I have to talk about the DIALOGUE because this is honestly impressive. Four main voices in these chapters and none of them sound the same.
He Shichen speaks in short, sharp, clipped sentences. "Wake up." "I don't want to see you sleeping in the next class." "What I mean is, you should do something productive!" He doesn't elaborate. He doesn't soften. His dialogue is built for authority, even when he's seventeen. The author doesn't give him any flowery language or self-reflection — he's all surface, all judgment, all ACTION in speech form.
Chu Qianli is the opposite. Her dialogue is loose, associative, occasionally dismissive. "Oh, now there is one. I'm pretty special, you know." "Be confident, the stars just point the way." "You put in more effort in this friendship, and I'll just do a little bit." She trails off. She shrugs. She deflects. Her speech patterns feel like someone thinking out loud rather than performing for an audience. And when she gets serious — like with Tan Muxing — the sentences stretch out and become genuinely thoughtful. The voice SHIFT changes, and you feel it.
Tan Muxing's dialogue is almost entirely HESITANT. Short answers. Qualifiers. "No way!" "I'm nowhere near as good as him!" "Because..." trailing off into vulnerability. When he talks about his crafts, his sentences get longer and more earnest — the only time he speaks without reservation. That's a deliberate character choice by the author, and it's effective.
The cafeteria girls (Qiu Qingkong, Ruan Ya) sound exactly like what they are — teenage gossipers. "But your zodiac signs are really compatible!" "Taurus and Virgo are a perfect match!" Their dialogue is enthusiastic, informal, punctuated with exclamation marks. They sound like people who are excited for someone else's life rather than living their own.
And the humor? Chu Qianli's deadpan delivery is the source of most of it. Tan Muxing calling her a "fortune teller or a scammer" and her responding "Be confident. Take out the 'like' part." That's genuinely funny. It's witty without trying to be. The author doesn't force jokes — they emerge from CHARACTER.
One line that stayed with me: Chu Qianli saying "This is the fate of an astrologer. When you speak honestly, people think it's all fake." That's almost THEMATICALLY loaded — a character acknowledging that her worldview will always be questioned, and doing so with a kind of weary humor.