Okay so I keep coming back to this one scene where Old Gu Six just... buys twenty pairs of thick-soled cloth shoes, five pairs of cotton shoes, and two pairs of deer skin boots for Gu Chang'an. Like he doesn't even blink. He'd be fine wearing straw sandals himself, no question. And Gu Chang'an pushes back on it, which is so smart of her, so practical, she's still growing, her feet are still changing, why buy so many? Just get ones that fit. And that little negotiation between them, that's the whole relationship right there. He gives extravagantly, she tempers him with logic. Not rebellion, not gratitude, just... a daughter telling her dad, hey, that's too many, here's why. And he lets her talk him out of it without any ego involved. That's a father who actually listens. I got a little misty-eyed which is embarrassing because I'm reading this on the train.
Then the village gossip hits and I want to scream. These people are standing around talking about how Old Gu Six abandoned his own father, how he's 'worse than animals,' how he 'kicked his mother out.' 'People like Old Gu Six, who would harm their own father, are worse than animals.' Bro. You know the full story. You saw the old hunter come for him. You saw the years of neglect before that. And yet the village conveniently packages his past into this neat little 'unfilial son' narrative that lets them feel superior while staring at his mule cart going by. 'How much money do you think he really has?' That's all they're thinking. Money. They don't see the father-daughter thing playing out in front of them. They see a stranger with resources and they're already calculating. It made me genuinely angry in a low, simmering way. Like, the village treats him like a resource to be judged and a moral failing to be discussed, and not one of these people says 'hey, he seems really protective of his kid, maybe that's what matters.' No one does. The gossip is its own little ecosystem and it's self-sealing. They'll tell these stories for years after he's gone south with his daughter.
And the other thing that keeps nagging at me: the old hunter. He's dead now, apparently, and that's the backstory that made the villagers call Old Gu Six back. But we barely get a glimpse of who he was. We know he was a hunter, we know he took this kid in when nobody else would, and that's it. He's a ghost in this chapter, just a reference point. 'The old hunter must have left him some inheritance before he passed away.' The way the village reduces his love for the child into a financial transaction. Ugh. I want a whole chapter of what their life was together, the hunting, the quiet, whatever it was. Instead it's just fuel for gossip. And Old Gu Six himself, he's so quiet. He drives the cart, he buys what his daughter says, he washes dishes, he carries hot water buckets. His whole presence is 'service without asking for anything back.' No one in this village will ever write him a kind sentence. But Gu Chang'an sees him clearly, 'a daughter like a little fairy, truly lucky and happy,' which the narrator drops in there almost as a winky wink to the reader. She knows. The child knows what she's been given.
What makes me wonder, like, where does Old Gu Six go after this? Because the village clearly doesn't want him, the village clearly will never see him as anything other than 'that unfilial guy who's got money now,' and Gu Chang'an is pulling him toward a future that doesn't include Qingfang Village. Is he ready to be a father who's finally free of the guilt trip? Because for a long time, I think being the villain in everyone's story was the easiest identity available to him. Nobody expected anything from him. So he could just... exist. And now he's building something else and it terrifies him a little, I think. Buying twenty pairs of shoes is how you say 'I'm going to keep this person safe' when you don't have words for it yet. He's learning. Slowly. And she's teaching him without even trying.