The Greatest Astrologist - Reviews

The Greatest Astrologist
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The author literally numbers Chu Qianli's methods of destroying He Shichen: 1. Blow him up, 2. Make him socially dead, 3. Drive him to death from anger. And then says the lethality increases from low to high. I screamed. This is such a perfect framing device for the entire conflict in this story. Because what are the actual stakes here? On the surface, it's a girl disrupting a prestigious school. But underneath, it's about power—who controls the narrative of the He family, who gets to define what 'respectable' looks like, and whether blood relation means anything when two people are fundamentally incompatible. He Shichen is fighting a war on three fronts simultaneously. Academically, he's the top student and former heir—he has to maintain perfection. Socially, his family's reputation is under attack by someone sharing his DNA. Emotionally, he can't even be angry at her directly because that would look petty, and if he ignores her, she keeps getting worse. The brilliance of the opening scene is that the conflict is established before a single word is spoken. Chu Qianli walking out of the changing room in BOYS' PANTS is already a declaration of war. Every choice she makes—from not wearing the skirt to napping during class—is a calculated move that strips away He Shichen's ability to control the situation. She's not rebelling against authority. She's rebelling against the very concept of him needing to control anything. And the stakes keep climbing because the more she naps, the more he seethes, and the more the classmates whisper. It's a pressure cooker and nobody's letting the lid off.
... Read More
Okay so can we talk about how perfectly calibrated this pairing is? I mean, they're sitting around going through Chu Qianli's grandpa's stuff and the energy is just… right. Not overly sweet, not awkward either. It's that comfortable silence people only reach after knowing each other for a while. The compass moment was everything. Tan Muxing notices something interesting about the crystal—'Is the red crystal magnetic?'—and instead of just leaving it at that, he sticks around. He doesn't walk away when she starts digging through tarot cards. He helps her find the deck. He watches her get absorbed in her thoughts. That's not casual friend behavior. That's someone who genuinely pays attention to what she's doing. And then there's the gem explanation scene where he casually drops knowledge about corundum and Chu Qianli responds with 'Your explanation gave me a real sense of class disparity.' BRO. She literally turned his intelligence into a joke about how rich kids learn gems for fashion instead of appraisal. But the way she says it—with a smile, half-joking—feels like the kind of thing you say to someone you feel safe with. Meanwhile, Tan Muxing growing up in Beijing and being completely blindsided by rural village politics? That contrast matters. It shows they bring different worlds to this partnership. He's grounded, practical, observant. She's intuitive, creative, unafraid to dive headfirst into something she barely understands. Neither one makes the other feel small for their differences. The most telling moment? When she decides to learn rain-praying rituals at the last minute like it's cramming for an exam. And he's just… there. Watching. Questioning. Not stopping her, not fully believing her, but staying in the room while she does it. That's the relationship dynamic I'm here for. They don't complete each other—they COMPLETE each other's blind spots. But seriously, when is this going to cross from 'desk mates' to something more? Because I'm tired and the tension is doing NOTHING
... Read More
Okay so this whole arc started with Yu Shen being sick and everyone conveniently hiding it from He Shichen because of his competition, which already feels like typical family-drama setup. But then the real twist hits when he walks in on that hospital scene — Chu Qianli making his mom laugh, He Zhenghe clapping along, the whole warm fuzzy family tableau — and something just snaps in his head. He decides he doesn't belong here. Like, full-on midnight-sneak-out-with-a-suitcase level of realization. The plot thickens when Chu Qianli is literally waiting for him outside in the courtyard watching cartoons, casually dropping the line "running away from home in the middle of the night is what's truly brainless." And the best part? She apparently divined this would happen. That girl is weirdly omniscient at the worst (or best) possible moments. I love how the author builds this tension where He Shichen is caught between his desire to leave and his inability to just walk past a complaining little sister. He even tries to explain himself — "I'll explain everything to Dad tomorrow" — but Chu Qianli just refuses to move. The whole confrontation feels like it's building toward something bigger, and honestly I need to know what happens next. Is he really going to run, or is this just another emotional turning point?
... Read More
Can we talk about how vividly this chapter moves between worlds? We open in a library—Chu Qianli sneaking her phone, Tan Muxing as cover, Qiu Qingkong focused on homework, Qi Yan smiling knowingly. The scene is claustrophobic in the best way. You can feel the tension of those three people trying not to get caught while He Shichen's 'icy stare' looms over them like some kind of academic dragon. The image of Chu Qianli 'shrinking behind Tan Muxing for cover' is so visually specific—it's almost cinematic. Then we shift to the group chat world, which is its own kind of space. The digital rebellion—creating secret group chats, changing avatars, negotiating rules—is portrayed with such attention to modern social dynamics. When Qi Yan chooses an avatar of 'Tong Ze Ailie, the reincarnation of Kurokori' and He Shichen picks 'Kihiko Mizuno,' the older brother of Sakura Kinomoto... this is worldbuilding through fandom references. It tells us these characters exist in a world where anime matters, where two-dimensional and three-dimensional worlds collide. The library scene itself is richly detailed: the five of them studying together, the contrast between He Shichen's 'large volume of classic questions' approach and Qi Yan's 'flexible thinking' method, Chu Qianli's desperate attempts to deflect. The tension builds until she's 'caught red-handed just after finishing the first stage performance video.' And then—the birthday scene! 'Warm yellow lights were on, decorative streamers were hanging on the walls, and the table was filled with sumptuous dishes.' This domestic warmth contrasts sharply with the academic pressure preceding it. Aunt Li in the kitchen, Yu Shen hurrying out, He Yuanyuan apologizing for traffic—these sensory details create a living, breathing world. The shift from cold exam halls to warm family gatherings feels intentional, like the story is saying: 'yes, pressure exists, but so does love.'
... Read More
Most people will read this passage and laugh at the comedy beats—which is totally valid, the humor is genuine and consistent—but I keep coming back to this one quiet moment: Tan Muxing thinking 'He didn't know much about Chu Qianli's past, but it seemed she had missed out on many childhood experiences.' That's it. Four sentences later the group is already joking about astrology content creation and I nearly missed it too. But it landed like a stone in my chest. Chu Qianli, who has built this entire persona around astrology and divination and being the 'mysterious transfer student,' is actually someone who grew up without the cultural touchstones that her peers take for granted. The Clow Cards anime reference isn't just a cute Easter egg—it's evidence of a gap. She's reaching for connection through shared interests, through the group chat, through reading old anime blogs at midnight. And Tan Muxing, of all people, notices this absence without judgment. He doesn't pity her. He just observes it with this gentle sadness that says he understands what it means to also feel unlabeled, to also not quite fit the mold. Their friendship isn't built on grand declarations. It's built on the small, unspoken recognitions. The 'big fluffy bear' nickname. The shared silence on the walk home. I'm not crying, you're crying.
... Read More
This chapter is a pacing masterclass and I need to talk about how it shifts gears. It opens with the absolute lightest tone—alarm clocks, messy rooms, playing cards, the comedic breakfast exchange. You're laughing, you're relaxed, you think this is just a cute slice-of-life story. Then Qiu Qingkong bursts in and suddenly we're in business territory. More comedy. Pun jokes, pricing discussions, Tan Muxing's media family reveal. Still fun, still light. And then—bam. Chu Qianli drops this entire philosophical framework about astrology and the people who need it most. "Those with power and influence might use the stars to consolidate their position, but the ones who really need the stars may never encounter them in their entire lifetime." The tonal shift is so sudden it nearly gave me whiplash, and yet it works because everything leading up to it was building toward this moment of genuine depth. The author isn't afraid to let the comedy breathe before hitting you with something heavy. The pacing feels natural, like a real conversation that meanders through jokes and observations before landing on something that actually matters. And then it ends mid-thought with Chu Qianli sighing that "many people oppose me"—leaving us hanging on a cliffhanger of ideas rather than plot. Smart structural choice.
... Read More
This chapter is obsessed with the question: what makes a child actually belong to a family? He Shichen spent seventeen years being the He family's heir, dressed perfectly, educated at elite schools, carrying himself like he owned every room. And then he finds out his biological parents are poor, shallow, malicious people who swapped him for their own child just to scam money. His father died in the hospital without getting a single penny. All that pride—shattered. Meanwhile Chu Qianli walks in wearing dusty clothes, with messy short hair, completely unbothered, already assessing the feng shui and bargaining with her new dad about star luck and money transfers. She has zero shame about where she came from. She doesn't perform belonging—she just belongs. The swapped babies trope is everywhere in fiction, but what's interesting here is how the text sets up an immediate power struggle. He Shichen thinks Chu Qianli might return "filled with anger and hatred" or be "shy and lacking in ability." But she's NEITHER. She's calm, witty, and completely at ease. The real threat to his position isn't a rival who plays by the rules—it's someone who never needed to in the first place. "Even though he was a despicable beneficiary, he was still the heir nurtured by the He family and could never willingly hand everything over." That line hit me hard. He knows his claim is built on a lie, but he won't surrender it. So what happens next when two kids who both deserve to be here finally collide?
... Read More
Okay so this whole sequence with Grandpa Qi is basically the emotional anchor of these chapters and I need to talk about it. He's giving away advice like he's already planning his exit—"after I'm gone, you two can do whatever you like." And Qi Yan's reaction? That sharp pain in her heart? Chef's kiss. The author doesn't overplay it, just one line and suddenly you feel how heavy this old man's calm acceptance is. Then the whole Xixi naming thing unfolds like a puzzle. Chu Qianli gets the birth dates, casts an oracle, and BOOM—figures out the name is poisoning the father's health. It's such a clever resolution because it ties together family drama, mystical elements, and actual consequences. The Tarot painting and armillary sphere subplot is basically the author setting up future plot threads—Chu Qianli getting things from Grandpa Qi, Qi Yan handling the divination herself next time. Classic setup. But honestly what stuck with me most is how Grandpa Qi wraps everything up with this weirdly cheerful energy. "As long as things return to normal, I'll have no regrets!" After literally talking about his own death like a grocery list. The pacing here is great—tension from the family confrontation, then a quiet room, then a mystical diagnosis, then warmth. It never drags.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Tan Muxing's internal monologue because it was honestly the funniest thing in this whole chapter. He literally goes from watching his desk mate casually stream to having a full philosophical crisis in real time. First he thinks she's radiating a 'Buddhist-like glow'—you know, like she's transcending the drama, above it all. Then he corrects himself: 'Maybe she wasn't pretending to be pure. Her words clearly inverted right and wrong—this was unmistakably a black lotus in disguise.' That's when I actually laughed out loud. This kid is sitting there doing homework, half-listening to a livestream that's essentially a digital bloodsport, and he's writing literary analysis on his desk mate's moral compass like it's a class essay. But here's the thing—I love that dynamic. Most stories would have the observer character either join the fight or be completely useless. Instead, Tan Muxing is this quiet anchor who watches Chu Qianli escalate from chill streamer to calculated predator, and his reactions are like a running commentary on exactly how terrifyingly competent she actually is. The relationship between them hasn't been explored much in these chapters, but moments like this tell you everything. He's not impressed; he's recalibrating his understanding of her. And honestly? That's way more interesting than if he was just cheering her on. It means he's paying attention, which makes me wonder what else he notices that other characters miss.
... Read More
Okay so first of all, I need to talk about Chu Qianli's absolute pivot when she finds out Tan Muxing's family owns an entire mountain. This woman goes from calling him "bro" to begging to call him "big brother" in like two seconds flat. "I called you my bro too soon; I was too hasty" — I literally laughed out loud. The fact that her immediate thought was NOT about his humility or how he handled being bullied, but rather "can I benefit from this"? That's peak Chu Qianli. She's not even pretend-about it, she just owns it. But here's what actually hit me — Tan Muxing's response. "...He Shichen will get mad." He's blushing, stuttering, genuinely uncomfortable with the whole situation. The text says it all: he could've crushed people at school with his family's power but chose silence instead. That's not weakness, that's a choice. And the fact that he still lets Chu Qianli drag him into her livestream scheme despite being awkward about everything? That's friendship. Or at least, tolerance of the highest order. The contrast with Ya Hun is crazy when you think about it. One person using fake powers to scam people for attention/money, another person with REAL power choosing to stay invisible. Who's actually the more dangerous one? Also watching Chu Qianli weaponize her poverty against Tan Muxing's wealth by immediately offering to do free readings for random commenters while sitting in his mansion? The energy is immaculate.
... Read More
I need to talk about this absolutely unhinged exchange between Chu Qianli and Tan Muxing at the very beginning: "Yuqing starts with Qing, the true talisman unites in harmony, and moves forth..." Chu Qianli recited softly, then hesitated. "What's this character? I forgot how to pronounce it." Faced with his classmate, who couldn't even read the chant fluently, Tan Muxing was exasperated. "I just remembered—we haven't done any homework since we got back to the village." "That's not the primary issue right now!" "But I think this character appears in our Chinese homework..." The two of them pulled out their summer homework and used the classical Chinese reading section to fill in the gaps in their knowledge. I literally screamed. You are telling me these two are about to confront corrupt miners and bureaucratic injustice and their immediate response is to check their summer homework?? The tonal whiplash from "ancient talisman chant" to "did you finish your Chinese reading comprehension" is comedic gold. It establishes their dynamic instantly—Chu Qianli is the mystic badass who somehow still doesn't know how to read her own spells, and Tan Muxing is the exasperated straight man who keeps her grounded. Their banter feels natural because it's rooted in something specific: they're classmates who share homework struggles, not characters who randomly have witty conversations. Then Wang Ping comes back and drops the absolute truth bomb: "That's why I can't stand government officials; hardly any of them are decent people!" and Chu Qianli's response? "Come on, that's a bit extreme. Let me look up how to file a report. Who says we don't know how to use the internet?" She immediately pivots from Taoist mystic to digital-age activist. The voice shift between characters is so clean here—you can tell who's speaking without tags.
... Read More
The emotional core of this scene isn't in the divination—it's in how Chu Qianli relates to the people around her. Her relationship with Qi Yan is the quiet center of everything. She's winning, dominating, performing—but when the crowd closes in, she shrinks behind Qi Yan. That gesture says everything: she's comfortable enough to be vulnerable, smart enough to know when not to engage. Qi Yan, in turn, stays beside her with teasing commentary and protective positioning. There's no grand declaration, no dramatic moment—just two people who understand each other in a room full of strangers. The Liu Kaijia dynamic is more complicated. At first, he seems like a straightforward antagonist—the rival master who can't handle losing. But as the scene progresses, you feel his genuine distress. He's not a bad man; he's a craftsman whose life's work has just been shown to be limited. When he panics and says “Impossible, you're tricking me!” there's something almost childlike in his denial. The author doesn't let us enjoy his humiliation too much. There's also this wonderful emotional whiplash between her confidence and her awareness. She's bold enough to dismantle a senior practitioner in front of his peers, then immediately backs off when pushed too far (“Alright, alright, no more playing”). She knows her limits. She knows when to stop. That self-awareness makes her feel real rather than overpowered. The crowd's desperation is almost funny but also strangely moving. These people are so hungry for answers—name your granddaughter, name your business, tell me my fortune. The author captures that universal human desire to believe there's a pattern, a system, someone who can make the chaos of life feel ordered. My favorite emotional beat is when she mentions her grandfather casually. “Her grandfather probably had a sect…he didn't care about that. He just taught whatever he wanted.” That single line carries so much warmth. It tells us she's loved, that she comes from people who prioritized joy over rules, that she learned because someone believed she was worth teaching. The personal history behind her skill is understated but deeply felt.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or