The Sin of Being Beside You - Reviews

The Sin of Being Beside You
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
'That Nergal was incredibly skilled at this.' First kiss ever and she's already being absolutely wrecked. I swear to god Ir's internal monologue of 'Am I really going to die like this?' had me simultaneously dying of laughter and absolutely losing my mind. This man is KILLING her with affection and she can't even breathe properly. And the worst part? She CANNOT stop herself from giving in. Even when she tries to scratch him, it comes out as weak tapping sounds—literally the most unhinged tantrum in literary history. But here's what actually destroyed me: the vulnerability. She's in this new, beautiful, delicate body that can barely walk without getting winded, and she's acutely aware of it. When Nergal removes her layers and she instinctively raises her arms to cover herself—it's not just embarrassment, it's that she doesn't even recognize her own body anymore. She sees it as unfamiliar, like she's looking at someone else's intimacy. And he notices. Of course he notices. He calls himself out: 'This makes me feel like some ruffian forcing himself on you.' Not 'I don't want to hurt you' or 'I care about your feelings.' He worries about how HE feels. And yet he stopped when she went limp. He checked her breathing. He ran his hand over his face and called HER a fool. This is the most emotionally stunted display of care I have EVER encountered and it is SO GOOD.
... Read More
The pacing in these first chapters is actually really clever when you think about it. It starts with something almost comedic—the palace gossip mill going absolutely feral over Nergal bringing a woman. You've got these noblewomen whispering and snickering, and it reads like court drama light. Then Nergal appears and the tone shifts immediately. The smiling. The hand-holding. The whispered line to Ir. Suddenly it's not gossip anymore—it's something real, something dangerous. The transition from public to private is BRUTAL. He walks her through the palace, everyone watching, and then—BANG—the door slams shut and suddenly it's just them and the tension is Palpable. He pushes her against the wall and the scene becomes this slow, deliberate build of physical intimacy. No rushing, no skipping ahead. The author takes their time here, which is a bold choice for what could've been a quick sex scene. Instead it becomes character development. Every touch tells you something about who these people are to each other. And then—WHAM—the flashback. We cut to 'If You Have a Wish, Grasp That Sword' and we're suddenly in a cave with a burned knight and her subordinates. This structural choice is genius because it explains SO MUCH without exposition dumps. We learn about Ir's past, her comrades, the fire, the Holy Sword quest—all through this fragmented memory that the present-tense intimacy triggers. The pacing mirrors how trauma actually works: one moment you're fine, the next you're somewhere else entirely. The chapter ends on this line about her ear being gone and her side exposed, and it just... stops. No resolution, no comfort, just the raw image of a warrior who lost everything. The cliffhanger isn't about plot—it's about emotional stakes. What happened? Why did her comrades die? What does the Holy Sword have to do with any of this? I need to know NOW.
... Read More
Okay so this man is literally the most confusing person. One minute he's devouring her in this intense kiss that nearly kills her and the next he's gently fixing her hair and covering her with a blanket like some sort of... what? He called HER a fool after she passed out, not himself. Classic Nergal. But then—then he remembers ALL her scars. Every single one. The arms of uneven length, the damaged arm from blocking that burning pillar, the broken leg. He's carrying this enormous guilt and you can FEEL it in his bones. "All of it had happened because of him." That's not just background flavor text, friend. That's the entire foundation of their relationship right there. And the hospital memory! He used to barely touch her with one finger and she'd SCREAM in agony. Now he's pulling her close and embracing her. The fact that he had convinced himself he'd never be able to touch her again—and then here she is, warm and breathing and ALIVE—hit me like a truck. This man thought he lost her forever and he's not letting go this time. Whatever it takes. Then cut to the carriage and he's all business again, barely touching her, staying out all day. Ir is over here wondering if he was serious about wanting her body or not, and meanwhile Nergal was THE ONE secretly taking care of her during her fever. Of COURSE he was. That man would rather die than admit he cares.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Nergal because THIS MAN. Like, throughout the entire first chapter he's established as this Ice Prince—cold, calculating, no emotions, just pure bureaucratic machine. And then BOOM, he's walking through the palace smiling. Not even a normal smile, like a genuinely gentle one that made everyone lose their minds. And it's only because of Ir. That's such a character moment right there. It tells you everything about how much he cares without him having to say a single word about it. But then there's Ir. Poor thing. She used to be a knight—actually a Vice Captain, no less. The burns, the melted fingers, half her face gone... and she's looking at her own reflection going 'wait, these are MY hands?' The transformation must be psychological as much as physical. She can't even recognize herself anymore, which makes me wonder how much of her identity survived whatever happened in that burning mansion. Their relationship is built on a CONTRACT. He helps her get revenge, she gives him her body. And yet when he presses her against that wall, the narration emphasizes she doesn't feel fear. She feels... something else. The text says he's been 'diligently accustomed her body to his actions over the past few weeks.' That word 'diligently'—he's been practicing? Learning how to please her? For someone who supposedly has ice and iron in his veins instead of blood, he's showing a lot of softness here. And she knows it. That's why she can surrender to him completely. Also, the fact that he calls her 'Ir' in front of everyone while introducing her as 'Ishtar' to the nobles? That's a whole language of intimacy right there. Ishtar is her childhood name, the goddess of war her father named her after. He's the ONLY one who knows that name now. He's claiming that version of her—the warrior, the knight, the girl she used to be—while publicly presenting her as his consort. Double life, double identity. This relationship is layered like an onion and I'm already obsessed.
... Read More
I have never read a line that landed so perfectly in my life. "A Holy Sword isn't meant to be drawn by a monster." It's delivered as mockery by the attackers, but the narrative frames it as prophecy. The prose itself seems to shudder around this moment. Ir's internal monologue doesn't argue with the word—it rehearses it. "Because my body isn't proper, because I look hideous, because I'm not of noble blood. Is that why I can't use you?" Each clause is shorter than the last, like her voice is being squeezed out. The attackers' dialogue is equally masterful in its deliberate ordinariness. They speak like bureaucrats, not villains. "They said this much would be enough to knock everyone out." Casual. Administrative. One of them comments on Ir's strength the way a gym teacher might: "Still so much strength." There's no theatrical evil here—just professional detachment, which makes it infinitely worse. And Ir's own voice—when she finally screams "I'll kill you! All of you! Even if I die, I'll crawl after you and have my revenge! Until the end!"—it's the closest thing to genuine catharsis in the chapter. But even that is undercut by the narration: "She knew it was impossible." The author won't let us feel triumphant. The prose itself keeps reminding us that hope is a luxury Ir cannot afford.
... Read More
Okay, let's talk about Ir for a second. I don't know if I've ever read a protagonist who is so thoroughly exhausted by being perceived. ‘Monster.' That's the word. The nobles screamed it. The palace adopted it as a synonym for her. Even the shepherd bolts because he can't look at her. And she's just… standing there, pulling her hat down, thinking it's her fault for letting her guard down. It's devastating in its mundanity. This isn't a tragic backstory she wails about; it's a daily tax she pays. What strikes me most is how her relationships are all filtered through this lens. Shulat and Utu are her people—literally the only division that doesn't flinch. But even they have their limits. Utu gets teary-eyed when drunk, then gets smacked for it. Shulat teases her but also genuinely worries about her stamina. And then there's Nergal. Oh, Nergal. The text only scratches the surface here—just a hint that he knew her when she was young, that he ‘torments' her in the office—but the implication is huge. Why does a crown prince single out a commoner knight for endless standing detentions? There's history there, and it's not friendly. I found myself obsessed with the casual cruelty of it all. Ir mentions she's from conquered territory—Levant—which explains why she'd be viewed as an outsider even without the ‘monster' label. But the text doesn't let us pity her too long; she turns it into self-mockery. ‘Should I have covered up more?' she thinks, not with bitterness, but with mild annoyance at her own mistake. It's a defense mechanism. The real heartbreak is in what she wants: not glory, not power, just to go back to the familiar quarters, eat with her squad, do boring missions. That's it. After everything she's endured, her dream is invisibility. And then the plot throws Shulat's head at her feet, shattering that quiet desire instantly. How do you relationship-analyze a cliffhanger like that? I'm just sitting here wondering who wanted Shulat dead, and whether Ir's past as a monster is somehow connected. The bonds in the 9th seem warm, but they're fragile. One second they're bickering about fruit breath, the next half your team is unconscious. It makes you question what kind of world this is, and what kind of people survive in it.
... Read More
What hit me hardest here wasn't the action itself—it was the subversion of every trope I've ever loved. The Holy Sword embedded in the wall, the legendary blade that only bows to the righteous, the one Ir has presumably dreamed about since childhood? It rejects her outright: "A Holy Sword isn't meant to be drawn by a monster." And then, in the single most devastating plot turn of the chapter, it comes free. Not because she became worthy. Not because some inner purity unlocked it. But because she was broken enough, desperate enough, willing to accept any price—crawling through mud and spit, losing everything, just to kill the people who destroyed her family. The author doesn't give us a triumphant selection scene. They give us a trembling, bleeding woman hanging from a rock face, arms tearing, whispering "Please... come out..." like a child begging a parent to stay. And the sword moves. Not with a heroic fanfare but with what the narrative calls "like a lie." That word—*lie*—is doing so much work. Did the sword truly choose her? Or did the earthquake force the sword loose while she clung to it? The ambiguity is glacial. What follows—the cave collapse, the fleeing attackers, Ir collapsing into darkness—is almost an afterthought structurally. The real climax happened in those seconds between rejection and reluctant acceptance. And then the epilogue hits us with strangers finding her unconscious, half-naked, and one of them making a crude assumption about her sexuality. The plot doesn't let up. It just changes genre.
... Read More
I just... I need a minute. The way Nergal carries Ir in his arms when he arrives at the villa. He's not being gentle in a fragile way — he's protective in a way that says no one else gets to see her like this. When Ishin tries to look at her face, Nergal's reaction is immediate: "clicked his tongue and held Ir closer to his chest" and then pulled up her hood like a territorial animal. Ishin even notes this is typical of "lovesick fools who had completely lost their minds." But it's not just possessiveness. Think about the bathroom scene. Nergal undresses a sleeping Ir, and despite his hands "freely roaming her body," she remains completely unaware. There's this tenderness underneath everything — he could've woken her, could've forced her awake, could've treated her like an object (which, given the contract premise, she technically is). But he doesn't. He's methodical, careful even. And that satisfied smile on his face? That's not domination. That's something dangerously close to devotion. Meanwhile Ir — she's trapped between being a knight who endures pain professionally and a woman experiencing physical sensations she has zero framework for. Her knight training says "keep your eyes open even when a sword comes to your neck" but pleasure isn't something she can strategy her way through. The contrast between her discipline and her body's betrayal is everything. And Nergal telling her "Don't hold back your voice" — that's not just sexual. That's him wanting her to stop performing composure around him. God, these two.
... Read More
The author really went all out with the sensory details in the bathroom scene and I am HERE for it. Let me paint the picture for you: the villa is on the outskirts of the capital in a luxury villa district, completely secluded, used maybe once or twice a year by Nergal. It's HIS private sanctuary, and now he's brought Ir into it. The bathroom is built in Arcad Empire style — instead of a standalone tub, it's a stone bath with beautiful mosaic tiles, adapted from large public bathhouses into something more intimate. Hot steam filling the room. Winter outside but heat inside. And the carriage scene? "The cool carriage interior had already grown hot with the heat they were both releasing." Just one line and suddenly I can feel the temperature rising. The contrast between the cold winter travel and the feverish intimacy inside is visceral. But what really elevated the worldbuilding for me was how naturally everything felt lived-in. The women who come to seduce Nergal at the palace — daughters of high-ranking nobles, the capital's most popular singer — they strip and approach him and he throws them out naked. Not a hint of romance or politeness. This is a man who has moved past performing courtesy. The empire feels real because the power dynamics feel real. Nergal's influence has grown precisely because everyone needs him to survive politically, which is why even the most scandalous behavior goes unchallenged. And Ishin pacing in the lobby, repeatedly looking outside — that single image captures the entire atmosphere of anticipation and dread surrounding this man.
... Read More
I need to sit with this chapter for a while because the symbolism is absolutely layered. The central image is Ir's scarless body—her physical self has been completely remade, yet she clings to those scars like they're proof of her existence. This is such a profound metaphor for identity itself. What makes us who we are? Our memories? Our experiences? Or the physical evidence of what we've survived? The Holy Sword is obviously symbolic on another level—it's the thing everyone is killing for, but it's also the thing that destroyed the 9th Knight Order. Power corrupts, truth gets buried, and the symbol of justice becomes the instrument of betrayal. The cave itself is worth thinking about too—it's this dark, enclosed space where the truth literally got buried under rubble, and now Ir has to dig it back up. There's also something deeply symbolic about names. Ishtar was her birth name, tied to goddesses of war and beauty—a name that would have made her burning-scarred body seem like a cruel joke. Her adoptive father gave her 'Ir Kala,' a name that let her keep her old nickname while giving her a fresh start. And now she's in a completely new body, which means she's essentially named Ir Kala for the third time. Each version of herself had to die so the next one could exist. The author keeps circling back to this idea that people can be erased—bodies changed, names forgotten, histories rewritten by whoever holds power. But Ir refusing to accept that erasure? That's the whole theme right there.
... Read More
The atmosphere in these chapters is something else. You've got this remote cave, dead-end wall, and a sword that's basically a metaphysical speed bump. The author really leans into sensory details—the echoing sounds that cause dizziness, the oppressive force that makes even trained knights groan, the way the sudden wind extinguishes every lamp. It's cinematic. You can picture the knights huddled, faces lit by dying flames, hearts pounding. But what's fascinating is how the worldbuilding isn't just set dressing; it's woven into the plot's mechanics. The Holy Sword isn't a prop; it's an active character. It vibrates, it repels, it exhausts. And the environment reacts to it. The path up takes longer than it should because of this ‘unknown reason' that dulls senses. That's smart—that's showing us a world where magic isn't just flashy spells, but a pervasive, draining force that bends physics and perception. Then you pull back and see the political landscape outside: nineteen heirs, no primogeniture, a conquered kingdom, a stable empire on the brink of chaos. All of it contrasts sharply with the intimate, claustrophobic cave scene. Up above, nobles are probably arguing over who gets to send an advance party. Down below, Ir's crew is dealing with literal life-and-death thresholds. The shepherd, btw, is a great touch. He's the everyman, terrified of both Ir and the sword, representing the common folk caught in these grand machinations. I also love the small details—the wooden gear-clock that tracks time accurately even in weird conditions, the Kurum fruit that makes urine smell foul (why do I find this hilarious and horrifying?), the marked boundary lines on the cave floor. It's a world that feels lived-in, where magic has rules and consequences, and politics are just as dangerous as any beast. The visual of the sword—dark blue, smooth, unadorned—is a nice subversion of the ‘gleaming legendary blade' trope. It doesn't look like a prize; it looks like a warning. And that final image, Shulat's head rolling to Ir's feet, is so abruptly violent it shatters the entire mood. One moment you're in a mythic quest adventure, the next you're in a body-horror thriller. The setting itself seems to betray them.
... Read More
Let's talk stakes because this book doesn't mess around. Ir's external conflict is obvious — she's a prisoner about to be sold, physically weakened, surrounded by men who see her as property. But the INTERNAL conflict is where it gets messy. She spent years being called a monster, ostracized for her scars, and yet she built her identity around enduring that. Who is she now when the scars are gone? The text makes it clear: she never thought about wanting to be beautiful. Beauty was irrelevant to her mission. But now it's the ONLY thing people see. Meanwhile, the Holy Sword chose her, saved her in some way that erased her past six months, and disappeared. That's not a rescue — that's a transaction she didn't agree to. And the imperial family member? They're digging up the cave obsessively. If they find Ir — the woman who matches the description of someone connected to the Holy Sword, wearing the face of a stranger — what happens? The stakes aren't just life or death anymore. They're about identity, purpose, and whether surviving means losing everything that made you recognizable to yourself. I'm on the edge of my seat and my stomach at the same time.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or