The Speedrun Manual of Miss Witch - Reviews

The Speedrun Manual of Miss Witch
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let's talk about what's actually at stake here, because it's MORE than just survival. Yes, Ciel is being hunted by the Blackwater Gang. Yes, someone named Braid Solari organized a ritual that got her killed. But the deeper conflict is about CONTROL. In the first simulation, Eddie was provoking her, pushing for a confrontation. In the second simulation, SHE kills Eddie. And that changes everything — the gang adjusts their plan, the ritual's parameters shift, and suddenly Ciel realizes that HER ACTIONS MATTER in ways that alter the outcome. She's not just a pawn; she's a variable that the antagonists can't predict. The ritual itself is the biggest unknown. What is it? Why does it require a sacrifice? Who is the church member involved? The author isn't answering these questions, which is both frustrating and genius — it's the kind of mystery that makes you keep reading just to feel that click of understanding. And the stakes just went up. Ciel now has a 【Death Reversal】 skill that lets her cling to life for a few critical seconds when she should be dead. In simulations, that's information-gathering. In reality? "Performing life-saving measures within that timeframe was nearly impossible." The skill is almost useless outside the sim. She's getting power, yes, but the power is narrowly scoped and costs resources she can't afford to waste. "If her next simulation didn't lead to a major breakthrough or earn her more points, she wouldn't be able to simulate again." That sentence alone raises the tension to a breaking point. She's gambling everything on one more try.
... Read More
"I won't... let your ritual... succeed." — that line absolutely wrecked me. Like, sure, it's a simulation, but the way Ciel writes it down in her notebook like it's already happened... and then she actually EXPERiences it again when she wakes up... you don't forget what it feels like to have a bullet enter your skull. Even the phantom pain on the left side of her face kept coming back. But here's what hit me even harder — the narrative itself refuses to soften this moment. Braid fires into her corpse. "Bang! Bang! Bang—!" He's putting rounds into a dead girl because he's terrified. And the text doesn't flinch from describing her as lifeless while he's doing it. That calmness in her eyes that unsettles him — "no fear, no panic—only a serenity that didn't belong to someone on the brink of death" — that image is going to stick with me for days. There's also this weird, almost intimate tenderness in how she grips his gun barrel with her bloodied hand and presses her forehead against the muzzle. It's violent and almost... loving? No, not loving. But it's the kind of desperate, close-quarters confrontation where you can feel someone's breath on your face as they die. The intimacy of violence. God. And yet, despite all this horror, Ciel's actual emotional response upon waking is almost clinical. She assesses the situation, checks her inventory, thinks about strategy. That contrast between the visceral horror of death and her cool-headed recalibration — that's her character in a nutshell. She's afraid, sure, but she's trained herself not to let fear drive the bus.
... Read More
The stakes in this section are fascinating because they operate on two levels simultaneously, and they constantly undermine each other. On one level, Ciel is fighting for her life against a quasi-transcendent being who can weaponize her own mind against her. That's classic survival stakes. But on the meta-level, she's in a simulation where death just means waking up in a bed with some Fate Points. So which conflict is real? The text keeps blurring the line. When she uses Death Reversal, the narrative treats it as horrific—her brain matter spraying, her consciousness fading—but then immediately cuts to the system evaluating her performance like a speedrunner. 'By defeating two adult men stronger than you and a quasi-transcendent… you unleashed a power even you couldn't imagine!' That clinical celebration of violence makes you question everything. Is any of this meaningful if she can just respawn? Yet the emotional weight stays. The exhaustion she feels afterward is real. The dread she felt during the mental attack was real. The stakes aren't about permanent death; they're about the cost of each attempt. Every time she dies, she loses something—not her life, but her sanity, her peace, her certainty about what's real. The suspense is maintained brilliantly through information control. We learn about the Church of the Savior Goddess gradually, through Duven's diary, then Thomas's, then the black market references. Each notebook opens a new layer of mystery while answering old ones. And that ending! One second it's quiet, she's wondering about the tendril, and the next—'A blood-curdling scream suddenly rang out from the tavern entrance.' The stakes just jumped from personal survival to sudden, chaotic danger. The author knows exactly how to keep you gripped by making the threat feel immediate while reminding you that consequences might be illusionary.
... Read More
The emotional spine of these chapters is the bond between Ciel and Lichie, and it hits so hard I had to put the book down after reading it once. Lichie is introduced mid-confrontation with thugs, fist clenched, veins popping on her scarred forehead. But then Ciel pulls her inside and says, “You're one minute late. The food is getting cold.” The contrast between the violence outside and that gentle demand at the dinner table—this is love expressed through routine, through the stubborn maintenance of normalcy in a world that offers none. The backstory about how Lichie got her scars broke something in me. A carriage accident. Lichie pushed Ciel out of the way. Chemical reagents splashed on her face and left side of her scalp. Her hands are burned, dexterity impaired, and she got fired from both the textile mill and then worked even harder at the coal plant for a fraction of the pay. Everything she earns goes to Ciel's education. And she's miserable about it—“I want to do better, to work harder... but I don't know how.” Meanwhile Ciel is carrying her own guilt in silence. She transmigrated three years ago, knows nothing about this world's magic system (which apparently doesn't exist), can't invent anything useful, and her only real skill is exam-taking. She watches her sister sacrifice herself and has no way to repay it. That tension—the love between them, the impossibility of reciprocation—is the engine driving everything. And there's this undercurrent with Amy too. Amy is hopelessly infatuated with Ciel, notices the way her hair catches light, forgets to press further when Ciel gives that polite deflection. It's tender and aching because we know Ciel won't ever be able to accept that kind of warmth without complicating things. The quietest moment in the whole text? When Lichie finishes dinner, reminds Ciel to lock the doors, and leaves for a night shift ending at 1 AM. Two sisters, both exhausted, both pretending everything is fine, both dreading what comes next.
... Read More
There's a scene in here that I can't stop thinking about. Ciel walks into the church, presses the button on the Good Luck Box, takes three coins, mouths "Goddess bless me," then puts one coin back and whispers it again. "Double the blessings—surely, if the Goddess existed, she'd be touched." This is the thesis statement of the entire novel compressed into twelve sentences. The church here is this enormous institution—built by the church, dictating factory schedules, distributing free food, giving workers their one-and-a-half-hour break—but its transcendent leadership is literally blind and wearing a mask with no eye holes. Uris can't see anything. She perceives through touch. She reaches out into darkness and grasps at people. And Ciel, the atheist, goes there anyway. She takes coins from a blessing box she doesn't believe in, because the system told her to. She pretends faith because it's tactical. She plays along with a religion whose highest priestess could be her murderer—or its savior, depending on how this goes. The mask itself is such a loaded image. White, geometric patterns for eyes and nose, then nothing below. A face meant to suggest a face without being one. Uris removes it and reveals someone who looks seventeen, sacred and fragile, eyes closed. She's both completely exposed and still hiding something—the chapter literally cuts before we learn what. And before all that, there's phosphorus. The matchstick factory. "Phossy jaw"—bones rotting from the inside out, an occupational disease that eats you slowly while you keep working because you have no choice. Lichie doesn't even know about it. She just smiles and shrugs. Another kind of slow consumption happening in the same world. The church eats people. The factory eats people. Potions eat people. Everything in this world is some variation on ingestion and transformation, and the question seems to be: who gets consumed, and who does the consuming? I need to sit with this for a while.
... Read More
OK so can we just take a moment for the fact that Uris is a HIGH PRIESTESS and she gets here and immediately starts PINCHING CIEL'S FACE LIKE A STUPID GIRL? Like, this is a transcendent being, blind, terrifyingly powerful, and her idea of bonding is kneading Ciel's cheeks. But here's the thing—I kind of love it. Because for a second, Ciel just stands there letting her do it. She doesn't push her away. She doesn't snap. She just… tolerates it, then calmly asks what Uris actually wanted to talk about. That tells me everything I need to know about their dynamic already. And then Uris touches the two notebooks and her WHOLE ENERGY SHIFTS. One second she's playfully squishing Ciel's face, the next she's holding the research notebook like it's something sacred, fingers tracing the embossed lettering. The contrast hits so hard. This woman went from goofball to gravestone in two seconds flat. The guilt Ciel feels when she sees Uris's dimmed expression—that's the real emotional beat, I think. It's not dramatic or tearful, just this quiet awareness that she accidentally touched a nerve. "It wasn't that Ciel discriminated against people with disabilities… it was just hard to associate a transcendent being with blindness." Oof. That line? That's the author sliding in a whole complicated truth about how we project perfection onto people who seem otherworldly. And then Ciel's confession—"I saw the future"—delivered with dead seriousness while Uris is literally checking if she has a fever. The image is almost comedic. But underneath it, there's this strange intimacy forming between them. Uris, who has never met Ciel, is about to be told the most impossible thing she's ever heard. And Ciel, who has apparently died multiple times in other timelines, is trusting this blind woman with her survival. The worst part for me? When Ciel thinks about how exposing herself to the church means giving up control. She's been playing it safe, running simulations, staying invisible—and now this powerful religious figure is offering her safety in exchange for everything she is. The trust is building and I'm terrified for her.
... Read More
Let me just say this: the stakes in this section are absolutely vicious, and not in the obvious way. On the surface, Ciel has an advantage. She KNOWS Thomas's plan. She has Duven's notebooks. She can simulate. She can backtrack. In theory, she's the most informed person in the room. And yet—the author systematically dismantles every single one of those advantages. First, the simulation time lands only ONE HOUR ahead. Not days. Not weeks. An hour. Which means the church is still open, which means she has to move through the real world almost immediately, which means she can't prepare as thoroughly as she'd like. She goes to the factory, she goes to the church, and within minutes of entering the building, warm hands are around her neck and her gun is gone. Think about that. She walked into a church with a loaded revolver, knew she might encounter transcendent-level opposition, and still got SWIPED in under two minutes. Uris didn't even need to fight. She just... took it. "Just a little joke…" she says, examining the gun like it's a child's toy. But here's what makes the conflict so effective: it's not just external. Ciel is also fighting herself. She's running simulations, calculating Fate Point returns if she dies, mentally rehearsing escape routes. She's treating her own life like a resource to be managed. And the chapter exposes how exhausting that is—her own system has to activate 「Calm Mind Lv.1」 just to remind her why she walked into the church in the first place. The stakes aren't just 'will she survive?' They're 'how much of herself is she willing to spend to survive?' And that's a question that gets worse every chapter.
... Read More
Okay can we just take a moment to appreciate how DIFFERENT every character sounds when they open their mouth? Start with Uris. Holy shit. From the moment she appears—"Little girl, why would you bring something so dangerous into a church?"—she has this completely distinct voice. It's soft, almost melodic, but underneath it is this complete lack of boundaries that makes you want to crawl out of your skin. She's touchy. She grabs Ciel's face. She says things like "What a beautiful little girl…" with this warm, almost maternal tone that is SO wrong coming from someone who just disarmed a armed woman in a church. And the system voice! 「Really? You're asking for help while taking their money?」 This little interjection at the Good Luck Box scene—it's such a small moment, but it establishes this whole running dynamic between Ciel and whatever narrative force is watching her. It's dry, it's slightly sarcastic, and it humanizes Ciel without breaking the tension. She's not just a chess player; she's a person who still makes small, petty moral compromises. Then there's Priest Mel, who exists almost entirely through dialogue tags. "At your service." "Go ahead, it's alright." She's the soft counterweight to Uris—warm, practical, grounding. Her lines are short and functional, which makes sense because she's basically a facilitator in this scene. But the real dialogue triumph is Ciel's internal monologue. 「She's not a pervert」 → 「She's not a pervert」 put back under serious reconsideration. This is HILARIOUS. The author lets us hear Ciel's thought process pivoting in real time, and it's so distinctly Ciel—pragmatic, slightly exhausted, willing to question her own assumptions even when she's being physically manhandled by a blind transcendent woman. No character sounds like any other character. That's rare. That's good writing.
... Read More
There's this one detail that kept making me smile throughout this whole chapter. Uris tries to SCARE Ciel into backing down by describing horrific side effects — crippled, insane, mutations, losing her mind decades later. The text says she paused for two seconds and judged Ciel to be "not more than 15 years old" because she figured fear would work on a kid. And then Ciel just says "thank you for the warning" and immediately asks if Uris knows the correct ritual steps. The audacity. The absolute unbothered energy. And then Uris's entire demeanor shift when she realizes this girl has ALREADY survived the ritual conditions — "the hairs on the back of her neck stand up" — she goes from confident priestess to genuinely shaken in one exchange. But here's what I actually love: Uris doesn't become an enemy or pull any trick. She respects Ciel's choice. She even helps facilitate the whole thing, stepping outside to draw the ritual boundary and instructing her on exactly when to drink the potion. That's not a obstacle character — that's someone who genuinely wants this to succeed. The ending where she wraps her own robe around Ciel and takes burns on her own hand while saying "don't be afraid" — she called her a saintess and then PROVED it. This relationship has so much more potential than I expected going in.
... Read More
OK the stakes in this section are SO high and I need to unpack why. On the surface, Ciel's goal is simple: survive the encounter with Thomas at the Hammer Tavern. She knows this because she's already lived it. She's died there. And now she's going back, armed with foreknowledge and a body that won't actually die—yet. But the real conflict isn't external. It's the gnawing worry she has the whole time: "Would following this path truly benefit her?" She's been playing it safe. Staying hidden. Using simulations as a shield. And now Uris—this terrifying, kind, blindly perceptive High Priestess—is offering her a way out that requires total exposure. Join the church. Become a saintess. Step into the light. The trap is beautiful and terrible: the very thing that could save her (the church's protection and resources) is also the thing that could destroy her (exposing her true nature as a simulator, a cheat, an imposter). "For now, her enemies were only half-trained transcendent beings and ordinary gang members. But once she entered the church's upper echelons, the crises she would face would no longer be solvable through simple simulations." This line changed everything for me. It's the moment Ciel realizes that growth requires risk, but risk requires trust, and she doesn't know if she can trust anyone—not even Uris, who seems genuinely benevolent. What if Uris decides Ciel is a threat? What if the church doesn't want a saintess who arrived through bizarre circumstances and claims divine visions that can't be verified? And then—THE GAMBIT. Ciel asks to drink the Avenger potion IN THE SIMULATION. Do you understand how bold this is? She's essentially saying: let me complete the ritual here, in this fake version of reality, and see what happens. If the system rewards her with Fate Points, she's gambling that the transformation might carry over. She's testing the boundaries of her own power. The stakes just went from "will I survive tonight" to "what am I actually capable of?" Meanwhile Uris is standing there in the dark, mask on, praying under an extinguished streetlamp, having absorbed ALL of this and still choosing to stay. Still choosing to believe Ciel. That's not just plot development—that's emotional investment from a character who has every reason to be skeptical.
... Read More
The worldbuilding in this section isn't in exposition dumps—it's in the blood. Like, the entire theology of this universe is revealed through gross, visceral imagery. Let's start with the black-robed man himself. The description is masterful: 'emaciated cheeks, sagging skin that refused to cover his muscles and bones, pustule-like growths on his scalp that pulsed grotesquely.' This isn't just body horror for shock value. It's showing us what happens when someone tries to bypass the proper channels of power. The Church has structure—priests, high priestesses, trials—but Duven and Thomas went direct, and their bodies are rejecting it. The flesh-colored tendril, the barbed growths, the translucent eggs spilling into black blood—this is a whole ecosystem of corruption. And the setting! We get this sudden shift from the tense, quiet confrontation to the tavern entrance scream that boils the street into chaos. One moment it's dead silent except for the schlick-schlick of a knife through a throat, the next there's panic and noise. That contrast makes the world feel alive—it's not just a arena for Ciel's fights; it's a place where other people exist. I also love how the simulation room contrasts with the in-world scenes. The rickety iron bed, the flickering silver-white screen, the system's clinical evaluation ('Combat! Exhilarating!')—it's all so sterile compared to the warm, filthy gore of the tavern. The world feels layered: there's the mundane church bureaucracy, the dark market where mystical markings get inscribed, the corrupted rituals happening in shadow, and then this meta-layer of simulations and Fate Points. Every layer has its own texture.
... Read More
Okay so here's the thing that genuinely blew my mind — Ciel's simulated self had already figured out the notebook trick. She'd been deliberately documenting decisions and events in Chinese so that when Ciel wakes up, she can read it and feel like she was actually there. The handwriting part? That was such a visceral detail. "Only after seeing the fresh, elegant handwriting in Chinese did she slowly exhale." I could literally feel Ciel's shoulders dropping. It showed how much she trusts this version of herself, like she's got a built-in ally who's always ahead of her. And then there's the whole dynamic with her sister. Reading those entries where the simulated Ciel decided NOT to tell her sister about dropping out of university because "a cold war isn't conducive to facing the challenges ahead together" — that is such a mature, strategic move. She's protecting her sister's feelings while also protecting her own mission. The sister clearly works hard, probably too hard, and Ciel knows it. Amy's subplot is fascinating too. She's this noble friend who genuinely cares but is trapped by her father's paranoia. The scene where she slips Ciel a letter through a nervous maid while under house arrest — that's the kind of friendship that feels REAL. And Ciel's refusal to stay at Amy's place because she knows the baron would just hand her over to the Blackwater Gang to save his own skin? That's not cynicism, that's hard-earned knowledge. These characters aren't archetypes. They're people making calculated choices about trust.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or