Let me just say this first: Natalie is one of the most hateable antagonists I've encountered recently, and I love her for it. She's not evil for the sake of being evil — she's a product of privilege, pampered by an adoring father, and completely convinced of her own superiority. The moment she forces Lisette to prostrate and then steps on her hand with a pointed shoe? That's not just cruelty, that's performative dominance. She wants Lisette to feel small in front of witnesses, and she wants the act to be ritualistic.
But here's what's interesting about their relationship — Lisette isn't helpless. She's endured this. She knows how to read Natalie's moods, how to avoid her, how to survive. There's a whole history between them that the text doesn't spell out but you can feel in every interaction. When Lisette thinks about who really resembles the emperor, she's not just making a passing observation — she's reminding herself that Natalie's legitimacy is questionable. That's a weapon Lisette carries silently.
Claude, on the other hand, is introduced almost entirely through his relationship with his men and his father. He's rigid, demanding, single-minded — but not cruel. The contrast is stark. While Natalie exercises power through humiliation, Claude exercises it through discipline. Yet both are trapped in their roles: Claude by duty, Lisette by birth.
And then there's Celia, who refuses to help Lisette but also refuses to abandon her. 'I'm worried about losing the employee I worked hard to find' — she says this like it's concern, but it's clearly self-interest. And yet, does that make her less valuable? Sometimes the friends who keep you around for practical reasons are the ones who stay when emotional loyalty would fail.
The dynamic between all three — Claude unknowingly buying from the shop where Lisette works, Natalie unknowingly destroying the sister who might outmaneuver her — feels like a chess game where the board is about to flip.