The Duke's Daughter Refuses the Crown Prince's Proposal Again Today - Reviews

The Duke's Daughter Refuses the Crown Prince's Proposal Again Today
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I swear, every time I think this chapter is winding down, the author hits me with something else. Let's trace the pulse here: Chapter 12 starts slow—Seirin and Noah's domestic moment, quiet character work, internal monologues about feelings neither will admit. Then BAM: 'I'm going to meet every single kid who bullied Ariel and make sure they never run their mouths again.' The shift from domestic calm to righteous fury happens in three lines and I'm immediately hooked. The market scene with the thief comes right after the emotional peak of Seirin comforting Ariel in the carriage. That's a deliberate pacing choice—the aftermath of trauma, then immediate action. No breathing room. I was reading at 11 PM and suddenly realized I'd been going for two hours straight. Then Chapter 13 opens with Kasel talking to his father about marriage politics, cuts to Sein having an emotional breakdown about his sister, and drops us right into 'Thief!!!' on page one. The structure is essentially: character drama → political maneuvering → crisis. Three movements, and each one accelerates the tempo. The author knows exactly when to pull back (Noah's quiet staring out the window) and when to push forward (the sword drawn, the noblewoman screaming). It's almost surgical in its timing.
... Read More
Okay first of all, the line 'Not once have you been anything but beautiful in my eyes' from Noah is going to live in my head rent-free. It's so simple and so direct and he says it like he's commenting on the weather. SEIRIN: 'You say that even though you know I eat like a beast?' NOAH: 'I told you, Seirin. Not once have you been anything but beautiful in my eyes.' I'm dead. But the dragon dialogue is where this text really shines. Astana the dragon-woman is like 'Such naive words. That day will never come. As long as humans or anyone else have hearts that reject and desires to conquer.' And Seirin just replies 'Still, I'll try.' Like, bro, you just got thrown a tree by a girl who was fighting your mate, and you're offering to feed her? 'Don't pity me, human. Just kill me instead.' 'I'm not going to kill you, I'm going to help you have your baby.' THIS CONVERSATION. And Gertos, the husband, just walks in, looks at Seirin, says 'You want to help us?' and after she says yes, he tells his wife 'Trust only me' and leaves to fight the Demon King. That's it. That's the entire characterization of this dragon husband. Perfect. Kasel's dialogue though—'Or should I let you write your will right here?' The man is threatening seventeen-year-old princes with death and they're signing papers like they're at a bakery. 'Who's been tormenting Seirin for twelve years?' 'I never tormented her.' 'Ha, really. Are you shameless or just stupid?' THIS DYNAMIC. I can't. And the Crown Prince has proposed 29,999 times. TWENTY NINE THOUSAND. SEIRIN COUNTED. She has a running tally. That's not dialogue, that's a stat sheet.
... Read More
I have to talk about the dress scene because it was one of the most vivid moments in this entire chapter. Seirin spills water on her own dress at dinner—such a human, clumsy moment—and then the Empress offers her a replacement. And what does she get? 'An incredibly extravagant dress' that the text describes as 'so ornate it was overwhelming just to look at. It was awkward to wear something so burdensome, but refusing the Empress's gift was even more unthinkable.' This dress wasn't clothing, it was a SYMBOL. Every glittering thread was another chain around Seirin's freedom. The text says: 'Anyone would think it's the Empress's dress!' Which tells you everything about the court politics—Seirin, a duke's daughter, is being dressed like royalty. Is this generosity or is this a statement? 'Look, we're treating her like an Empress already, because that's where she's going.' The visual of her in that red dress, walking back into the dining hall where everyone is staring and praising her, must have felt like walking onto a stage where she didn't know her lines. And the fountain scene! Noah waiting under the fountain, Seirin sprinting toward him in that ridiculous dress, grabbing his hand. The contrast between the stifling palace interior and the open night air outside—the fountain as a meeting point, a liminal space between duty and freedom. The author really understands how to use settings as emotional barometers. Also the physical comedy of Princess Pesopotemia's 'voluptuous chest enveloping Seirin's small face' while she's trying to breathe? I laughed out loud. It's absurd but it also reveals something—the princess means well but her affection is suffocating, literally. Everything about this world feels alive and layered.
... Read More
There's something deeply symbolic about Kasel's fire magic being literally present in these chapters. He's holding pillars of hot fire in both hands, threatening the twin princes. Fire is his nature—intense, consuming, impossible to ignore. And that's exactly what his affection for Seirin is. He can't help it. It's in his bones. When he says “I wish there would be a day when she smiles at me so sweetly,” that's not just romantic longing, that's someone who understands his own heat is dangerous and he's scared of it. And Seirin? She wants to learn memory alteration. Think about that. She doesn't want to forget him out of hatred—she wants to erase the situation entirely because the pressure of being wanted this loudly, by a crown prince AND a foreign princess, is suffocating her. Her desire to alter memory is really a desire for agency. She's been the object of everyone's attention for twelve years and she's never once been asked what she wants. Even the princess's declaration—“I'll make you queen of my country”—is another form of erasure. She's not asking Seirin, she's offering her a gilded fate. Both men and the princess are projecting their desires onto Seirin, and her counter-move is to literally rewrite minds. It's a beautiful, layered commentary on autonomy wrapped in fantasy romance packaging. The book keeps asking: who gets to choose? And Seirin's answer, quietly, is “me.”
... Read More
'Those girls... And every single one of them...' The way Seirin thinks this without even needing to ask shows such efficient character work. You don't need descriptions when you've established pattern recognition through previous chapters. But the real standout scene has to be the drawing room confrontation. Let me set the stage: Seirin marches into Marquis Loretta's mansion unannounced, sees the guilty party immediately, and basically drags Lady Loretta into a private conversation while everyone else sweats nervously. The atmosphere in that room—every servant frozen, the Marquis clutching his throat, the other ladies backing away—it's like watching a predator enter its prey's territory and immediately taking control. I keep coming back to one line: 'Seirin didn't need to ask Ariel to know.' That's worldbuilding through relationship history, not exposition dumps. We understand these characters' bond because the author trusts us to connect the dots. The physical space matters too. The gate, the drawing room, the carriage waiting outside—it creates a geography of power. Seirin enters as the dominant force, controls the flow, and leaves on her terms. The mansion itself becomes almost a character in this scene, with its hierarchy of servants and nobility mirroring the social dynamics at play.
... Read More
Okay so first of all, can we just talk about how wild it is that Seirin's conclusion after everything is “I need to master memory alteration magic”? Like. The girl just survived being unconscious for two days, dodging both twin princes AND a full-blown princess declaration, and her takeaway is essentially “fuck this, I'm gonna rewrite reality to protect myself.” That's actually brilliant plot design if you think about it. The main thread is still Kasel pursuing her—of course—but here's the twist: he's genuinely sweet in these chapters. The cheek-stroking moment? The “I'll miss you, My Lady”? The way he watches her laugh with Noah and feels that pang? That's not a stalker plot anymore, that's… something messier. He's not forcing anything, he's just heartbreakingly hopeful. And Seirin? She's not playing along. She's plotting her escape route through arcane magic. Meanwhile the princess subplot lands like a comedic nuke. She rolls up with desserts, drops “you can marry me later,” then follows up with “expect it—I'll try to make you fall for me” as she walks away. That's not harassment, that's aggressively wholesome and it completely derails Seirin's emotional state. I literally laughed out loud at Seirin's internal screaming. The Eric-Louis conversation also quietly raises the stakes with Princess Tipetoria and her witch mother history. That's a landmine left planted for later, for sure. The plot is layering threats from multiple directions and I'm here for it.
... Read More
This section operates like a pressure cooker slowly building to—well, not an explosion, but a very uncomfortable simmer. Let me trace the structure. It opens with Isabel's quiet observation about Noah and the 'ten-year-old' being treated harshly. This is a LOW point—intimate, whispered, almost mundane. Then we cut to Chapter 6 with Seirin already IN THE THICK of things, having spilled water and changed dresses. That jump from quiet gossip to active crisis is jarring in the best way—it mirrors how Seirin's life works: one moment you're fine, the next you're trapped at a royal dinner you can't escape. The middle section is where the pacing really shines. Seirin tries to leave the dinner ('Now I just need to find the right moment to slip away!') and each time she gets closer to freedom, someone pulls her back. First the Empress offers a dress (wait, longer). Then the Crown Prince asks her to stay (wait, longer). Then Noah gets invited too (wait, EVEN longer). It's a series of mini-clauses, each one tightening the net. The author uses repetition as a structural device—you feel the trap closing because every escape route gets blocked in sequence. The transition from the dining hall to the fountain is a BREATHING ROOM. Fresh air, night, Noah waiting. It's calm before the next storm. And then—PRINCESS PESOPOTEMIA appears like a tsunami in human form. The pacing shift from quiet intimacy to physical comedy is seamless. You go from 'Noah felt his heart race' to 'Mmmpf! Prin—mmph!' in three seconds flat. Then Chapter 7 opens with MARIANA exploding onto the scene. 'A consort? Who says!' The energy spike is enormous. The author knows exactly when to release tension and when to compress it further. By the end of this batch, the reader is left with three rival factions all circling Seirin, and the question isn't 'will she escape?' but 'when will the system collapse under the weight of everyone wanting her?'
... Read More
'Chapter 12: Burning Up.' On the surface, it's about Seirin learning dangerous magic. But what's she actually burning up? Her patience? Her grief? Her willingness to wait for someone who won't commit? The memory alteration magic is such a perfect symbol here. She wants to literally rewrite someone's mind because the current reality is unbearable. That's not just plot device—that's thematic honesty. What would you do if you couldn't change the past, couldn't fix the present? Maybe you alter the memory itself. Noah's room full of photos—'the wall covered with photos of memories with Seirin'—that's physical proof of emotional accumulation. He's built an archive of moments while she moves through them unaware. The contrast between her forward momentum and his retrospective fixation says everything about their relationship. And then there's the title again: 'Above the Running Lady, Flies the Crown Prince.' Running. Flying. Different speeds, different directions, but both chasing something. Seirin runs toward justice, toward Ariel, toward danger. Kasel hovers above, calculating, manipulating. One is fire, the other is wind—both elemental, both uncontrollable, both dangerous to whoever gets caught between them. The burning isn't just magic. It's desire, grief, rage, ambition—all the things that make people do impossible things for love.
... Read More
Okay so this chapter is pure chaos and I love it. The author just keeps stacking awkward situations on poor Seirin like she's a piñata of misfortune. First the princess won't let her sleep because of snoring, then she collapses at breakfast, then some random rabbit hugs her and turns out to be a prince. What is even happening. But here's what's actually interesting about the structure - the author is setting up this whole romance comedy where Seirin is constantly interrupted from having any peaceful moment by male love interests. Noah tries to confess in the garden, Sein crashes the moment, Kasel is watching from across the table, and then Luel just physically tackles her. It's almost too much comedy. The real plot engine here though is the magic system. Kasel deciding he needs to learn white magic to protect Seirin from black magic is a solid setup. It raises the stakes and gives him a goal beyond just being the grumpy hot knight. That scene where he puts his fist to his chest and swears protection was actually pretty intense for a comedy. Also the rabbit reveal was a great twist. I thought I was reading some weird fanfic where Seirin gets hugged by an actual bunny but nope, it's a prince in disguise. Classic trope but executed well. Who else thought that rabbit was suspicious?? Nobody. I was the only one. And the prince's hair catching fire from her magic and then Noah having to save him with water - the chaos level is unmatched. This chapter also sets up the gift subplot which feels like it'll come back later. The princess wanting to apologize properly and Gerard trying to give her sane advice is funny because she keeps rejecting every option. A white horse? No. Jewelry? No. Something thoughtful? She has no idea what that means. I bet whatever she eventually gives will be either wildly inappropriate or accidentally perfect.
... Read More
I need to just say this outright: the way Noah looks at Seirin is making me feel things I didn't sign up for. He's her childhood friend, her neighbor, the guy who brings her mountainous amounts of food when she wakes up from using magic—and he says things like 'Not once have you been anything but beautiful in my eyes.' BRO. He says it so casually too, like it's just a fact, not a declaration. And Seirin's just eating soup, completely unaware that this guy is practically radiating feelings. But here's what kills me—the sister thing. Ariel, Seirin's sister, she's standing there watching all this affection between her brother and Seirin, and she's thinking 'Neither brother nor father wants me. It would have been better if I had died instead of mother.' And she's covering her mouth so Noah doesn't see her cry because she thinks he already dislikes her. THIS GIRL IS SO LONELY AND NOBODY IS EVEN NOTICING. And then there's Seirin herself, who's supposedly the strongest second-generation mage but really just wants to eat snacks and live quietly. She's this incredibly powerful person who can heal anyone, summon divine beasts (wait, does she have one? I need to recheck), fight dragons with trees, and negotiate with literal monsters—all while being completely oblivious to Noah's feelings and the Crown Prince's absurd persistence. The dynamic between Seirin and the dragons though? That's new. She throws a tree at a dragon to save Noah, then immediately apologizes and offers to feed her? That's so Seirin. She's fierce and soft at the same time, and that combination is dangerous in the best way.
... Read More
"Stop that right now!" Seirin kicks open a carriage door mid-journey and drops into a street fight. That is the pacing of this chapter in a nutshell—zero transition, zero warning, just straight into action like the author doesn't even believe in buffer zones. What I love about how this chapter is structured is that it moves through three completely different energy levels in rapid succession: the thug confrontation (high tension, comedic violence), the dress shopping with friends (warm, low-stakes, chatty), and then immediately pivots to the morning of the ceremony where Seirin is grumbling about not wanting to go (emotional shift, setup for the palace drama). There's no filler between any of these. No "meanwhile, back at the mansion" bullshit. The chapter just keepsMOVING. The thug scene especially is a masterclass in pacing—Seirin identifies the problem,dispatches it physically, applies magical aftermath, heals the collateral damage, and is back in the carriage before Rohan can finish his sentence about the door. Three minutes of narrative time, enormous amount of character establishment. Who is Seirin? Someone who doesn't ask permission, who can bend reality with a spell, who heals her enemies after threatening them, who cares about justice but has absolutely zero patience for bureaucracy. And then it cuts to her eating meringue cookies like nothing happened. The tonal whiplash is intentional and perfect.
... Read More
I keep coming back to this cracked video stone. Kasel snatches it from Sein, it's broken on the outside, but the photos inside are perfect. He kisses Seirin's face in the printed photos. He curates them into an album. He copies some to give to her brother with this casual dismissal. What a devastating object, really. The stone is damaged—representing how damaged Kasel's understanding of Seirin is—but the images inside are pristine, carefully preserved, obsessively collected. He doesn't want the real Seirin who kicks carriage doors and fights thugs and eats twelve meringue cookies in one sitting. He wants the version in the photograph: smiling, hugging a cat, compliant, cute. And the memory magic itself is another symbol that won't leave my head. Seirin plants fragments of memory in people's heads as threats—literal psychological manipulation. Meanwhile Kasel is trying to manipulate Seirin's feelings through persistence and grand gestures. Both are forms of controlling someone's internal world, just at different scales. One is magical, the other is emotional. The parallel is too clean to be accidental. There's also the coming-of-age ceremony itself as a symbol—Seirin standing on the threshold of adulthood, dreading it, refusing to participate mentally while her body is being dressed up for display. "I don't want to go! I really don't want to go!!" She's not ready to be seen the way they want to see her. And the Empire wants to see her. The Crown Prince wants to see her. The Perverted Princess wants to see her. Seirin just wants dessert and quiet and maybe to never have turned sixteen.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or