The Villainess Wishes for Redemption - Reviews

The Villainess Wishes for Redemption
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Can we talk about how layered everyone is in this section? Like, nobody is who they first appear to be. The Duke — he offers Vieta dresses but his first instinct is insulting her clothes. He says "Are you becoming like Susan?" with zero warmth. But then he also gets genuinely angry when Vilter attacks her on the stairs. He picks her up and carries her himself. He's contradictory, manipulative, and somewhere in there might actually care about his bloodline's reputation in a way that includes her. Or maybe he just wants the perfect weapon against Winter. I can't tell and I'M CRAZY ABOUT IT. Winter though — oh god. She's vicious. "More precisely, she's just an illegitimate child born of vulgar blood." She calls Vieta a blemish. But then she proposes marrying her OFF to Count Dillent. Is this protection? Is she trying to save Vieta from being displayed at the dinner party like livestock by giving her a different kind of fate? Or is she genuinely cold and calculating, willing to sacrifice her rival's daughter to protect her own children? And Vilter and Amy — their hatred isn't just simple villainy. Amy blocks Vieta's path because she's TERRIFIED of losing the Duke's attention. "After slandering my mother, now you're trying to take the lady's position too!" Vieta correctly diagnoses it: "So, since it's difficult to block the Duke's side, they've come to break me." These kids are pathetic and cruel and desperate for love in a house where love is currency. The most beautiful relationship here is still Vieta and Susan. The vocabulary book. The 'I love you' card. That embrace. "Though only for a brief moment, the mother and daughter thoroughly enjoyed their private happiness." That sentence wrecked me.
... Read More
The pacing here is weirdly controlled in the best way. Let me break down why this works so well. It opens at full velocity—Hesion's memories of the rebellion, the torture, his father's sacrifice, Leytan's manipulation—all compressed into a tight flashback sequence that hits like a truck. You don't get breathing room. It's relentless, and that's intentional because Hesion is forced to confront these memories with no escape. Then the door bursts open and suddenly it's citron tea and warm domesticity. The shift is so jarring it almost feels like a trick. Is this real? Did he actually go back? The author doesn't explain—the scene just HAPPENS and you're along for the ride. This is exactly how Hesion must feel: disoriented, overwhelmed, grasping at warmth because he can't process how he got here. After the reunion, there's a lull—the lunch scene, the servant-scrutiny, the return to his room. But even in this quieter space, tension is building. The snow outside, Ray's care, the books, the mention of Esta's arrival. Each detail is a small ticking clock. We know Esta is coming. We know Hesion is dreading it. The chapter lets us sit in that dread. Then BAM—the garden flashback. Esta's pregnancy reveal, Leytan's arrival, the confrontation, Hesion's cold dismantling of her lies. This section moves fast, almost too fast, like memories themselves—flash and gone, leaving you breathless. And then back to present day, where Hesion sends her away without a second glance. The Vieta section that follows slows everything down. We're in the kitchen, in the Lukbiche mansion, watching a young girl endure abuse. The pace becomes almost cruel in its slowness—we watch every humiliation unfold in real time. This contrast between the fast political scenes and the slow domestic abuse scenes is masterful. The chapter ends mid-scene with the Duke arriving. No cliffhanger per se, but the structural choice to end on the Duke's entrance rather than any resolution creates this incredible momentum. You need to know what happens next. The chapter doesn't give it to you, and that's the point. Overall: the pacing moves between breathless action and suffocating stillness, which mirrors Hesion's emotional state perfectly. He's either running from his past or drowning in it, with very little middle ground.
... Read More
These chapters do something I don't see enough of in fiction—they use flashbacks that feel structurally necessary rather than decorative. The manuscript-writing frame in the present, where Hesion is burning letters and numbering his revenge list, creates a calm surface that the torture chamber flashback violently ruptures. This isn't exposition dumping. Hesion is actively processing his past as he writes, and the return to the dungeon feels like a memory that won't let him go. The transition back to the present—him folding the paper, chewing it, swallowing it—is such a clean structural beat. He consumes his own plans literally. That image stays with you. The Duke's conversation with the Grand Duke is paced differently but equally deliberately. It moves in layers of social politeness that slowly peel back to reveal genuine political maneuvering. The Emperor's illness, Leytan's legitimacy, marriage alliances—each topic enters casually and burrows deeper. The Grand Duke's nonchalance about Hesion's changing friendships, his dismissive answer about Vieta, the subtle negotiation around sending invitations—all of this unfolds through dialogue that looks like small talk on the surface. The tension builds not through action but through what remains unsaid between two men who understand each other too well. The Vieta reveal at the end functions as a structural pivot. After two scenes of political maneuvering, we're dropped into her attic, alone, watching the ceiling. The pacing slows dramatically, almost to a standstill, and that stillness contrasts sharply with everything that came before. The chapter ends not on a dramatic action beat but on anxiety—Winter watching her father's mood, fearing scandal. It's a quieter cliffhanger, but it keeps you turning pages because you want to know what happens when Vieta's hidden existence collides with the political world below. The only note I'd make is that the transition between Hesion burning letters and Duke Lukbiche's arrival feels slightly abrupt, but it's a minor interruption in an otherwise well-controlled narrative rhythm.
... Read More
This batch reads like someone poured cold water on your face and then pushed you down a staircase. It starts SO GENTLY. Susan and Vieta making the vocabulary book together. The soft moments. "I love you." Warm firelight. This is the calm BEFORE. I let my guard down because the writing is tender and intimate. And then — BAM — Duke summons her. The pacing from there is relentless. The Duke scene alone contains so many beats: the insult about her clothes, the dress offer, the contract negotiation, her pretending to read upside down, the thumbprint. It's one long exchange but the author keeps shifting the power dynamic every few paragraphs. First he's condescending, then intrigued, then impressed despite himself. Then immediately after she leaves, the rumor spreads in TEN MINUTES. The siblings ambush her. The bread attack. The fainting. Winter and the Duke appear. The argument. The Count Dillent announcement. ALL in what feels like one continuous sequence of escalating disaster. The author understands something crucial here: tension doesn't come from big events, it comes from the gap between what Vieta wants and what's happening to her. She wants to escape the attic. She gets her contract. Then she gets attacked before she can enjoy it. She's building a life with her mother. Then Winter announces a marriage she can't refuse. Every time she takes a breath, the story yanks the rug. That's why I couldn't stop reading.
... Read More
The author's use of setting in this section is genuinely cinematic and I want to talk about three specific scenes. First: the barefoot walk through heavy snow. Vieta is walking across frozen ground with no shoes, and the cold is cutting her feet, but she's SMILING. The greenhouse in the distance is emitting a soft glow, described as "nothing less than an entrance to heaven." This isn't just atmosphere—that glow is the only warm thing in her entire world right now, and it represents truth, evidence, and vengeance all at once. The snow obscuring their vision? Perfect metaphor. Nobody in this mansion can see clearly anymore. Second: the greenhouse itself. Warm humidity hitting Vieta's face like an embrace. She's spent her whole life in cold attics and colder treatment, and the warmth of this place—where the evidence of her mother's vindication literally sits in a small box—feels like the first real comfort she's ever known. The shovels clanging as she knocks over the cabinet. The box hidden in a rectangular hole in the floor. These aren't just props; they're the考古 of a crime scene that's been waiting decades to be opened. Third: the Rekton family garden scene. Hesion's garden, filled with exotic flowers his mother loves. The butterfly on the flower-patterned tablecloth. And then Vieta deliberately chasing it away, making that philosophical point about butterflies being both pollinators and pests. Beautiful and destructive. Exactly what she is in this world. And then Esta appears with purple columbines—flowers whose spurs resemble an eagle's talons. Vieta strikes her own head with the flowers, scattering purple petals, leaving a red scratch on Esta's cheek. The image of purple petals fluttering through the air is haunting. It's almost poetic violence, and the author doesn't flinch from it.
... Read More
The sensory details in this section are SO specific and I need to talk about them. The attic — Vieta gathering firewood, blocking window gaps with worn cloth, making the fireplace warm for Susan. The kitchen imagery of ash and warmth against the cold. Then: "climbing up and down the steep stairs was quite exhausting." Those stairs are a CHARACTER in this story. They represent everything keeping her trapped. The Duke's study scene is a masterclass in visual storytelling. No grand descriptions needed — just the Duke looking up from his documents, noticing her bare feet and thin nightgown, and the whole power dynamic of the room crystallizes. We know this is a place of authority because that's where he sits and she enters. But the bread scene — that's the one that's living in my head rent-free. Vilter smashing rye bread into her face. "The hard rye bread left powder in Vieta's hair as it fell miserably to the floor." I can literally SEE this. The crunch, the dust, the shattered bread on stone stairs. And then the thud of her body hitting the steps. Amy's scream. The Duke's heavy footsteps descending. It's cinematic. Purely cinematic. And Winter's hallway confrontation with the Duke — she's trembling with humiliation, he's holding Vieta in his arms, the siblings watching from above like an audience in a Greek tragedy. The whole mansion feels like a stage where everyone is performing roles they didn't choose. The vocabulary book itself is such a vivid image — holes punched in paper, bound with worn cloth, silly drawings next to words. It's the most honest thing in this entire corrupt household.
... Read More
Okay I need to process what I just read and I am SHAKING. Let's start with Vieta's final moments before execution. The scene where she's dragged to the guillotine and Leytan—the EMPEROR—shows up? I thought maybe, JUST MAYBE, there was still a chance for her. And then she decides to embrace it. She confesses to trying to kill Esta, gives this tragic speech about fearing becoming like her mother and fearing the unborn child becoming like her, and Leytan just—slaps her? Across the face? After everything? I literally gasped. This man, who supposedly loved her, who promised her a future, who stood beside her at her execution—all he could do was slap her and call it justice. And then he orders her executed. The betrayal is so clean it's almost elegant. But then the real gut punch: Vieta's last thought before her head rolls is that her revenge is complete because she dies without leaving a single Lukbiche seed in this world. SHE SMILES. As she dies. This woman who was tortured, imprisoned, betrayed, and executed—and her final act of defiance is refusing to leave behind any legacy for the people who destroyed her. That's not just tragedy, that's something far more complicated. And then—BAM—she wakes up in her mother's arms in the attic as a child. The time travel twist is one thing, but the emotional whiplash of going from death to that cold attic floor where her mother is still alive and sleeping beside her? I am not ready for what this means. If Vieta has a second chance, every emotional beat from before is going to hit differently. She KNOWS what's coming. She knows her mother dies in the snow. She knows Winter. She knows Vilter. She knows everything. And now she's thirteen years old again with a grown woman's trauma and memories. The emotional potential here is absolutely insane.
... Read More
Can we talk about how Vieta speaks versus how everyone ELSE speaks? Because the contrast is intentional and brilliant. Vieta's dialogue is almost disarmingly simple. When she drops the bomb about the knight, it's: "I saw the blonde knight." Not a dramatic declaration. Not a confrontation. Just a statement of fact, delivered with what sounds like childish confusion. Then she layers on the performance: "W-what are you talking about, Vieta?" Winter's panic versus Vieta's fake trembling voice. "I'm afraid he might take Mother away. Maybe that's why he came back!" She sounds like a frightened child and it's the most dangerous thing in the room. The Duke's dialogue is notably cold and utilitarian. "Show me." Two words. No emotion, just command. Later: "You'll need to explain this properly." Still cold, still measured. He doesn't yell. He doesn't rage. He just removes people from his life quietly, which is somehow more terrifying. Vilter's dialogue is all reactive noise. "Shut up!" He has nothing substantive to say because he has nothing to hide behind but anger. His actions speak louder—his pupils shaking, his arms slashing like a drowning person—but his words are empty. Hesion and Vieta's exchange is the best dialogue in this entire passage. It's almost a duel. "How much do you love Miss Esta?" "I love her enough to give her my heart." "...I see. Then, have you thought about expediting that marriage?" She asks the most inappropriate question possible and treats it like casual conversation. When he gets uncomfortable, she presses harder: "Do you have any intention of becoming Emperor?" And when he explodes, she just says "...I see." Like she already knew the answer and was confirming it. Her voice is calm, analytical, occasionally polite to a fault. His voice is reactive, emotional, easily provoked. Every exchange between them is Vieta controlling the temperature of the room while Hesion sweats through his formal posture.
... Read More
There are so many layers to unpack in these first seven chapters and I'm only just beginning to see the surface. The central symbol—the "cursed seed"—is doing incredible work. Vieta is called a cursed seed not just because of her violent deeds but because she represents something bigger: the idea that some people are born into circumstances that make them inherently destructive. But the novel keeps asking, explicitly and implicitly, WHO planted this seed? Was Vieta born evil, or was she made? Her mother Susan—mute, gentle, ultimately frozen to death in the snow for a crime she didn't commit—is the antithesis of Vieta's cursedness. And yet they share the same blood. The novel seems to be asking: which one is the real curse? The daughter who kills, or the system that forced her to? The snow is another massive motif. It appears at Vieta's death—"a day when heavy snow fell so thick that carriages couldn't move"—and it appears again when her mother is thrown out into it to freeze. Snow as erasure. Snow as silence. Snow as the great equalizer that buries both the guilty and the innocent under the same white blanket. The fact that Vieta rewinds to a moment of heavy snow is not coincidental. Winter (the stepmother's name is literally WINTER) and the snow are thematically linked—both are cold, both consume, both hide what's underneath. And then there's the ring. That diamond ring becomes this tiny object around which an entire chain of destruction spirals—Susan's tongue cut out, her death in the snow, Vieta's lifelong trauma. A single piece of jewelry, stolen by Vilter, blamed on Vieta, used as justification for murder. The novel is basically saying: look how small an excuse it takes to destroy a life in this world. I also can't ignore the father-son scene with Hesion and his dad. The fig scent. The warmth. It's almost TOO tender after everything else, and I think that's intentional—the novel is showing us what these characters lost, what they're fighting to protect or reclaim.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is genuinely masterful and I need to unpack why it works so well. It starts almost claustrophobically slow—Hesion watching through a curtain, Vieta walking alone on ice, the almost domestic routine of her hiding her mistakes. Then BAM, the carriage appears and the entire rhythm shatters. He kicks the door open and runs. The prose itself seems to speed up, shorter sentences, urgent internal monologue, and then we cut to VIETA'S perspective and suddenly we're running alongside her too. What I love is how the author uses the rescue scene as both the emotional climax AND the turning point. Everyone expects the saved person to feel grateful, right? That's the trope. But instead, Hesion uses the rescue as cover to deliver the most cutting thing he's ever said to her. The tension doesn't deflate after he pulls her out—it INCREASES. That's bold structural choices, having the interpersonal conflict peak at the exact moment of physical survival. And the cliffhanger? Vieta limping away from Hesion, leg swollen, and then Leytan's calfskin boots appearing at the edge of her vision? The author just handed her a choice and cut to black. I swear I read that last paragraph four times. She's standing between two boys—one who just saved her life and destroyed her with words, and one whose hand she can't trust but reaches toward anyway. What is she choosing? Because something tells me this changes everything.
... Read More
There's a symbol in this text that kept haunting me, and I think it's the yellow dress. Amy's yellow dress—the one Leytan complimented, the one she Treasures, the one she'd scream if even a speck landed on it—ends up on Vieta's battered body. Winter forces it on her as punishment, as a way to humiliate her in front of the Duke and her siblings. But Vieta? She pulls the skirt up and shows her callused feet deliberately. She turns the dress from a tool of oppression into a banner of defiance. The dress represents everything the Lukbiche household values: appearance, status, the performance of refinement. And Vieta, the illegitimate daughter, the abused one, the one they treat like garbage, wears it anyway. She makes it hers. The fact that it doesn't suit her gaunt frame only makes the image more powerful—she's a ghost wearing someone else's skin, haunting the house that tried to destroy her. But then there are the scars. Or rather, the absence of them. Vieta's body is unblemished compared to her mother Susan's, which means the violence has been redirected, passed down through generations of women in that house. The punishment meant for Vieta lands on Susan. This is inherited violence—the kind that doesn't stay with one person but spreads through a family like a disease. And the snow. Hesion watches it swirling outside his window and thinks of Vieta's voice, harsh from screaming. Snow is beautiful and merciless. It covers everything, buries things under white perfection, but underneath it's all frozen and dead. The Lukbiche estate is the same—beautiful exterior,rotten core. What's interesting is how Hesion's relationship to violence changes across timelines. In his first life, he was a victim of it—tortured, framed, imprisoned. In this life, he's already identifying threats, planning to eliminate spies, calculating who can be rehabilitated versus who can't. The victim is becoming the strategist. But the question that keeps bothering me is whether he's becoming what he hates, or whether he's finally learning to fight back in a world that rewards exactly that kind of ruthlessness. The text mentions that Vieta killed her half-siblings in her previous life. They pleaded for their lives. She realized they were just weak humans. That realization—seeing abusers as merely fragile—is itself a kind of liberation. But liberation for whom? And at what cost?
... Read More
The tension in this section is absolutely suffocating, and I think that's because every single character has real stakes at play. For Vieta, the stakes are survival. Simple as that. If she makes the wrong move, she and her mother die. She knows this—'Leaving the ducal residence with nothing meant possibly starving to death on the streets.' But she's also playing a longer game. She remembers the banquet, remembers that this is where everything with Leytan began. She's positioning herself for an escape route that doesn't involve running away empty-handed. Winter's stakes are equally high, which is what makes her a compelling antagonist. She's not just protecting her position—she's protecting her daughter Amy. The revelation that Amy might be the daughter of a knight threatens everything: her marriage, her status, her social standing. When Vieta mentions Amy's resemblance to a knight, Winter's reaction is visceral panic. 'Stop! Shut that mouth!' This isn't just anger—it's terror. The Count Dillent marriage threat adds another layer. Vieta was supposed to be sold to an old man, and while that particular threat has been delayed, it hasn't disappeared. Winter's solution—endure until the marriage, then make Vieta infertile—is so cold it makes me shudder. It shows that no matter what Vieta does, the conflict isn't over. And then there's Hesion, who 'had been able to grow up as a lady of the ducal family thanks to the generosity of Winter' but now 'the more he thought about it, the less favorably Hesion could view Vieta.' His shifting loyalty adds yet another variable to an already volatile equation. What I love about how the author handles stakes is that they keep expanding. Just when you think you understand the conflict, a new layer emerges—the knight's blood, the Count's interest, Leytan's return. Every resolution creates a new problem. The suspense never lets up, and I find myself turning pages desperately because I need to know what happens next.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or