment he's staring at snow, the next he's in the imperial garden smelling flower fragrance that makes him nauseous because Esta just told him she's pregnant with the Emperor's child. The second scene that wrecked me visually: Vieta standing naked in the kitchen corner, waiting to be dressed. The cold wind cutting through door cracks, red scratches from the scrubbing pad on her delicate skin—marks that looked like ten cats had climbed over her body. And all the bruises that SHOULD have been on her were instead on her mother Susan's body. This detail about displaced violence just... stopped me cold. The mother took the punishments meant for the daughter. That's the kind of world-building detail that makes you understand the entire toxic ecosystem without a single exposition dump. Then Winter drags Vieta out in Amy's yellow dress—the same dress Amy loved because Leytan complimented it on her. Vieta wearing it is a middle finger to every power dynamic in that house. She shows her callused, bruised feet deliberately, and Winter slaps her hand away like it's obscene. The dress becomes a weapon, a flag, a battlefield. The Lukbiche household feels so alive and suffocating. Every object carries history, every piece of clothing is a symbol of who has power and who doesn't.
... Read More
The mother-daughter scene. The ONE scene with almost no conflict, no stakes, no manipulation—and it wrecked me completely. Vieta buries her face in Susan's embrace. Susan is sleeping, warm, alive. In Vieta's past life, she had NOTHING. No one truly loved her—not Leytan, not Esta, not anyone. All those sweet whispers, all those tender gazes, all that warm touch from Leytan? Lies. Every single one. He used her because she was an unloved illegitimate child who would be a reliable ally in bringing down the Lukbiche family. "Apart from my mother, not a single person had truly loved me." That line. That absolutely devastating line. Vieta spent her entire first life thinking she had allies, that she had purpose, that someone cared. And the only genuine love she ever received was from a woman who could barely protect herself. So now she's telling Susan about a dessert shop on Hering 3rd Street. About a mont blanc that comes out once a day at 3 o'clock. About a dressmaker named Madame Reina who will be famous in ten years. About a port city called Lehil with a sea that looks like Vieta's eyes. She's listing all the beautiful things she experienced in her past life like she's planning to buy them as souvenirs for her mother's birthday. And Susan—this broken, haggard woman who looks like an invalid, whose face is drained of blood—she just strokes Vieta's head and nods because her daughter's eyes are shining. Susan sighs at Vieta's worn clothes and expresses apology. And Vieta smiles. She SMILES and says "Let's live there. It's my favorite place." She's not asking. She's promising. And the tragedy is that Susan probably can't fully believe her, but she believes in her daughter enough to pretend. This is the emotional core of the entire book. Not revenge. Not political manipulation. A daughter who survived hell and came back just to make sure her mother never has to suffer again.
... Read More
The emotional core of these chapters lives in the spaces between what characters say and what they feel, and no moment captures this better than Hesion laughing in the torture chamber until his wound splits open. This isn't the laughter of someone who has found peace. It's defiance weaponized. Leytan tries to cover his nose, to maintain some distance from the filth, but Hesion's laughter is invasive—it reaches him, unsettles him, makes his expression harden. In that moment, Hesion holds all the power because he refuses to be broken. And then there's the kiss. Hesion mentioning it with such casual devastation—'Along with a kiss so regrettable that I forgot the advice'—carries the weight of everything unsaid between him and Vieta. Is it genuine affection? Is it revenge? The ambiguity is painful because we know Hesion is using it as a weapon against Leytan, but the fact that he remembers it so clearly suggests it meant something to him too. Leytan's violent reaction confirms that Vieta occupies something central and dangerous in his emotional landscape, even if he can't articulate what it is. The Grand Duke's relationship with Hesion is rendered in quiet strokes that hit harder than any dramatic confession. 'These days he tries to appear dignified, but to my eyes, he still looks like a baby.' This is a father seeing his son clearly, even across impossible circumstances. And yet, he sends Hesion into danger. He chooses friendship with Leytan over open warfare. His love is real but complicated by political calculation, which makes it feel painfully human. Vieta's scene in the attic is emotionally devastating in its simplicity. She's alone, watching the ceiling, surviving. The Duke's internal conflict about her—how she looked 'somewhat presentable' in a gown, the shame he feels masked as incompetence—reveals a father who is failing his daughter in ways that have nothing to do with malice and everything to do with weakness. The final image of Winter anxiously watching her father, fearing her own misconduct might cause trouble, extends this emotional chain of harm across generations. Everyone in this story is hurting someone they care about, and that's what makes it so ache-inducing to read.
... Read More
Okay, so let me just say this straight up: the whole rebirth setup here is doing something really interesting with cause and effect. In my previous life, Hesion lost everything—his family, his freedom, his chance at happiness—all because he trusted the wrong people and failed to see the real manipulator. Leytan played him like a fiddle, used his father's love against him, and then watched him get tortured while laughing from the throne. But now? Now Hesion is back, and the plot has shifted on a dime. The first thing he does is hug his mom and cry like a bastard—because apparently she's alive this time. And Ray too! Both of these people who died in the previous timeline are standing right in front of him. That hits different. What I love most is how the author handles the Esta situation. Remember that garden scene where she dumps the pregnancy bomb on him? In the original timeline, this probably broke him further. But now? He literally tells Ray to send her home mid-snowstorm and says "I don't want to see her again." No drama, no last-minute softening. Just cold, clean closure. The author doesn't even let Esta cry her way back in—that's a first for Hesion's story. And then there's Vieta. The woman who mocked him from prison, who thought his suffering was some tragic romance—she's still out there being awful, but Hesion's new assessment is fascinating. He's not just hating her; he's actually thinking about rehabilitating her instead of Esta. That pivot alone tells me the plot is going to spiral in directions I'm not ready for. So here's what's eating at me: Leytan eliminated Hesion as a political threat first, and as a love rival second. This changes EVERYTHING about how you read his earlier betrayal. It wasn't some jealous ex move—it was calculated statecraft. Does that mean Vieta was just another pawn too? She called his ending "a love so pitiful it makes one's eyes ache" and had no idea she was wrong. That dramatic irony is chef's kiss. I keep waiting for the other shoe to drop. With Madam Rekton alive, with the Lukbiche siblings young again, with Vieta still in that house somewhere—what's the actual endgame here? Is Hesion going to rebuild his power base from scratch, or does he already have plans he didn't have last time?
... Read More
I need to talk about the relationship between Vieta and Winter because it is absolutely fascinating and deeply disturbing in the best way. Winter is one of those villains who is almost sympathetic in her own twisted logic. She's not just evil for the sake of being evil—she's protecting her position, her real children, her secrets. When she says 'How can you think that someone like you, who inherited such lowly and dirty blood, could be a lady of the Lukbiche family?' you can hear the genuine fear underneath the cruelty. She's terrified of losing everything. And Vieta? She's become someone Winter genuinely doesn't understand anymore. Winter's internal monologue reveals this perfectly: 'How did that cowed child become so cunning?' 'Did she have a dark side, hiding her claws all this time?' There's a moment of genuine shock in Winter's voice when she realizes the girl she's been abusing has been playing along the entire time. The relationship between Vieta and her mother Susan is heartbreaking too. Susan was silenced—her tongue literally cut out—and Vieta spends the entire passage trying to protect her. Even when Rana mocks Susan, Vieta doesn't engage because she knows 'there were many powerful enemies in the mansion, and increasing their number would be foolish.' That's not weakness, that's survival intelligence far beyond her years. Then there's Amy, who is apparently 'the daughter of a knight whose origin is unknown.' Vieta using this knowledge as leverage against Winter is such a clever move—she's not just defending herself, she's offering Winter a deal. The dynamic shifts from abuser-victim to something closer to two people in a mutual hostage situation. Winter's final conclusion—that she should 'endure until Count Dillent and Vieta get married' and then 'make Vieta infertile'—is chilling. It shows she hasn't learned anything. She's recalculated but not changed. And that sets up whatever conflict comes next perfectly.
... Read More
"The precious things he had lost in the past were unbelievably before his eyes again. It was an excessive gift from God. No religious heaven could be sweeter than this." I am not okay. I am genuinely not okay right now. Let me just sit with this for a second. Hesion just got tortured, framed for treason he didn't commit, watched his father take the fall and die, watched his loyal servant Ray get cut down by imperial knights, watched EVERYONE he cared about get destroyed by people he trusted—and then he wakes up and his mother is ALIVE. Standing in the doorway with warm citron tea and fruit like nothing happened. And his reaction isn't some stoic noble composure. He cries. He buries his face in her shoulder and just weeps until his eyes are swollen. Like a kid. Because for all his political maneuvering and cold fury, at the end of the day this is a young man who missed his mother more than anything in the world. The text says he hugged her even though her hands and feet had been marked by torture in his previous life—but there's no trace of it now. Swollen eyelids, purple bruises, burst lips—all gone. She's beautiful again, whole again. And he KNOWS this. He knows what was done to her. He knows she refused to name him as the rebellion's mastermind even with her fingernails pulled out. This reunion hit me in the chest. Not the romantic stuff—though the Esta subplot is absolutely delicious in its cruelty—this FAMILY thing. The way he scrutinizes every servant after lunch like a paranoid general? Fine. But before that, before the scheming and calculating, he just wanted to be held by the parents who loved him. And what about Vieta? "A villain unworthy of rehabilitation from the start. That was his assessment of Vieta, his prison mate." But then he thinks about rehabilitating HER instead of Esta. There's something so complicated there—resentment and curiosity tangled together, the ghost of someone who laughed at his suffering becoming someone he might actually try to save. I need a moment.
... Read More
Okay can we just talk about Ray for a second because this kid is genuinely the MVP of every scene he's in. So Hesion walks in looking like his brain is actively malfunctioning—grabbing his head, groaning, all that—and Ray immediately clocks it. But here's the thing that made me laugh out loud: Ray immediately assumes it's about Esta. Of COURSE he assumes it's about romance. Meanwhile Hesion is over here carrying the weight of knowing how the entire future unfolds and Ray thinks he needs advice on asking a girl to tea. And then Hesion tells him this fairy tale about a panther and a lion and Ray? Ray takes it completely seriously. He actually sits down and gives genuine strategic advice about befriending the panther before the lion even meets it. The man has zero idea he's listening to a deeply personal confession about Vieta, and yet somehow his crude, off-the-cuff wisdom is actually sound. 'Keep your enemies closer'—Ray, you beautiful idiot, you just solved Hesion's entire problem without knowing what the problem was. What hit me hardest though was Hesion looking at Ray and realizing this guy has no idea he's from the future. That moment where he opens his mouth to confide but can't—because how do you tell someone you're literally the person they knew in another timeline? That restrained, frustrated silence says more than any monologue could.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this part had me literally gasping. You know how usually the reincarnated protagonist has already planned everything and knows exactly what's coming? Not here. Because Leytan shows up unexpectedly in an imperial carriage and suddenly Hesion is back in that panic spiral. I love how the narrative cross-cuts between Hesion sprinting down the stairs and Vieta already on the pond—it's like we're getting two countdown clocks ticking simultaneously and the reader is just screaming internally. The most devastating beat though? Hesion resurfaces with Vieta and instead of the tender rescue moment you'd expect, he immediately latches onto the excuse he's been waiting for: "My mother was only deceived into sympathizing with your situation as an illegitimate child." Like, bro, you just almost DIED saving someone and your first thought is to weaponize her birth status? That's such a Hesion thing to do and it absolutely wrecked me for Vieta. And then she just... admits it. She says yes, it was pity, and drops the ruined flower. That moment hit harder than any action scene in this whole book. And then—AND THEN—Leytan appears right after Hesion leaves and offers his hand like nothing happened. The timing is almost comically cruel.
... Read More
I've been thinking about the symbolism in this chapter and it's actually staggering how layered everything is. Let's start with the flower. A yellow flower from Lady Rekton. What does it represent? It's the first unconditional gift Vieta has ever received—no strings attached, no political maneuver, just 'I wish you happiness.' And Amy destroys it. Of course she does. Amy represents everything Vieta has never had: legitimacy, privilege, a family that protects her. She can't stand that Vieta received something she couldn't give. Throwing the flower out the window isn't just jealousy—it's an attempt to invalidate the idea that Vieta deserves kindness. But Vieta retrieves it. She gets on her knees on a sofa, risks falling, ignores her injured ankle. That flower becomes a symbol of self-worth. Of choosing to believe you deserve goodness even when everyone around you says otherwise. Then there's the head injury. Both Vieta and Hesion hit their heads in this chapter. Vieta from the collision, Hesion from literally falling backward after she shoves past him. This feels significant—like their relationship is being literally reshaped through physical impact. They're both wounded, both leaving the encounter injured, both changed. And Hesion's blood on his hand—that image of him looking at his palm and seeing red? It's almost like a mark of connection now. He's physically marked by his encounter with Vieta. The mirror in Amy's room! Hesion notices it immediately and it stops him. 'A mirror as tall as an adult.' Mirrors are always about identity and self-perception. Vieta's room is more luxurious than Amy's, has a full-length mirror, elaborate decorations—and yet Vieta is treated like a maid's child. The mirror reflects the contradiction: Vieta looks the part of nobility but is denied the status. She sees herself through others' eyes and it breaks something. And the frozen pond—the flower lands on ice, spinning, before coming to rest. Frozen. Beautiful. Alone. That's Vieta right there. Trapped in cold surfaces, caught between movement and stillness, waiting for someone to notice she's still turning. The deeper the symbolism gets, the more I realize this author is building a whole language of images.
... Read More
OK so let me just say—Winter is absolutely diabolical and I am here for it. "Vieta is sure to tattle to Count Dillent. She might completely forget her own wrongdoings and only spread rumors about us!" This woman is running a full-blown smear campaign in her head and her children are literally nodding along like yes mom you're totally right. Vilter and Amy embracing their mother after being disciplined?! That's not love, that's fear dressed up as obedience. The Lukbiche kids have been trained to see Vieta as an existential threat to their status, which is honestly brutal because Vieta isn't even doing anything—they're just terrified that their mother's schemes will backfire and take them down with her. But then you flip it and look at the Duke, who brings Vieta to see her mother in THAT attic. He notices everything—the wound on her cheek, Susan's trembling shoulders—and yet he still says "Don't think about interfering and please stay quietly here." Like bro, you dragged a child into this situation and now you want her to just perform gracefully? And Susan's response is just silence and tears. The powerlessness in that scene is suffocating. And then Lady Rekton comes in and just completely dismantles everyone's expectations by being genuinely kind to Vieta. Not performative, not calculating—just warm. And that line about the winter aconites meaning "eternal happiness" despite its scary name? Chills. Actual chills. I need a minute.
... Read More
That winter aconite. That stupid, beautiful, meaningless flower. I keep thinking about it and I think it might be the most important symbol in the entire novel. Vieta runs across a frozen pond—risking her life, risking falling through ice that could kill her—for a flower that was already destroyed. Her own narration is almost merciless: "Have I become a dog wagging its tail tearfully at a mere small kindness?" She knows she looks pathetic. She knows the flower is ruined. And yet she picks it up anyway, gathering the scattered petals like they still matter. The winter aconite is everything. It's the kindness Lady Rekton offered—something beautiful that bloomed in Vieta's frozen world, but also something that could be crushed by careless hands. Vilter threw it away. The ice almost killed her for it. And when Hesion tells her it was just pity, she drops it. Not metaphorically—she literally lets the dead flower fall to the ground. But here's what broke me: even as she's drowning, her hand still tightly clutches the stem. Stripped of petals, ruined, worthless—and still she won't let go. That's Vieta. That's every person who's ever accepted love they weren't sure was genuine because at least it was warmth in the cold. And then Leytan appears with his perfect white hand and his kind smile, and she reaches for it anyway. Because her mother deserves better. Because she's learned that being weak is survivable if you have someone stronger holding your hand. The tragedy isn't that she's being manipulated—it's that she sees it and does it anyway. She's not naive anymore. She's just desperate.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or