The dialogue in this chapter is genuinely exceptional and I want to break down why.
Cecilia's voice is instant and unmistakable. "Aww, but I want to hear more…" The whine. The ellipses. The complete lack of filter. She's a child and the author writes her like one—demanding, impulsive, genuinely enthusiastic about tarts. When she insists "Tarts are delicious!" and then eats two pieces, that's not just dialogue, that's personality.
Jonas is different. His speech is halting, formal, nervous. "Eh, me?" "Y-yes. Understood!" Even when he's trying to be brave for Cecilia, there's this underlying tremor. But then when he asks Simon to sleep with him, it comes out direct and desperate—"Could you sleep with me?!" No hesitation, no fancy words. Just raw need. That shift in his voice is incredible.
Simon's dialogue is sparse but weighted. Every line he says carries more meaning than the words themselves. "You are my son, Jonas." Three words that do three things at once: acknowledge, comfort, claim. "I think rumors require your permission too, don't they?" —that's Simon being Simon. Cold, logical, but with this weird protective undertone.
Tantania's voice is the most layered. She has the formal politeness she uses with society (“It's an honor, but Your Highness…”), the warm affection she shows the children (“Of course, naturally” while stroking Cecilia's hair), and then her inner monologue where she's honestly terrified and confused. The contrast between her outward calm and internal panic is where the real voice lives.
The narrative voice itself is interesting too—it dips into omniscient commentary sometimes (“There are three things gossipmongers love…”) and then pulls back into close third person. It's a style that lets the author hint at bigger themes without breaking the story's immersion.
One line that stuck with me: “Her calm voice wrap around his ears like a swamp.” That's not dialogue but it's narration doing the work of dialogue—Simon's visceral reaction to Tantania's voice, captured in a single比喻.