There is so much going on beneath the surface of this text that most readers will probably glide right over. I've re-read certain passages four times and each time I notice another layer.
Let's start with the most obvious symbol: milk. Breast milk is literally life—Evelyn is sustaining this child, Johanson, who is not hers biologically but whom she cares for. And the Duke, the man who holds absolute power over her life and death, fixates on this very substance. 'Is the scent of milk naturally this sweet?' His question reduces her most maternal, nurturing act into something to be inspected, evaluated, consumed. The milk becomes a symbol of everything he can take from her—her body, her labor, her autonomy. And yet, her body responds to him anyway. The milk flows, her body trembles, her 'lower stomach clenches.' She is simultaneously the most powerful (nurturing life) and the most powerless (violated, exposed) version of herself, all at once.
Then there's the moonlight. The Duke holds his wet palm up to the moonlight after wringing out her handkerchief. Moonlight in literature has always been tied to feminine power, to wildness, to things that operate outside daylight reason. Here it illuminates the evidence of her violation—but also, strangely, it's the only light in the scene. Daylight would mean witnesses, civilization, rules. Moonlight means this happens in a liminal space, outside the law, outside consequence.
The dress is another symbol I can't stop thinking about. Evelyn keeps losing control of her clothing—partially exposed, loosely fastened, ribbon untied. Each time the Duke demands she 'unbutton your clothes,' it's not just sexual; it's about stripping away her social identity. She enters as a nanny, a wet nurse, a servant. By the end of the scene, she's reduced to a body. The dress is her armor against this reduction, and it keeps failing her.
And what about the stillbirth? That ghost haunts every page. Evelyn's body produced nothing but a dead child for her first husband, and now it produces life-sustaining milk for another woman's child under the gaze of a dangerous man. Her body has betrayed her, been used by her, failed her, and yet it continues. It persists. 'She had survived, so she must live.' Those final words carry the weight of every symbol in this text—the body as site of suffering AND survival.
Is this a romance? A horror story? A feminist dismantling of the male gaze? I think it's all three and that's what makes it so unsettling.