I need a minute. I actually needed to put the book down for a second.
The flashback to when they were nine years old—the wolf attack at the hunting festival—was written so casually within Garcia's thoughts that at first I barely registered it, and then it completely dismantled me. Lisa shoved Garcia out of the way of a wounded wolf. She got badly hurt shielding him and Lena, and while she was dripping blood and smiling at them saying "I protected you," Count Cayu scooped up Lena and rushed away, leaving Lisa behind.
He was rescued a beat later. A BEAT LATER.
"After that day, their leader Lisa was gone." Garcia thought this. He carried this. And now he's sitting in a carriage, tapping his fingers to the rhythm of horse hooves, repeating silently: "This time, without fail, I will keep the promise I made that day."
The memory itself is described in these fragmented, visceral images—blood on his face, Lisa's strange smile, her hair matted with blood, him sobbing and clutching at it, saying "next time, next time, I promise" over and over. The narrative doesn't slow down to make us sit with it; it just embeds this trauma inside Garcia's head the way real traumatic memories work, intruding on the present without warning.
And the emotional complexity here is what gets me. Lisa—our Lisa, the one who doesn't actually remember any of this—feels this overwhelming guilt about having "taken Lena's person" for her own gain. She apologizes to Garcia for everything, promises to break off the engagement once her curse is lifted and help him find his way to Lena instead. She thinks she's doing the noble thing. She thinks she's being selfless. But she's also the one who just outmaneuvered a Count in his own dressing room and made him freeze in silence.
There's this beautiful tension between what the original Lisa and Garcia shared and what the current Lisa is becoming. Garcia sees something different in her now—she's returning "to the way she had been as a child" after collapsing in that strange room, and he reads it as a homecoming. When he asks if she remembers what he said when they were young, and she falters, he covers for her so easily: "Even if you don't remember, it doesn't matter. I'll keep the promise no matter what."
That line broke me. He wasn't asking for nostalgia. He was giving her an out while reaffirming his commitment. He knows she doesn't remember and he doesn't care because the promise isn't about her memory—it's about his choice.
"Lisa and I, engaged." The way he smiles in that carriage—not bright, not dark, just certain. I am not okay.