Villainess Who Has Been Killed 108 Times - Reviews

Villainess Who Has Been Killed 108 Times
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There's a line in here that I just cannot stop thinking about: 'people turn into such demons because of love.' Said almost casually by a ghost, but it lands like a hammer. This entire opening sequence is layered with motifs of blood — literal and symbolic — that keep resurfacing. The mother's blood illness. Bradd's knowledge of 'how the blood flows through her.' The assassin school that attacks 'blood vessels in the body.' Blood as life, blood as weapon, blood as betrayal. And then there's the Duchess herself — a woman who wagered everything on having a son, who couldn't handle the disappointment of a daughter, and was drugged into a murderous frenzy. Is she a villain? Or is she a victim of a system that told her worth was tied to producing an heir? The text refuses to give us a clean answer. And Bradd — the assassin who saved her — represents another kind of blood loyalty. He's from a clan expelled from the crown's favor, from a lineage deemed 'cowardly' for their surgical precision. His people were cast out for being too good at killing. Yet here he is, choosing to protect a baby instead of finishing the job. The irony is suffocating: the monster saves the child, while the mother tries to destroy her. The 108 deaths weigh on every page. This protagonist isn't just reborn — she's TRAUMA-BONDED to her own history. When she says 'I held no grudge against her' about her mother, it's not forgiveness, it's exhaustion. She's seen too many endings to have the energy for hatred. The deepest theme here might be the question of whether anyone in this world gets to choose their own blood — the family they're born into, or the ones they survive to find.
... Read More
"I love your smile." Three words. That's all it takes to build something so beautiful and then rip it apart. The way this chapter makes you fall in love with Ethelreed and Marie — it's almost cruel in how gentle it is. They're just... talking. In a garden. She calls him "Master" but it's not really about status at that point, is it? It's about devotion. And when she says "You have a wonderful smile, Ethelreed. You're a good person, there's no doubt in my mind!" — I actually paused reading and sat with that for a second. Because then she dies smiling. That's the image that won't leave my head. A girl with no money, no education, no family — she's given everything by choice, and even in her last moments she's worried about how she looks to him. "I have to smile. I can't write words, so my last message will be a smile." She literally uses her final breath to give him what he loves most. "My favorite Ethelreed. I really did love your smile." I'm not okay. This is the kind of romance that doesn't want you to be okay. It makes the happiness real so the loss actually hurts. And Ethelreed holding her cold body saying "I am nothing now... I am... dead!" — that's not dramatic writing, that's grief on the page. Pure grief. The Shylocks didn't just kill a girl, they killed the one person who saw Ethelreed as a person instead of a commodity.
... Read More
Let me map out what's actually at stake here because this story keeps escalating in ways that make my heart race. Marie is dead. That's the baseline conflict—gone, finished, no coming back. But the real stakes are what happens NEXT. Ethelreed has declared open war on the Shylock company. He's not just grieving; he's committing to a path where he will 'never die' until he gets revenge. That's not a promise—that's a curse he's placing on himself. The external conflict (Shylock family vs. Ethelreed) is now personal, visceral, and irreversible. Meanwhile, the Crimson Duke is sailing into enemy territory. His wife is giving birth. He's allied with Seraphy whose entire family was destroyed by the Shylocks. The stakes here are literally life and death—childbirth in a world with rudimentary medical care, a ship that's the last remaining property of a destroyed company, and a conspiracy that the Duke is only beginning to understand. And the baby POV? She references having lived 108 previous lives and says 'I would not lose this time.' That's a ticking clock embedded in the narrative itself. We know she's carrying knowledge from past iterations, which means every decision she makes now has the weight of 108 failures behind it. The stakes are infinite because she's already failed this scenario 108 times. What's terrifying is how all these conflicts are converging. The Shylocks destroyed the Orange Company. The Shylocks killed Marie. The Shylocks are poisoning the Duke's family. Three separate storylines, one common enemy, and they're all about to collide. The tension isn't just maintained—it's compounding.
... Read More
I need to talk about how this section is structured because it is WILD what the author does here. We go from one of the most emotionally devastating scenes in the entire novel—Ethelreed's breakdown, the murder of two siblings, a dead girl, a broken father—to a one-year-old baby's internal monologue complaining about making weird faces and calling someone a pervert. There is no transition. No bridge. No soft landing. Just: cut. On first read I was like what the heck but on subsequent reads I've come to respect this immensely. The author is doing something very deliberate here. The first part is heavy, dense, operatic tragedy. The second part is light, snarky, almost comedic. And the third part—suddenly we're on a ship, reading about sea voyages and trade wars and secret political alliances. Three completely different genres in three consecutive sections. If the author had stuck with the tragedy, it would have become unbearable. If they'd stayed with the comedy, it would have felt disrespectful to what we just witnessed. The pacing choice forces the reader to breathe, to reset, to engage with the story on different emotional frequencies. The chapter titles themselves do weird stuff too. Part 3 is called "I love your smile" which is deeply ironic given everything that just happened. And Chapter 16's title is this massive mouthful: "A story from over the seas. My father discovers the conspiracy and...huh? Wait, I make an appearance!?" The author is basically winking at the reader, acknowledging the absurdity of the narrative structure while also dropping a major plot hint. It's chaotic. It's messy. It's exactly right.
... Read More
"I'm fine where I am now as concubine. I desire a higher social standing, so I must unseat his wife and dispose of her. I will soon be at his side, and there is no man in this kingdom that can stop me." I need to sit with this line for a moment. This woman is SO honestly vulgar in her ambition that it's almost impressive. She doesn't hide behind polite noble language — she says exactly what she's doing, as if announcing her weather. And then Dexter's response: "Money is the weight of all things." Just... that's it. That's his entire philosophy compressed into four words. The dialogue throughout this chapter has such distinct voices for each character. Ethelreed's lines are fragmented, emotional, full of exclamation marks and unfinished thoughts — he's the one still capable of feeling, so his speech reflects that chaos. The ghosts' dialogue is in italics and tilde marks, presented as overlapping whispers, which is such a clever narrative choice. It makes them feel like a collective murmur rather than individual spirits. But the most chilling dialogue belongs to the noble ladies during the humiliation scene: "Look at her. I wonder what odd spectacle she'll show us." "She smells like the mountains." "Maybe her people's customs are to avoid bathing." This is casual cruelty dressed up as witty conversation, and that's what makes it so disgusting. They're not shouting slurs — they're making polite observations while systematically destroying a human being. The author understands that real villainy doesn't always announce itself with dramatic threats. Sometimes it arrives wearing silk and asking if you'd like some bread.
... Read More
Let me just quote this because it needs to be preserved: "Ah, it's the seamstress that comes to our house many a time...she's died so peacefully. My..." She abandons the scene to pick up a copper coin. "Well, seems that she found some copper coins, that's why she's happy. I really envy the poor because they can find happiness with so little." I have never wanted to throw a book at a character so badly. Ambrosine is not just evil—she's the kind of evil that makes you question whether the author has ever encountered a human being with basic empathy. And the dialogue is SO specific to her. She doesn't speak in grand villain monologues. She speaks like someone who genuinely cannot comprehend why other people aren't like her. The casual cruelty, the bored tone, the way she tosses out philosophical-sounding platitudes about the poor while actively torturing a grieving father—that's not just good writing, that's character work at the highest level. And Dexter? His voice is different. More performative. More focused on the spectacle of his cruelty. "I can take it back...will you have money to pay for the funeral?" He's showing off. He wants an audience. These two siblings are each evil in completely distinct ways, and the dialogue makes that crystal clear without the author ever having to tell us. Then Ethelreed enters and the entire linguistic texture shifts. His dialogue becomes sparse, guttural, almost inhuman. "Don't mock Marie by staying here." Two words from him that carry more weight than pages of Ambrosine's sneering.
... Read More
Let's talk about voices, because this book has some of the most DISTINCTIVE narrative voices I've encountered in a long time. First, the protagonist's inner monologue. Oh my god. The sheer volume of personality packed into a baby's thoughts. 'What kind of dense idiot is this kid?' 'You IDIOT! Can't you tell I'm resisting!?!?' 'As if boys look this good!?' The voice is sassy, self-aware, deeply cynical but with this weird tenderness bubbling underneath. She's been killed 108 times, she knows exactly what kind of person she is ('a villain queen'), and yet here she is, getting emotional about her MOTHER holding her for the first time. The contrast between her hardened exterior thoughts and her soft interior moments? That's not just writing — that's character. Then there's Bradd, whose dialogue is almost comically casual given what he IS. 'Don't worry...you're like a little brother or sister to me now.' Said by a professional assassin who just broke into a Duke's mansion on his birthday. His tone is so effortlessly warm, so naturally protective, that it hits differently because he clearly doesn't even realize the weight of his own kindness. 'Heh, you're just a girl!' after dodging a tackle? This man is unhinged in the best way. And the narrator's direct address to the reader — 'My name is Scarlet Ruby Noel Lingard...a villain queen killed 108 times' — has this incredible conversational, almostconfessional tone. Like she's pulling you aside at a bar and telling you her story. The author's voice shapes the entire reading experience into something intimate and subversive.
... Read More
I need to talk about the dialogue in this chapter because it's genuinely remarkable how natural it feels, especially for a translated work. "I don't know what happened, but Ethelreed is still Ethelreed. No matter what who his family is." Marie's voice is so distinct — uneducated, direct, emotionally intelligent in a way that cuts through all the noble nonsense. She doesn't have fancy words but she has truth. And Ethelreed? His voice cracks beautifully. "I've forgotten how to laugh. How can I laugh when I have this cursed Shylock blood!" That's not melodrama — that's a person actually falling apart. The back-and-forth between them when they're confessing? Perfect. He pushes, she retreats, he insists, she surrenders with humor. "Of course, I love you. Ethelreed...you." The ellipsis, the whisper, the way she can barely say it. And his response — turning it into a game about smiles — that's how people actually recover from trauma. Through small, human moments. Then contrast that with Desmond and the siblings: "We should take this money and crush that girl with it." / "Hey, don't try to steal more than your share!" Pure transactional language. No emotion except greed. It's jarring on purpose, and it makes Marie and Ethelreed's scene hit even harder because we know exactly what's coming. The author's narrative voice — that meta moment where they address the reader directly, "Those of you that scrolled this far, good job in noticing" — it's playful but it also signals the tonal shift. "This story has gotten so dark, the author wanted to provide a little extra." That wink before the knife twist. Bold move. I respect it.
... Read More
I NEED to talk about the pacing here because the author is playing 4D chess with structure and I am here for it. Let's trace the arc: You open with the most intense possible moment — a mother trying to kill her newborn, an assassin breaking in, a baby who remembers 108 lives. Peak tension. Then Bradd picks you up, thinks you're a boy, offers to adopt you into his assassin village, and suddenly it's comedic relief. The protagonist screaming internally 'YOUR VILLAGE IS THIEVES DON'T TAKE ME' while physically just being a baby? Chef's kiss. Then Mary wakes up, tackles Bradd, falls onto the duchess, chaos ensues. It's chaotic, fast, almost slapstick. And THEN — right when you think it's going to stay light — the duchess calms down, holds the baby, weeps, and apologizes. The tone just DROPS. Goes from comedy to something achingly quiet in a single beat. And then Bradd drops the poison revelation like a bomb and the chapter ENDS with 'H…' — a broken sentence from a baby who can't speak. The cliffhanger isn't action, it's FRUSTRATION. The protagonist knows everything, feels everything, and can't say a word. I literally gasped. The ghost interlude in Chapter 6 is a structural masterstroke too. It pauses the main narrative, gives us exposition through humor, and then snaps back to the emotional core. Without that breathing room, the duchess's apology scene would have landed differently. The author knows exactly when to accelerate and when to let you sit with the silence.
... Read More
Okay so can we just talk about the mom scene for a second?? I was not prepared. One minute you're walking by the pond and hearing mysterious archery sounds, totally oblivious, and then BOOM—your mother is just over there, hair tied messily, wearing fur and boots, absolutely shredding the target range. And that description? "Her high cheeks looked healthy and dignified...it looked as though this was her true home." I literally stopped breathing. This woman has been sick in bed, we've been worried sick, and apparently she's been secretly training with a bow the entire time?? The contrast between her delicate sickly appearance and this wild, capable archer energy is everything. And Scarlet's internal reaction was the perfect comedic relief after all that emotional buildup—"Oh! You have no idea what I'm saying! I KNOW! I can't talk, can't walk, so how the heck am I going to use all these knowledge cheats from my past 108 lives?! It's like I have a mountain of gold that I can't spend!" I was wheezing. But underneath the comedy there's this genuine ache—you realize how much she's been hiding, how much strength she has, and Scarlet is just delighted she gets to see this side of her mom. The mother-daughter bond is so understated but it's there in every glance and every moment of understanding between them. Also the way Bradd completely missed that Scarlet was excited and instead deadpanned "I can tell by the blood flow"?? Iconic friend energy right there.
... Read More
Let me just say this once and for all: the narrative voice in this book is absolutely elite. Scarlet's internal commentary is so distinct and consistently hilarious that I laughed out loud multiple times reading this batch. Some highlights that live in my head rent-free: "None of those sounds are from a woodpecker pecking into a tree. And so I reached out to her face to try to dissuade her of it ¯_(ツ)_/¯" "Thanks, I guess. This was a bit weird for a baby with the memory of adulthood. Embarrassing, in fact. I blushed." — HOW DO YOU BLUSH AS A BABY THIS IS SO FUNNY "I've been covered in breast milk from head to toe, but yet to be baptized. Looks like this lifetime is starting out to be a total disappointment. Guess I'm bearing my original sin." — Dark. So dark. I love it. "BRADD, YOU IDIOT! Stepping all over my attempts to dodge embarrassment!" — The exclamation marks alone carry so much emotion And Bradd's deadpan delivery of "I can tell by the blood flow" to explain why he knows Scarlet is faking sleep is the perfect comic counterpoint to all her dramatic internal monologues. Their dynamic is chef's kiss. The ghost dialogue was also surprisingly good—"You think a woman is just to be protected? No, she is here to protect her own in thisss mansion" had such a distinct, slightly unhinged energy that fit perfectly. Every character has a voice that pops off the page. The author isn't playing around.
... Read More
This section does something really clever with its structure that I need to unpack. Chapter 10's subtitle is essentially the thesis statement for how this whole novel operates: "Even though I remember everything in my 108 lives, what happened outside of my sight was unknown — the love, malice, and sadness." And then the chapter immediately proves this by showing us an entire sequence of events that Scarlet had absolutely no knowledge of—the death of her wet nurse Mary, the murder orchestrated by Alisa, the unborn sibling we never knew existed. This is such a brilliant narrative device because it fundamentally changes how we read everything we've seen so far. Every time Scarlet interacted with Mary, every moment of warmth and comfort we thought was just background sweetness? Now it's layered with the knowledge that Mary was already grieving, already carrying a child she couldn't name, already walking toward a violent end that no one in the mansion could have predicted. The plot twist here isn't just emotional—it's structural. The author is telling us that Scarlet's 108 previous lives also had blind spots. There were people suffering, loving, dying right outside her periphery, and she never knew. This fundamentally reframes her entire mission to change fate. She can't just focus on her own loops—she has to learn to see what's happening around her, to notice the people she's been overlooking. Then in Chapter 11, we get the ghost scene which introduces a whole new layer of mystery. The assassins are still coming, a storm is brewing, and someone in the mansion is identified as a key ally—but we're deliberately kept in the dark about who. It's the author winking at us, saying the game is just getting started. The pacing here is masterful. We start with domestic comfort, get hit with grief, then cold murder, and end on ominous foreshadowing. That's a lot of emotional whiplash in two chapters and it works perfectly.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or