The Couple Who Hide Their Preferences - Reviews

The Couple Who Hide Their Preferences
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about Celiana. Like. Talk about her. Because this woman is living a whole little novel inside her own head and I am here for it—or maybe I'm just aching for her, depending on the day. There's this one moment that just got me. She's in the carriage, Robert has found the box, and she lies through her teeth saying she doesn't like it. That she'd return it. And the worst part? She meant it when she said it in that moment. She lied because she thought that's what he wanted to hear. But we know better. We know her heart was doing backflips just thinking about using those things—with him, with Robert. And then the next part absolutely wrecked me. She goes back to her study, alone, puts the collar around her neck, and... nothing. No reaction. 'She felt no excitement.' Why? Because in her fantasies, the person treating her roughly is always Robert. Without him in the picture—without that connection, that tension, that unspoken electricity between them—the kink is just leather and metal. It's dead. This is the saddest kind of loneliness, isn't it? Not being alone physically, but being alone in your desires. Erta gets it. Erta has it. Erta and her husband are soulmates who talk about everything. And Celiana? Celiana is married to a good man who left home an hour early to avoid her, and she can't even bring herself to say the words. The author just slaughters me every time Celiana thinks about Robert. That moment when she imagines calling him 'Master' and her stomach flutters—that's the same woman who then lies to his face. The self-betrayal is so sharp.
... Read More
I need to talk about Robert and Celiana for a second because my heart is still broken for them. Like, we have this husband who is literally solving equations all day at the Treasury, completely rational, completely composed, and then one night he finds cuffs and a collar in a carriage and his entire world tilts. The way the author writes his internal monologue is brutal: he wants so badly to believe she shares his taste, and for one agonizing moment he actually thinks it, but then she says no with that shocked reaction and he has to watch his own hope die in real time. That line — 'the oasis before his eyes was nothing but a mirage born of longing' — I read that three times and just sat there. Because isn't that what unrequited desire feels like? You know it can't be real, but you're thirsty anyway. What kills me most is that they're married and neither of them knows the other the way they want to be known. He's hiding the deepest part of himself from his wife. She's avoiding him because things have been awkward since that dream. And they're both just... orbiting each other in this cold mansion, neither reaching out. The scene where he wants to say something but chooses silence instead — 'saying anything more would only worsen the mood' — he's so gentle and so cowardly at the same time and I just wanted to shake him. But also, I get it. If I discovered my husband had these dark desires and I freaked out the way Celiana did, he'd never bring it up again. The mutual misunderstanding between them is the real tragedy here, not the kink stuff. And now the old woman has appeared and given Robert this bizarre instruction about putting things under the bed tonight. I don't know if this is going to resolve things or make everything worse, but either way my chest is tight waiting to see what happens. Please let them finally talk to each other. Please.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or