The Idyllic Scenery is Infinitely Good - Reviews

The Idyllic Scenery is Infinitely Good
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
What strikes me most about the dialogue here is how distinct every voice is, even in translation. Li Cui Cui sounds like exactly what she is — a scheming aunt who phrases everything as if she's giving wise advice but is actually calculating mortgage payments. Her line about afterlife accountability for not having children is genuinely chilling when you stop to think about it. It's not just mean, it's weaponized tradition. Lin Cheng's voice is sharper, shorter, more defensive. "Don't tell me this crap!" feels like someone who's used to getting his way and is genuinely rattled. But then his softer moments with Lin Mai — "No, you can't..." — those fragments are so much more honest than anything he says to the Li women. And Lin Mai's dialogue is barely there, which IS the point. "It's okay. I'm used to it anyway." One sentence and you understand his entire backstory. "I really have an emergency here. You let go of me first!" — clipped, impatient, not performing politeness for anyone. His silence speaks louder than everyone else's speeches combined.
... Read More
I need to talk about Lin Cheng because something shifted here and I wasn't expecting it. In earlier chapters he's been this kind of casual, go-with-the-flow guy, but watch how he handles the Li Fang conversation. He doesn't back down from saying 'what if I really have feelings for you?' That's not a kid playing around anymore. And then his interaction with Li Xiaoju reveals something important—she's entitled, sure, but his response to her is almost too harsh, like he's projecting all his frustration about the gossip onto her. He sees her as another person trying to control his choices. Meanwhile, the scene with Mai Zi where he just leaves her standing there dumbfounded saying 'I'll come back for you tomorrow'—that's not reckless, that's deliberate. He's making a choice in real time and committing to it. And Aunt Chen, bless her, represents the whole village's pressure to conform, to marry someone practical rather than someone you actually want. Lin Cheng deflects her subtly by defending good-looking people, which is basically code for Mai Zi without saying it. The web of relationships here is tight—he's simultaneously protecting Mai Zi from rumors, rejecting Li Xiaoju's advances, dodging Aunt Chen's matchmaking, and navigating his uncle's warnings. Nobody gets a clean win in this chapter except maybe Li Xiaoju's stubborn delusion that he'll regret it someday, which honestly makes me kind of uneasy for him going forward.
... Read More
The dialogue in this passage is absolutely phenomenal and I have to highlight why. Lin Cheng and Aunt Wan's exchange reads like a verbal knife fight and both characters have incredibly distinct voices. Aunt Wan: 'What qualification do you have to scold me? You really take yourself too seriously.' — Wait no that's Lin Cheng. Aunt Wan goes: 'You just wait! Later, I'll get my brothers from my mother's family to deal with you!' Classic toxic energy delivered with zero self-awareness. And Lin Cheng's response: 'You know that I'm not good at anything, I just have the physical strength and the skill to kill a pig. You think if I get impulsive, will I go straight to your house with a pig killing knife?' This is either the most threatening thing anyone has ever said to me or the funniest. Both at once. The way Chen Ama pokes him on the forehead and tells him to stop lying — that grandmother energy is so warm and authentic. 'It's still too early for you to lie to your Chen Ama.' I can absolutely picture this scene as a TV drama. Every character has a recognizable voice and the banter flows naturally without feeling scripted. The dialogue carries so much personality without needing heavy narration.
... Read More
There's this scene under the peach tree where Li Cui Cui drags Xiao Ju to sit, pats the empty space beside her, and demands Lin Cheng join them. A peach tree—usually associated with romance, with blossoms, with spring—becomes this stage for something so painfully awkward it makes your teeth ache. The author keeps returning to physical spaces that should feel warm but don't. The meat stall. The courtyard. The bamboo pole where Lin Cheng hangs his clothes. These are domestic, intimate places, and yet none of them feel like home for these characters. Lin Cheng is alone in his yard. Lin Mai is always entering, never staying. Xiao Ju is a stranger being sold like merchandise. And the word 'ger'—that repeated classification, that social label—functions like a symbol throughout. It marks difference. It marks hierarchy. It marks the invisible line that separates people even when they want to cross it. Lin Mai knows what 'ger' means. Lin Cheng knew it too when he said it, which is why he immediately tried to take it back. But words, once spoken, have the same permanence as meat cut from the block. What strikes me most is how the story treats marriage proposals not as romantic milestones but as economic transactions wrapped in concern. Li Cui Cui isn't evil—she genuinely believes she's doing good. But that's what makes it worse. The system doesn't need villains. It just needs normal people making normal suggestions.
... Read More
Lin Da Shan is my favorite character in this batch, hands down. This big, loud, seemingly annoying older brother who keeps getting elbowed and mocked but never actually stops caring? The moment he says 'As your brother, I will definitely stand on your side!' even after all the teasing—that's the kind of line that makes you soft inside. He's protective, jealous, clumsy with words, but loyal as hell. And then there's Lin Cheng, who pretends not to care but clearly does. Watch how he acts when Lin Mai shows up: he freezes, almost hits his foot with the hoe, and suddenly becomes hyper-concerned about whether Mai Zi is worried about his Ama staying home alone. He even hurries him off to rest because the sun is hot. Come on, we all know what's happening here. The way Lin Da Shan remarks 'The person is gone yet you are still staring at it?' is pure observation, and Lin Cheng deflects with 'Then should I stare at you instead?'—smooth, but we see right through him. And the hairpin shopping scene with Aunt Chen? Lin Cheng rejecting the flashy butterfly hairpin because 'the person I am going to marry is a girl and not a ger'—wait, he said ger? Probably a translation glitch, but either way, he's being intentional, choosing simplicity because it suits Mai Zi. That tells us everything about how he sees their future together.
... Read More
There's something really interesting about how these chapters shift the emotional temperature, and I think the author is doing this deliberately through pacing. The opening hits fast and hot — Lin Cheng is practically vibrating with excitement. 'I should marry someone like Mai Zi!' This is peak dopamine. The dialogue zips along, Aunt Chen is relentless, the pork is bribed, the agreement is made. Three paragraphs and he's engaged. I devoured this section. Then — and this is where I want to highlight the craft — the scene with the forgotten instructions. He's distracted. Lost in thought. The pacing deliberately slows down. We get the little details: scratching his hair, giggling foolishly, the aunt's exasperation. It's almost humorous but underneath there's genuine tension. Will he mess this up? Is he ready? And then the walk to the field. The song humming. The stop at Mai Zi's closed courtyard door. This is where the chapter achieves something beautiful — the external action drops away and we're left with pure internal feeling. He doesn't even go in. He just looks. He shrugs. He keeps walking. The author trusts us to sit with that uncertainty. The chapter ends on a seemingly casual interaction with Lin Da Shan, but the structure is doing heavy lifting here. It moves from excitement → doubt → quiet acceptance → the warm safety of family. It's a complete emotional arc compressed into what feels like a few ordinary hours. That's mastery.
... Read More
I need to talk about Aunt Chen because this woman deserves her own fan club. The moment she pokes Lin Cheng with her 'orchid-shaped fingers' and calls him out for spacing out — I literally laughed out loud. The detail about the orchid finger gesture being from traditional Chinese opera? Chef's kiss. That's the kind of specificity that makes a side character feel like they have a whole life outside these pages. But what really got me was her reaction to the money. She doesn't just take it. She weighs it, checks it, and hands it back saying she'd be 'sold' if she lost it. This woman has boundaries. She's helpful but not a pushover. And the way she pivots to 'let's go together' — that's a grandmotherly energy that's warm without being suffocating. Then there's Lin Da Shan. God, I love this character. Sitting outside dozing in the sun, getting caught snoozing, then immediately grabbing a hoe because 'you've been impossible to find these past two days.' That line — 'instead of thinking about you, I might as well think about...' — and then the text cuts off but you can literally feel the rest of the sentence. He's worried. He cares. And he's the type who would never say that directly. The relationship between Lin Cheng and his dad/elder figure here is everything. It's the kind of bond where affection hides inside complaints. And Lin Cheng's little giggle when he sees his dad dozing? That's the author showing us how much he loves this person without having him say a single sweet word.
... Read More
There's this recurring motif in the text I can't shake—the fields. So much happens outdoors, in open spaces where everyone can see but nobody says anything outright. Lin Cheng and Lin Mai working side by side in the field, weeds being pulled, grass growing taller than vegetables if left untended. Isn't that exactly what their relationship feels like? Something natural that just needs tending, but if you ignore it, it overtakes everything. And then the hairpin scene! Aunt Chen pushing for the ornate butterfly hairpin while Lin Cheng insists on the simple bamboo-shaped one. This isn't just about taste—it's about values. He's choosing authenticity over performance, simplicity over spectacle. And the shopkeeper calling the butterfly one a 'bestseller'? Irony. The crowd goes for flashy, but the right choice is the one that fits the person you actually want to marry. Even the title 'The Idyllic Scenery is Infinitely Good' feels loaded. It's pastoral, peaceful, almost naive—but underneath, there's gossip, tension, unconfessed feelings, and the weight of societal expectation ('what will people think?'). The author keeps layering these contrasts: open fields vs. private feelings, loud rumors vs. quiet gestures, expensive ornaments vs. simple bamboo. It all points to one truth—the best things in life aren't performative. They're the ones you notice when you're not looking.
... Read More
Can we talk about how the dialogue in this book actually sounds like REAL people talking? Most novels get dialogue wrong. Characters either sound too polished or too on-the-nose. But here? Every line feels like eavesdropping. Take this exchange: "Ama, what are you thinking about? The meals are ready. Let's eat!" And then immediately after, the grandmother's response isn't a grand speech—it's a frown at a plate of food and a worried question about where the pork came from. That's how real families talk. You orbit around the real concern without ever naming it directly. And Lin Mai's line about the gossip: "In their eyes, even if I just talk to other guys, I'm still accused of being unrestrained." Said so quietly his grandma almost doesn't hear it. THEN he just picks up his chopsticks and eats. He doesn't Elaborate. He doesn't demand comfort. That silence after the statement? Chef's kiss. The author trusts the reader to feel the weight. Lin Cheng's voice is completely different—looser, warmer, with that practical humor: "I'm a pig slaughterer, I don't have much of anything but only pork." He deflates Lin Mai's guilt with self-deprecation and physical gesture (the head pat) instead of words. Their dialogue rhythms are distinct. I could tell who was speaking without looking at the names. The author's narrative voice is also doing a lot of quiet work—mostly staying close to Lin Mai's perspective, filtering everything through his observations and internal responses. It's restrained, never over-explaining, which makes the emotional beats land harder.
... Read More
I need to talk about Lin Dashan because WOW. This kid just walked in with a basket of goodies and immediately became the emotional anchor of the entire chapter. Think about it—Lin Cheng is being besieged by his toxic aunt, this woman who treats him like an ATM with legs, and then Dashan appears like 'Hey bro, I brought food!' and suddenly the whole mood lifts. The narration drops this little detail that broke my heart a bit: 'As an orphan, he was often laughed at by the children in the village because he had no parents. Lin Cheng was happy to play with him.' Just one line. ONE LINE and suddenly you understand why their bond is so deep. These two kids found each other in a world that made fun of both of them in different ways—Lin Cheng for being 'different,' Dashan for having no family. They became each other's chosen family. And Lin Cheng's reaction? 'If it weren't for you, I would have been annoyed to death. Go! Let's go to the kitchen, Ge will make you something delicious.' The way he immediately shifts from hostile mode to caring mode just because his friend walked in—that tells you everything about who he really is underneath the gruff exterior. This man can tell a manipulative aunt to get lost in five points but he'll cook for his bro without hesitation. Meanwhile Li Cui Cui's departure is absolutely perfect. 'She was too embarrassed to cry here again, so she carried the basket and left without saying hello.' No dramatic exit, no last word. Just shamefaced retreat. After everything she put him through, she doesn't even have the decency to say goodbye. The power dynamic here is SO clear. I also can't ignore how Lin Cheng refers to himself as 'Ge' (older brother) to Dashan. They're not blood related but he's claiming that role proudly. That's the kind of detail that makes you realize this story isn't just about survival or business—it's about building the family you choose.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Grandmother Li Fang because this woman is genuinely one of the most fascinating characters in the entire book and nobody is giving her enough credit. Here's this old lady who sits in the courtyard, coughs a little, looks harmless—and then proceeds to dismantle two young men's emotional lives with surgical precision. First she corners Lin Mai, who is already looking guilty as sin, and starts fishing for information. The kid says nothing happened, waves it off with that classic teenage deflection energy, but the reader knows—he's blushing. Then Lin Cheng walks in, sweet boy that he is, and instead of letting him off the hook she pivots directly to marriage market territory. Do you have a girl or a ger you like?? Bro. She goes from zero to matchmaking in three seconds. And the genius part is that she's not actually being mean—she genuinely believes she's protecting them both. "I watched both of you grow up." That line hit me somewhere because it's so much more complicated than it sounds. She loves them, she's worried, and she's trapped between believing her own grandson and believing the entire village. The dynamic between these three is chef's kiss.
... Read More
Okay so the worldbuilding in these chapters is subtle but effective. I love how the setting feels lived-in rather than described at you. Lin Da Shan sitting on stone stairs when Lin Cheng comes home — that's such a specific, grounded image. You can picture it. The village has this atmosphere where everybody knows everybody's business, which becomes really clear later with the gossiping women. But even before that scene hits, you feel it. People are pointing at Lin Cheng wherever he goes. The world feels small and watchful. And the economic reality is woven into everything without being preachy about it. Lin Mai can't afford medicine. Lin Da Shan's master got shut down by soldiers, so he lost his apprenticeship. These aren't backdrop details — they're active forces shaping the characters' choices. The traditional crafts matter too. Embroidery, shoe-making, carpentry — these aren't just color. They represent a way of life that's fragile. When the master's shop closes, it's not just a business problem, it's a disruption of knowledge transmission. Lin Da Shan is frustrated because he only learned 70-80% of the craft. That's a real loss. And the domestic spaces feel authentic — the kitchen where dinner gets cooked, the stone stairs, the latrine comment (which made me laugh out loud). The author doesn't spend pages describing the village layout but you understand it through action. Lin Cheng walking home, passing villagers, going into the kitchen, cooking dinner — the geography emerges naturally. I also appreciate how the scene with the two whispering women escalates. It starts with passive observation (pointing, gossiping) and then becomes direct confrontation. Auntie Wan defending her right to scold anyone she wants — 'This is my mouth' — that line is iconic. It captures something about rural social dynamics where reputation is currency and everyone feels entitled to spend it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or