The Greatest Astrologist - Reviews

The Greatest Astrologist
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I came for the plot and stayed for the warmth and honestly these chapters wrecked me in the gentlest way. There's this one moment — and I don't even know if the author intended it this way — where Tan Muxing is standing on a boulder taking pictures of plants and ants and distant people, and Chu Qianli is somewhere behind him probably complaining about snakes, and Wang Ping is foraging like her life depends on it, and the village chief is watching from below wondering why his friend walks so far to throw someone out. This is a found family. Not because they declared it, but because they show up for each other in specific, unglamorous ways. Tan Muxing carries the basket. Wang Ping cooks what they gather. Chu Qianli brings the wisdom that matters when it counts. And when the mood shifts from peaceful to alarmed, none of them hesitate — they all pivot together toward the problem. The line that got me was Chu Qianli's sudden seriousness about the Four Sacred Sands. She spends most of these chapters joking and lounging and being scolded by Wang Ping, and then in one moment her voice changes and she's talking about something her grandfather cared deeply about, something she apparently didn't even bring a compass to check because she was so relaxed. That loss of innocence — the realization that the mountain she played on as a child is now under threat — that's the emotional core of this passage. It's quiet. It doesn't scream. But it lands.
... Read More
This batch is structured like someone slowly tightening a screw. It opens with Chu Qianli's internal monologue about the Tarot paintings — exposition-heavy, but necessary, and it establishes her motivation clearly. Then it pivots to her scheme forming, the conversation with Qi Yan where both are dancing around the real topic, then the family preparation scene that's almost comedic in its domestic normalcy before everything goes sideways. The birthday banquet arrival is where the pacing really shifts. The description of the villa area, the luxury cars, the celebrities, the festive decorations — it's all sensory overload. And then Chu Qianli starts feeling dizzy, losing focus, overwhelmed. The narrative pace slows down almost imperceptibly here, matching her internal state. You can feel the atmosphere getting heavier even as the surface events stay light. The transition from the warm, slightly comedic family scene (Chu Qianli being dramatic about clothes and gifts) to the cold, tense mansion interior is brutal. One moment she's cheering about being a mama's girl, the next she's walking into a house full of strangers where someone is dead (Liyang), the grandfather is possessed by superstition, and a mysterious master has been brought in by the second uncle. And it ENDS on a cliffhanger that's almost cruel — Ji Yagen starts explaining about the grandfather's obsession and then trails off with "it's all because of the thing with Liyang. If it weren't for him, your grandfather wouldn't..." The sentence is unfinished. The chapter breaks there. I literally had to stop and stare at the ceiling for a minute.
... Read More
'Xingxing, Xingxing, Polar Bear Xingxing, Zhi Shi Xingxing...' I am literally dying. This scene is everything. The way Tan Muxing goes from cool stoic guy to full-blown flustered mess just because Chu Qianli decides to call him his childhood nickname? The contrast is so perfectly written. He's been this unreadable character who refuses to believe in metaphysics, who has 'strong resistance' built up from being hurt before — and she pierces through all of that not with grand romance gestures but with the most casual, playful thing possible. A nickname. And his response? Covering his ears like a child. Meanwhile she's just delighted, turning it into a chant. The subtext here is massive. When she says 'I'll make sure to be a civilized person. Otherwise, when I say 'Damn it, Xingxing,' it'll still hit you too' — that's Chu Qianli being Chu Qianli, and it's adorable and so telling. She's testing boundaries, pushing buttons, and he's letting her. This dynamic where she initiates and he reacts is giving main couple energy without either of them acknowledging it. Also the fact that he gets embarrassed about his grandfather's name being reduced to 'Xiaozhi' in the journal? That's someone who cares about family history, even if he won't admit to believing in the mystical stuff.
... Read More
I'm convinced the author wrote this whole scene just to show off how good they are at dialogue, because every line is doing triple duty. Let me give you examples because I cannot stop quoting: "Can you tell me when I'll get married then?" — Teacher Liu, immediately abandoning all her previous dignity the second she thinks there's a real answer. Perfect. "Wasting money and getting nothing in return is just sad!" — Chu Qianli, turning emotional manipulation into a joke about financial efficiency. Iconic. "Are you trying to use feudal superstitions to defeat my parents' decision?" — Teacher Liu's internal monologue. The fact that this thought exists in the text without being spoken out loud is such a smart narrative choice. It's her reacting to Chu Qianli's solution without having to address the absurdity directly. "I still wish the star chart could give people some privacy." — Teacher Liu's closing line of the scene. This is the line that defines her entire character: she wants connection but she wants it on her terms, she wants mystery preserved even as she opens herself up. And Chu Qianli's voice is SO distinct — short sentences, exclamations, switching registers from professional astrologer to chaotic little sibling in the span of three lines. The author never lets them sound the same, which is the mark of genuinely good dialogue writing. Most web novels I read have every character sound like the author, but here Teacher Liu's voice is measured and slightly exasperated while Chu Qianli's is rapid-fire and fearless. When they talk to each other, you can hear both frequencies playing at once.
... Read More
There's a layer beneath this chapter that I think deserves attention, and it's hiding in plain sight. The repeated motif of 'two-dimensional world' vs 'three-dimensional world' isn't accidental. When Chu Qianli mutters about how 'the two-dimensional world can't blend into the three-dimensional world,' she's articulating something much deeper about identity and belonging. These characters exist in a world where anime avatars, fan references, and fictional symbols matter—and that matters THEMATICALLY. Consider the avatar choices: Qi Yan picks Tong Ze Ailie (reincarnation of Kurokori)—a character associated with transformation and hidden identity. He Shichen picks Kihiko Mizuno—associated with being the protective older brother, the one who watches over others. Even their avatars are statements about their roles in this story. The 'cash machine' metaphor—He Shichen forcefully joining the group chat to monitor Chu Qianli—symbolizes how institutional power operates. He's not just a boyfriend; he's a supervisor, a monitor, a gatekeeper. His 'stern teaching method' contrasts with Qi Yan's 'gentle approach,' and together they represent two philosophies of control. Then there's the birthday celebration. Warm yellow lights, decorative streamers, sumptuous dishes—these symbolize warmth, family, acceptance. They're the antidote to the cold pressure of academic achievement. The story seems to be asking: what matters more? Test scores or the people who love you? And the recurring question of 'who will she choose?'—not just about romance but about which philosophy of life she'll adopt. Will she follow He Shichen's discipline or Qi Yan's flexibility? Or will she forge her own path, as she's done throughout the series?
... Read More
I need to talk about this line. It appeared like a quiet thunderclap in the middle of all this everyday stuff and I just stopped reading for a full minute. "It's better to be a fool than a general." He wrote it somewhere in his head, maybe even on paper, and it's the whole confession he'll never say out loud. He'd rather be the fool beside her than the general who tries to win her. That's not restraint — that's a whole philosophy of love built on self-effacement. And then the birthday gift scene comes in and it's so painfully tender. She asks for both and he just... agrees. No drama, no 'but what if you only like one.' He's already conditioned himself to prioritize her want over his own anxiety. Meanwhile she's over there using astrology as an excuse to skip studying and he's the one gently pulling her back toward responsibility. Who's really taking care of whom? What killed me was the ending of this whole sequence — she runs away from the boy band practice like it's a horror movie and hides behind him. And he sighs and mediates. Of course he does. He's always the buffer between her and the world, always absorbing the chaos so she doesn't have to. That's love. That's also kind of exhausting to watch, you know? I kept wanting to shake him and say "what do YOU want?" But then she looks at him with those pleading eyes and I get it. He wouldn't have it any other way.
... Read More
I know this sounds weird because Yahui is definitely not the protagonist, but can we talk about the one moment that made me actually feel something in this entire chapter? When Chu Qianli sends the birth chart privately and Yahui's phone buzzes? The text says her 'face turned pale' and she 'felt a chill run through her limbs.' That's it. Two sentences. But I felt that. I genuinely felt theterror of having your most protected secret calculated by someone who clearly knows what they're doing. It's interesting because the rest of the chapter is so absurdly over-the-top—the gift wars, the chaotic chat, the fake crystal powder discussion—but that one beat of genuine fear from Yahui grounded everything. She's not a cartoon villain here; she's someone who built an empire on image and influence, and in one message, Chu Qianli proved she could dismantle it without even entering the room. There's also this quieter emotional current in how Chu Qianli carries herself. She's not gloating. She's not angry. She's almost... peaceful? The narrative describes her as having a 'Buddhist-like glow' while simultaneously orchestrating one of the most ruthless takedowns in the chapter. That dissonance is fascinating. She's not emotionally invested in the conflict the way Yahui is, and that detachment is itself a weapon. You can't intimidate someone who doesn't seem to care whether you win or lose—they're playing chess while you're still trying to figure out the rules.
... Read More
I need everyone to understand that Tan Muxing might be the most tragically beautiful character I have ever encountered in any novel, and I am not even being dramatic. Let's talk about this kid for a second. He's big, he's strong, he's wealthy, he could have ANYTHING he wants—except he hates what he's good at. His body is built for violence, but he despises violence. He likes making clothes, which is apparently 'useless' to everyone around him because 'these days even warfare is digitized.' Who writes this?! Who sits down and decides that this character's greatest talent is something he loathes?! The cruelty of it is exquisite. And then he drops this line that has been living in my head rent-free: "As long as you lack appearance, no one will notice your inner self. If you can't provide value to others, then you're a dispensable, worthless person." HE IS THE WALTZING KID WHO SEES TOO MUCH. He watches his classmates drift away because hanging out with him means enduring Wang Zheng's harassment, and he doesn't blame them. He literally says it's because his value as a friend 'doesn't outweigh the hassle.' He has internalized the oppression so deeply that he's now policing his own worthiness of love and friendship. But here's what makes his relationship with Chu Qianli so interesting—she's the ONLY person who seems to genuinely see him. She calls him 'amazing' after watching him defend himself. She offers to do a fortune-telling for him, which sounds like a joke but is actually HER way of saying 'I see you, and I want to help.' She recognizes his worth when he can't recognize it himself. And He Shichen! Don't think I forgot about him. The way he watches Chu Qianli from a distance, conflicted about whether to protect her or keep her away from people like Qi Yan—it's giving 'I don't believe in emotions but apparently I'm deeply invested in this one person's wellbeing.' He Shichen, you are so transparent and I love it. The contrast between Chu Qianli (high social value, surrounded by friends because of her abilities) and Tan Muxing (physically powerful but emotionally isolated, filtered out by everyone) is the kind of character pairing that makes you question everything about how society assigns worth.
... Read More
I didn't expect to be this invested in a side character's facial expressions, but here we are. Tan Muxing's entire emotional arc in these chapters is basically him trying not to make things weird after his family background gets exposed. The way he looks back at Chu Qianli "awkwardly," flushes with embarrassment, and then offers a weak "Sorry"—you can literally feel the social discomfort radiating off the page. And Chu Qianli's reaction is perfect because she doesn't know how to process it. She just stares at him internally screaming "This guy betrayed the revolution?!" She's genuinely moved by his apology in the wrong direction, which means she cares about him enough to be confused by his shame. That's... actually kind of sweet when you think about it? The unspoken thing between them is what makes this work. Neither of them acknowledges the class difference as a real problem between them, but Tan Muxing clearly feels it, and Chu Qianli's complete cluelessness about luxury goods and wealth becomes this unintentional act of reassurance. She doesn't care about his money, which somehow makes the whole situation more tender than if she'd said so directly. Also can we talk about how Qiu Qingkong casually drops that Tan Muxing's family has owned clothing brands since his great-grandfather's time and then immediately pivots to business strategy? That girl has zero filter and I love her for it.
... Read More
'What pattern can that possibly be…' STOP I literally chugged coffee reading this line. He Shichen's internal monologue that we don't get to hear out loud but the narration makes clear he's thinking—that moment where he instinctively反驳s her Marxist joke but can't even finish the sentence because the sheer absurdity short-circuits his brain. And then HER response: 'You can argue with me, but don't argue with money!' I AM DEAD. This woman has built an entire philosophical framework around astrology and karma and then caps it with a financial ultimatum like she's a mama explaining why you should eat your vegetables. The tonal register shift is so sharp it should have its own warning label. Let's talk about the car scene dialogue specifically because the author does something really clever here. Chu Qianli's voice is this weird hybrid of deeply spiritual and completely pragmatic. She'll drop a line like 'Among humans, I'm barely all-knowing, but not all-powerful' and then immediately follow it with 'I guess you could call me a semi-god?' like she's discussing the weather. The casual arrogance is SO well-calibrated—it reads as genuine lack of filter rather than performative confidence. He Shichen's voice is the perfect foil. His sentences are shorter, more clipped, more defensive. 'Enough, I don't want to hear this.' 'Aren't you supposedly barely all-knowing among humans? Why don't you know the answers to the homework?' He's always circling back to challenge her, to find the contradiction, to prove she's not as omniscient as she claims. But the narrator keeps telling us his eyes are darkening, his voice is trembling—he's not as composed as his dialogue suggests. The dialogue between them is basically a fight that occasionally remembers it's supposed to be friendly. And the homework scene at the end is peak comedy because it reduces their entire cosmic dynamic to someone just wanting to photocopy page 137. One thing I want to flag: the WeChat messages at the end. The author writes out the exact text of her messages, including the bracketed labels [High emotional intelligence] and [Low emotional intelligence]. This is such a modern, distinctly contemporary touch. It's not just dialogue—it's screenshot dialogue. It makes the characters feel like real people in a real phone. I love that the author doesn't shy away from showing us the unflattering version of her request, the one where she's trying to hack social interaction like it's a software problem. This author's voice throughout is warm but never sappy, and the dialogue carries most of the weight. No overwrought descriptions, no purple prose. Just people talking, failing to talk, and accidentally revealing themselves through what they say and don't say. Also Tan Muxing's '...' response. That's not nothing. That silence says volumes.
... Read More
I have to talk about the DIALOGUE because this is honestly impressive. Four main voices in these chapters and none of them sound the same. He Shichen speaks in short, sharp, clipped sentences. "Wake up." "I don't want to see you sleeping in the next class." "What I mean is, you should do something productive!" He doesn't elaborate. He doesn't soften. His dialogue is built for authority, even when he's seventeen. The author doesn't give him any flowery language or self-reflection — he's all surface, all judgment, all ACTION in speech form. Chu Qianli is the opposite. Her dialogue is loose, associative, occasionally dismissive. "Oh, now there is one. I'm pretty special, you know." "Be confident, the stars just point the way." "You put in more effort in this friendship, and I'll just do a little bit." She trails off. She shrugs. She deflects. Her speech patterns feel like someone thinking out loud rather than performing for an audience. And when she gets serious — like with Tan Muxing — the sentences stretch out and become genuinely thoughtful. The voice SHIFT changes, and you feel it. Tan Muxing's dialogue is almost entirely HESITANT. Short answers. Qualifiers. "No way!" "I'm nowhere near as good as him!" "Because..." trailing off into vulnerability. When he talks about his crafts, his sentences get longer and more earnest — the only time he speaks without reservation. That's a deliberate character choice by the author, and it's effective. The cafeteria girls (Qiu Qingkong, Ruan Ya) sound exactly like what they are — teenage gossipers. "But your zodiac signs are really compatible!" "Taurus and Virgo are a perfect match!" Their dialogue is enthusiastic, informal, punctuated with exclamation marks. They sound like people who are excited for someone else's life rather than living their own. And the humor? Chu Qianli's deadpan delivery is the source of most of it. Tan Muxing calling her a "fortune teller or a scammer" and her responding "Be confident. Take out the 'like' part." That's genuinely funny. It's witty without trying to be. The author doesn't force jokes — they emerge from CHARACTER. One line that stayed with me: Chu Qianli saying "This is the fate of an astrologer. When you speak honestly, people think it's all fake." That's almost THEMATICALLY loaded — a character acknowledging that her worldview will always be questioned, and doing so with a kind of weary humor.
... Read More
Okay, so this entire chapter is basically Chu Qianli weaponizing astrology against these trainees and honestly? Chef's kiss. The whole premise of her sitting in there with these birth charts, cross-checking with her phone, and then blurtin' out whatever uncomfortable truth she finds? That's not just a plot device—that's the funniest running gag in the whole book and it keeps getting better. What really got me is how this scene mirrors the broader stakes. Qiu Qingkong's company is betting everything on this boy band debut, and instead of doing some normal career counseling, she's got this divination thing going on. The comedy hits different when you realize both of them are just terrified the whole thing will flop. Chu Qianli literally says 'I can't control others' fates—I can only offer suggestions' but she's clearly not that great at keeping her own nerves in check either. The way the plot unfolds is brilliant, though. It starts with these individual comedic consultations—first guy denies his true nature, second guy gets exposed about his girlfriend—and then it culminates with Shi Cheng, who actually tells the truth. That moment where he just... admits he's only doing this for money and he knows he's not that talented? 'Honestly, I know that too.' That's such a clean pivot in the narrative. Everyone else was putting on performances, and suddenly you've got this one guy who's refreshingly honest about his mediocrity. The subplot threads are all coming together too. Qiu Qingkong sorting through the debris of her collapsing empire while categorizing trainees by potential scandal risk—that's background worldbuilding that pays off later. And those trainees in the hallway spreading rumors about the 'background checks' is classic dramatic irony setup. They're already scared before the boy band even debuts. 'Luck is just an amplifier. If someone has no ability, no amount of amplification will help.' And honestly, that line works on multiple levels. It's about astrology, sure, but it's also about the entertainment industry itself—talent shows promise overnight success, but without actual skill, the exposure means nothing.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or