I need to address the dialogue in chapter 2 because it is doing SO MUCH WORK and I am not okay.
First, the casual banter early on: “A little?” “You were a v*rgin?” “You, you too. You were too!” This feels natural. Real. Two people who know each other forever, half-joking, deflecting through humor. The asterisk-censored word is such a small detail but it makes Rosie's voice feel authentic — she's flustered, she's not typing formally, she's just reacting.
But then Theo's voice changes. It's almost nothing — one line, really:
“You have to marry me. That's how it is. I'll handle the preparations, you just have to show up.”
No question mark. No “can we talk about this?” No “I'm sorry.” Just a statement. A decree. The dialogue drops all the conversational markers that would make it sound like a negotiation. It becomes command language. And that shift? It's devastating because it happens so quietly. He doesn't raise his voice. He doesn't slam doors dramatically — well, the door DOES slam, but it's described as “louder than usual,” which means Theo himself isn't even angry in that moment. He's just done.
Rosie's internal voice is also worth praising. “Crazy bastard. Spineless bastard.” She calls him that TWICE. That's not the voice of someone who sees him as a romantic hero. That's the voice of someone who is genuinely scared and trying to label the threat.
And the narrator? Absolutely minimal. No authorial commentary, no moralizing, no “little did she know.” Just pure scene. The voice trusts the reader. I respect that. This is not a novel that explains its own emotions. It shows them through what people say — and more importantly, what they refuse to say.