The Affairs of Expelling Demons and Capturing Ghosts with Second Martial Uncle - Reviews

The Affairs of Expelling Demons and Capturing Ghosts with Second Martial Uncle
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The wooden puppet and the ash box are two objects that anchor everything this chapter is about. The puppet represents the father's lingering control — a substitute for his body that continues to bind his son even in death. Burn it, seal its seven orifices with vermilion, and the binding breaks. But the ash box is where things get truly interesting. Mr. Hong places it outside his door with paper money inside, and when Second Uncle checks days later, the box is empty — 'taken by an Underworld Official.' This is the chapter's central metaphor laid bare: payment. Everything in this supernatural economy requires transaction. The binding technique demanded the father's life and his son's obedience. The Uncle brothers performed the ritual and received five thousand yuan. The Underworld Official collected the paper money and presumably settled the spiritual debt. Even the protagonist's relationship with Second Uncle operates on this logic — equal pay split, protection given, knowledge transmitted. But the deepest symbolism is the forgetting. The protagonist can't remember his mother's face. Memory, like the ashes in that box, is something that gets carried away whether you want it to or not. The only question is whether it goes to the Underworld or just vanishes into nothing.
... Read More
Okay so this whole section starts with Tong Yi having this incredibly vivid dream about the Ancestor asking him to do something, and it immediately sets off a chain of events that feels anything but random. The Old Taoist's dream theory is actually really clever because it foreshadows exactly what's happening—this isn't just a random dream, it's a real sign. And then the plot starts moving like a domino effect: he arrives in Guangzhou, gets picked up by a mysterious motorcycle driver, ends up at a hotel, waits until late at night reading Daoist books, and then BAM—Second Martial Uncle appears out of nowhere with that terrifying scar running from his eye to his mouth. The pacing of these reveals is well done. First there's the confusion of being picked up by a stranger who somehow knew exactly what he looked like (the description on the note was hilariously blunt: "wearing clothes that look like they were discarded by others"). Then the fifty-yuan misunderstanding where he's mistaken for a beggar, which honestly made me laugh. And the biggest twist? Second Uncle already knows he's in the city. How? That's a question the text doesn't answer immediately and it's exactly the kind of mystery that keeps you hooked. The plot also drops this detail about the three Daoist books being special—only Tong Yi and the Old Taoist can read them. That's a classic setup for future plot development. The author is clearly building toward something bigger.
... Read More
Beneath the surface-level plot of a Daoist master investigating a possessed girl, this section is quietly probing deeper questions about knowledge, power, and the boundaries between the natural and supernatural worlds. The talismans on the door operate as a powerful symbol—they represent humanity's attempt to impose order on chaos, to mark thresholds and create protection through ritual. But the fact that some are real and some are fake, drawn by different hands and traditions, complicates this symbol. Order is not monolithic; it's layered, contested, and sometimes fraudulent. The darkness of the room is another resonant image. Second Uncle's instruction—"Don't turn on the light, don't scare her" —suggests that visibility is not always advantageous, that sometimes the optimal strategy is to remain partially blind, to move by other senses. This inverts the ordinary assumption that knowledge equals light. In the hidden world, ignorance can be protective. Second Uncle's refusal to shake President Lü's hand is a small gesture loaded with thematic meaning. It marks the boundary between two orders of being—the businessman who operates in the visible economy of money and reputation, and the Daoist who operates in the hidden economy of spiritual forces and karmic consequence. Their handshake would have been a fiction; the refusal is an honesty. And the narrator's question at the end—"Second Uncle, are there really ghosts in this world?"—while simple, opens onto the deepest theme of all. Second Uncle's indirect answer, that the world is small yet vast, that one person can only understand a tiny fraction of all phenomena, is a philosophical statement about epistemic humility. The supernatural is real, but it is also vast beyond comprehension, and that limitation is not a failure but a condition of human knowing.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this: the master-disciple relationship in this opening is doing some serious heavy lifting and I am HERE for it. The old Taoist priest? Absolute enigma wrapped in rags. Ten years he raises Tong Yi, makes him bath water every single day in this mysterious green liquid, feeds him Daoist scriptures he apparently can't explain the meaning of — and doesn't say more than five words in a row. And then BAM, decides it's time to kick him out. Just like that. What gets me is that moment when Tong Yi asks if he can get married. The old Taoist's reaction: he smiles. A KIND smile. Just... smiles. No answer. That's the most human thing this stoic character has done in ten chapters and it DESTROYS me. Why does he smile there? Is it pity? Amusement? Something else? And don't even get me started on the Second Martial Uncle incident. One argument, the old Taoist shows visible emotion for the first time in a decade, and then the guy just... vanishes. Down the mountain and never returns. What were they fighting about? Why did it change the master so fundamentally? My brain is working overtime here. The weird part is that Tong Yi's attitude toward his master shifts subtly across these chapters. At first it's just routine — obey, study, don't question. But by the end, when he's packing his bags and asking useless questions like whether he needs the green bath water recipe, there's this undercurrent of genuine reluctance. He doesn't want to leave. He just doesn't know HOW to say that directly to someone who communicates exclusively in one-word answers.
... Read More
Okay, so this section had me absolutely hooked. Let me just say it straight — the moment that Bagua Mirror starts reflecting green light toward the candle next to the coffin, I knew something was about to go down. Second Uncle's entire demeanor shifts from meditating half-asleep to eyes snapping open and whispering 'They're here.' That's when I sat up. Really sat up. The whole setup with the old man's soul trying to evade the Underworld through Nightmare Binding is genuinely clever plot design. He didn't just die and move on — he spent a fortune on some expert who told him to build a wooden puppet, mix his vital blood with water, pour it over forty-nine days, and then cast a spell to deceive the Underworld Official coming to collect his soul. Think about how much backstory is packed into that one exchange. A whole philosophy of the dead refusing to accept death, and the lengths people will go to cheat the system. But here's what really got me: Second Uncle didn't just dismiss the old man outright. He actually asked about the technique. 'Suppressing Enchantment or Nightmare Binding?' And when the guy admitted it was Nightmare Binding, Second Uncle's face changed. You could practically feel the anger radiating off the page. The way he explained that the old man 'lost the moment he encountered me' — that's not just power flexing, that's a fundamental cosmic principle being asserted. Birth, aging, sickness, death, and Heavenly Dao reincarnation are the normal laws of this world. Period. The reveal about the corpse being past its seventh day and the delay caused by the wife causing trouble — that's a detail that makes the whole thing feel lived-in and messy, not like some clean supernatural fairy tale. And the ending where the uncle drops this bomb about the Taiji Yin Yang Conversion Scripture possibly allowing a living person to visit the Underworld? Hooked. Completely hooked. How does he not cultivate it himself if it's that powerful? Come on.
... Read More
Okay so can we talk about this one moment? When Second Uncle looks at Realist Jingqing and that flicker of disbelief crosses his face? That's the kind of detail that makes you want to reread the whole thing backwards. Because here's the thing — everyone else in that car is either terrified or businesslike. Captain Zhao's being a dutiful cop. Jingqing's all cool and detached. But Second Uncle? He's sizing her up. And I love that the NARRATOR is the only one who catches it, because obviously, they've spent enough time together to read him like a book. It also raises SO many questions. Why does he distrust her? Is it because she's from the Wonderful Dharma Lotus Sect? Remember what Second Uncle said earlier — that different Taoist lineages seem harmonious on the surface but aren't really compatible underneath? So now we've got this layered tension: the two factions exist in the same storyworld but clearly don't trust each other, and Jingqing showing up uninvited just amplifies everything. She claims she's there because her master sent her, but Second Uncle doesn't buy it. Neither do I, honestly. The way she stares at the narrator in the car — that's not just curiosity. That's something else. And then there's the narrator themselves. They went from being this wide-eyed sidekick to someone who actually notices these things. Who tracks micro-expressions. That growth arc is so subtle but it hits hard when you pause to think about it.
... Read More
"The wild grass around Liu Youde's son's graveyard had been cleared, indicating someone had visited the grave not long ago." This single line does SO much worldbuilding. It tells us that graves in this setting get maintained, that people come here deliberately, that there's a ritualistic relationship between the living and the dead in this village. And then — "The coffin lid seemed to have flown out of the grave. Why do I say 'flown'? Because the way the coffin lid landed was unnatural; it was stuck in the ground at an angle, not like something a person would place. It looked more like it had been thrown." I stopped reading and just sat with that image for a full minute. This is the moment where the supernatural stops being implied and starts BEING THERE. A coffin lid thrown from the inside. A missing body from a sealed grave. The narrator's narration actually breaks into analysis — explaining WHY they chose the word 'flown' — which is such a brilliant stylistic choice. It makes you feel like you're inside their head, reconstructing the scene in real time. The whole sequence builds atmosphere masterfully: the three-hour drive in silence, arriving past six in the evening, the decision to go at night instead of waiting until tomorrow, flashlights cutting through darkness, the mountain path that's harder to navigate after sunset. The author doesn't over-describe anything — just enough sensory detail to make you feel cold and slightly uneasy. And then that final image of the angled coffin lid just... hangs there. No explanation. No resolution. Just the visual, raw and unsettling.
... Read More
The voices in this are so distinct, it's like listening to a play. Second Uncle's dialogue is all clipped edges and implicit meaning. "Alright, I happen to have time. I can go over and take a look today." No drama, just a man who treats the supernatural like a Tuesday appointment. But when he's teaching, his sentences expand, explaining the logic behind the lore. Mr. Zhang, the local liaison, speaks in a completely different register. He's nervous, formal. "Master Dao, my apologies. You see, my memory failed me, and I forgot your rule." The way he flinches from a handshake with Second Uncle tells you everything about hierarchy and respect in this circle. It's not just dialogue; it's social choreography. Then there's Mr. Hong, the refined man in glasses. His speech is polite, deferential, but there's a quiet strength in how he manages the family crisis. "Masters are indeed Masters." He defers, but he also gets things done. The narrator's voice is that of an eager apprentice, full of questions. "Second Uncle, why don't you want the old woman to keep vigil?" His curiosity is the reader's curiosity. And the author's narrative voice? It's a brilliant blend of folklorist and crime reporter. It reports the uncanny with the same flat tone as the taxi fare. "One hundred and twenty yuan for two people to Dongguan Bridgehead." Then it pivots seamlessly to, "The Taiji Yin Yang Conversion Scripture contains methods for soul crossing." There's no winking at the reader, no hint of disbelief. The matter-of-fact tone is what sells the magic. It makes the whole world feel documented, like you're reading field notes from a hidden profession. Even the silence between lines speaks volumes. Second Uncle's refusal to shake hands isn't explained with a paragraph; it's just stated as fact, and you feel the weight of tradition in that single gesture.
... Read More
Okay let's talk about what's actually at stake here because on the surface this seems like a simple "young cultivator leaves home" setup but the conflicts underneath are WAY more interesting. First layer: the immediate external conflict. Tong Yi has been LOCKED on this mountain for ten years. He doesn't know the outside world. He has no money, no plan, no social skills outside the temple. The old Taoist just dropped him into reality with three blank books and a smile. What could possibly go wrong? Everything. Everything is going wrong. But the REAL conflict is internal. Tong Yi is an ATHEIST in a Taoist temple. He doesn't believe in the Three Pure Ones, he doesn't believe in cultivation realms or magic or any of it. And yet — the master made him bathe in this green liquid for a DECADE. If nothing happened, why keep doing it? If something DID happen, why hasn't Tong Yi noticed? The conflict between his materialist worldview and the impossible reality he's lived his entire life is fascinating. Then there's the mystery of the old Taoist himself. Who is this man? Why did he take in a abandoned child? What happened with the Second Martial Uncle that caused him to show emotion for the first time in ten years? What are those three blank books? Why tell him to descend NOW? The stakes aren't just "will he survive outside" — they're deeper. The author is building this question: what happens when someone who doesn't believe in magic discovers that magic is real? Tong Yi's entire identity framework is about to get shaken. The master knows this. The master planned this. And that terrifies me in the best way. The little girl's subplot adds another layer — her father is a murderer, she's ostracized, and the master explicitly says he considered destroying the children who bully her but chose not to. So the master HAS the power to intervene in the mortal world, but chooses silence. What does that mean for Tong Yi when he goes down there? Will the master protect him? Will he intervene? Or is he truly letting Tong Yi face everything alone?
... Read More
Let's just sit with the core horror of this chapter for a second. A living girl — cognitively impaired, traded like livestock by her own father — was buried alive in a sealed coffin. And then she's GONE. Not just escaped (which would be nearly impossible anyway), but completely vanished from an enclosed underground space. That's the kind of premise that raises the stakes from "mystery to solve" to "something fundamentally wrong with reality itself." And it's not just her. The young man who arranged the whole thing? Locked in his room, died with the same MO as the other victims — heart removed, no forced entry, no signs of outsiders. Three deaths, one pattern, zero logical explanation. Captain Zhao literally says "I'm truly out of options." That's a professional investigator admitting defeat, and it signals to the reader that we've entered territory where normal rules don't apply. But here's what really keeps me up at night: the provincial bureau sent ONLY Captain Zhao and his partner. Two people for what should be a multi-agency supernatural investigation? Something is actively being suppressed or concealed at an institutional level. Second Uncle catches this immediately and it tears at him. The stakes aren't just about solving murders anymore — they're about what powerful forces are trying to keep buried, literally and figuratively. The girl could still be alive. The grave was opened from the INSIDE. What if she's not the victim in this story — what if she's something else entirely? That possibility changes everything.
... Read More
Let me be honest — when I started this I wasn't sure what to expect. A Taoist temple setting with a young protagonist who can't leave? Sounded like it could drag. But the author knows EXACTLY how to pace this. Chapters 1-3 are basically establishment — daily life, the master-disciple routine, the little girl, the blank books mystery. It's slow but deliberately so. You're supposed to feel the weight of ten years passing, the monotony, the routine. The green bath liquid detail keeps coming back like a motif — every time Tong Yi thinks about it, the author reminds us this man is doing something strange and unexplained. Then chapter 4-5 is where the energy shifts. The master tells him to descend the mountain. Everything changes. The pace quickens because suddenly there's a deadline, a decision, a departure looming. Tong Yi starts asking questions he's never dared ask before. The reader starts connecting dots. Chapter 6-7 is basically an emotional gut punch wrapped in a cliffhanger. Packing his bags. The little girl crying. The master meditating. Tong Yi realizing he has absolutely no plan for life after the mountain. The final line about needing travel expenses because the master gave him NOTHING? Perfect comedic timing right before the actual story begins. What I love about the structure is how the author withholds information strategically. We learn about the Second Martial Uncle's disappearance in a single paragraph. We find out Tong Yi is a materialist through internal monologue rather than exposition. The blank books get revealed gradually — first the little girl can't read them, then we see they're genuinely empty, and the implication is that they might be empty FOR HER specifically. The pacing leaves me wanting to immediately start chapter 8. I'm downstairs with this kid and he has zero resources and three mysterious blank books and I NEED to know what happens next.
... Read More
'Although Second Uncle was meditating with his eyes closed, he seemed to sense my state and quietly reminded me: Little Child, don't stop burning the paper money; keep it going.' Let me just sit with that image for a moment. Half-asleep apprentice, exhausted from hours of burning paper money into a basin, eyes drooping, yawning constantly, and this almost casual reminder from Second Uncle to keep going. The mundane and the supernatural are woven together so naturally it doesn't even feel strange anymore. And that's what makes the atmosphere of this book absolutely phenomenal. Then the shift happens. A flash of green light. The Bagua Mirror standing up AS IF IT WERE ALIVE. Pointing at the candle. Then pointing at the entrance. And THIS old man materializing — crawling, panting in pain, flickering faintly. Every single sensory detail works. I could feel the dampness of the mourning hall, the flickering candlelight, the weight of silence before the old man spoke. The two-hour scene where the old man just stares at his own corpse isonestly one of the most haunting passages I've ever read. Two hours. Just sitting there, looking at the body he used to inhabit. No words, no drama, just this raw, aching moment of a soul confronting its own mortality from the outside. And I was there, frozen, legs numb, too afraid to move. That's immersive writing right there. And then the yellow font scriptures rising around my body, circling once, then flying to the old man's soul like sand dissolving into light — I literally got chills. The visual of this is cinematic. It's like a movie scene that I never want to end.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or