I rate this at 4 stars primarily due to the relationship dynamics between MC and Curtis, which is something I haven't typically commented on before. Initially, I intended to give it 4 stars but accidentally rated it 3, so I'm correcting it now.
I appreciate the main character, MC, for her relatability and intrigue. The story itself is enjoyable, despite some sexual content, as it doesn't overshadow the plot. However, the peculiar dynamic between MC and Curtis is a sticking point. Initially, I hoped Curtis wouldn't be a romantic interest, but he is.
It's important to consider the backstory here. Curtis' behavior towards MC might not be favorable at first, but it's crucial to remember that he was severely abused by OG!Edith both emotionally and physically. The abuse they both endured creates sympathy for both characters, though their relationship is toxic. Normally, I wouldn't mind toxic relationships in fiction, but in this case, seeing Curtis' vulnerability after being hurt resonates more than it should.
While MC didn't physically abuse Curtis, being in the body of his abuser sometimes leads to insensitive reactions from her, which frustrates me. It's hard to watch Curtis struggle with the emotional scars left by OG!Edith, especially since she's no longer around.
In Chapter 54 pt2, a scene where Curtis reacts painfully to MC's cold demeanor further highlights this issue. It's disheartening to see him still affected by Edith's actions, despite her absence. Overall, the complex emotions and lingering effects of their past make the story engaging, but also uncomfortable in its portrayal of their relationship.