The Idyllic Scenery is Infinitely Good - Reviews

The Idyllic Scenery is Infinitely Good
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Man, this chapter hit different. I didn't expect to be tearing up over a scene where someone just “faints” and a doctor checks their pulse, but here we are. The plot here isn't about dramatic twists or big reveals — it's about that moment when you realize something has been broken inside your family for years and you're just now hearing about it. Lin Mai running to the door, letting go of old man Lin's hand, seeing his mother lying there — the author could've made this super dramatic, but instead they kept it quiet. That's what made it hurt more. And then the reveal: this wasn't just some random illness. It was the “incompletely cured illness” from when she gave birth to his father. So the grandfather died because of this, and now the mother is slowly dying too? The plot is basically saying: grief and loss run in this family, and there's nothing to do but wait and watch. I also love how the subplots weave in naturally. Lin Cheng showing up — at first he was going to the field but then he remembers the grass, grabs his hoe, and ends up walking home with Lin Mai. The author uses these small actions to show care without words. Then later, after they get the medicine, Lin Cheng walks him home again. When Lin Mai asks why he's not going to the field, Lin Cheng says he “would like to see and visit your Grandma.” No drama, no big speech. Just that. The ending with the sweet potatoes and corn is such a weird contrast to everything else. One minute you're dealing with a terminal illness reveal, the next you're breaking a sweet potato in half and sitting together. But that's life, right? You don't get to process everything. You just keep going. And that's what makes this plot feel so real.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about Zhao Wen because this guy is an absolute commodity and I think the author wrote him purely for comedic relief but he somehow became my favorite character in three paragraphs. Let's look at his dialogue: "Lie to me, huh? Since when does your family have a little brother? Tell me honestly, is it your sweetheart?" Bro. You've known Lin Cheng for a year and your immediate leap is sweetheart? Not brother? Not orphan? Not literally any other possibility? The man operates on pure bro-instinct and zero hesitation. And then the way he handles the egg transaction—whispering conspiratorially, giving Lin Cheng this meaningful smile like they're co-conspirators in some grand romance scheme, when actually Lin Cheng is just trying to help a kid sell eggs. The physical comedy in their interactions is chef's kiss. "Lin Cheng turned round and stretched out his hand to beat Zhao Wen a little but didn't make a sound" —that's not violence, that's affectionate bro-slapping. And Lin Cheng's response of just rolling his eyes and giving up on explanation? Perfect. The dialogue between the two of them feels lived-in, like these guys have been bouncing off each other for years. Then contrast that with Lin Mai's voice—short answers, hesitant, always responding rather than initiating. "Oh." "Needles and thread ah." "Brother Chengzi, I'm back from shopping." He speaks in fragments while everyone else is bantering. It's a subtle but brilliant characterization choice. Even the village gossip women have distinct voices—Yu Xiaoli is loud and performative (covering her chest with an "as if she was scared" expression) while Li Cui Cui is sharper, more venomous, the one who actually witnessed the hand-holding incident. You can tell them apart just from how they talk. And Lin Cheng's internal monologue, that one moment where he sighs helplessly about Lin Mai never understanding—there's so much unspoken love in that resignation.
... Read More
There's this recurring motif of clothing and bodies that I can't shake. Lin Mai makes clothes — two sets for Lin Cheng, a cotton coat for his grandma. These are acts of care, literal warmth against the coming cold. Meanwhile Li Xiao Ju is dressed up to seal a transactional marriage, and Yu Xiaoli walks around with medicine she probably gave to someone else. The bodies in this text are either sick, collapsing, or performing health. Lin Mai's grandma is on the floor. Lin Cheng is emotionally cold despite his wealth. Li Xiao Ju performs weakness while calculating her next move. And Lin Mai himself — he's always running, dragging, carrying. Running to Lin Cheng's place with gifts. Running back to his grandmother. Running to old man Lin's house for help while dragging the old man back. His body is an instrument of care in a world that doesn't care about him. The title of Chapter 5, "The Idyllic Scenery is Infinitely Good," feels almost ironic against what actually happens — unless the idyll is something internal, something Lin Mai protects for himself despite everything surrounding him crumbling. Or maybe it's just bitter irony. Either way it lands.
... Read More
The stakes in this passage keep escalating and I am HERE for it. Let me break down the layers: Layer 1: Physical survival. Aunt Wan is literally trying to scratch Lin Cheng's face. He has to dodge. His threat about the pig-killing knife raises the physical danger to a ridiculous but genuinely tense level. At any moment this could turn violent and neither party is rational enough to stop it. Layer 2: Social destruction. The rumor about Lin Mai. In this village setting, a girl's reputation IS everything. If people start talking about her having relations with a bachelor like Lin Cheng, it could ruin her marriage prospects, her standing in the community, maybe even her safety. He recognizes this immediately: 'Lin Mai was a ger, it was eventually always a bad thing to be rumoured like this.' Layer 3: Emotional exposure. Lin Cheng's internal admission that he might actually develop feelings for Lin Mai — this is the most vulnerable moment in the entire passage. He's this tough guy who threatens people with farm knives but internally he's just a boy wondering if maybe, possibly, something could grow between him and this girl. The author masterfully stacks these conflicts on top of each other. You finish one tense scene and immediately get pulled into another. Lin Cheng escapes Aunt Wan only to discover the real battle is just beginning.
... Read More
I need to talk about Lin Cheng because this character is SO much more interesting than he first appears. On the surface he's a rich boy who plays with people's feelings — promised one girl, immediately ditched her for another, sweats and apologizes afterward like a guilty dog. But the way he treats Lin Mai? Completely different energy. He's genuinely worried about him. "Didn't I let you make one set for yourself?" "This won't do, the weather will get cold!" He's nagging, insisting, caring — and he does it without making it a big emotional moment. That's how people who actually care talk. They don't perform it. And Lin Mai's reaction is everything. He steps on Lin Cheng's foot (subtle rebellion!) but is secretly happy. He gives him two coats and keeps the third for himself as an excuse. The unspoken understanding between them is so much richer than any confession scene ever could be. Meanwhile Lin Cheng doesn't even realize he's being manipulated by Li Xiao Ju's冷笑 at the end — totally unaware he's already the target. Dramatic irony at its finest.
... Read More
The pacing here is masterful in its restraint. The author doesn't rush. Half a month passes between the meat stall incident and the next time we see these characters interact. That gap does more work than a thousand words of internal monologue could. We feel the weight of those thirty days of avoidance. We sit in that discomfort. Then Li Cui Cui arrives—and suddenly everything accelerates. Within a single scene, we go from silence to a full-blown marriage proposal to an interrupted confrontation. The chapter structure mirrors the emotional experience: slow burn, then sudden heat, then the cold aftermath of Lin Mai's laugh. What's remarkable is how the author controls information. We don't get Lin Mai's thoughts. We don't get Lin Cheng's full explanation. We get fragments—the glances, the unfinished sentences, the way Lin Mai's face changes from sullen to smiling in one instant. The reader becomes an investigator, connecting dots that the characters themselves can't bring themselves to see. And that ending—'He... Lin Mai laughed coldly'—it's not a cliffhanger in the traditional sense. There's no explosion, no revelation. Just a laugh and a turned head. But it haunts you. Because you know exactly what he wanted to say, and you know he'll never say it. The author understands that the most powerful moments aren't the ones where characters speak their truth—they're the ones where truth dies in the throat.
... Read More
I have to talk about the atmosphere in these chapters because the author really knows how to paint a world without drowning you in description. The courtyard under the peach tree—that single image does SO much work. It's where Li Fang sits to rest, where she watches Lin Mai move between kitchen and table, where she has those private moments of grief. A peach tree in a Chinese rural courtyard is basically a whole emotional symbol system by itself, and the author doesn't even need to explain it. You just feel it. The kitchen scenes are equally grounded. The pot being reheated, the stir-fried pork with dried radish on the table, the bowl set on the counter at Lin Cheng's place. These aren't decorative details—they're the texture of daily survival. You can feel the heat of the stove, the weight of the dishes, the worn surfaces of everyday life. And the village itself is a character even when it's not physically present. You never see the gossipping women directly, but they're everywhere—in Li Fang's fears, in Lin Mai's shrugs, in the way every interaction is filtered through the lens of what people will say. The social pressure of a small community where everyone knows everyone's business andjudgment is constant and inescapable. That's brilliant worldbuilding. The world isn't just the physical setting; it's the invisible web of reputation and expectation that cages these characters. The contrast between the intimate interior spaces (the bedroom, the kitchen) and the exposed public space (walking through the village) creates this constant tension between safety and vulnerability. I felt it in my bones.
... Read More
The contrast between these two scenes is masterful. First you're in this tense, almost theatrical space where Lin Cheng's apartment becomes a stage for Li Cui Cui and Li Xiao Ju's performance of outrage — the handkerchief swinging, the dramatic gasps, the whole thing feels like a soap opera. Lin Mai just walks in and collapses the entire production with his presence. The clothes bag he throws at Lin Cheng is such a perfect detail — domestic, practical, warm. It physically disrupts their confrontation. Then Chapter 5 hits you like a gut punch. "A Ma!" Lin Mai stumbling into his grandmother's room, finding her collapsed. The shift from social drama to raw emergency is brutal and necessary. And Yu Xiaoli — oh god, Yu Xiaoli bumping into him with her medicine, demanding an apology while his grandmother is literally on the floor dying? The contrast between her petty performative outrage and Lin Mai's genuine terror is almost cruel. But it makes the world feel real. Not every interaction is meaningful. Some people are just obstacles in your way when you're already drowning.
... Read More
I'm not even going to try to hide this—this whole chapter made my chest hurt in the best way. Lin Mai's internal monologue throughout this scene is just pure, unfiltered panic masked by indifference. He tells his grandma repeatedly that there's nothing between him and Cheng Zi Ge, but his actions scream the exact opposite. He's scratching his hair, he's blushing, he's sidling up to let Lin Cheng in and then walking slowly behind him wondering if Lin Cheng knows about the rumors. This boy is so into him it actually pains me. And Lin Cheng—oh my god, Lin Cheng. The moment Grandma asks if he likes someone, he freezes. Not a pause. A full system crash. He glances back at Lin Mai before answering. ANOTHER GLANCE AT LIN MAI. The tension in this house is so thick you could cut it with a knife. And the worst part, the absolutely devastating part, is that neither of them has said a single word about how they actually feel. They're drowning in everyone else's assumptions while standing right next to each other. I've re-read this section four times and I still can't breathe.
... Read More
I have to address the dialogue here because the author's voice in this passage is razor-sharp. Let me start with Li Xiaoju's meltdown: "I didn't hurt anyone! It's all you guys fault! If you hadn't been talking about me, I wouldn't have gotten angry, and then I wouldn't have hurt anyone! Yes, it's all your fault, it's all your fault!" That repetition — "it's all your fault" twice in a row — isn't a writing flaw. It's characterization. Someone who's spiraling doesn't craft elegant arguments. They loop. They repeat. They graspingly throw words at the wall to see what sticks. And the author nails it. Then contrast that with Aunt Cuicui's calculated politeness: "This girl is still young and can't speak well, so you have to be more considerate ah. Don't argue with her, but she's not entirely wrong, is she?" Read that again. She's not defending her niece's ACTIONS. She's framing her niece's ACTIONS as innocent and the NEIGHBORS' WORDS as the real problem. "She's not entirely wrong" is the most manipulative phrase in the English language, and it's deployed perfectly here. Cuicui sounds reasonable while completely inverting the moral landscape. And Lin Cheng's voice? Understated, direct, slightly sarcastic: "Auntie, why are you staring at me? Can't you see that my hand is still hurt? You still think I'm bullying your niece, don't you?" He calls it out. He doesn't play along. He names the absurdity and moves on. This is a guy who's been wronged and refuses to be gaslit, even when the gaslighter is family. The neighbor's retort is equally great: "I think it will be difficult for this girl to be married in the future ah." Said with the casual cruelty of someone who's heard it a thousand times and knows it cuts deepest. Every character has a distinct verbal fingerprint. You could cover their names and still know who's speaking. That's rare. That's skill.
... Read More
Let me just say — this passage makes the village setting feel SO alive. You can picture everything: women and elders sitting outside the Village Chief's house doing embroidery work, the dusty paths, the open-air gossip network that operates faster than any social media platform. This is a world where everyone knows everyone's business and reputations are currency. The scene with Aunt Wan is particularly vivid. She's rolling up her sleeves like she's about to start a fight at a wet market. Her husband abandoned her because she was impossible to live with — 'who could bear it, when he just went home after a long day's work and being so damned tired yet he still had to receive scolding from his own wife?' The author doesn't just tell us this is a rough rural setting, they SHOW us through the behavior of its inhabitants. And then there's this beautiful contrast — Lin Cheng gets threatened with a knife threat involving agricultural equipment, then immediately transitions to being dragged into a cozy conversation with Chen Ama who pats his shoulder and offers him a stool. The world shifts from violent confrontation to warm community instantly, and that's the texture of village life right there. It's not polished or safe but it's genuine. The embroidery detail, the way people sit and chat while working — it all paints this picture of a tight-knit community where nothing stays hidden.
... Read More
I need to talk about Li Xiao Ju because my hands are literally shaking from how much I hate her in this chapter. Like, okay, she sees Lin Cheng walking with someone else and instead of just letting it go she just spirals so hard it's impressive. The way she blocks their path pretending to be sweet but it's so obviously not – Lin Mai even notices and is confused about who she is at first which honestly is the right reaction. And then when the villagers start gossiping she LOSES IT. She gets defensive and calls everyone names and the absolute audacity of someone trying to sabotage a relationship getting called out publicly for being ugly as a revenge burn. But here's what actually got me – when she lunges at Lin Mai with that hairpin. Lin Cheng instinctively shields Lin Mai and gets cut. This woman is genuinely dangerous and I cannot believe she's been established as some romantic interest at any point. The dynamic between Lin Cheng and Lin Mai though? That subtle tenderness when Lin Mai immediately drops everything to check if Chengzi Ge is okay, vs how Lin Cheng casually says 'my future Fu Lang is here' like he's stating a fact everyone should know about their relationship. The contrast is everything.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or