The Academy’s Mad Dog Is Actually Mad Beautiful - Reviews

The Academy’s Mad Dog Is Actually Mad Beautiful
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There's this ONE image that won't leave me: Josef's body growing transparent, the moss and vines of the lake showing CLEARLY through his skin. He's becoming one with nature. Surrendering. The text describes it almost poetically: "Eyes closed in peace, body surrendered to the earth around him, the faint upward curve of his lips as though something pleased him. It was the picture of someone whose passing would be called a good death." A GOOD DEATH. He's a CHILD. He's seventeen or whatever and the narrator is describing him like he's already at peace with dying. And then there's the dream sequence — Aileen stepping INTO Josef's memories, into his past trauma. She becomes a child herself, small enough to move among them unseen. The fact that she had to SHrink to enter his world feels symbolic. You can only truly understand someone's pain when you make yourself small enough to fit inside it. The wind spirit Aerial literally THROWS Aileen into the forest. No gentle invitation. A physical launch. And when she lands, she's already standing, brushing herself off, complaining about "invitation etiquette." This girl meets the supernatural with SARCASM. That's also a kind of symbolism — she refuses to be awed into paralysis. And the spirits! They're invisible, inaudible to ordinary people, yet they're the ones who CARE most. The unseen witnesses to suffering. They bicker and panic and one of them (Aerial) expends "every last bit of her strength" just to bring someone who can actually HELP. The deeper question this raises: who gets to be seen? Who gets heard? Josef can't speak. His body is disappearing. The spirits can only watch. Aileen had to literally ENTER HIS MIND to find him.
... Read More
I keep coming back to how the author turns an ordinary classroom into this suffocating arena where social hierarchy plays out in real time. Let me paint what I saw: students clustered in factions, the Potion Brewing girls howling like a pack behind Claire, the Hollow laugh breaking out from different seats like radio signals. The whole room is arranged like a colosseum and Aileen is the gladiator who didn't know she'd been entered. But the genius detail is the sensory layering. You don't just see the scene—you smell it. "Someone had cupped both of her ears, bringing with them a familiar scent. Pine needles." That's it. Two words and suddenly I can smell Josef before I see him. The author trusts us to connect pine needles to the character without spelling out "it was Josef." And the sound design is incredible. The silence when Josef covers Aileen's ears—"Only Claire, standing across from him, could look directly at his face." The entire auditory landscape shifts. Aileen is cut off from the crowd, from the gossip, from the hostile hum of the faculty. She's placed in a bubble of quiet while Josef stands between her and everyone else. The physical blocking tells the whole story. Then there's the academic worldbuilding dropping in casually: capture artifacts, the Imperial family's baseline of extraordinary beauty, the possibility of expulsion for incitement to dark magic, the student council disciplinary committee. None of this is explained with infodumps—it's woven into conflict. We learn what these things mean by watching characters react to them. The final image of the chapter—Owen opening a door to an unfamiliar atmosphere, students looking at him with pity instead of admiration—that's worldbuilding through subversion. The corridor itself changes texture because the social web has shifted. Even the architecture knows something is different.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about this scene because it absolutely wrecked me. Remember how in previous chapters Aileen kept looking back at Owen with this guilt and confusion? Well here we get the full picture and oh my god. She wasn't just some random classmate. She literally spent her DAYS in the library searching for a way to heal his mind wound after his mother died. She was trying. Actually trying. And then four years ago during a dance practice with Kaya, he just... snapped. "Don't come near me." Cold hand. Cold words. Red eyes like HE was the one who'd been rejected. That line hit me like a truck: "She hadn't known what to make of it. She hadn't been able to bring herself to approach him." This is someone who genuinely cared and got burned for it, and now she's sitting on this bench processing it alone. Meanwhile Owen's over there unraveling again. And the worst part? The absolute worst part is that Aileen's theory right now — that SOMETHING is wrong with Owen, something connected to his illness — she's probably right. But she'll never know the real reason. That dramatic irony is going to杀 me eventually. Also can we talk about how she handles rejection? She doesn't spiral. She gets CURIOUS. That wind pulls her toward the lake and instead of running she goes IN. Same energy as when she walked into Josef's dream territory. This girl does not know how to back away from a mystery that needs solving.
... Read More
I have never, EVER encountered a character like Josef and I am OBSESSED. The first time he speaks — and this is the FIRST TIME his lips have ever opened — the narration stops everything: "From Josef's lips, which had never once opened, a mysterious voice flowed out. [Lambar.] Aileen startled and looked up at him. She had never heard such a beautiful voice in her life. It was a clear, delicate tone, like a dewdrop falling softly in a deep green forest." And then IMMEDIATELY undercut with: "[Shut up.]" The dissonance between that voice and that word — it's PERFECT characterization in two lines. Someone so buried inside themselves that when they finally break silence, it's defensive and sharp. But the VOICE itself, that description... "dewdrop falling softly in a deep green forest" — I've read that sentence four times and it just keeps getting better. Then the dialogue between Josef and Lambar is BRILLIANT: "I could just lick your shoes." Aileen's reaction: "What?!" — and not just her, Lambar too. This kid who's been silently bullied and his RESPONSE is offering to debase himself? It's so unhinged and so protective of Aileen that it loops back around to being sweet in the worst way. And his final line to Aileen: "Why are you still here." Not unkindly. Just... wearily. Like an old man trapped in a child's body. The kid said it looked "as weary as an old man who had lived a thousand years." Every character's voice is DISTINCT. Aileen's internal monologue is practical and direct. Lambar's dialogue is all swagger and threats. Josef's few words carry weight like cannonballs.
... Read More
Can we just take a moment to appreciate how terrifyingly good Claire's dialogue is here? "S, so Josef, what I meant was……" The stutter isn't genuine fear—it's performance. One second she's going hard on Aileen, the next she's restructuring her entire sentence to slide into respectful mode the moment Josef appears. That switch-flip in a single breath? Chef's kiss. The author doesn't need to tell us Claire is manipulative. Her mouth does it for her. And then later: "Hehe. A handsome man with a red face, the absolute best." Absolute psychopath energy. She just got caught using a capture artifact on someone, she's about to ruin a girl's academic career, and she's giggling like she just found a rare beetle specimen. Which, honestly, is kind of how she treats people. Everything is specimen collection to Claire. But Josef's dialogue— or lack thereof—is where the writing really shines. He barely speaks. Instead of words, we get: > He raised one firm index finger. He moved it horizontally, and words rose into the air. This is such a clean narrative choice. Josef is physically incapable of normal emotional expression (the whole curse thing), so when he DOES try to communicate, it's these floating letters, these fragmented words. "From now on, don't...me." We piece together the meaning the same way Aileen does. The incompleteness IS the emotion. He can't even say the full thing because saying it out loud—whether in words or in floating letters—would make it real. And then his entire face going red as his response? That's louder than any dialogue could be. The body speaking what the mouth cannot.
... Read More
This opening sequence at the Academy gate is one of the most vividly staged scenes I've read in forever. Let me just— It starts with Kaya standing there, breathing in the noise. After a lifetime of birdsong in the countryside, the sound of students is physically overwhelming: "Her ears... prickled at the noise." The camera pans across the crowd, snippets of conversation floating past—Professor Matthew's assignment, Rafiola's drama—and Kaya realizes she was wrong about humanity nearly going extinct. There are SO MANY people. She scoffs at herself. A frog in a well. That self-awareness, that tiny involuntary sound escaping her—it makes her immediately real. Then Silvia appears, golden hair, sharp eyes, surrounded by girls. The visual contrast is almost cinematic: Kaya, red hair that smolders like magma, deep-set predatory eyes, against Silvia, this perfect blonde monument. And then the crowd shifts when Owen arrives. Suddenly everyone's praising him, calling him handsome, and Kaya's internal monologue is just bitter and hilarious: "Some of us are standing here being called the Empire's greatest eyesore. Must be nice. Guess coming to the Academy is really paying off for him." But the real showstopper is the collapse-and-carry sequence. One second they're at the main gate surrounded by students and the headmaster, the next—THUD. FWUMP. Kaya is on the ground, scraped hands pressing into earth, Owen beside her, and she has NO IDEA how they got there. "While the students' attention had been on the professor, she had grabbed Owen's sleeve and told him quietly to follow her." She literally blacked out mid-rescue. That transition from public confrontation to private thicket is seamless and disorienting in the best way. You feel her confusion. You're disoriented with her. And then Robert the headmaster finds them like some bewildered NPC walking into a cutscene he wasn't prepared for. His back going out trying to lift Owen is such a perfect comedic beat after all that tension.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this chapter structure is *chef's kiss* because the author doesn't give us one massive info dump about Kaya being the Emperor reincarnated — they do it in layers and honestly it works so much better. First layer: the headmaster walks in, sees Kaya, and drops to his knees saying "Empire's sun" like his spiritual instinct immediately recognizes something. Second layer: he makes the artifact joke, completely missing it, and everyone in the room just stands there dying of awkwardness. This is funny BUT it also tells us that her resemblance to Emperor Ulicia is so perfect it's almost supernatural. Third layer: the entrance exam. She answers every single question correctly except one, on a test that Professor Leopold deliberately made absurdly hard. This isn't just "she's smart" — this is someone whose academic ability is off the charts, which perfectly sets up why a reincarnated emperor would blend into the weakest faculty. Fourth layer (the best one): the classroom scene. Everyone is intimidated by her, Laura lies about a fake rule to get her away from Josef, and Kaya's response is just "I'll go have a word with this Claire." No panic. No fear. Just... matter-of-fact. And then Josef — who hasn't even spoken properly yet — sits up because for the first time someone asks about HIS feelings instead of screaming at his appearance. The plot keeps escalating without feeling rushed. Each scene reveals something new about Kaya while simultaneously creating new tension. What happens next when she actually meets "Claire"? What's going on with Josef? The narrative arc here is building this picture of a girl who looks harmless but is actually operating on an entirely different level than everyone around her. I cannot wait.
... Read More
This hit harder than anything else in the entire chapter. Lucas let a guy pour food on his head and didn't even get angry. Just stood there silently wiping it off with his sleeve. He's mastered the art of enduring—that's what the narration literally says—and he was fine with it. But then Aileen shows up, flattens the guy who did it, and Lucas breaks down crying. Not because he's hurt. Because someone stood up for him. Someone he barely knows. Someone who might become a real friend, maybe. The realization that something nice actually happened to him overwhelmed him so badly he couldn't hold it together. And Aileen? She's panicking on the inside. She sees him cry and immediately assumes it's because of her—because she acted unilaterally, because her father once told her nobody likes a person who helps people without asking first. She's so wound up in guilt she can't even process that his tears are the good kind. Then he laughs. He actually laughs and says 'You're really something, Aileen' and asks to go outside. That is a turning point. That's the moment their friendship shifts from 'he was excited to eat with someone' to something real. What destroys me is that Lucas wanted to look good in front of her. For once, he straightened his hunched shoulders instead of self-deprecating. He almost told the truth—almost said why he sits near the trash bin—and then got food dumped on him before he could. 'I only ever dreamed about things like this. But...' That ellipsis is doing so much work.
... Read More
Let me list what's actually at risk right now because my brain is racing: 1. JOSEF IS DISSOLVING. His body is becoming transparent. The spirits have accepted this might be terminal. "Just like with Cecilia" — so this has happened BEFORE to someone he's connected to. A PATTERN. 2. AILEEN JUST TOUCHED HIM. She held his hand, whispered to him, and got pulled into his dream/past. She collapsed beside him. What happens to HER now? Is she trapped? Is she in danger? 3. THE WIND didn't want Lucas there. It ACTIVE LY pushed him away. This is a controlled, intentional supernatural force — and it chose Aileen specifically. 4. Owen's condition. Four years ago he snapped during a dance practice with Kaya and has been deteriorating ever since. Aileen suspects it's connected to whatever is happening with Josef RIGHT NOW. If she's right, then Owen is in the same boat — fading, suffering, and nobody knows how to stop it. 5. Lambar knows something about Josef. When Josef says "I could just lick your shoes," Lambar goes from smug bully to RIGID with fear: "You, you, how did you know about that..." There's a secret history here and Josef just weaponized it in three words. 6. The servants are closing in ON THEM in the dream. Aileen's logic: "getting caught might be the clue I need to get out." She's treating a DREAM like a puzzle box. This is either incredibly brave or incredibly stupid. The suspense is MAXIMUM. We just lost two protagonists to the supernatural (Owen's condition worsening + Aileen pulled into Josef's dream) and the author has not given us a single answer. Just questions piling on top of questions like a house of cards waiting to fall.
... Read More
There's a constellation of symbols here that I can't stop thinking about. First: the artifact. Kaya thought of it as a "trivial condition" since childhood, something she just wore without questioning. But it's what allows people to call her the Empire's greatest eyesore while she stands there unprotected. The people who actually knew her—Adam, Fabro, Emily, Robiet—are gone, dismissed for mentioning her appearance. The artifact concealed her face but it also concealed the truth about how cruel people could be. When she finally removes herself from the fishbowl, she discovers the world has been lying to her about what it thinks of her. Not just strangers—her own household. Then there's the NAME. "Kaya Rikart"—Owen says it and the text specifically notes how his voice changes, that low scraping sound he makes when holding back anger. The girl says "Kaya Rikart?" and the entire scene pivots. Her name is both a shield and a target. People whisper about "Lady Rikart" as if she's a ghost, a dragon conjured from nothing. Owen says "don't ever say that name in front of me again" and meanwhile he's the one who's never been adopted into the grand ducal household despite everyone assuming it would happen. The name carries weight neither of them fully understands. And Owen's voice—"Disgusting." That's the recurring motif that haunts everything. It started four years ago during a dance lesson. His body reacted, his heart lurched, and the voice spoke. Is it supernatural? Psychological? The text won't tell us, but it mirrors Kaya's experience perfectly: both of them carry invisible burdens that the world amplifies. She's called ugly. He hears disgust. And when the crowd says the words out loud, his body can't sustain the lie anymore. They're both performing for people who don't see them, and the performance is killing them both.
... Read More
This sequence is so brilliantly constructed I can't even. The wind comes out of NOWHERE — "Whoooosh" — and it's specifically targeting Aileen. She grabs the bench, her red hair whipping like fire, and the narration explicitly tells us: "An ordinary student would have been swept away in the direction it was pulling long before now. But Aileen was different." Then Lucas shows up and here's where it gets MEANINGFUL. The wind doesn't just ignore him — it actively tries to separate them. Starting from their joined hands, it SPLIT and pushed them in opposite directions. This is not random supernatural activity. This is an invitation with EXCLUSIONS. And Aileen figures this out in real time: "I think it's telling you not to come." Then she lets go. Just... lets go. Of Lucas's hand. Into the dark. Meanwhile in the forest, Josef is half-submerged in water, growing TRANSPARENT. The spirits are bickering like desperate worried moms: "Wait? What if Josef disappears while we're waiting!" "Maybe it would be easier for Josef to just follow his mother to the spirit world." And Aerial literally THROWS Aileen through the air like a projectile. "Aileen came flying in at tremendous speed and drove straight into the ground." The cause-and-effect chain is: Owen's unexplained illness → Aileen's investigation → the wind's summons → Josef's crisis → the dream sequence. Everything is CONNECTED. I'm convinced Owen and Josef are tied to the same mystery and the reveal is going to be massive.
... Read More
Let me just say — the tension in these chapters is UNNECESSARY and I loved every second of it. On the surface, the stakes are clear: get out of the spirit world or be trapped forever. But the real stakes are underneath, and they're eating me alive. Josef literally thinks being trapped might be preferable to facing what he feels. That's not just internal conflict, that's a full psychological breakdown happening in real time. He walks Aileen to the portal, lets her go, and then collapses alone. The spirits pull him back through by the hair. He's not choosing anything — he's being rescued from himself, which is the most violating and tender thing that could happen. Meanwhile Aileen has no idea any of this is happening. She's all bright and excited, talking about lunch being almost over. The dramatic irony is suffocating. We know Josef is falling apart and she's stepping back into her normal life like nothing changed. The gap between their experiences in those final paragraphs is devastating. And then Josef wakes up and says the worst possible thing at the worst possible moment. The spirits are devastated. Aileen is confused. And the reader is just sitting there screaming because we can see the trap closing around him in real time. Every hug he refuses, every wall he builds, every hiccup he tries to hide — it all piles up and the question becomes: how much more can this kid take before he either breaks or finally lets someone in?

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or