The Greatest Astrologist - Reviews

The Greatest Astrologist
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
"People obsessed with divination don't end up well. They all face their karma eventually." I need this printed on a poster. That line stopped me mid-scroll. It's such a perfect narrative mirror — Chu Qianli saying it almost too quietly, almost to herself, but the author placed it right where the reader needs to feel the weight of it. And then the next line: "Master Liu's 'karma' was meeting her. She too would have her own karma." This is the author winking at us while simultaneously setting up a thematic framework that's gonna pay off later. The dialogue throughout this chapter is surprisingly punchy for what's essentially a setup scene. Master Liu's arrogance comes through in his speech patterns — short, declarative sentences, lots of 'Of course!' energy. Chu Qianli's lines are longer, more self-deprecating, full of qualifiers and hedge words, which makes her eventual shift into directness more impactful. The banter between Qi Yan and Chu Qianli at the start has that comfortable rhythm that only comes from established friendship.
... Read More
Okay so the media company visit is honestly one of the funniest scenes this book has ever produced and I have never laughed this hard at a divination-based rejection before. Chu Qianli walking into that practice room, seeing these trainees, and her entire spiritual compass just short-circuiting is genius writing. She's a person who claims to believe in natural laws and Marxism, but then her face literally says "I need to escape this punishment." The image of her cowering behind Tan Muxing like a startled cat while Qiu Qingkong is desperately holding her backpack strap — I could see this as a film. Just pure visual comedy. And her line about rocks! "No matter how much you try to eat a rock, it's still a rock. It's just inedible by nature." That's not astrology. That's just raw, unfiltered honesty wrapped in a metaphor. She looked at decades of fortune-telling experience and concluded that some things are just... not fixable. Not by crystals, not by rituals, not by any known mystical method. The worldbuilding detail I loved most was how the company was set up — specific zones, practice rooms, the whole entertainment industry machinery. It felt real, not like a generic backdrop. You could smell the sweat and desperation in that practice room just from her reaction. Also the fact that Qiu Qingkong's dad is apparently always getting scammed is such a lovely running joke woven into the world. This family has problems.
... Read More
This chapter is a masterclass in how to raise stakes without changing genre. One minute you're reading about teenagers calling each other nicknames during self-study and the next you're sitting at a teahouse table while someone casually drops that a five-billion-dollar selection process for metaphysical consultants is about to begin. The conflict here operates on at least three levels simultaneously. First, there's the external conflict — this mysterious client with absurd money and vague requirements, screening multiple masters across the country. Second, there's Chu Qianli's internal conflict between her desire to avoid responsibility ('solve the unemployment problem of this poor student') and the fact that she's already deep in metaphysical research on her own. Third, and this is the one the author doesn't state outright, there's the temporal pressure — Chu Qianli herself says she can foresee 'an old acquaintance would visit' and that she'll be busy with something else soon, so she's racing against her own future to prepare now. The line 'From my calculations, I'll be busy with something else in a while, so I won't have the energy for this' is genuinely chilling when you think about it. She knows something is coming. She's trying to stockpile knowledge and skills before whatever arrives takes her attention elsewhere. That's not setup — that's a countdown.
... Read More
"When a section of the pipeline at the factory in Province T was dismantled, a large stone rolled out. No one knew where it had come from. The following week, the old factory experienced no further malfunctions. Considering the two factories were in different provinces, the incident baffled everyone." I need to sit with this. A stone rolls out of a pipeline in Province T—a province where Boss Zhang doesn't even have an operation connected to his main factory—and suddenly everything stops breaking? What is that stone? Is it symbolic? Is it literal? Or is the story asking us to stop distinguishing between the two? This is the book's central question really: what is the relationship between cause and effect, and who gets to define which is which? Boss Zhang sees it as a practical victory. "This little girl has some real skill," he says. He's already reduced cosmic justice to a business consultation. But the stone—from nowhere, from somewhere else entirely, rolling out of a pipe that has no business containing it—is the story whispering: something moved, and something was displaced. And that fortune-teller's line again: "Good fortune, bad fortune, regret, and shame all arise from movement." The stone MOVED. The pipeline was DISMANTLED. Boss Zhang MOVED away from accountability. And every time someone tries to move fate around without addressing the root, something else rolls out of the pipes. I'm not sure the book is saying Chu Qianli's methods are wrong. I think it's asking whether Boss Zhang will actually change, or whether he'll just collect enough good fortune to gamble again.
... Read More
Let me just sit with this for a second. A teacup. A single ceramic vessel sitting on a table, held up near a camera lens, and suddenly the entire power dynamic of an online industry shifts. The stakes in this chapter operate on multiple levels simultaneously, and the author manages to escalate each one without ever breaking the casual tone. At the lowest level, there is the troll — a single viewer threatening to 'wreck her stall.' This is petty, almost comical. But Chu Qianli handles it with such chilling accuracy that the threat dissolves into genuine fear. The stakes here are trivial but the psychological escalation is real: the man goes from angry to spooked to nervously defensive in under five minutes. At the middle level, there is the professional rivalry with Yahui. This is where the actual industry stakes live. Viewers are comparing pricing models, questioning ethics, defending their favorite fortune-tellers. The comment section becomes a battleground where reputations are won and lost through sheer volume of opinion rather than demonstrated skill. And Yahui — brilliant antagonistic architect that she is — refuses to engage directly, knowing that participation legitimizes the competition. But then the author drops the birth time rectification challenge and everything changes. This is no longer about who has the better marketing or the louder fanbase. This is about a technical skill that even skeptical viewers acknowledge is genuinely impressive. An astrologer who can do this accurately 'could be teaching at institutions instead of messing around on streaming platforms.' That single line raises the stakes from entertainment competition to professional credibility test. And internally, Chu Qianli faces her own conflict: she recognizes her advantage lies partly in circumstances she did not earn and cannot control. The wealthy environment, the beautiful teaware, the mountain backdrop — these are not skills. They are accidents of birth. Yet she chooses to lean into them strategically rather than feel guilty about them. That is a fascinating moral conflict to embed in what appears to be a lighthearted chapter.
... Read More
The worldbuilding in this chapter is deceptively simple on the surface—just a modern high school with physical fitness tests and basketball practice—but the author layers in enough texture that the setting actually feels alive. The opening lines about wealthy families comparing grades and hobbies immediately establish the social hierarchy of this school. This isn't just any school; it's one where your family's status follows you into report cards. That detail does so much work in one sentence. Then there's the sports field scene. I love how the author contrasts the organized chaos of the physical test with the quiet corner where Chu Qianli is crouching. Everyone else is participating, performing, being normal. She's on the margins, doing divinations, completely separate. The visual of her pressed against the wall while her deskmate stands guard is almost cinematic. And the basketball court—'a sharp throw, a basketball slammed hard against the rim'—the sound design in that moment is incredible. You can hear the bounce, the warning shouts, the impact. The author writes physical space the way a filmmaker shoots it: wide shots of the line of students, close-up on Chu Qianli's anxious face, then sudden motion when the ball enters frame. The walk back to class with the open basketball court alongside them, the sound of bouncing balls creating background rhythm—it's all very sensory. This school feels like a real place where magical incidents could plausibly happen alongside mundane ones.
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter are enormous and the entire conversation happens at what feels like a casual volume. That's what makes it so tense. He Shichen's external conflict is obvious — he's torn between leaving this house and something pulling him back. But the INTERNAL conflict is where it gets real. He's convinced he's the perpetrator now, the one wronged by a baby swap, and he's bracing for war. Chu Qianli sees right through it. Not in a smug way, but almost clinically. She names his dark thoughts before he can weaponize them. When she says "You're just thinking how much better it would be if I disappeared" — that's not an accusation, it's a diagnosis. And the Rupert's Drop metaphor? That's her telling him she knows exactly what breaks him. His pride, his control, his entire identity built on being the smart one in the room. The fact that HE ends up sitting down on that bench, pulled back in by her words, means she's the one holding the strings. But here's the thing that really gets me — neither of them is fighting for love or loyalty. They're fighting over POWER. Over who gets to define what happened with the baby swap. That's dark. And then she reveals she knew all along and still chose this life. The stakes just shifted again. Now it's not about revenge or justice, it's about WHY she stayed.
... Read More
What struck me most about these chapters isn't any grand spectacle but rather the quiet intimacy of ordinary school life layered with these mystical undertones. The scene where Chu Qianli pulls the tarot deck out of her uniform pocket and hands him the Fool card - you can just picture it. Two students on what seems like a normal school day, but then this card with its imagery of someone standing at a cliff's edge, pure white rose in hand, suddenly makes the whole setting feel charged with meaning. The classroom becomes a stage where astrology and real human emotion intersect. Even the smaller scenes do this. Qiu Qingkong hurrying back from asking about filming techniques, finding out two companions got into a bully altercation - it all feels lived-in. You can see the group chat, the phone scrolling, the casual way they bounce ideas around about video themes. The world feels grounded despite the astrological elements because it's rooted in these everyday interactions. The school setting, the uniforms, the phone calls home, the online book orders for clothing design - it's all so specific and tactile that you never forget these are teenagers navigating real lives, even as they dabble in tarot and natal charts.
... Read More
Okay, let's talk about the objects. The compass. The Tarot cards. The red crystal. These aren't props—they're worlds. When Tan Muxing pulls out the appraisal results and says the compass might be from the Ming dynasty, I could practically see Chu Qianli's eyes widen. She held it like it was nothing—"Grandpa didn't treasure it at all when he used it"—and now it's worth more than she'll ever know. That contrast between use and value, between ignorance and discovery, is so visceral. The appraiser's line about the economic boom, the flourishing craftsmanship industry, the refined technique... It made me want to Google 17th-century Chinese navigation instruments immediately. But the red crystal? That's the hook. Lyle Gadbury's Tarot cards from the 18th century, a Ming dynasty compass, both using the same unidentifiable material. Two artifacts from different continents, different centuries, different purposes—and they share a genetic link. The text says it plainly: "These two items were created in vastly different places and centuries apart, yet they shared an extraordinary connection." Extraordinary doesn't cover it. Mysterious doesn't begin. And the setting—the house, the table, Auntie Li bringing fruit and drinks, retreating to the kitchen like a period drama extra. It's domestic, ordinary, safe. Which makes the fact that someone tried to break in to steal from them hit even harder. The contrast between the mundane (homework, summer vacation, university applications) and the extraordinary (antique compasses, unidentifiable crystals, supernatural inheritance) is what makes this world feel alive. It's not a fantasy novel where magic is everywhere—it's our world where magic is hiding in plain sight, tucked into Grandpa's junk drawer.
... Read More
There's a lot happening beneath the surface in these chapters that I think deserves its own space. The imagery keeps circling back to two opposing forces: the sky above and the earth below, knowing and not knowing, fate and choice. The stars. Chu Qianli's grandfather was a feng shui master, and Tan Muxing is described as someone who 'only knows how to observe the stars and moon, absorbing their essence.' Meanwhile, Wang Ping is digging in the dirt, raising chickens, serving soup made from vegetables pulled straight from the ground. One character looks up, the other looks down. Neither is wrong. Both are needed. Then there's the chicken coop — Chu Qianli poking at it with a stick, examining something small and alive and confined, while Tan Muxing watches her from a distance. It feels accidental but it's not. She's a person who reads patterns in the sky, and here she is, bent over a chicken coop in the dark, trying to understand something that lives in the dirt. The metaphor writes itself. The philosophical core of these chapters is about knowledge as both burden and gift. Chu Qianli's position — that knowing the future doesn't change it, that sometimes it's better not to know — is genuinely compelling. But Tan Muxing flips it: for ordinary people who can't choose whether to seek out readings or not, knowledge is the only agency they have. The siege metaphor he uses is perfect — trapped either way, but at least knowing gives you a chance to fight. What's haunting me is the idea that Chen Lili's tragedy isn't that she was doomed — it's that she was warned and chose anyway. And maybe that's the point. Maybe the story isn't about whether fate can be changed but about whether the attempt matters.
... Read More
There's a lot happening beneath the surface of these chapters, and I want to pull at a few threads. The central symbol is probably the river. Liu Kaijia arrives at a river on a one-way street. He can't go back. He can't cross. He can only stand there and call his master. The river feels like fate itself—moving in one direction, indifferent to his frustrations, impossible to negotiate with. And the fact that he's a fortune teller, someone whose entire profession is supposedly about predicting and controlling outcomes, makes his powerlessness by the river all the more pointed. He can calculate stars but he can't calculate a cab route or catch a bicycle. "Karma" is the other big symbol, and it's loaded with meaning. Tan Muxing carries the label of "killing karma" from a past life he doesn't remember. But here's the thing—the story keeps showing us that he hasn't actually DONE anything bad. He's a gentle kid who accidentally hurt someone while being tugged over a toy. His "crime" is accidental violence, not malice. So the karma label is questionable, maybe even unjust. It becomes a metaphor for how society brands people based on things they didn't choose and may never have done. The Tan estate itself is a powerful symbol. It's vast but confining. Beautiful but haunted. Full of memories that both comfort and terrify Tan Muxing. The long corridor he walks down is like a timeline—stretching back to his childhood, leading toward an uncertain future. The plants and trees haven't changed, which means time stands still for the estate even as people move through it. It's a graveyard of moments. There's also the symbolism of hiding. Young Tan Muxing hides behind a secret door. Adult Tan Muxing hides behind politeness and distance. Liu Kaijia hides behind arrogance. The fortune teller hides behind calculations. Everyone in this story is concealing something—either from others or from themselves. The one-way street where the novel opens is perhaps the most economical symbol in the text. Life moves forward. You can't detour. You can't change direction. And sometimes you miss the people you're looking for because the road only goes one way. I keep thinking about that last line of the excerpt, cut off mid-sentence: "The injured child was taken to the infir." The sentence breaks off like the memory itself—fragmented, incomplete, unable to reach a satisfying conclusion. Just like Tan Muxing's understanding of his own past.
... Read More
Can we talk about how funny this is? Like, genuinely funny, not just witty but the kind of comedy that makes you want to reread passages? Chu Qianli telling Boss Zhang to sell his house and car, then when he brings the money she's already calculated the timeline for property transfers and anticipated his half-assed effort—that's not exposition, that's a character study in dialogue form. She doesn't say 'I anticipated you'd be dishonest.' She says 'I don't even need to calculate to know you're holding something back.' Which is both a flex and a threat wrapped in one sentence. The heavily made-up woman's dialogue is pure theater. 'You can't sell! Those are mine!' and then later 'Nonsense! You're just a fraudster pretending to be a fortune-teller!' She's so committed to her victim narrative that she misses the irony completely. Meanwhile Chu Qianli's response—'Oh come on. They say too much money can bring trouble. I'm just worried it might burn you out, so I'm helping you take on this burden. How can you be so ungrateful?'—is so deadpan absurd that I literally gasped. She's weaponizing fortune-teller speak to make a thief feel guilty. Boss Zhang's voice is distinct too. Short, practical sentences. 'Priorities, woman!' He doesn't get dramatic. He gets efficient. Even when he's being a terrible husband, he's efficient about it. Tan Muxing's dialogue is sparser but purposeful. He's the audience surrogate mostly, asking the questions we'd ask. 'Are you really going to help him?' That's his job in these scenes—to ground Chu Qianli's strangeness in normal human confusion. The author's narrative voice has this dry, slightly sardonic undertone that never quite commits to being ironic. It's earnest about the comedy without winking at the reader. That's a harder balance to strike than it looks.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or