Take My Trash - Reviews

Take My Trash
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
So this chapter had me holding my breath the whole way through because there are literally two separate scheming operations happening simultaneously and they might collide at any moment. On one side, you have Jeff playing the long con for Deborah — pretending she's got tuberculosis just to buy time while she's secretly pregnant with Edgar's child. That's a incredibly dangerous game. If anyone finds out the truth, Deborah is dead. Period. "You don't want Deborah, your friend's daughter, to die miserably, do you?" — Jeff basically blackmails the doctor into helping, which shows how deep in the mud this whole situation is. Meanwhile, Hildeltrud is running her own operation with Elisabeth as the bait. The picnic scene? Man. She dressed Elisabeth in that off-shoulder dress on purpose, signaled Leah to trip her, then deliberately fell ON TOP of Elisabeth so Edgar would have to help HER up first. Then she left Edgar alone with the injured Elisabeth. That's not just clever, that's calculated to the degree it's almost scary. And the Empress? She's actively pushing Hildeltrud and Edgar together, prohibiting Edgar from going to the basement where Deborah is. The Empress knows about the basement secrets too, or at least suspects something, and she's maneuvering everyone like chess pieces. What's killing me is how these two storylines are converging. Hildeltrud's plan needs Edgar's attention, but Edgar is already tied up with Deborah downstairs. The tension between these two plots is fantastic. I kept waiting for one to crash into the other. The pacing is relentless — no filler, every scene advances at least two plot threads simultaneously. That's why I couldn't put it down.
... Read More
I need to talk about Kiserian because WOW. 'I'm in love with the Duke's daughter, Hildeltrud.' Roel's reaction—'Please tell me this is a dream'—literally my face while reading this. The fact that he's been pining for her for so long it could 'turn back time,' and she loved Edgar in her past life, makes this SO angsty in the best way possible. He calls it 'forbidden love' and says it 'suits me perfectly' like he's embraced the drama of his own life. And the detail that he never confessed because she loved someone else? Ugh, my heart. Meanwhile Hildeltrud is just... going along with these tea meetings thinking it's a business arrangement, not knowing the prince she barely remembers is the one paying attention to her. There's this ache in every scene where they interact. When Kiserian watches her 'delicate hand holding the teacup' and thinks she looks like 'a single lily in bloom'—the romantic tension is palpable even though she's sitting there completely oblivious. And then he leaves when he hears Roel approaching? The man can't even handle being close to her without almost blowing his cover. This is the kind of slow-burn forbidden romance that makes you want to shake the characters and yell 'just talk to each other!'
... Read More
'His uncontrollable lust remains unchanged.' That line. That single line. It hit me like a truck because everything we'd seen of Edgar up to this point — the gentle touches, the whispered promises, the 'you're always welcome at my palace' sweetness — was suddenly reframed as manipulation. He's not a devoted husband; he's a predator in velvet gloves, and Hildeltrud knows it. What I find absolutely fascinating is the power dynamic shift happening between these two. In every scene they share, Edgar thinks he's in control. He steers the conversation, he initiates physical contact, he frames everything as romantic devotion. But Hildeltrud? She's playing 4D chess while he's still learning checkers. When she removes his hand from her shoulder and holds it with both of hers — that gesture reads as tender on the surface, but the narrator tells us she's coldly watching him leave. The reader gets the full picture; Edgar gets the performance. Then there's Elisabeth, and oh boy, the betrayal sting is real. Hildeltrud treated her like a sister, gave her comfort, shared everything beautiful with her — and Elisabeth stole her husband and helped bring down the Ducal family. The scene where Elisabeth grabs Hildeltrud's hand saying 'You're the only one I can rely on' while Hildeltrud inwardly smirks? That's one of the most deliciously tense moments in this entire passage. Elisabeth thinks she's manipulating Hildeltrud into moving her to a better room, but Hildeltrud sees right through it and lets her hang herself with her own rope. And Kiserian! The second prince who avoids dinner not because he's lazy (okay, also because he's lazy) but because he can't bear to see Hildeltrud beside Edgar? His jealousy is understated but palpable. He calls it 'consideration' to Roel, but we know it's something else. I'm genuinely invested in whether he'll become an ally or something more for Hildeltrud. The maid hierarchy with the colored belts is also a clever way of showing social dynamics — even within the servant class, there are ranks, tensions, and power plays. Elisabeth trying to assert dominance over Leah and failing miserably? Classic.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about Elisabeth for a sec because my blood is literally boiling. This girl walks into Hildeltrud's room like she owns the place—no knocking, no respect—and Hildeltrud's whole face changes when she sees her. I could feel the hatred radiating off the page. "She had been truly foolish and naive." Oof. And Elisabeth's all fake-concerned, asking if she's alright, dragging her out to a dessert shop like nothing happened, while Hildeltrud is sitting there internally screaming but forcing a smile. The way Hildeltrud handles her now versus how she would've in her past life is SO different. She doesn't blow up, doesn't expose anything—she just politely declines and sends her away. That's not weakness, that's calculated. She knows exactly what Elisabeth is and she's already three steps ahead. But here's what gets me: Hildeltrud still feels pain when she looks at Elisabeth's face. She has to actively suppress anger. That means this friendship wasn't totally fake to her at some point, which makes the betrayal hit even harder. Who else in this story can be trusted? The fiancé who betrayed her, the best friend who was actually the mistress's pawn... who's left? Just Jenny and her family, and even then, Hildeltrud's walking on eggshells. I keep wondering if there's anyone she can genuinely connect with anymore, or if revenge is going to isolate her completely.
... Read More
Every chapter in this passage ramps up the tension in a different way, and the author is clearly building toward something massive. On the personal level, Hildeltrud's conflict with Edgar is the centerpiece. She's married to a man who killed the Emperor (or was involved in it) and betrayed her family, and she's playing the role of the loving wife while secretly orchestrating his destruction. The stakes here are enormous — if Edgar discovers she knows the truth or is working against him, everything falls apart. Every interaction between them is a minefield. 'Knowing that you are always by my side brings me peace, Your Highness' — what a devastating line because the reader knows she means the exact opposite. The Emperor's death is the ticking clock over everything. Hildeltrud's guilt about not preventing it ('If only she had warned him earlier') adds a layer of personal stakes that goes beyond revenge. She feels responsible, and that's what makes her determination to expose Edgar feel almost compulsive rather than merely strategic. Then there's the basement mystery — 'Room 2' and 'Room 3,' someone who might be ill and must not be discovered. This is a completely separate thread of danger that raises the stakes exponentially. What is Edgar hiding down there? Who is in those rooms? The author won't let us forget that Edgar is dangerous on multiple levels. Even the maid storyline has stakes baked in. Elisabeth's attempts to undermine Leah, her threats to get her fired — these small conflicts matter because in the imperial palace, a single mistake can ruin someone's position, and by extension, Hildeltrud's reputation. Liza's warning that 'it will reflect poorly on Lady Hildeltrud' makes this personal too. The suspense maintenance is excellent throughout. No resolution is rushed, no mystery is fully unveiled, and the emotional and physical dangers keep accumulating. I genuinely cannot wait to see how all these conflicting forces collide.
... Read More
I'm not okay. I'm genuinely not okay after reading Chapter 1.1. Let me just... let me just say it. Hildeltrud getting stabbed. TWICE. In the rain. And she's cursing them out as she's dying—"Even in death… I will never forgive you"—and the rain is literally crying for her. I cried for her. Then she wakes up and her first instinct isn't panic or confusion, it's to run to her father. Barefoot, in her chemise, not caring that the knight is looking away embarrassed. She just throws open the door and hugs him and says "I love you" and I— I physically had to pause the book. The way the Duke's hand strokes her head. The brother who's like "are you sick, you're giving me chills" and she replies "I was sick, but now I'm fine. Truly." That line wrecked me because we KNOW she's not fine. She's carrying an entire lifetime of trauma and betrayal and grief in a twenty-year-old's body, and all she wants is this stupid, simple moment with her family. And then the comedy relief of her running around half-dressed and Patrick nagging her about it. It grounded the scene so perfectly. One second I'm devastated, the next I'm like okay this is a family and they're alive and they're BICKERING and I can breathe again. But then she's alone in her room practicing her smile in the mirror like she's prepping for war. That contrast between the warmth of the family scene and the cold calculation afterward? Chef's kiss. Absolutely ruthless.
... Read More
I need to talk about Hildeltrud because oh my god the emotional complexity of this character is insane. Everyone keeps reading her as naive and sweet, but look at the actual text. She sees Edgar intentionally touching Elisabeth's hand during the picnic. She watches him pretend not to notice. And what does she do? She SPILLS ORANGE JUICE ON HERSELF and leaves them ALONE so she can see what happens. That's not innocence. That's controlled fury. When she returns and Edgar immediately puts his arm around her shoulder to cover up whatever just happened between him and Elisabeth, she hugs him and says 'I'm so happy!' while looking at Elisabeth with that cold smile. The text literally says '{a cold smile hidden beneath her innocent expression}' and I about fell out of my chair. She's performing love while dissecting her own betrayal in real time. And then there's the scene where she tells her father about entering the palace. Leopold looks worried and she says '{If that's your decision, I'll make the preparations}' with a polite bow. But internally she's thinking about using whatever she has to achieve her goals. She's not doing this for love. She's not doing this for duty. She's doing it because she has a plan and Edgar doesn't even know he's part of it. The emotional devastation hits different when you realize she's mourning someone who never actually existed. That line '{I'm curious to see how far your so-called love will go}' isn't jealousy—it's grief masquerading as scientific curiosity. She's already lost him and she's trying to understand what she thought she had. Meanwhile Edgar is up in those underground chambers treating women as interchangeable replacements for her, literally calling out '{Hildeltrud, you're so beautiful}' while doing it to someone else. The emotional irony is absolutely suffocating and I can't stop thinking about it.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is absolutely ruthless and I respect it so much. Let me break down the structure because it's actually quite clever. Scene one: the garden picnic. This is slow-burn tension. You've got three people on a mat, everyone smiling, everyone lying. The author stretches every gesture—the hand brush, the leaf in the hair, the deliberate spill. It feels almost languid but the pressure is building because we KNOW Elisabeth is onto something and we KNOW Hildeltrud sees it too. Then scene two cuts immediately to Edgar returning to the palace and meeting his mother. This is structural brilliance. The Empress Isabel conversation is short, cold, and political. No warmth, just transaction. '{Once we're married, I'll give you the legitimate heir you desire}'—that line alone tells you everything about how this world works. Then Edgar slumps on the sofa exhausted and immediately goes to the underground chambers. The transition from political duty to private depravity happens in one paragraph and it's jarring in the best way. Scene three is the palace decree and Hildeltrud's response. Back to her perspective and suddenly she's not a victim at all—she's mobilizing. She goes to Cain, gets a maid, signs a contract, requests teleportation and illusion artifacts. The pacing here accelerates because her agency is finally visible. We've been watching her perform helplessness and now she drops the act. What makes the pacing work is that each scene ends with a revelation that recontextualizes everything before it. The picnic ends with Hildeltrud's cold smile. Edgar's evening ends with him using substitutes. Hildeltrud's morning ends with her signing away her freedom to gain real power. Every beat turns the story in a new direction and there's zero filler.
... Read More
So many layers here and I can't stop thinking about them. The mirror is the obvious one, right? Hildeltrud looks at herself and sees not the innocent girl she was, but the cold calculating woman she's become. "The image of Hildeltrud reflected in the mirror was no longer the pure and innocent woman she once was." But it goes deeper than that. There's the whole motif of masks—both literal and figurative. Master Cain wears a golden mask. Hildeltrud practices smiling in the mirror because she has to wear a mask to deceive Elisabeth. "If you treat me with insincerity, I'll wear a mask for you as well." The mask isn't just deception; it's armor. She's learned that being genuine got everyone she loved killed. And then there's the rain—starting as a mourning force and ending as a cleansing one. Her old self dies in the rain, and she's reborn in her bed. The date check—April 1st—feel intentional? Fool's Day? She was the fool, and now she's the one holding the knife. The jewelry store being called Moon's Gate ties into the rare piece she wants: "The Moon Embracing the Stars." Isn't that exactly what she's doing? Trying to reclaim something that belongs to her? Or is she the star being embraced by something darker? I keep circling back to this line: "She couldn't even forgive her own naive self." The real tragedy isn't just the betrayal—it's that she has to murder her own innocence to survive. Every revenge story is about justice, but this one feels like it's also about whether justice is worth the cost of who you have to become.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about the picnic because this is where everything emotional exploded for me. Hildeltrud dressed up, chose the flowers, planned everything to look like a romantic outing with Edgar. She even dressed Elisabeth nicely — and here's the thing that got me, Elisabeth ACTUALLY felt happy about it. "Though outwardly hesitant, Elisabeth felt proud inside and deliberately clung to Hildeltrud." She trusted her. She thought Hildeltrud was being genuinely kind. And Hildeltrud used that trust as a weapon. "It's so beautiful." "I had these flowers planted for you, Lady Hildeltrud." Edgar saying that to HER while Elisabeth watches from the sidelines with those envious eyes — it's so painfully clear who's being seen and who's being used. But then the fall happens and everything shifts. Elisabeth is lying there hurt, and Hildeltrud performs this incredible bit of acting — crying, worried, pretending to be helpless — just so Edgar will attend to Elisabeth herself. And Edgar? He's so smitten with Hildeltrud's tears that he wipes them away with his fingertips. The man is completely bewitched. Meanwhile poor Elisabeth is stuck alone with Edgar, injured and flustered, and I swear I could feel her heart racing through the pages. "Elisabeth's face turned red as she received Edgar's support. However, she couldn't show her emotions and instead exaggerated her pain. After all, Hildeltrud was watching." This whole dynamic between these three — the manufactured romance, the genuine attraction forming between Edgar and Hildeltrud despite it all being a setup, Elisabeth's helpless position — it's emotionally devastating and I couldn't look away.
... Read More
Patrick and Leopold. Just— Patrick and Leopold. Hildeltrud had been getting dressed since dawn and the text says she was moved to tears by gifts from her father and brother. Tears! This is a woman who spent the whole chapter calculating, negotiating, planning infiltrations, and she fell apart over a dress and some accessories. And then the goodbye scene—Patrick placing his hand on her shoulder, telling her 'if life in the palace becomes too hard, tell us anytime,' Leopold worrying she's too kind for her own good. Hildeltrud hugged them both before getting in the carriage and I swear to god if I hadn't been reading this at 2am I would've made a sound. What hits me most is how honest Hildeltrud is with them. She doesn't pretend she's not going in to crush people. She just... lets them love her anyway. And then there's Elisabeth, who gets shut out so hard—'Maids sit here,' Leah says, and Hildeltrud shuts the carriage door on her best friend's face. The cruelty of it! But also the necessity. If Elisabeth suspected anything, the whole plan blows up. Hildeltrud looks back at her crestfallen face with pity, and I could feel her conscience splitting in two. She's becoming someone who has to choose between being loved and being safe, and every time she makes that choice a little piece of her dies.
... Read More
I keep coming back to the flower scene because I think it contains the entire thesis of this novel in a single image. Edgar tells Hildeltrud he had those beautiful garden flowers planted specifically for her. On the surface, this reads as romantic devotion. But the reader now knows — we know Hildeltrud manipulated him into this. She orchestrated the entire picnic, chose the dress, triggered the fall, and positioned herself as the victim so he'd rush to her side. Those flowers might as well be part of her trap. Love and control are indistinguishable in this palace. There's another recurring symbol that bothers me: the rules. The book of imperial regulations that Hildeltrud already memorized from her past life. Every rule was written after some scandal, some disaster, some betrayal. "Incidents frequently occurred in the imperial family, leading to the creation of new rules." The Empire tries to legislate morality into existence, but the people inside it keep finding ways around every single rule. The prohibition against maids and masters living in the same palace? Hildeltrud overrides it. The underground basement full of imprisoned women? It exists right beneath the palace, untouched by any rulebook. And pregnancy — that's the biggest symbol of all. Deborah's hidden pregnancy represents everything the Empire tries to suppress: female bodies as political currency, children born from coercion, the consequences of power running exactly opposite to what the official narratives claim. Hildeltrud, meanwhile, is being groomed to produce an heir through what looks like love but is really strategy. Two kinds of pregnancies, two kinds of power, one empire that calls itself civilized.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or